Search

The Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act (PPACA) was signed into law President Barack Obama in March 2010. From the standpoint of a clinical surgeon, Dan Ullyot examines healthcare reform of the US system and asks: What is healthcare reform? Do we need it? What would ideal reform look like? And to what extent does the PPACA approach ideal reform? This article is a primer for understanding the salient features of this complex piece of federal legislation, which will have an enormous influence on the lives of this generation and those of the future.

Objectives: This study was undertaken to determine the extent to which cardiovascular specialists are involved with and affected by managed care and to ascertain their attitudes toward it. This survey also served as the follow-up to an initial study on the subject performed by the American College of Cardiology in 1993., Background: The initial 1993 study was performed to address the lack of any comprehensive examination of the impact of managed care on cardiovascular specialists. In 1995, to reexplore this question and follow up the 1993 findings, the College conducted a survey of its membership in the following areas: 1) physician relationship with managed care plans; 2) number of managed care contracts; 3) breakdown of revenue by payment source; 4) changes in practice in response to managed care; and 5) physician attitudes toward managed care. To the extent feasible, the 1995 questionnaire paralleled the 1993 instrument to facilitate comparisons., Methods: A questionnaire was mailed to 5,147 practicing College members in the United States, who were categorized by specialty as pediatric cardiologists, adult cardiologists or cardiovascular surgeons. Mailings were sent to 1) all pediatric cardiologists and cardiovascular surgeons; 2) randomly selected adult cardiologists practicing in 10 states with high managed care penetration; and 3) randomly selected adult cardiologists in the nine U.S. census areas who were not practicing in the 10 states with high managed care penetration., Results: Usable surveys were returned by 1,236 respondents, for an overall response rate of 24%. Involvement with at least one type of managed care organization was reported by 89% of respondents, up from 76% in 1993. Although managed care relationships had increased across physician age, region, practice and specialty, respondents indicated that, on average, well below 50% of their practice revenues stem from managed care contracts. To adapt to the managed care environment, strategic practice changes, such as joining a cardiovascular network, implementing continuous quality improvement systems and adopting clinical pathways, were being instituted by most respondent practices of nine or more physicians. Smaller groups were less active. Most respondents involved with managed care disliked its effects, particularly in clinical matters. Their attitudes toward the assumption of risk, managed fee-for-service arrangements and a private versus single-payer system show that there is no uniformity of opinion regarding the best means to contain costs and promote efficiency., Conclusions: Managed care has become an established part of cardiovascular specialist practice in the United States. Although this trend is viewed with some disfavor, most respondents are making practice changes to adapt to this new environment.

Objective: Our goal was to determine if breath-hold cine MRI in transaxial planes can be used for the evaluation of thoracic aortic dissection instead of conventional cine MRI since rapid imaging is required in this clinical setting., Materials and Methods: Twelve patients with thoracic aortic dissection were imaged using a 1.5 T imager. Breath-hold images were acquired with fast cine MR sequence (TR/TE = 9/2.8, 20 degrees flip angle) using segmented k-space data acquisition. Conventional non-breath-hold cine MR images (TR/TE = 22/7.5, 35 degrees flip angle, 2 averages) were taken with flow and respiratory compensation., Results: Sharpness of edges of the vessels on fast cine MR images was better than that on conventional cine MR images in 34 (57%) of 60 images. Inhomogeneous blood signal in aortic lumen due to motion artifacts was found in 2 (3%) of fast cine MR images and in 15 (25%) of conventional cine MR images. The contrast-to-noise ratios of fast cine MR images were significantly better than those of conventional cine MR images (26.4 +/- 9.1 vs. 18.5 +/- 10.1; p < 0.05) when the region of interest for noise was placed to include ghosting artifacts., Conclusion: Breath-hold cine MRI is a rapid technique that gives high quality images of thoracic aortic dissection and can provide a diagnosis in < 10 min of imaging time.

The optimal management of patients with small aortic anulus or left ventricular outflow tract obstruction remains unclear. Between 1976 and March, 1982; 18 patients have undergone enlargement of their left ventricular outflow tract by means of the Konno or a modification of the Konno procedure. Fourteen of these 18 patients had previous operations for aortic stenosis or tunnel left ventricular outflow tract, and two patients had undergone three previous operations. All 18 patients had symptoms of either heart failure of chest pain, or had electrocardiographic evidence of strain. They ranged in age from 4 years to 58 years, with 13 of the 18 patients being less than 20 years of age. A Dacron patch was used to enlarge the left ventricular outflow tract after incising down the ventricular septum. In all patients, at least a 21 mm valve could be placed, with between 50% and 65% of the valve anulus being made up of natural tissue. The remaining portion of the valve anulus was constructed from the Dacron patch. The patch was extended up to enlarge the ascending aorta, and a pericardial patch was used to close the defect in the right ventricular outflow tract. In all 18 patients the gradient was obliterated at the time of operation. There was one early death in a patient who had previous insertion of a left ventricular apical-aortic conduit in which the heterograft valve had degenerated. There has been one late death because of bacterial endocarditis in a child who also had a parachute mitral valve and evidence of pulmonary hypertension. The remaining 16 patients are functioning well after the Konno procedure. Three are receiving warfarin sodium, and 13 are receiving aspirin. These results suggest that this is an acceptable method of treating patients with small aortic anulus or left ventricular outflow tract obstructions and would appear to have advantages over a left ventricular apical-aortic conduit.

