Search

Objectives. Evidence regarding the long-term impact of health and other community development programs on under-5 mortality (the risk of death from birth until the fifth birthday) is limited. We compared mortality in a population served by health and other community development programs at the Hôpital Albert Schweitzer (HAS) with national mortality rates among children younger than 5 years for Haiti between 1958 and 1999. Methods. We collected information on births and deaths in the HAS service area between 1995 and 1999 and assembled previously published under-5 mortality rates at HAS. Published national rates for Haiti served as a comparison. Results. In the early 1970s, the under-5 mortality rate at HAS declined to a level three fourths lower than that in Haiti nationwide. More recently, HAS rates have remained at one half those for Haiti nationwide. Child survival interventions in the HAS service area were substantially higher than in Haiti nationwide although socioeconomic characteristics and levels of childhood malnutrition were similar in both areas. Conclusions. HAS’s programs have been responsible for long-term sustained reduction in mortality among children aged less than 5 years. Integrated systems for health and other community development programs could be an effective strategy for achieving the United Nations Millennium Goal to reduce under-5 mortality two thirds by 2015.

Background: The degree to which local health systems contribute to reductions in under-five mortality in severely impoverished settings has not been well documented. The current study compares the under-five mortality in the Hopital Albert Schweitzer (HAS) Primary Health Care Service Area with that for Haiti in general. HAS provides an integrated system of community-based primary health care services, hospital care and community development. Methods: A sample of 10% of the women of reproductive age in the HAS service area was interviewed, and 2390 live births and 149 child deaths were documented for the period 1995-99. Under-five mortality rates were computed and compared with rates for Haiti. In addition, available data regarding inputs, processes and outputs for the HAS service area and for Haiti were assembled and compared. Results: Under-five mortality was 58% less in the HAS service area, and mortality for children 12-59 months of age was 76% less. These results were achieved with an input of fewer physicians and hospital beds per capita than is available for Haiti nationwide, but with twice as many graduate nurses and auxiliary nurses per capita than are available nationwide, and with three cadres of health workers that do not exist nationwide: Physician Extenders, Health Agents and Community Health Volunteers. The population coverage of targeted child survival services was generally 1.5-2 times higher in the HAS service area than in rural Haiti. Discussion: These findings support the conclusion that a well-developed system of primary health care, with outreach services to the household level, integrated with hospital referral care and community development programmes, can make a strong contribution to reducing infant and child mortality in severely impoverished settings.

Lessons learned from Haiti's integration of a training program for traditional birth attendants with the maternal and child health and family planning program are reported. The available data on illness and deaths reveal that Haiti has continuing problems of gastroenteritis, malnutrition, tuberculosis, malaria, and tetanus. The latter is of particular interest since neonatal tetanus derived from umbilical cord contamination continues to affect up to 10-20% of Haitian newborns in rural areas lacking health programs. Neonatal tetanus has largely disappeared in the Artibonite Valley due to a mass immunization program for the entire population, including young women, against tetanus. In the Albert Schweitzer Hospital program for indigenous midwives in Artibonite Valley, at least 36 midwives were reached on a regular basis in 1968 -- less than 1/3 of the midwives operating in the Artibonite Valley. There was a rapid decline in neonatal tetanus admissions during the period following 1968. This decline has been attributed to the use of rural health auxiliaries in immunizing the women in the hospital district, but indigenous midwives may have played a role. By 1970, the Albert Schweitzer Hospital program had grown from 36 midwives regularly attending midwife classes to 175 registered with the program during 1970. Although direct supervision proved difficult due to lack of communication and transport to the scene of delivery, some deliveries were observed and indirect supervision by the community became evident. An important finding of the traditional midwife training program of the Albert Schweitzer Hospital was the amount of time required for an indigenous midwife to have referred 50 newborns to the hospital for BCG vaccination. At the end of the 1st year of this program, only 2 midwives reached this goal. Another surprise was the increase in demand for "cord cut" services at the outpatient clinic rather than increased use of the nearby maternity unit. The elimination of neonatal tetanus as a cause of infant mortality was the most important outcome of the maternal and child health component of the community health program.

Deaths and their causes in a rural Haitian population of 8820 were studied through hospital records, death registration, a disease survey, and health surveillance. The results were used in selecting eight diseases for the delivery of health services by village-level health workers. The impact of the services was measured by monitoring annual age-specific and disease-specific mortality rates and by comparing them with officially estimated national mortality rates. Mortality rates fell progressively during five years, to levels only one fourth as high as the national estimates. The fall in mortality was associated principally with services that prevented deaths due to tetanus, malnutrition, diarrhea, and tuberculosis. The total program of hospital and village health services saved 495 years of potential life per thousand population per year. Most of the saving was attributable to preventive services. The program eventually served more than 115,000 persons, and it has been replicated by other agencies for an additional 135,000 Haitians.Deaths and their causes in a rural Haitian population of 8820 were studied through hospital records, death registration, a disease survey, and health surveillance. The results were used in selecting 8 diseases for the delivery of health services by village-level health workers. The impact of the services was measured by monitoring annual age-specific and disease-specific mortality rates and by comparing them with officially estimated national mortality rates. Mortality rates fell progressively during 5 years, to levels only 1/4 as high as the national estimates. The fall in mortality was associated principally with services that prevented deaths due to tetanus, malnutrition, diarrhea, and tuberculosis. The total program of hospital and village health services saved 495 years of potential life/thousand population/year. Most of the saving was attributable to preventive services. The program eventually served more than 115,000 persons, and it has been replicated by other agencies for an additional 135,000 Haitians.