16 results on '"historical-comparative method"'
Search Results
2. Evgenia Vladimirovna Gutnova as a Historiographer of the English Medieval Parliament: The Anglo-American Research Perspective
- Author
-
Т. А. Sidorova
- Subjects
e.v. gutnova ,anglo-american historiography ,english medieval parliament ,marxist methodology of history ,research and political-ideological components ,historical-critical analysis ,liberal-whig historiography ,critical trend ,“parliamentarians” ,“corporatists” ,historical-genetic method ,historical-comparative method ,methods of historical analysis and synthesis ,History of scholarship and learning. The humanities ,AZ20-999 - Abstract
This article considers the Anglo-American historiography of the early English parliament based on the extensive contribution and heritage of Evgenia Vladimirovna Gutnova (1914–1992), an outstanding Soviet and Russian medievalist and historiographer. E.V. Gutnova was a pioneer and groundbreaker in the historical and historiographical study of the English state and medieval parliamentarism during the 13th–14th centuries. Through her work, she expanded the pool of historiographical sources available to the scientific world. This vast collection included the fundamental works on the English constitutional history of the Middle Ages published by major historians of England and the USA in the middle of the 19th–the first half of the 20th centuries. She performed a detailed analysis of their concepts of the English medieval parliament by comparison of the Whig-liberal (W. Stubbs) and “critical” (F.W. Maitland) models in line with the Marxist methodologies of history. Here, based on the historical-genetic and -comparative methods, along with historical analysis and synthesis, E.V. Gutnova’s role in the study of the early English parliamentarism within the Anglo-American historiography was defined. The conclusion is made that she developed and introduced an innovative historiographical concept, which has become a widely used algorithm for research in the field of foreign history of historical science, with the Anglo-American historiography of early parliamentarism in England as its integral part.
- Published
- 2024
- Full Text
- View/download PDF
3. Lost in translation: A historical-comparative reconstruction of Proto-Khoe-Kwadi based on archival data.
- Author
-
Fehn, Anne-Maria and Rocha, Jorge
- Subjects
LINGUISTIC change ,HISTORICAL source material ,PHONEME (Linguistics) ,LANGUAGE contact ,PHONOLOGICAL awareness ,LEXICAL access - Abstract
Copyright of Diachronica is the property of John Benjamins Publishing Co. and its content may not be copied or emailed to multiple sites or posted to a listserv without the copyright holder's express written permission. However, users may print, download, or email articles for individual use. This abstract may be abridged. No warranty is given about the accuracy of the copy. Users should refer to the original published version of the material for the full abstract. (Copyright applies to all Abstracts.)
- Published
- 2023
- Full Text
- View/download PDF
4. Tendencies of Change of Socio-Political Lexicon in Persian and Azerbaijani Languages
- Author
-
Gunel Mazahir Orujova
- Subjects
socio-political terms ,azerbaijanian language ,historical-comparative method ,persian language ,religious terms ,middle ages sources ,statehood ,iranian sources ,Science - Abstract
Socio-political terms exist in all world languages and are directly related to the socio-political structure of each country. The words related to statehood, religion and political system were mentioned in sources associated with the ancient period of Persian and Azerbaijani languages. In the article, among such sources, "The Book of Dede-Gorgud", Orkhon-Yenisei" on Turkic languages, and the samples selected from the work "Shahnameh" on Persian are analyzed by the historical-comparative method. When studying terms related to religion, it should be investigated in more detail whether these terms correctly reflect events in the socio-political life of the country they belong to, as they are subject to purposeful interventions in several cases. Considering Manichaean, Islam, Sufism and other religious directions, which are thought to be related to Zoroastrianism and Zoroastrianism in Iran, this picture is further complicated. In the article, medieval Persian dictionaries were also reviewed among the sources related to the Middle Ages. It was noted that words related to almost all areas of social life are included in them. The social and political situation after the Iranian Islamic Revolution and the terms that were created in connection with this situation is considered in the history of Iran. The article also contains information about using borrowed words in both languages' social and political fields. Then the place of the terms in the form of abbreviations in the speech was analyzed. In the article, the data gives grounds to say that as a result of any historical event, the most profitable sphere is linguistics. So, although the changes in other areas cause stagnation and decline in some instances, linguistics is enriched with new words. Political linguistics is also included, and the rising line of political discourse during World War I can serve as an example.