The surgical management of symptomatic tetralogy of Fallot in infants is debatable. The question of total correction versus palliation and the type of palliative procedure remain controversial. During the past 4 years, 30 infants, aged 1 day to 12 months (mean 5.6 months) with symptomatic tetralogy of Fallot underwent either total correction (21 infants) or palliation by relieving the pulmonary stenosis with a right ventricular outflow tract patch (nine infants). The ratio of diameter of the right pulmonary artery to diameter of the ascending aorta (PA/Ao ratio) was calculated from the anteroposterior cineangiogram of all patients. There were three operative deaths in the total correction group; two of these occurred in infants with PA/Ao ratios less than 0.3. One death occurred in the 19 patients undergoing total correction with PA/Ao ratios greater than 0.3 (mortality rate 5.3%). All nine infants undergoing right ventricular outflow tract patching had PA/Ao ratios less than 0.3, and one operative death occurred in this group. Four patients who had right ventricular outflow tract patching have had repeat cardiac catheterization 2 to 15 months postoperatively. All four have shown symmetrical enlargement of the pulmonary arterial tree and significant increases in their PA/Ao ratios.

To evaluate the application of radionuclide infarct scintigraphy to diagnose myocardial infarction after revascularization, we obtained postoperative technetium 99m pyrophosphate myocardial scintigrams, serial electrocardiograms and CPK-MB isoenzymes in ten control and 51 revascularized patients. All control patients had negative electrocardiograms and scintigrams, but eight had positive isoenzymes. Eight revascularized patients had positive electrocardiograms, images and enzymes and two had positive scintigrams and enzymes with negative electrocardiograms. Thirty-four patients with negative electorcardiograms and scintigrams had positive isoenzymes; in only seven patients were all tests negative. Our data suggest radionuclide infarct scintigraphy is a useful adjunct to the electrocardiogram in diagnosing perioperative infarction. The frequent presence of CPK-MB in postoperative patients without other evidence of infarction suggests that further studies are required to identify all factors responsible for its release.

Seven of 12 patients (58%) undergoing myocardial revascularization surgery became hypertensive in the immediate postoperative period. The hypertensive patients had significant elevations in peripheral vascular resistance (22.0 +/- 2.0 S.E. resistance units) compared to measurements in normotensive patients (15.6 +/- 1.3 S.E. resistance units) (p less than 0.05), whereas the heart rates and cardiac indices were similar. Administration of thoracic epidural anesthesia to postoperatively hypertensive patients lowered systemic arterial pressure by decreasing peripheral vascular resistance (p less than 0.005) but not affecting the pulse rate and cardiac index. The ratio diastolic pressure-time index/systemic pressure-time index (DPTI/SPTI), an indirect measurement of subendocardial oxygenation, increased from preanesthetic values of 0.80 +/- 0.08 S.E. to 1.09 +/- 0.09 S.E. (p less than 0.025) after the systemic arterial pressure was lowered in postoperatively hypertensive patients. Hypertensive episodes following myocardial revascularization procedures appear related to increased alpha-adrenergic activity, which products elevation in peripheral vascular resistance. Decreasing peripheral vascular resistance by chemical sympathectomy with thoracic epidural anesthesia lowers the systemic arterial pressure and improves the DPTI/SPTI ratio.

From June 1969 to December 1974, 142 patients underwent aortocoronary bypass surgery at the Veterans Administration Hospital, San Francisco. Seventeen patients developed new Q waves; two of four deaths in the hospital occurred among these 17 patients. Preoperative and postoperative catheterization data were available for analysis in 12 of the 15 surviving patients. Longitudinal, transverse, and hemiaxial segmental analysis of preoperative and postoperative single plane, 30 degrees right anterior oblique left ventriculograms revealed deterioration in wall motion in all 12 patients. The deterioration corresponded to the area on the electrocardiogram where the new Q waves appeared. In ten of 12 patients, ejection fraction also deteriorated. Twenty-six of 29 grafts were patent. New Q waves after aortocoronary bypass surgery correlate well with the appearance of localized abnormalities in wall motion. We found no evidence that perioperative appearance of Q waves was not due to new perioperative myocardial infarction.

