1. Newborn with Ohtahara Syndrome and absence of respiratory trigger: ethical issues in the NICU|Neonata con Sindrome di Ohtahara e assenza di trigger respiratorio: questioni etiche in Terapia Intensiva Neonatale
- Author
-
Corsano, Barbara, Sacchini, Dario, Vento, Giovanni, Costa, Simonetta, Esposito, Alice, Battaglia, Domenica Immacolata, Quintiliani, Michela, Spagnolo, Antonio Gioacchino, Corsano B., Sacchini D. (ORCID:0000-0002-1581-3018), Vento G. (ORCID:0000-0002-8132-5127), Costa S., Esposito A., Battaglia D. (ORCID:0000-0003-0491-4021), Quintiliani M., Spagnolo A. G. (ORCID:0000-0002-5762-2164), Corsano, Barbara, Sacchini, Dario, Vento, Giovanni, Costa, Simonetta, Esposito, Alice, Battaglia, Domenica Immacolata, Quintiliani, Michela, Spagnolo, Antonio Gioacchino, Corsano B., Sacchini D. (ORCID:0000-0002-1581-3018), Vento G. (ORCID:0000-0002-8132-5127), Costa S., Esposito A., Battaglia D. (ORCID:0000-0003-0491-4021), Quintiliani M., and Spagnolo A. G. (ORCID:0000-0002-5762-2164)
- Abstract
Introduction: Ohtahara syndrome (OS) is a rare drug-resistant epileptic encephalopathy characterized by frequent tonic spasms or focal motor seizures associated with the specific electroencephalographic pattern of burst suppression. It begins in the first months of life and represents less than 4% of childhood epilepsy cases. The prognosis depends from the aetiology and is generally poor with death in most cases during early childhood. The management of severe encephalopathies associated with OS is controversial, especially regarding the strategies to ensure the well-being of young patients and their families, requiring a continuous modulation of medical interventions: from the intensity of care waiting for the diagnosis, to palliative care where a prognosis of incurability, up to the possible desist from intensive/invasive treatments when they are no longer proportionate to the current clinical situation. Objective: Through the case of M, a 38-week-old newborn, intubated and mechanically ventilated since birth due to the absence of spontaneous respiratory activity, for whom the clinical diagnosis of OS was reached at about 4 months of life, we intend to investigate the related ethical issues: a. the proportionality and ethical-clinical appropriateness of treatments in patients for whom a poor prognosis quoad vitam is reached; b. the decision-making process to be shared with the parents, those were unable to accept the irreversibility of their daughter's illness, despite the psychological support offered to them from the beginning. Discussion: In a situation of probably irreversible pathology, such as severe encephalopathy with cortico-subcortical dysfunction and electrical-clinical picture of OS, associated with the absence of respiratory trigger, in which elements capable of modifying the prognosis quoad vitam do not emerge, and it is difficult for the parents to elaborate awareness about the seriousness of the disease, it becomes difficult to identify the limits
- Published
- 2023