Search

Canada thistle (Cirsium arvense (L.) Scop., CT) is one of the worst weeds threatening temperate regions of the world. A host-specific rust fungus, Puccinia punctiformis (F. Strauss) Rohl., is known to cause systemic disease of CT, ultimately killing individuals and reducing stand densities. In 2013, it was demonstrated that fall inoculation of rosettes with coarsely ground leaves bearing P. punctiformis telia can successfully initiate epiphytotics. In the same year, a cooperative project between the Colorado Department of Agriculture and United States Department of Agriculture was initiated, in which CT patches across the state of Colorado (USA) were inoculated and tracked over subsequent years for changes in stem density. Here, we report our findings from 8 years (2014–2021) of monitoring effort. At most sites (N = 87), CT stem densities declined, from a mean (±SE) of 87.9 (±6.5) stems to 44.7 (±4.2). These declines however were spatially-autocorrelated, and likely attributable to local growing conditions, as mean annual daily maximum temperature and standard deviation of elevation, as well as climatic conditions around the times of both treatment and monitoring, were found to be important predictors of CT decline. Further, we observed that the amount of inoculum deployed, timing since last release, and method in which it was spread locally at a site were also associated with the magnitude of CT stem decline. These results are indicative of the value of P. punctiformis as a CT biological control agent.

Cirsium arvense (Canada thistle) is a perennial weed that causes significant economic losses in agriculture. An extensive rhizomatous root system makes C. arvense difficult to manage, particularly in agricultural systems that use tillage as a primary management tool. There is a need for the development of integrated weed management toolsets that include C. arvense biological controls. Puccinia punctiformis (thistle rust) is an autoecious fungal pathogen that systemically infects C. arvense, with the potential to reduce host vigor over time. The goal of this study was to integrate the P. punctiformis biocontrol with a simulated annual cropping sequence in a greenhouse environment and evaluate C. arvense’s above-and belowground biomass production, and its competitive ability. Repeated P. punctiformis inoculations produced systemically infected C. arvense stems in greenhouse pots over time. Cirsium arvense that was inoculated with P. punctiformis had 1.6 grams/pot (p = 0.0019) less aboveground biomass and 5.6 grams/pot (p< 0.001) less belowground biomass, compared to the non-inoculated (control). Puccinia punctiformis and crop competition interacted additively to lower aboveground (p

• Canada thistle is one of the worst weeds threatening temperate regions of the world. • Puccinia punctiformis is known to cause systemic disease of Canada thistle, ultimately killing individuals and reducing stand densities. • A statewide biological control program was developed, in which telia were harvested and released at invaded sites with subsequent population monitoring. • Canada thistle stands exhibited significant declines following treatment, however these declines were associated with local site conditions and method of treatment. Canada thistle (Cirsium arvense (L.) Scop., CT) is one of the worst weeds threatening temperate regions of the world. A host-specific rust fungus, Puccinia punctiformis (F. Strauss) Rohl., is known to cause systemic disease of CT, ultimately killing individuals and reducing stand densities. In 2013, it was demonstrated that fall inoculation of rosettes with coarsely ground leaves bearing P. punctiformis telia can successfully initiate epiphytotics. In the same year, a cooperative project between the Colorado Department of Agriculture and United States Department of Agriculture was initiated, in which CT patches across the state of Colorado (USA) were inoculated and tracked over subsequent years for changes in stem density. Here, we report our findings from 8 years (2014–2021) of monitoring effort. At most sites (N = 87), CT stem densities declined, from a mean (±SE) of 87.9 (±6.5) stems to 44.7 (±4.2). These declines however were spatially-autocorrelated, and likely attributable to local growing conditions, as mean annual daily maximum temperature and standard deviation of elevation, as well as climatic conditions around the times of both treatment and monitoring, were found to be important predictors of CT decline. Further, we observed that the amount of inoculum deployed, timing since last release, and method in which it was spread locally at a site were also associated with the magnitude of CT stem decline. These results are indicative of the value of P. punctiformis as a CT biological control agent. [ABSTRACT FROM AUTHOR]