Fifty patients with 117 coronary bypass grafts were studied by contrast-enhanced computed tomography at an average of 5 +/- 4 days after surgery to determine if this technique was a feasible method for detecting early postoperative graft occlusion. The study was limited in only three patients because of incisional chest pain (one patient) or multiple metal clips attached to the graft (two patients). The distal patency of sequential grafts cannot be determined by current techniques. There was a lower graft patency rate (70%) in the 10 patients with perioperative myocardial infarction than in the 40 (95%) without (p less than 0.025), but most regions of infarcted myocardium were perfused by patent grafts. There were eight graft occlusions in eight patients. The graft occlusion rate (30%) was significantly higher (p less than 0.025) in grafts with intraoperative flows less than 45 ml/min. The postoperative complications of myocardial dysfunction, arrhythmia and coronary artery spasm did not correlate with graft occlusion. Early graft occlusion is uncommon (7%) and usually occurs in grafts with low flows or severe distal disease (seven of eight grafts), or both. Thus, the need for early reoperation is very infrequent. It is concluded that contrast-enhanced computed tomography is feasible for the assessment of coronary bypass graft patency. Because early graft occlusion is unusual the technique may be an ideal noninvasive screening method.

During the period 1975 to 1980, 21 patients with thoracic aortic dissections underwent surgical treatment. The operative technique was resection and tube graft replacement of the segment of the aorta containing the entry point into the false channel. Eleven Type A and 10 Type B dissections were resected. The hospital survival rate was 95%. The single operative death occurred in a patient with an acute Type A dissection. Three patients had total resection of the dissected segment; three had clotted false lumina; five had distal anastomosis to true and false lamina; and 10 had distal anastomosis to the true lumen only, with proximal entry into the false lumen obliterated by incorporating both intimal and adventitial walls in a single suture line. The late survival rate was 95% (mean 32 months, range 8 to 63 months). No late ruptures occurred. Computed tomography (CT) with contrast enhancement was used to evaluate the aorta and any residual false lumen at follow-up. Seven of eight patients in whom obliteration was attempted and CT scans performed demonstrated persistence of false lumen perfusion; in six of the eight, preoperative angiograms were adequate for evaluation of false lumen runoff. Major vessels arose from the false lumen in all cases, except in the one patient in whom obliteration was later successful. This report demonstrates that there is persistence of false lumen perfusion in patients in whom obliteration is attempted, and the mechanism of this persistence is the presence of major vessel runoff. It suggests that the mechanism by which long-term survival is achieved is by resection of the segment of aorta containing the entry site, which is frequently the site of subsequent enlargement and rupture, rather than obliteration of the false channel.

Coronary artery bypass graft patency was examined by contrast-enhanced computed tomography in 18 patients with perioperative myocardial infarction soon after surgery to determine the role of graft occlusion. Preoperative coronary angiograms were reviewed to assess native coronary disease and visible collateral channels in the distribution of the myocardial infarction. Perioperative myocardial infarction was diagnosed if creatine kinase-MB was elevated, characteristic electrocardiographic changes occurred and, in the majority of cases, the pyrophosphate scan was positive. Fourteen patients (78%) had patent grafts and perioperative myocardial infarction in the distribution of the grafted vessel. Four patients had an occluded graft with infarction in the distribution of the grafted vessel. Among the 14 patients with patent grafts, there was a significant difference (p less than 0.0005) in the degree of the mean (+/- standard deviation) diameter stenosis of 80 +/- 11% in native coronary vessels supplying the perioperatively infarcted myocardium versus a 55 +/- 12% mean diameter stenosis in the 23 bypassed native coronary vessels supplying noninfarcted myocardium. It is concluded that the majority of perioperative myocardial infarcts associated with coronary artery bypass operations are not caused by graft occlusion. The severity of coronary obstruction in the grafted vessel and the lack of collateral vessels to the region of perioperative infarction in patients with patent grafts suggests that an island of jeopardized myocardium exists that is subject to inadequate intraoperative preservation.

Early saphenous vein coronary bypass graft patency has been found to range from 82% to 94%. Recent advances in computed tomography have led to the development of a safe, effective, and "relatively noninvasive" means of assessing early graft patency. We designed a prospective study using contrast-enhanced computed tomography (CECT), postulating that selected grafts might be redone prior to the development of pericardial adhesions if early closure was demonstrated. Forty-three random patients undergoing elective coronary artery bypass comprise the study group. All patients underwent CECT study of graft patency an average of 6 days postoperatively (range 1 to 17 days). Ninety of 96 grafts were open, for an early patency rate of 94%. Three of the grafts were closed because of poor run-off or extensive distal coronary atherosclerosis. Two additional grafts were closed, one in a patient with severe atherosclerosis of the ascending aorta and one in a patient having triple vessel bypass using cephalic vein because of limited conduit material. Only one graft was closed without apparent cause and judged potentially suitable for reoperation. CECT was found to be a safe and potentially useful means of assessing early graft patency, particularly in patients sustaining untoward clinical events.

