Search

In the introduction, we briefly recall old but classic evidence that there is no tolerance to paternal alloantigens in a first pregnancy. Therefore, we performed small- and large-scale microarrays in CBA × DBA/2 and CBA × BALB/c combinations, recently described as a murine model for preeclampsia. Our results are in line with other data suggesting a very early deregulation of local immune vascular events rather than a break of immune tolerance. Other data presented at the Tioman 2010 Preeclampsia Workshop supporting this hypothesis are briefly summarised, as well as indications and caveats from a recent human microarray on implantation failure and recurrent pregnancy loss., (Copyright © 2011 Elsevier Ireland Ltd. All rights reserved.)

In this paper, we briefly survey the history of concepts in reproductive immunology from antibody-mediated tolerance to the "fetal allograft" to the current concept of an embryo "bathing in a sea of cytokines". We then review the paradigm that "allopregnancy is a Th2 phenomenon" and some of the evidence gained in animals and humans supporting it. We continue by discussing the light it sheds on immunologically caused recurrent abortion, and the present status of the concepts. We next show the limits of the Th1/Th2 paradigm by reviewing the role of "inflammatory" cytokines in implantation (as first seen with leukemia inhibitory factor). We go on to discuss recent data showing that interferon-gamma is not solely a "bad guy", e.g. abortifacient as the paradigm would predict, but is needed at low doses for the vascular development and transformation of uterine spiral arteries required for implantation and successful pregnancy. We conclude by discussing the emerging role of NK and IL-12, IL-15, IL-18 tripods and other cytokines in local angiogenesis and tissue remodelling, a series of new data bringing us well beyond the Th1/Th2 paradigm in pregnancy which, in this context, appears now obsolete and an oversimplification, although it has indeed been useful at first. Rather, step-specific events have to be considered and a key role is seen in local tissue remodelling, in which immune cytokines play an important role while not always being secreted by immune cells., (Copyright 2004 S. Karger AG, Basel)

We briefly review the history of concepts (some of which are still valid) which have lead to the present situation where pregnancy is viewed as being a Th2 phenomenon. We recall some of the early evidence which has been taken as supporting the general validity of this concept in murine and human pregnancy. We then recall some of the recent data dealing with "newer" cytokines and the role of uterine natural killer (NK) cells at the feto-maternal interface which fit neither with a steady-state concept nor with inflammatory cytokines, being solely "bad guys" as the paradigm would predict, nor with the concept of reduction of NK "activity" being required for successful pregnancy. As an example of the newer complexity, we briefly recall some of our recent micro-array studies in mice, and describe briefly our most recent data in human pointing out the importance of the tripod IL-12/IL-18/NK in successful or failed pregnancy in human, perhaps under IL-15 control. We conclude by a repeated warning against the so-called rationales of lymphocyte alloimmunization for therapy of recurrent spontaneous abortion and improvement of implantation rates.

Problem: Human in vitro fertilization (IVF) embryo transfer is accompanied by a low implantation rate even after a very successful IVF, and there are a certain number of 'idiopathic sterilities' which are due to repeated implantation failures. In the very same vein, the question of improving implantation rates is of prime importance in agricultural research to improve the management of livestock. Preimplantation prenatal diagnosis cannot be accomplished in individuals who have a high rate of implantation failure, whether women undergoing IVF, or animals, during genetic cloning. Implantation cytokine networks need to be known in such a perspective., Methods: We review the evolution and theories in reproductive immunology, briefly deal with the complexity of implantation as a step by step developmental event, and then present some of our recent data in mice and human., Conclusions: We conclude that the T helper cell type 1/2 (Th1/ Th2) paradigm, as useful as it has been to explain pregnancy, is no longer sufficient in view of the emerging complexity of the cytokine network at the materno-fetal interface. This is peculiarly true for implantation, which, as a step by step developmentally regulated process, involving inflammatory molecules, cannot fit into such a scheme.

We restate briefly why we consider that the Th1/Th2 paradigm, as useful as it has been, is now no longer adequate and is obsolete. We take as an example the role of IL-18, abortifacient at high doses but cardinal for the control of natural killer (NK) cell effects on spiral artery remodelling in mice, and likely also in humans. We then describe briefly our recent studies on cytokine defects and implantation failure in humans, a key feature being the link between uterine cytokine dysregulation and abnormal uterine vascular scores. We draw lessons for preeclampsia, and describe features of a model for its immune aetiology.

