Search

Curing HIV infection will require the elimination of a reservoir of infected CD4(+) T cells that persists despite HIV-specific cytotoxic T cell (CTL) responses. Although viral latency is a critical factor in this persistence, recent evidence also suggests a role for intrinsic resistance of reservoir-harboring cells to CTL killing. This resistance may have contributed to negative outcomes of clinical trials, where pharmacologic latency reversal has thus far failed to drive reductions in HIV reservoirs. Through transcriptional profiling, we herein identified overexpression of the prosurvival factor B cell lymphoma 2 (BCL-2) as a distinguishing feature of CD4(+) T cells that survived CTL killing. We show that the inducible HIV reservoir was disproportionately present in BCL-2(hi) subsets in ex vivo CD4(+) T cells. Treatment with the BCL-2 antagonist ABT-199 was not sufficient to drive reductions in ex vivo viral reservoirs when tested either alone or with a latency-reversing agent (LRA). However, the triple combination of strong LRAs, HIV-specific T cells, and a BCL-2 antagonist uniquely enabled the depletion of ex vivo viral reservoirs. Our results provide rationale for novel therapeutic approaches targeting HIV cure and, more generally, suggest consideration of BCL-2 antagonism as a means of enhancing CTL immunotherapy in other settings, such as cancer.

HIV persists, despite immune responses and antiretroviral therapy, in viral reservoirs that seed rebound viremia if therapy is interrupted. Previously, we showed that the BCL-2 protein contributes to HIV persistence by conferring a survival advantage to reservoir-harboring cells. Here, we demonstrate that many of the BCL-2 family members are overexpressed in HIV-infected CD4+ T cells, indicating increased tension between proapoptotic and prosurvival family members-and suggesting that inhibition of prosurvival members may disproportionately affect the survival of HIV-infected cells. Based on these results, we chose to study BCL-XL due to its consistent overexpression and the availability of selective antagonists. Infection of primary CD4+ T cells with HIV resulted in increased BCL-XL protein expression, and treatment with two selective BCL-XL antagonists, A-1155463 and A-1551852, led to selective death of productively infected CD4+ T cells. In a primary cell model of latency, both BCL-XL antagonists drove reductions in HIV DNA and in infectious cell frequencies both alone and in combination with the latency reversing agent bryostatin-1, with little off-target cytotoxicity. However, these antagonists, with or without bryostatin-1 or in combination with the highly potent latency reversing agent combination phorbol myristate acetate (PMA) + ionomycin, failed to reduce total HIV DNA and infectious reservoirs in ex vivo CD4+ T cells from antiretroviral therapy (ART)-suppressed donors. Our results add to growing evidence that bona fide reservoir-harboring cells are resistant to multiple "kick and kill" modalities-relative to latency models. We also interpret our results as encouraging further exploration of BCL-XL antagonists for cure, where combination approaches, including with immune effectors, may unlock the ability to eliminate ex vivo reservoirs. IMPORTANCE Although antiretroviral therapy (ART) has transformed HIV infection into a manageable chronic condition, there is no safe or scalable cure. HIV persists in "reservoirs" of infected cells that reinitiate disease progression if ART is interrupted. Whereas most efforts to eliminate this reservoir have focused on exposing these cells to immune-mediated clearance by reversing viral latency, recent work shows that these cells also resist being killed. Here, we identify a "prosurvival" factor, BCL-XL, that is overexpressed in HIV-infected cells, and demonstrate selective toxicity to these cells by BCL-XL antagonists. These antagonists also reduced reservoirs in a primary-cell latency model but were insufficient to reduce "natural" reservoirs in ex vivo CD4+ T cells-adding to growing evidence that the latter are resilient in a way that is not reflected in models. We nonetheless suggest that the selective toxicity of BCL-XL antagonists to HIV-infected cells supports their prioritization for testing in combinations aimed at reducing ex vivo reservoirs.