- Published
- 2022
- Full Text
- View/download PDF
5. METODA HISTORYCZNO-KRYTYCZNA W GRAMATYCE ANDRZEJA SZTOCHLA.
- Author
-
Żurek-Huszcz, Aleksandra
- Subjects
COLLEGE teachers ,HISTORICAL linguistics ,GRAMMAR ,PRONUNCIATION ,NINETEENTH century - Abstract
Andrzej Sztochel (1786-1846), the author of a grammar book, graduated from Jagiellonian University and was a teacher of Polish. Gramatyka historyczno-krytyczna języka polskiego (Historical and critical grammar of Polish), published posthumously, is one of two of his studies; it is dedicated to the science of the word, in particular inflectional descriptions, in its entirety. The book is written in accordance with the historical method, which was innovative in Poland at that time. It stands out from grammar books of those days by its numerous references to proposals of other grammarians, writings by authors of old times, and dialectal pronunciation. Most of the then reviewers evaluated the grammar book negatively and not many contemporary researchers notice any innovativeness in it either. [ABSTRACT FROM AUTHOR]
- Published
- 2022
- Full Text
- View/download PDF
6. A Matter of Method
- Author
-
Steffen Ducheyne
- Subjects
Lambert ten Kate Hermansz. (1674-1731) ,Isaac Newton (1642-1727) ,historical-comparative method ,early Enlightenment study of language ,History of Low Countries - Benelux Countries ,DH1-925 - Abstract
The Amsterdam-based self-educated polymath Lambert ten Kate (1674-1731) was well versed in different subjects. His contributions to the study of language and the new methods he employed to pursue it are the focus of this article. Ten Kate was well in tune with the natural philosophical developments of his day. Unsurprisingly, it has been argued that the methods he developed in the study of language were inspired by Isaac Newton’s (1643-1727) natural philosophical approach. I argue that a more nuanced understanding of the relation between Ten Kate’s methods in the study of language and Newton’s natural philosophical approach is called for. De Amsterdamse autodidact Lambert ten Kate (1674-1731) was bedreven in verschillende disciplines. In dit artikel staan zijn bijdragen aan de studie van de taal en de nieuwe methodes die hij daartoe ontwikkelde centraal. Ten Kate volgde de ontwikkelingen binnen de natuurfilosofie op de voet. In de literatuur wordt betoogd dat de methodes die hij aanwendde bij het bestuderen van de taal geïnspireerd waren door Isaac Newtons (1643-1727) natuurfilosofische aanpak. Ik argumenteer echter dat de relatie tussen de door Ten Kate gebruikte methodes bij de studie van de taal en de natuurfilosofische benadering van Newton genuanceerder ligt.
- Published
- 2022
- Full Text
- View/download PDF
7. P. Willis的《學做工》:概念、方法 與研究方向.
- Author
-
黃庭康
- Abstract
Copyright of Bulletin of Educational Research is the property of National Taiwan Normal University, Department of Education and its content may not be copied or emailed to multiple sites or posted to a listserv without the copyright holder's express written permission. However, users may print, download, or email articles for individual use. This abstract may be abridged. No warranty is given about the accuracy of the copy. Users should refer to the original published version of the material for the full abstract. (Copyright applies to all Abstracts.)
