Search

Background. Although numerous important contributions have originated from basic science research performed by surgeons, it seems that such dedicated work is becoming increasingly difficult to accomplish. What are the reasons for this change and what improvements can be made? This study aims to characterize the basic research training and careers of senior academic surgeons to assess and devise strategies for sustaining productive and quality surgical research. Methods. A 25-item survey was sent to 850 senior-level members of academic societies, including the Association of Academic Surgeons, Society of University Surgeons, and American Surgical Association. It addressed each surgeon's clinical and research training and career, as well as opinions concerning surgical research. Results. Three hundred seventy-seven (44%) surveys were received. Mean age was 64 years, and 73% were full professors. Seventy-two percent of respondents performed basic science research during training, and for 71% of this group, research was a significant reason for choosing a clinical specialty. Ninety-one percent performed research in the same specialty area during and after training. Of those who performed research during training, a full 99% continued to perform research on completion of training. However, 38% stopped performing basic research by age 39. Seventeen and twenty-three percent stopped basic research between 40 and 49 and between 50 and 59 years of age, respectively. The most common factors causing them to stop were increased clinical load (40%) and increased administrative duties (38%). For respondents who had stopped research prior to age 40, 73% cited increased clinical load as the primary reason. Eighty-five percent felt a dedicated research period should be included in surgery training. Conclusions. Most respondents had participated in basic research during training, and continued similar research after training. However, an overwhelming clinical practice at the junior faculty level seemed to hinder research. We conclude: (1) the majority consensus is that research training is integral to the development of academic surgeons; (2) such research training opportunities appear adequate; however, (3) faculty performing research, particularly at the junior level, need to be better protected from other academic duties, such as clinical practice and administration. The challenge to the leadership of academic surgery will be to enhance such research productivity in the context of increasing academic demands.

A retrospective review of patients treated for carcinoma of the common bile duct has demonstrated improvement in diagnostic capabilities, leading to earlier management by resectional therapy. The ability to resect these tumors is directly translatable to improved long-term survival. Efforts to obtain proof of malignancy prior to resection are often frustrated by the inability to obtain adequate representative tissue for frozen section. Choledochoscopic biopsies and incisional biopsies have given the highest yield of positive diagnoses. In experienced hands, a program of fewer preoperative tests with emphasis on early operation, diagnosis, and definitive treatment may be more cost-effective in the management of patients with common bile duct cancer.

We reviewed the records of 340 patients with a tissue diagnosis of pancreatic cancer treated at UCLA Medical Center between 1973 and 1988. Sixty-one patients underwent pancreatic resection (group I), 173 had some form of surgical palliation (group II), and 106 had neither (group III). The diagnosis was made 1 to 2 months more quickly in the last 8 years of the review than in the first 8 years, but the effect of early diagnosis on curability was negligible. Biliary obstruction was best treated by cholecystojejunostomy or choledochojejunostomy, which were equally effective. Anastomoses to the jejunum were safer and more effective than were those to the duodenum for the relief of biliary obstruction. Gastrojejunostomy should be performed prophylactically as well as therapeutically. It was effective and safe in both settings. Surgical palliation for pancreatic cancer was generally effective and was associated with an operative mortality rate of less than 10%. However morbidity was high, with significant complications occurring in one third of cases.

Objectives To characterize the career choices and developments made by leading senior surgeons in this country and to examine hypothetically whether application of a short tracking program would have hindered their career decisions. Design A survey pertaining to each surgeon's career, decisions, and opinions concerning surgical training. Setting and Participants Senior surgeons of regional and national surgical societies. Main Outcome Measure Survey responses. Results A total of 352 surveys (41.4%) were received. Respondents answered that the most common reasons for choosing a specialty were role models or mentors (56%), research (51%), and available patient population (23%). The 2 most common stages in a career at which the respondents became interested in a specialty, or an area of expertise, were at the junior residency level (when the specialty was chosen) and at the assistant professor level (when a more specific topic within the specialty was chosen). The most common stage at which the group believed they acquired their expertise was also at the assistant professor level. Seventy-one percent of respondents believed broad training was superior to a short tracking system, although none had participated in shortened surgical training. Conclusions Most leading senior surgeons in this country still believe that broad surgical training is superior and should be maintained. Because career specialties in this surveyed group were generally chosen in early residency, a hypothetical application of the short tracking system would have still allowed for these important decisions to be made. Also, it seems likely that specialty and career development would not have been hindered because "expertization" mostly occurred after training was completed. Regardless of training method, a role model or mentor seems most important in career choices and developments.