HIV persists, despite immune responses and antiretroviral therapy, in viral reservoirs that seed rebound viremia if therapy is interrupted. Previously, we showed that the BCL-2 protein contributes to HIV persistence by conferring a survival advantage to reservoir-harboring cells. Here, we demonstrate that many of the BCL-2 family members are overexpressed in HIV-infected CD4(+) T cells, indicating increased tension between proapoptotic and prosurvival family members—and suggesting that inhibition of prosurvival members may disproportionately affect the survival of HIV-infected cells. Based on these results, we chose to study BCL-X(L) due to its consistent overexpression and the availability of selective antagonists. Infection of primary CD4(+) T cells with HIV resulted in increased BCL-X(L) protein expression, and treatment with two selective BCL-X(L) antagonists, A-1155463 and A-1551852, led to selective death of productively infected CD4(+) T cells. In a primary cell model of latency, both BCL-X(L) antagonists drove reductions in HIV DNA and in infectious cell frequencies both alone and in combination with the latency reversing agent bryostatin-1, with little off-target cytotoxicity. However, these antagonists, with or without bryostatin-1 or in combination with the highly potent latency reversing agent combination phorbol myristate acetate (PMA) + ionomycin, failed to reduce total HIV DNA and infectious reservoirs in ex vivo CD4(+) T cells from antiretroviral therapy (ART)-suppressed donors. Our results add to growing evidence that bona fide reservoir-harboring cells are resistant to multiple “kick and kill” modalities—relative to latency models. We also interpret our results as encouraging further exploration of BCL-X(L) antagonists for cure, where combination approaches, including with immune effectors, may unlock the ability to eliminate ex vivo reservoirs. IMPORTANCE Although antiretroviral therapy (ART) has transformed HIV infection into a manageable chronic condition, there is no safe or scalable cure. HIV persists in “reservoirs” of infected cells that reinitiate disease progression if ART is interrupted. Whereas most efforts to eliminate this reservoir have focused on exposing these cells to immune-mediated clearance by reversing viral latency, recent work shows that these cells also resist being killed. Here, we identify a “prosurvival” factor, BCL-X(L), that is overexpressed in HIV-infected cells, and demonstrate selective toxicity to these cells by BCL-X(L) antagonists. These antagonists also reduced reservoirs in a primary-cell latency model but were insufficient to reduce “natural” reservoirs in ex vivo CD4(+) T cells—adding to growing evidence that the latter are resilient in a way that is not reflected in models. We nonetheless suggest that the selective toxicity of BCL-X(L) antagonists to HIV-infected cells supports their prioritization for testing in combinations aimed at reducing ex vivo reservoirs.

HIV persists, despite antiviral immune responses and effective antiretroviral therapy, in viral reservoirs that seed rebound viremia if therapy is interrupted. Previously, we showed that the BCL-2 protein contributes to HIV persistence by conferring a survival advantage to reservoir-harboring cells. Here, we demonstrate that many of the BCL-2 family members are overexpressed in HIV-infected CD4+ T-cells, indicating increased tension between pro-apoptotic and pro-survival family members – as well as raising the possibility that the inhibition of pro-survival members may disproportionately affect the survival of HIV-infected cells. Based on these results, we chose to further study BCL2L1 (encoding the protein BCL-XL), due to its consistent overexpression and the availability of selective antagonists. Infection of primary CD4+ T-cells with either a clinical isolate, a CCR5-tropic strain, or a CXCR4-tropic strain of HIV resulted in increased BCL-XL protein expression; and treatment with two selective BCL-XL antagonists, A-1155463 and A-1551852, led to disproportionate cell death compared to uninfected CD4+ T-cells. In a primary cell model of latency, both BCL-XL antagonists drove significant reductions in total HIV DNA and in infectious cell frequencies both alone and in combination with the latency reversing agent bryostatin-1, with little off-target cytotoxicity. However, these antagonists, with or without bryostatin-1, or in combination with the highly potent latency reversing agent combination PMA + ionomycin, failed to reduce total HIV DNA and infectious reservoirs in ex vivo CD4+ T-cells from ART-suppressed donors. Our results add to growing evidence that bonafide reservoir-harboring cells are resistant to multiple “kick and kill” modalities - relative to latency models - and uncover BCL-XL antagonists as a facile approach to probing mechanistic underpinnings. We also interpret our results as encouraging of further exploration of BCL-XL antagonists for cure, where combination approaches may unlock the ability to eliminate ex vivo reservoirs.

Curing HIV infection will require the elimination of a reservoir of infected CD4+ T-cells that persists despite HIV-specific CTL responses. While viral latency is a critical factor in this persistence, recent evidence also suggests a role for intrinsic resistance of reservoir-harboring cells to CTL killing. We explored the hypothesis that this resistance is mediated by BCL-2 family proteins, which can antagonize CTL-induced apoptosis. We show that the reactivatable HIV reservoir is disproportionately present in BCL-2hi CD4+ T-cells, which are relatively resistant to CTL. BCL-2/BCL-XL antagonists were sufficient for inducing the elimination of HIV-infected cells from a primary-cell model of latency, but did not drive reductions in ex vivo viral reservoirs when tested either alone or with a latency reversing agent (LRA). The triple combination of LRAs, HIV-specific T-cells, and a BCL-2 antagonist uniquely enabled depletions in ex vivo viral reservoirs, providing rationale for novel therapeutic approaches targeting HIV cure.