- Published
- 2017
8. Tendencies of Change of Socio-Political Lexicon in Persian and Azerbaijani Languages
- Author
-
Orujova, Gunel Mazahir
- Subjects
Sprache ,language ,Azerbaijan ,Wortschatz ,socio-political terms ,Azerbaijanian language ,historical-comparative method ,Persian language ,religious terms ,middle ages sources ,statehood ,Iranian sources ,Iran ,Literaturwissenschaft, Sprachwissenschaft, Linguistik ,Literatur, Rhetorik, Literaturwissenschaft ,Science of Literature, Linguistics ,LСC Subject Category: PE1001-1693 ,Languages ,Aserbaidschan ,Literature, rhetoric and criticism ,ddc:800 ,vocabulary - Abstract
Socio-political terms exist in all world languages and are directly related to the socio-political structure of each country. The words related to statehood, religion and political system were mentioned in sources associated with the ancient period of Persian and Azerbaijani languages. In the article, among such sources, "The Book of Dede-Gorgud", Orkhon-Yenisei" on Turkic languages, and the samples selected from the work "Shahnameh" on Persian are analyzed by the historical-comparative method. When studying terms related to religion, it should be investigated in more detail whether these terms correctly reflect events in the socio-political life of the country they belong to, as they are subject to purposeful interventions in several cases. Considering Manichaean, Islam, Sufism and other religious directions, which are thought to be related to Zoroastrianism and Zoroastrianism in Iran, this picture is further complicated. In the article, medieval Persian dictionaries were also reviewed among the sources related to the Middle Ages. It was noted that words related to almost all areas of social life are included in them. The social and political situation after the Iranian Islamic Revolution and the terms that were created in connection with this situation is considered in the history of Iran. The article also contains information about using borrowed words in both languages' social and political fields. Then the place of the terms in the form of abbreviations in the speech was analyzed. In the article, the data gives grounds to say that as a result of any historical event, the most profitable sphere is linguistics. So, although the changes in other areas cause stagnation and decline in some instances, linguistics is enriched with new words. Political linguistics is also included, and the rising line of political discourse during World War I can serve as an example.
- Published
- 2022
9. OPTATIVUL ÎN GREACA VECHE ŞI ÎN LATINĂ. O ABORDARE DIACRONICĂ.
- Author
-
RUS, VASILE
- Abstract
The Optative Mood in Ancient Greek and Latin. This study proposes a diachronical approach to the theme of the optative expressions in the classical languages, Ancient Greek and Latin. In a logical ascendant discourse we start from the problem of the Indo-European origin of the Optative Mood in the frame of the Verb System in the Proto-Language developed in two theoretical prolegomena and two ending attachments, to approach after two analytical and classificatory sections dedicated to the Optative Expressions in Ancient Greek and in Latin. We conclude with two Appendices regarding the specific problem of the origin of the "secondary" verbal endings used by the Optative, respectively the modern theories on the Indo-European origins of the Optative Mood. [ABSTRACT FROM AUTHOR]
- Published
- 2016
10. P. Willis的《學做工》:概念、方法與研究方向 P. Willis’s Learning to Labor: Concepts, Method, and Research Direction
- Author
-
黃庭康 Ting-Hong Wong
- Subjects
反學校文化 ,historical-comparative method ,歷史比較方法 ,anti-school culture ,競逐性再生產 ,contested reproduction ,school organization ,lcsh:L7-991 ,學校組織 ,lcsh:Education (General) - Abstract
Willis的《學做工》把文化及行動者主體性重新引入批判教育研究,建立了一個能夠兼顧結構與行動、客觀與主觀因素的分析架構,也超越了當時的再生產理論,觀察到學生並不只是被動地接受學校的洗腦,並指出學校教育與經濟體系的斷裂,單靠學校不足以延續不平等的階級關係。Willis以實證資料證明階級子弟因為抗拒學校的「教學典範」—而非服從學校的教導—而繼承勞動階層的位置;而「小子」們反抗有部分是因為從學校以外場域而來的風格、意義及實踐替「反學校文化」提供了資源。筆者認為,應在Willis的基礎上繼續探討教育與社會再生產的關係。具體的做法包括:一、把階級文化的意義擴大至涵蓋個人層面;二、嚴謹地定義「反抗」及「反學校文化」等關鍵概念;三、利用Willis的洞見對不同學生群體、階級及社會進行比較研究。 Paul Willis’ Learning to Labor is a classic in critical education studies. By bringing agencies and culture back to the discussion in sociology of education, it developed an analytical framework that synthesized structure and action as well as objectivity and subjectivity. Willis also went beyond conventional reproduction theory. He discovered that students were by no means passive recipients of the dominant ideology, that class domination was perpetuated because working-class students resisted-but not acceptedschools’ teaching, and that anti-school culture was formed at least partly by meanings, styles and practices from spheres outside schools. This article encourages scholars to use insights from Learning to Labor to further explore the connections between school education and social reproduction. It also urges that researchers go beyond Willis by extending cultural analysis to the individual level and private domain, adopting more rigorous and theory-guided definitions of “resistance” and “anti-school culture” and employing comparative method to investigate student cultures among different social groups and in diverse social settings.
