Search

Cryo-electron tomography (cryo-ET) is an imaging technique that allows three-dimensional visualization of macro-molecular assemblies under near-native conditions. Cryo-ET comes with a number of challenges, mainly low signal-to-noise and inability to obtain images from all angles. Computational methods are key to analyze cryo-electron tomograms. To promote innovation in computational methods, we generate a novel simulated dataset to benchmark different methods of localization and classification of biological macromolecules in tomograms. Our publicly available dataset contains ten tomographic reconstructions of simulated cell-like volumes. Each volume contains twelve different types of complexes, varying in size, function and structure. In this paper, we have evaluated seven different methods of finding and classifying proteins. Seven research groups present results obtained with learning-based methods and trained on the simulated dataset, as well as a baseline template matching (TM), a traditional method widely used in cryo-ET research. We show that learning-based approaches can achieve notably better localization and classification performance than TM. We also experimentally confirm that there is a negative relationship between particle size and performance for all methods., Workshop version of the paper can be found here: https://diglib.eg.org/handle/10.2312/3dor20211307

Cryo-electron tomography (cryo-ET) is an imaging technique that allows three-dimensional visualization of macro-molecular assemblies under near-native conditions. Cryo-ET comes with a number of challenges, mainly low signal-to-noise and inability to obtain images from all angles. Computational methods are key to analyze cryo-electron tomograms. To promote innovation in computational methods, we generate a novel simulated dataset to benchmark different methods of localization and classification of biological macromolecules in tomograms. Our publicly available dataset contains ten tomographic reconstructions of simulated cell-like volumes. Each volume contains twelve different types of complexes, varying in size, function and structure. In this paper, we have evaluated seven different methods of finding and classifying proteins. Seven research groups present results obtained with learning-based methods and trained on the simulated dataset, as well as a baseline template matching (TM), a traditional method widely used in cryo-ET research. We show that learning-based approaches can achieve notably better localization and classification performance than TM. We also experimentally confirm that there is a negative relationship between particle size and performance for all methods., Eurographics Workshop on 3D Object Retrieval, Short Papers, 5, 17, Ilja Gubins, Marten L. Chaillet, Gijs van der Schot, M. Cristina Trueba, Remco C. Veltkamp, Friedrich Förster, Xiao Wang, Daisuke Kihara, Emmanuel Moebel, Nguyen P. Nguyen, Tommi White, Filiz Bunyak, Giorgos Papoulias, Stavros Gerolymatos, Evangelia I. Zacharaki, Konstantinos Moustakas, Xiangrui Zeng, Sinuo Liu, Min Xu, Yaoyu Wang, Cheng Chen, Xuefeng Cui, and Fa Zhang, CCS Concepts: Information systems --> Evaluation of retrieval results; Specialized information retrieval; Multimedia and multimodal retrieval; Retrieval models and ranking

Different imaging techniques allow us to study the organization of life at different scales. Cryo-electron tomography (cryo-ET) has the ability to three-dimensionally visualize the cellular architecture as well as the structural details of macro-molecular assemblies under near-native conditions. Due to beam sensitivity of biological samples, an inidividual tomogram has a maximal resolution of 5 nanometers. By averaging volumes, each depicting copies of the same type of a molecule, resolutions beyond 4 Å have been achieved. Key in this process is the ability to localize and classify the components of interest, which is challenging due to the low signal-to-noise ratio. Innovation in computational methods remains key to mine biological information from the tomograms. To promote such innovation, we organize this SHREC track and provide a simulated dataset with the goal of establishing a benchmark in localization and classification of biological particles in cryo-electron tomograms. The publicly available dataset contains ten reconstructed tomograms obtained from a simulated cell-like volume. Each volume contains twelve different types of proteins, varying in size and structure. Participants had access to 9 out of 10 of the cell-like ground-truth volumes for learning-based methods, and had to predict protein class and location in the test tomogram. Five groups submitted eight sets of results, using seven different methods. While our sample size gives only an anecdotal overview of current approaches in cryo-ET classification, we believe it shows trends and highlights interesting future work areas. The results show that learning-based approaches is the current trend in cryo-ET classification research and specifically end-to-end 3D learning-based approaches achieve the best performance., Eurographics Workshop on 3D Object Retrieval, SHREC Session 1, 49, 54, Ilja Gubins, Gijs van der Schot, Remco C. Veltkamp, Friedrich Förster, Xuefeng Du, Xiangrui Zeng, Zhenxi Zhu, Lufan Chang, Min Xu, Emmanuel Moebel, Antonio Martinez-Sanchez, Charles Kervrann, Tuan M. Lai, Xusi Han, Genki Terashi, Daisuke Kihara, Benjamin A. Himes, Xiaohua Wan, Jingrong Zhang, Shan Gao, Yu Hao, Zhilong Lv, Xiaohua Wan, Zhidong Yang, Zijun Ding, Xuefeng Cui, and Fa Zhang, CCS Concepts: Information systems --> Evaluation of retrieval results; Specialized information retrieval; Multimedia and multimodal retrieval; Retrieval models and ranking