In an effort to determine the role of interventional radiologic and endoscopic techniques in the management of benign biliary strictures, a retrospective analysis was carried out on 194 consecutive patients with bile duct strictures treated at UCLA between 1955 and 1990. Patients were classified as group 1 (1955 through 1979; n = 138) or group 2 (1980 through 1989; n = 56). Follow-up was for a minimum of 24 months and was in excess of 3 years in 179 patients (92%). Although the incidence of recurrent strictures was similar in the two groups (21% and 23%), the reoperation rate was significantly lower (P less than .02) in group 2 (6%) than in group 1 (21%). Percutaneous transhepatic biliary dilatation, used in 20 patients in group 2, was successful in 13 (93%) of 14 patients with anastomotic strictures and three (50%) of six patients with primary strictures (P less than .05). We conclude that surgical reconstruction remains the standard therapy for patients with primary bile duct strictures. Percutaneous transhepatic biliary dilatation has limited usefulness for these patients, but may be more appropriate for those with anastomotic strictures.

In the US, the remarkable decline in the incidence of gastric cancer during the mid-portion of this century has leveled off during the last two decades as an equally remarkable and poorly understood increase in the percentage of the generally more unfavorable cardia cancers has become apparent. The importance of H. pylori infection is being actively investigated and treatment to reduce the infection may offer a means of decreasing the disease, particularly in areas of high incidence. The potential danger of inciting gastric cancer by the prolonged use of drugs that severely reduce or eliminate gastric acid has been mentioned, but the degree of risk must await the passage of years before it can be properly evaluated. "Early gastric cancer" or, probably more appropriately, "superficial gastric adenocarcinoma" continues to comprise a relatively small segment of gastric cancers in the US and most Western countries. Seventeen per cent of cases in the ACS series were classified as stage I, a much higher incidence than reported for early gastric cancer in most individual North American series. The ACS report suggests "special education of the surgeon in the requisites for adequate gastrectomy with node dissection, coupled with effective adjuvant therapy" as a means of improving results in the US. This is a significant consideration because, unfortunately, gastric surgery for ulcer or cancer no longer plays the important role it did in past decades in many US surgical training programs. As has been demonstrated in Japan and in certain larger US series, excellent surgical technique, particularly for cardia tumors, plays an important role in obtaining improved results. The value of radical lymph node dissection continues to be controversial in US cases, and a successful chemotherapeutic regimen has yet to be found. Subtotal gastric resection, as noted in the ACS report, continues to be the procedure of choice in the US for most gastric cancers, even for cardia cancers. Although there is no improvement in survival, quality of life is thought by some to be better after total gastrectomy for cardia cancers rather than proximal subtotal esophagogastrectomy. However, equally important for improved survival is the ACS recommendation of earlier referral for gastric surgery patients with precursor lesions, but the lack of improvement in the pathological stage of disease in the two ACS time periods suggests that little progress is being made in this country in this regard.

• Recent studies have advocated the nonoperative treatment of elderly patients with bile duct cancer using biliary endoprostheses. In addition to a 30-day mortality rate of 9%, disadvantages with this approach include lack of a definitive diagnosis and the inability to assess resectability. For comparison, we reviewed 42 consecutive cases of bile duct cancer managed surgically at UCLA (from 1954 to 1988) among patients age 70 years or older. Histologic confirmation of bile duct cancer was obtained for 40 surgical patients (95%) in the series. The 30-day mortality rate was 10%. There was a trend to more aggressive surgical management during the study, with a concomitant doubling in survival rates (from 21% among patients treated between 1954 and 1978 to 53% among patients treated between 1979 and 1988 at 1 year after surgery.) We conclude that elderly patients should not be denied surgical evaluation of malignant neoplasms of the bile duct simply on the basis of age. (Arch Surg. 1991;126:1186-1191)

• Improvement in survival rates for solid tumors, the cancers of greatest concern to the surgeon, has lagged far behind the dramatic advances that have been made in the treatment of leukemias, lymphomas, and certain childhood tumors. The application of new technical procedures and an aggressive approach to certain metastatic lesions offer chances for improving operative results, but the greatest contribution to curing cancer that can be made by surgeons at this time is the complete removal of the small localized primary tumor. By more active participation in "early detection programs" surgeons can increase their opportunities to treat cancer at this stage. The American College of Surgeons, in consultation with the National Cancer Institute, has conducted a detailed survey that analyzes the lack of surgical participation in clinical trials with a view toward developing a more active surgical interest in evaluating new methods of treatment for the solid tumors. One of the current efforts to improve the outcome of these recalcitrant cancers involves increasing the number of trained surgical scientists in the field of cancer. (Arch Surg. 1990;125:158-162)

