Objectives Although pancreas transplants were started at our center in 2014, the number of pancreases procured have remained low. This report presents an audit of donors over the past 18 months with the aim to identify factors preventing pancreas utilization. Methods This was a retrospective study. All deceased donors from January 2018 to July 2019 were included in this study. The medical records of deceased donors were reviewed with regard to donor characteristics such as demographics, biochemical parameters, and preterminal management. Results Organs were retrieved from 49 deceased donors over the duration of the study. Mean age of the donors was 35.34 ± 18.2 years (11 months to 72 years). Most donors were men (M:F 41:8). In total, 45/49 (92%) donors had central nervous system trauma as a cause of brain death. Out of 49, multiple abdominal organs were retrieved from 21 donors (42.8%), whereas kidneys alone were retrieved from the rest. Pancreases were retrieved from 8 donors (16.3%). Pancreases were rejected in 21 donors (42.8%) because of age limit criteria. Other reasons for refusal included donor sepsis (n = 12, 24.5%), severe hemodynamic instability (n = 5, 10.2%), donation after cardiac death (DCD) (n = 2, 4.1%), and ischemic hepatitis (n = 7, 14.3%) while 3 (6.1%) donations happened while awaiting license renewal. A suitable recipient was not available for 1 donor (2.0%). Conclusion Pancreas retrieval rates remain low because of donor-related factors. Expansion of age limits and better donor management could improve pancreas transplant activity.