Changes in oxyhemoglobin dissociation compensate partially for decreased O2 transport caused by high altitude, anemia, and cardiac disease. This investigation determined whether similar changes occurred in patients undergoing myocardial revascularization and the possible significance of such changes. In 15 patients scheduled for coronary vein bypass surgery the following were inserted: a #7 French catheter into the coronary sinus or great cardiac vein, a pulmonary arterial catheter (Swan-Ganz), and a radial arterial catheter. Patients were anesthetized with either halothane-N2O 50% or morphine (2 mg/kg IV) with N2O 50%. Hemodynamic status was measured and blood samples were taken from the catheters in the preoperative period and after endotracheal intubation, sternotomy, bypass, and chest closure. Blood samples were analyzed for pH, blood gas tensions, and O2 saturation. Values for P50 for mixed venous and coronary sinus blood were calculated from O2 tension and saturation. Patients were divided into two groups on the basis of peroperative mixed venous P50 values: group I had normal P50 levels of 26.1 +/- 2.0 torr (mean +/- SD); group II had elevated values for mixed venous blood P50 of 32.5 +/- 1.6 (mean +/- SD). Unlike group I, group II had depressed ventricular function and higher P50 values for coronary sinus blood than for mixed venous blood. Induction of anesthesia increased P50 values in group I but not in group II and removed the significant differences between group I and group II mixed venous P50 values. In group II patients, cardiopulmonary bypass lowered the elevated P50 of coronary sinus blood so that it equaled P50 for mixed venous blood. It is concluded that induction of anesthesia may elevate P50 in patients who have normal preoperative P50 values. The already elevated P50 values of patients with ventricular dysfunction did not change. Cardiopulmonary bypass decreased coronary sinus P50 in group II patients, and this change might be deleterious if the original elevation represents a compensatory response to a reduction in O2 transport.

Two hundred consecutive patients undergoing coronary artery bypass for stable and unstable angina pectoris were followed clinically 3 to 53 months (mean 27) and with serial electrocardiograms (ECG's) 3 to 43 months (mean 18.5) postoperatively. Complete (twelve lead) resting ECG data including preoperative, early postoperative (in hospital), and late (post hospital) studies were available in 98 per cent (196/199) of hospital survivors. A total of 2,304 ECG's were examined by two cardiologists for a total follow-up of 3,629 patient months. Myocardial infarction was defined as the appearance of a new, significant (Minnesota Code) Q wave. Fifty-four per cent (108/200) had triple vessel disease and 24 per cent (47/200) preinfarction angina pectoris by strict criteria. There was one hospital death for an operative mortality of 0.5 per cent (1/200). There was one late fatal and three late nonfatal myocardial infarctions. Seventeen patients developed new Q waves in the early postoperative period, a perioperative infarction rate of 8.5 per cent (17/200). The 43 month cumulative myocardial infarction rate, including all early and late postoperative new Q waves and three late deaths from cardiac disease, was 14 per cent. Twenty-two per cent (20/91) showed disappearance of Q waves present at the time of hospital discharge. These data suggest that the late myocardial infarction rate is low in surgically managed patients.

MR imaging is known to be an effective technique for the noninvasive diagnosis of thoracic aortic disease, but it has not been used to monitor the appearance of the aorta or the fate of the false lumen after surgery for aortic dissection. This study describes our initial experience with postsurgical MR imaging of aortic dissection (nine type A and two type B) to evaluate prognostically important features, including the status of residual false lumen. The most notable findings were (1) aneurysmal dilatation beyond the interposed graft (11/11 cases), (2) residual intimal flap (10/11 cases) with at least partial patency of the false lumen (10/10 cases), and (3) origin of a visceral vessel from the false lumen in persistently dissected abdominal aorta (6/9 cases). Evaluation of residual false lumen by double-spin-echo-intensity and phase-display techniques showed evidence of slow blood flow with variable amounts of thrombus in eight of 10 cases. Differentiation between signal within the false lumen due to slow flow and signal due to thrombus was facilitated by phase display. MR imaging can be used for noninvasive monitoring of the aorta after surgical repair of aortic dissection. Since the false lumen usually remains patent after surgical repair, such follow-up of its status seems necessary for identifying potential complications of the original dissection and/or the therapy.