1. Balancing Acts: Navigating the Ethical and Legal Challenges of Genomic Medicine in Healthcare
- Author
-
Kong, Eugene
- Subjects
Genomic Medicine ,Standard of Care ,Pate v. Threlkel ,Safer v. Estate of Pack ,medical malpractice ,Genomic Counselors Medical Malpractice ,Duty of Care ,Standard of Care Workflow - Abstract
This paper delves into the intricate relationship between the evolving field of genomic medicine and healthcare providers' legal and ethical responsibilities, with a particular focus on the duty to warn in the context of genetic risks. Through a critical examination of landmark cases such as Pate v. Threlkel and Safer v. Estate of Pack, this study underscores the expanding scope of healthcare providers' duties to include not just the patient but potentially at-risk family members as well. It highlights the legal, ethical, and practical challenges that arise when balancing patient confidentiality with the need to prevent harm through the disclosure of genetic information. The descriptive portion of the paper outlines the current legal precedents and the ambiguity surrounding healthcare providers' responsibilities. The prescriptive portion proposes the establishment of comprehensive, clear guidelines to support healthcare providers, particularly genomic counselors, in navigating these complexities. This includes recommendations for policy changes and the development of protocols that respect patient autonomy while addressing the preventive potential of genomic medicine. Through an analysis of legal frameworks and ethical considerations, this paper argues for a nuanced approach that equitably balances individual rights with the collective good, ultimately advocating for a future where genomic medicine is integrated into patient care in an ethically responsible and legally sound manner.
- Published
- 2024