- Published
- 2017
11. The consonant template in synchrony and diachrony.
- Author
-
Wälchli, Bernhard
- Subjects
BALTIC languages ,CONSONANTS ,PHONOLOGY ,HISTORICAL linguistics ,LATVIAN language - Abstract
This paper investigates the importance of (unique) consonants in identifying cross-linguistic cognates. It is argued that consonants play a crucial role both in diachrony for the identification of cognates and in synchrony for the identification of stemforms. The same algorithm -- alignment of the consonant template (ACT) -- is applied both in diachrony for identifying cognates and in synchrony for aligning stemforms. It is argued that identifying cognates is essentially the alignment of their consonant templates. Since the alignment of consonant templates is over-generating, ACT must be strongly constrained by semantics. A method is presented to extract cognates directly from parallel texts which is exemplified and evaluated mainly on the basis of Lithuanian and Latvian. For identifying cognates, a three step procedure is applied: (a) finding semantically equivalent forms (SEF), (b) finding equivalent consonants (EC), and (c) alignment of the consonant template (ACT) [ABSTRACT FROM AUTHOR]
- Published
- 2010
- Full Text
- View/download PDF
12. In ricordo di Mirella
- Author
-
Mancini, Marco
- Subjects
Latin ,Etymology ,Palmira Cipriano ,Iranian Studies ,Greek ,Historical-Comparative method - Published
- 2018
13. A summary reconstruction of proto-maweti-guarani segmental phonology
- Author
-
Meira, Sérgio and Drude, Sebastian
- Subjects
Tupi Languages ,Linguística Diacrônica ,Línguas Maweti-Guarani ,Historical-Comparative Method ,Linguistic Reconstruction ,Línguas Tupi ,Diachronic Linguistics ,Método Histórico-Comparativo ,Maweti-Guarani Languages ,Reconstrução Diacrônica - Abstract
This paper presents a succinct reconstruction of the segmental phonology of Proto-Maweti-Guarani, the hypothetical protolanguage from which modern Mawe, Aweti and the Tupi-Guarani branches of the Tupi linguistic family have evolved. Based on about 300 cognate sets from the authors' field data (for Mawe and Aweti) and from Mello's reconstruction (2000) for Proto-Tupi-Guarani (with additional information from other works; and with a few changes concerning certain doubtful features, such as the status of stem-final lenis consonants *r and *ß, and the distinction of *c and *č ), the consonants and vowels of Proto-Maweti-Guarani were reconstructed with the help of the traditional historical-comparative method. The development of the reconstructed segments is then traced from the protolanguage to each of the modern branches. A comparison with other claims made about Proto-Maweti-Guarani is given in the conclusion. Resumo: Este artigo apresenta uma reconstrução resumida da fonologia segmental do Proto-Maweti-Guarani, a protolíngua hipotética intermediária, dentro da família linguística Tupi, da qual se desenvolveram o Mawé, o Aweti e as línguas Tupi-Guarani atuais. Baseando-se em cerca de 300 conjuntos de cognatos, provenientes dos dados de campo dos autores (Mawé e Aweti) e dos dados lexicais publicados por Mello (2000, Tupi-Guarani), em informações adicionais de outras fontes publicadas (com algumas modificações relativas a certos aspectos duvidosos das reconstruções atuais do Proto-Tupi-Guarani, como o status das consoantes lenes *r e *ß em fim de palavra, e a distinção entre *c e *č), reconstruímos as consoantes e vogais do Proto-Maweti-Guarani com o auxílio do método histórico-comparativo tradicional. Ao fim do artigo, traça-se o desenvolvimento dos segmentos reconstruídos desde a protolíngua até cada um dos três ramos modernos. Na conclusão, oferecemos uma comparação rápida com outras hipóteses sobre o Proto-Maweti-Guarani.
- Published
- 2015
14. General regularities and specific content trudmobilizovannyh Russian Germans in forced labor camps in the Urals
- Author
-
Kirillov, V. M.