The method of surgeon payment influences several important aspects of surgical care. The preoperative processes of laboratory tests and radiographic procedures were performed more frequently and less selectively by salaried surgeons without any corresponding improvement in outcome. Socioeconomic factors and difference in severity of disease accounted for most of the variations in outcome, but in appendicitis there was a trend for fee-for-service surgeons to undertake earlier operation resulting in fewer secondary complications. Although the patient-physician relationship was least developed by salaried surgeons, this was not reflected in any less knowledge of the procedure by the patient or dissatisfaction with surgical care. Operative workloads were highest for surgeons receiving salary plus percentage in fee-for-service group practice.

Over a 21 year period, 245 cases of cancer of the pancreas were operated upon and followed-up at UCLA Hospital. A further 34 cases of periampullary tumor were treated by partial or total pancreatectomy. Apparent clearance of tumors at the time of pancreaticoduodenectomy that was confirmed by subsequent histopathology resulted in a patient survival time of 20.3 months as compared with a figure of 12.9 months when the pathological examination revealed tumor in a resection margin, although the surgeon believed that excision had been complete at the time of operation. Frozen section examination of resection margins is therefore mandatory. The result of performing a pancreaticoduodenectomy in which tumor was seen to be left behind was a survival time of only 6.8 months, which is similar to the survival time of 6.2 months following a palliative biliary bypass. Pancreaticoduodenectomy in patients over the age of 70 resulted in an average survival of only 7.6 months. Of patients having a palliative biliary bypass alone, 13% required subsequent reoperation to bypass distressing duodenal obstruction. A duodenal bypass should therefore be a routine concomitant of a biliary bypass. Total pancreatectomy with duodenectomy for pancreatic cancer gave an increased average survival of 26 months, and it is likely that the frequency of performance of this operation will increase.

Jaundice is rarely encountered in polycystic disease of the liver. In the present case, pressure from tense cysts at the hilus of the liver caused a marked narrowing of the common hepatic duct and slowing of bile flow with the formation of stasis stones. Decompression of the cysts and removal of debris in the intrahepatic ducts resulted in a rapid decrease of the serum bilirubin level.

For many years, the classical Whipple procedure has been the standard operative treatment for resectable periampullary cancer. Recently, the pylorus preservation operation has also been applied to periampullary tumours. This newer procedure has potential advantages in terms of ease of performance and postoperative physiology, but has yet to be proved as an adequate cancer operation. We, therefore, undertook the present retrospective analysis to compare the outcome following the pylorus preservation operation (n = 13) with that of the classical Whipple resection (n = 13) in 26 patients with histologically proved adenocarcinoma of the head of the pancreas. The two groups of patients were comparable for age, sex, pre-operative laboratory data, and resected margins free from tumour. More patients undergoing the classical Whipple resection had Stage I disease (10 versus 4, P < 0.05). However, this difference would not be significant if the two patients in the pylorus preservation group with carcinomas in situ were considered to have stage I disease. Mean tumour diameter in the pylorus preservation patient group (3·2±0·6 cm) was smaller (P

In a series of 50 patients with cancer of the pancreas who wee undergoing resection of the pancreatic head and the duodenum, the average survival was 16.2 months. If the resected margin was free of tumor the average survival was 20.3 months. In 103 less favourable cases treated by biliary bypass, with or without gastroenterostomy, the average survival was only 6.2 months. Although these series are not comparable, pancreaticoduodenal resection for cancer of the pancreas and periampullary area has been utilized in cases without distant metastases in an effort to extend the period of palliation and to achieve occasional long-term survival. Currently available diagnostic techniques may permit earlier diagnosis and improved results. A positive tissue diagnosis is not essential before proceeding with resection, but this aspect of the operation should be fully discussed with the patient. An unfavorable condition of the residual pancreas for anastomosis, or a positive frozen section examination of the pancreas at the line of transection may indicate total pancreatectomy, but complete resection is not used routinely. The incidence of jejunal ulceration, a serious late postoperative complication, may be reduced by utilizing a 60-70% gastric resection or antrectomy and vagotomy.