Problem: Expression and hormonal regulation of pro-inflammatory cytokines and their role in blastocyst activation and implantation is poorly known. The present study is aimed at analysing the expression and hormonal modulation of two pro-inflammatory cytokines [interleukin-1alpha (IL-1alpha) and IL-6] in mouse blastocysts during implantation., Method of Study: Blastocyst-uterine interactions are inhibited by progesterone during implantation and subsequent treatment with oestrogen triggers events that allow implantation to begin. Using this delayed implantation mouse model, dormant and activated blastocysts were recovered from mice treated with progesterone alone and progesterone plus oestrogen therapy, respectively. Expression of IL-1alpha and IL-6 messenger RNA (mRNA) was analysed in normal, dormant and activated blastocysts by in situ hybridization using specific labelled sense and antisense RNA probes, and the protein expression of the same was analysed by immunocytochemistry., Results: In situ hybridization revealed IL-1alpha and IL-6 mRNA localization in normal, dormant and activated blastocysts and a differential expression was observed in relation to the exposure to progesterone and oestrogen. There was less expression in the dormant blastocysts as compared with the normal and activated ones, and the pattern was similar for both cytokines. Immunocytochemistry also revealed a similar pattern of protein expression to that of the mRNA expression for both the cytokines., Conclusions: Using a delayed implantation model, we show that mouse blastocysts express both IL-1alpha and IL-6 mRNA as well as their respective proteins. Both mRNA and the protein levels of IL-1alpha and IL-6 seem to be hormonally modulated in mouse blastocysts during implantation.

Focussing attention on cytokines at the materno-foetal interface represents one of the major advances made in the field. This owes much to the visionary views of Tom Wegmann, and to the changes brought about in the field by immunotrophism and Th1/Th2 paradigms. We review these briefly and also point out some emerging problems.However, a certain number of newly discovered cytokines do not fit into the classical Th1/Th2 dichotomy. Yet, by their capacity to activate or downregulate NK cells, by their action on adhesion molecules, and by their regulatory effects on the vascularisation process, they are of possible interest within the materno-foetal relationship. Therefore, as a first step, we have undertaken a systematic study of the expression of IL-11, IL-12, IL-13, IL-15, IL-16, IL-17 and IL-18 in the uterus, the peri-implantation embryo, and later on decidual and placental tissues throughout pregnancy. These cytokines were detected in every case, with, in each case, a precise localisation, which will be detailed, and which indeed suggests important regulatory functions, especially during implantation. In some cases, as will be shown in the peri-implantation uterus, those cells are perfectly expressed by uterine GMG-NK-like cells. Comparative ELISAs and quantitative RT-PCR have been or are being conducted, but already the expression patterns that are observed, and the very precise window of appearance that is observed for some of the GMG NK-like cells, either around or in the implanting embryo, as well as the complexity of the respective distributions, strongly suggest that, as useful as it certainly was for a while, the Th1/Th2 paradigm must now be considered as an over-simplification. Rather, the existing data point to sequential windows and are suggestive of a system where an extreme complexity is allied to very precise timing and tuning. They also suggest that the materno-foetal relationship is not simply maternal tolerance of a foreign tissue, but a series of intricate mutual cytokine interactions governing selective immune regulation and also control of the adhesion and vascularisation processes during this dialogue.

The immunotrophic theory was enunciated by Tom Wegmann. Since then, the involvement of cytokines in implantation and materno-fetal tolerance has emerged as a central topic in reproductive immunology. This brief survey covers the historical background leading to the specification of the crucial role of cytokines at the feto-maternal interface, and the present known patterns of their function. Focus is addressed to the most recent concept, e.g. pregnancy as a Th2 phenomenon (the immune response of the mother is biased towards the production of anti inflammatory cytokines, amongst them IL-10 which suppress inflammatory responses). A brief description of the role of inflammatory cytokines in implantation is presented to explain why it does not fit into such a scheme, and other recent data, for example on gamma interferon, also fails to accord with the Th2 phenomenon.