- Subjects
историко-сравнительный метод ,Тагиллаг ,Богословлаг ,лагеря принудительного труда ,trudmobilizovannye Germans ,социальный портрет ,Bogoslovlag ,УДК 94(=112.2)(470.5) «1942/1945» ,historical-comparative method ,001.8 [УДК 94(=112.2)(470.5)«19»] ,Tagillag ,social profile ,трудмобилизованные немцы ,ГРНТИ 03.23 ,special contingent ,ITL-Bakalstroy Chelyabmetallurgstroy ,спецконтингент ,ИТЛ Бакалстрой- Челябметаллургстрой ,forced labor camps - Abstract
Исследование проведено руководителем лаборатории «Историческая информатика» Нижнетагильского педагогического института, которая является главным центром осуществления международного проекта «Gedenkbuch: Книга памяти репрессированных российских немцев». Источниками исследования стали электронные базы данных по ИТЛ Тагиллаг, Богословлаг и Бакалстрой — Челябметаллургстрой общим объемом 68 тыс. персоналий, созданные в период 1999—2013 гг. Предварительно, с помощью специально-исторических методов и методов исторической информатики (баз и банков данных, просопографического) проведено изучение истории создания лагерей, условий жизнедеятельности их контингентов, реконструирован социальный портрет трудмобилизованных. В данной статье на основе материалов трех лагерей принудительного труда Урала рассматриваются закономерности и особенности формирования, жизнедеятельности ИТЛ , социального портрета советских немцев-трудармейцев. Путем применения историко-сравнительного метода выявляется типология лагерей принудительного труда, имеющая значение для реконструкции военно-мобилизационной модели экономики. Research is conducted the leader of laboratory the «Historical informatics» of the Nizhnetagil’skogo pedagogical institute, which is the main center of realization of international project «Gedenkbuch: Book of memory of the subjected to repression Russian Germans». Research sources were become by electronic databases on ITL Tagillag, Bogoslovlag and Bakalstroy-Chelyabmetallurgstroy by a general volume 68 thousands of personalias, created in the period of 1999—2013. Preliminary, by special-historical methods and methods of historical informatics (bases and banks of data, prosopograficheskogo) the study of history of creation of camps is conducted, terms of vital functions of their contingents, the social portrait of trudmobilizovannykh is reconstructed. In this article on the basis of materials of three camps of the forced labor of Ural conformities to law and features of forming, vital functions of ITL, social portrait of soviet nemcev-trudarmeycev are examined. Tipologiya of camps of the forced labor, mattering for a reconstruction military-mobilizational model of economy comes to light by application of istoriko-comparative method. Кириллов Виктор Михайлович, доктор исторических наук, профессор кафедры гуманитарных и социально-экономических наук, Нижнетагильский государственный социально-педагогический институт (филиал), Российский государственный профессионально-педагогический университет, автор более 140 научных работ, в том числе 2 авторских и 13 коллективных монографий по истории политических репрессий. E-mail: history_vmk@mail.ru. V. M. Kirillov, Nizhny Tagil State Socio-Pedagogical Institute, Nizhny Tagil, Russian Federation, history_vmk@mail.ru
- Published
- 2015
15. Vokiškosios senųjų Klaipėdos krašto kapinių epitafijos: kalbinis aspektas
- Author
-
Bukantytė, Eglė
- Subjects
Epitaphs ,Tarmės. Dialektai. Dialektologija / Dialects. Dialectology ,Dialecticisms ,Dialecticism ,Epitaph ,epitaphs ,interaction of German and Lithuanian languages ,historical-comparative method ,archaism ,dialecticisms ,Epitafija ,Vokiečių ir lietuvių kalbų sąveika ,Klaipėda. Klaipėdos kraštas (Klaipeda region) ,Archaizmas ,Lietuva (Lithuania) ,Epitafijos ,Istorinis-lyginamasis metodas ,Archaism ,Vokietija (Germany) ,Historical-comparative method ,Aukštaitija - Abstract