Major hepatic resections were performed on 138 patients for a variety of conditions. There was one intraoperative death. Including this patient, there were 15 deaths within 30 days of the operation (operative mortality 10.9%). Important postoperative complications were intra-abdominal sepsis (17%), biliary leak (11%), hepatic failure (8%), and hemorrhage (6%). The results of 30 resections for the benign lesions, liver cell adenoma, focal nodular hyperplasia, hemangioma, and cystadenoma showed no operative mortality and low morbidity. Of 26 patients with hepatocellular carcinoma, seven died within a month of operation. The cumulative survival of the 26 at five years was 38%, and of the 19 who survived the procedure, 51%. Poor survival followed resections for cholangiocarcinoma and "mixed tumors." The five-year cumulative survival of 22 patients who had colorectal metastases excised was 31%. Apart from a patient with carcinoid, prolonged survival was rare after resection of other secondaries and after en bloc resections for tumors directly invading the liver. Hepatic resection was of value in the management of some patients with hepatic trauma, Caroli's disease, liver cysts, and intrahepatic stones.

Reports, early in this century, on the treatment of portal hypertension by surgical diversion of the portal blood flow about the liver were largely ignored because of the anticipated high mortality. Whipple, Blakemore and Lord in the early 1940's described a technique of performing a splenorenal or portacaval shunt with an epithelial lined vitallium tube. Blalock, whom I assisted, was one of the first outside of the Whipple Group to successfully perform such an operation. Although he used the vitallium tube technique in his first cases he soon became convinced that the results were better with a direct suture anastomosis. Venous shunts, which seemed such a logical way to treat portal hypertension, were widely and quickly adopted. Little attention was paid to the problem of portal encephalopathy which had been described in experimental animals years before by Pavlov. As some of the follow up studies on these shunted patients began to appear it was evident that this was a common and at times a severe problem. Some of the earliest doubts about the shunt operation were expressed by surgeons in Japan. The most successful methods developed to date for the treatment of portal hypertension provided a shunt for blood from the esophageal variceal region while at the same time preserving portal blood flow through the liver. Two of these methods have been (1) the distal or selective splenorenal shunt proposed by Warren & Zeppa and (2) the coronary caval shunt first described by Inokuchi. These methods, although somewhat more difficult technically than end to side portacaval shunts, reduce portal hypertension and preserve blood flow through the liver thereby lowering significantly the incidence of encephalopathy. The vascular stapling instrument developed by Professor Inokuchi in the 1950's has allowed him to perform this and other types of difficult vascular surgery with excellent results.

Four patients with hepatic cell adenoma have been treated at the UCLA Hospital since 1965. The most recent was a 22-year-old woman who underwent subtotal resection of a giant hepatic cell adenoma after an unusual and confusing clinical presentation. The tumor may be the largest reported to date and may have excreted metabolically-active substances. Increased familiarity with the varying clinical and radiographic presentations of these rare tumors may facilitate earlier diagnosis and management.

Three patients with biopsy proven histiocytosis X who developed a clinical and pathological picture compatible with sclerosing cholangitis are reported. In one patient, operative biopsy of the common bile duct revealed histiocytosis X in the granulomatous/xanthomatous phase. At necropsy, however, only fibrosis of the biliary tree was seen, a picture consistent with sclerosing cholangitis. Fibrotic obstruction of the biliary tree led to death from liver failure in all three patients. The aetiology of primary sclerosing cholangitis is unknown and may be multifactorial. Perhaps involvement of the biliary tree by histiocytosis X is one cause.

Despite recent advances in perioperative support care, surgery for obstructive jaundice is still associated with significant morbidity and mortality. For this reason, preoperative percutaneous transhepatic drainage (PTD) has been recommended for these patients. This method of management, however, has only been supported by retrospective and nonrandomized studies. Therefore, a prospective, randomized study was performed to determine the effect of preoperative PTD on operative mortality, morbidity, hospital stay, and hospital cost. Thirty-day mortality was 8.1% among 37 patients undergoing preoperative PTD, compared to 5.3% for 38 patients who went to surgery without preoperative drainage. Overall morbidity was also slightly, but not significantly, higher in patients who underwent preoperative PTD, (57% versus 53%). However, total hospital stay was significantly longer (p less than 0.005) in the PTD group (31.4 days versus 23.1 days). The cost of this excess hospitalization and the PTD procedure at our university medical center was over +8000 per patient. The authors conclude that preoperative PTD does not reduce operative risk but does increase hospital cost and, therefore, should not be performed routinely.