Tyrimo objektas – vokiškosios Klaipėdos krašto senųjų kapinių epitafijos. Remiantis istoriniu-lyginamuoju metodu vokiški įrašai gretinami su lietuviškais, siekiama atskleisti tekstologinius ir lingvistinius jų ypatumus. Tiriant vokiškųjų antkapių užrašus pastebėta, kad juose dažnesni nei lietuviškuose pažyminiai, nurodantys mirusiojo santykius su artimaisiais. Neretai nurodoma moters mergautinė, kartais ir našlautinė pavardė. Dažniau nei lietuviškose epitafijose pasakoma mirusiojo profesija. Nuo XX a. 3-iojo dešimtmečio išplėstinių priedėlių konstrukcijos retesnės, epitafijos darosi lakoniškesnės. Dažniausiai vartota įžanginė antkapių liturginė formulė – hier ruhet in Gott, kiek retesnė – hier ruhet in Frieden. Apie šių epitafijų ištaką kalbama atskirame tyrime. Lakoniška epitafijų kalbinė raiška ir struktūra riboja jų kalbinę įvairovę ir lingvistinio tyrimo galimybes. Atliekant analizę trumpųjų epitafijų kalba laikyta gyvosios kalbos faktais, o Šv. Rašto ir giesmių citatos kalbiniu aspektu netyrinėtos. Nustatyta keletas tarmybių ir archaizmų, pvz., archajinė veiksmažodžio geben forma es giebt. Aptiktas vokiečių aukštaičių tarmei būdingas reiškinys – balsių redukcija. Šiame straipsnyje neaptartas lietuviškų vardų, pavardžių bei vietovardžių vokietinimo principas ir vokiškų epitafijų pasiskirstymas Klaipėdos krašto vietovėse. Laukiama ir naujų duomenų, galėsiančių papildyti lingvistinį tyrimą The object of the research is German epitaphs in the old cemeteries of Klaipėda Region. German inscriptions are compared to Lithuanian ones on the basis of the historical-comparative method with the aim of disclosing their textological and linguistic characteristics. The analysis of inscriptions on German tombstones showed that, compared to Lithuanian tombstones, the attributes indicating the relationship of the deceased to family members were used more frequently. The profession of the deceased was indicated more often than in Lithuanian epitaphs. Starting with the 20s of the 20th century, the constructions of extended appositions were less frequent, and the epitaphs became more concise. Laconicism of linguistic expression and of the structure of the epitaphs restrained their linguistic diversity and the potential for linguistic research. The analysis considered the brief language of the epitaphs as the facts of the living language, whereas Bible and canticle citations were not studied. A few examples of dialecticisms and archaisms were identified, e.g. an archaic form of the verb geben: es giebt. Vowel reduction, a phenomenon characteristic of the High German dialect, was identified. The present article did not discuss the principle of Germanization of Lithuanian names, surnames, or place names, as well as the distribution of German epitaphs over the localities of Klaipėda Region. New data are expected that may promote linguistic research
- Published
- 2012
16. A summary reconstruction of proto-maweti-guarani segmental phonology
- Author
-
Sebastian Drude and Sérgio Meira
- Subjects
Linguistics and Language ,Archeology ,Tupi Languages ,lcsh:Latin America. Spanish America ,History ,Línguas Maweti-Guarani ,Field data ,Historical-Comparative Method ,lcsh:F1201-3799 ,Phonology ,Diachronic Linguistics ,Método Histórico-Comparativo ,Linguistics ,Language and Linguistics ,Reconstrução Diacrônica ,lcsh:Social Sciences ,lcsh:H ,Linguística Diacrônica ,Linguistic reconstruction ,Anthropology ,Historical linguistics ,Linguistic Reconstruction ,Línguas Tupi ,Cognate ,Maweti-Guarani Languages - Abstract
This paper presents a succinct reconstruction of the segmental phonology of Proto-Maweti-Guarani, the hypothetical protolanguage from which modern Mawe, Aweti and the Tupi-Guarani branches of the Tupi linguistic family have evolved. Based on about 300 cognate sets from the authors' field data (for Mawe and Aweti) and from Mello's reconstruction (2000) for Proto-Tupi-Guarani (with additional information from other works; and with a few changes concerning certain doubtful features, such as the status of stem-final lenis consonants *r and *ß, and the distinction of *c and *č ), the consonants and vowels of Proto-Maweti-Guarani were reconstructed with the help of the traditional historical-comparative method. The development of the reconstructed segments is then traced from the protolanguage to each of the modern branches. A comparison with other claims made about Proto-Maweti-Guarani is given in the conclusion.
Catalog
Discovery Service for Jio Institute Digital Library
For full access to our library's resources, please sign in.