Management of the Pancreas After Pancreaticoduodenectomy SHERRELL ASTON;WILLIAM LONGMIRE; Annals of Surgery

Although pyloric preservation can be performed during pancreaticoduodenectomy without increased morbidity or mortality or decreased survival, the long-term benefit of this technique remains unproven. In this study, the functional status of patients recovered from pyloric-preserving pancreaticoduodenectomy was evaluated by comparing 6 long-term survivors of the standard Whipple procedure (1–7 years postoperative; mean, 4.7 yr) to a similar group of 6 patients recovered from pylorus preservation pancreaticoduodenectomy (1–7 years postoperative; mean, 3.0 yr). All patients completed a questionnaire evaluating postgastrectomy symptoms. Fasting blood specimens were obtained for hematologic and biochemical analysis. Ten of the 12 patients then underwent endoscopy; perianastomotic and midgastric biopsies were graded for inflammation. Gastric emptying of both liquid and solid phases was measured with an isotopically-labeled meal. Gastric emptying data were compared between groups and also to a group of 7 normal controls studied previously using the same methodology. Analysis of questionnaire results and mean laboratory values revealed no significant differences between the 2 surgical groups. Serum carotene levels were low in most patients. Several patients demonstrated abnormal indices of iron homeostasis. No significant abnormalities were noted on endoscopic examinations and biopsy results did not differ between the 2 surgical groups. Liquid gastric emptying was significantly prolonged in patients following standard pancreaticoduodenectomy (t1/2=98.3±26.2 min) as compared to pylorus preservation patients (t1/2=37.5±10.9 min) or normal controls (t1/2=33.1±2.8 min). We conclude that, in the long-term, pylorus preservation appears to be at least functionally equivalent to the standard pancreaticoduodenectomy. As such, we believe that pyloric preservation, obviating vagotomy and gastric resection, deserves consideration during pancreaticoduodenectomy.

Records were reviewed for all patients who underwent primary treatment for adenocarcinoma of the stomach at two UCLA hospitals between 1956 and 1975. Division of the data into two, ten-year time periods reveals a pattern of unchanging presentation and pathologic characteristics which probably accounts for the unaltered response to operative therapy. The consistency of certain prognostic findings justifies a surgical approach in which extensive resections are only selectively employed.

Surgeons who are completing their training should be enabled to assume final patient responsibility for 1 year in an environment where they can easily obtain advice and guidance. A cooperative adjustment in the number of surgical specialists should be made as long as inadequately qualified physicians are appropriately retrained. Separate training programs should be considered to emphasize experience with frequently performed low-risk procedures. Equitable entrance requirements should be established for all graduates of various preparatory health care schools not endorsed by the CCME who might be qualified for admission to approved surgical training programs and subsequent Specialty Board examinations. We should be prepared to assist in the making of difficult recommendations regarding priorities in the expenditure of health care dollars as funds become increasingly restricted. A surgeon's performance should be monitored in his hospital and as long as he meets locally approved standards of practice, all other quality control measures should be optional. The development of surgical investigators should be encouraged by providing financial and job stability during the prolonged period required for research and surgical training. Much of what I have said regarding medical education, practice and research is related to the role of the government. What will be the rules and regulations of the government under which our schools must operate and our surgical practice and research be conducted in the future? How much money will the government offer to support education and research, and what funds will be available for patient care? Obviously, the profession has taken on a big, aggressive, domineering partner in all of these fields since many of us graduated from medical school. Our governmental partner is fairly new to the problems of medicine, but since many of today's problems are also new to us, we must learn to work effectively with the government and all of its agencies as we attempt to meet the challenges of the future.

Injuries to the porta hepatis pose difficult problems in management, and transection of the bile ducts, portal vein and hepatic artery is among the most challenging. Twenty-one patients with severe injuries to the porta hepatis were treated over a ten-year period. Ages ranged from 13 to 56 years, and follow-up was up to nine years. Among the 14 patients with bile duct injury, eight were found to have complete transection, and five suffered a tangential laceration or incomplete disruption with a portion of a duct wall remaining intact. Five of the eight patients who had complete transection underwent primary end-to-end repair with T-tube splinting, while three were treated with primary Roux-en-Y choledocojejunostomy. All patients with incomplete disruption underwent primary repair with or without T-tube splinting. Of the five patients with complete disruption who were treated with primary end-to-end anastomosis of the bile duct in conjunction with T-tube splinting, all required secondary biliary tract reconstruction of some type. No patient with complete transection that was treated with primary Roux-en-Y biliary enteric anastomosis required reoperation. Partial transections were successfully treated with primary repair. Portal vein injury was encountered in ten patients. Injury was successfully managed by primary closure, interposition of a vein, or splenicmesenteric vein bypass. Associated injuries to liver, pancreas, kidney and duodenum were common. In four patients there was injury to the main or left or right hepatic artery which was managed successfully by repair or ligation, with or without hepatic lobectomy. By adhering to the principles of management to be outlined, many patients with injury to the porta hepatis will survive, and the long term outcome can be gratifying.