The weevil Ceratapion onopordi Kirby (Coleoptera: Apionidae) shows a mutualistic interaction with the rust fungus Puccinia punctiformis (Str.) Röhl (Pucciniaceae). One of the weevil's host plants, the thistle Cirsium arvense (L.) Scop. (Asteraceae), is also the host of the rust fungus. It has been argued that weevils prefer rust-infected thistle shoots for egg deposition and consequently should be able to detect such shoots. Olfactory, visual, and gustatory orientation was tested using a four-chamber olfactometer, a visual testing arena, and feeding choice tests. Whereas the weevils used olfactory cues to find their host plants, visual orientation does not seem to be important. Rust-infected thistle shoots were not preferred over healthy shoots in any of the tests. We conclude that host plants infected with rust fungi, which are rather rare in the field, appear to be found more or less by chance. [ABSTRACT FROM AUTHOR]

An existing method to induce systemic rust infections in creeping thistles (Cirsium arvense) using an insect vector, the weevil Ceratapion onopordi, was successfully applied in the field. Urediniospores of Puccinia punctiformis were experimentally transmitted to naturally grown thistles, to our knowledge for the first time resulting in systemically infected shoots in an established thistle population. [ABSTRACT FROM AUTHOR]

Copyright of Basic & Applied Ecology is the property of Urban & Fischer Verlag and its content may not be copied or emailed to multiple sites or posted to a listserv without the copyright holder's express written permission. However, users may print, download, or email articles for individual use. This abstract may be abridged. No warranty is given about the accuracy of the copy. Users should refer to the original published version of the material for the full abstract. (Copyright applies to all Abstracts.)

K luth S, K ruess A & T scharntke T (2005) Effects of two pathogens on the performance of Cirsium arvense in a successional fallow. Weed Research 45, 261–269. Biological control of weeds by natural antagonists is of increasing interest. To reduce densities of the weed Cirsium arvense (creeping thistle) in a successional fallow, we applied spores of two pathogens, the biotrophic rust Puccinia punctiformis and the perthotrophic Phoma destructiva, for three consecutive years individually at different dates and combined. The proportion of systemically Puccinia punctiformis-infected C. arvense was not influenced by the treatments, but local rust infection was a good predictor of systemic infection in the following season. Artificial inoculations with P. destructiva increased the incidence of this pathogen in the third year as a result of synergistic effects, when co-inoculated with P. punctiformis. Inoculations with either pathogen had little effect on C. arvense shoot density, although there were transient reductions after combined inoculations with both fungi compared with the fungicide treatment. Cirsium arvense decreased from 60% to 5% cover within 3 years, while the cover of the co-occurring fallow vegetation increased. Under field conditions, with an already high degree of natural P. punctiformis infection, the effects of inoculations of the single pathogens were minor, but reductions in shoot density after combined inoculations indicate that this inoculation may have the potential to cause a decline of this weed. [ABSTRACT FROM AUTHOR]

As a first step in the development of a mycoherbicide for biological control of Cirsium arvense indigenous fungal pathogens that had been isolated from diseased hosts were tested both singly and in combination on potted plants under environmental conditions. Disease symptoms (necroses, chloroses and macerations) and parameters of growth and development were evaluated to determine the potential for weed control. During 1998, Phoma destructiva, Phoma hedericola, a Mycelia sterilia and Puccinia punctiformis were inoculated singly. With the exception of the obligate biotroph P. punctiformis (local infections), the single inoculations reduced the measured parameters. A combined inoculum of P. punctiformis and Ph. hedericola was less effective than Ph. hedericola alone. In 1999, Ph. hedericola, Ph. destructiva, Ph. nebulosa and the Mycelia sterila were applied both singly and as a combined inoculum. Of all the tested inocula, the mixture of four pathogens had the greatest potential for biocontrol, significantly reducing reproductive capacity of the plants. These results demonstrate the importance of taking advantage of synergisms in developing a mycoherbicide. [ABSTRACT FROM AUTHOR]

Summary 1. In order to develop an effective biological control technique, the influence of mechanical and pathogen treatments on performance and nutrient storage of the weed creeping thistle Cirsium arvense was studied over a 2-year period. To our knowledge, this is the first study to evaluate the effect of a combination of cutting and application of the rust Puccinia punctiformis as a possible biocontrol organism on thistles. 2. We conducted a complete two-factorial design using potted plants, with the application of the rust and cutting of thistles as the treatment factors. Treatments were applied once every year in June. 3. Inoculation reduced above-ground biomass in the first year. First year cutting reduced the number of thistle shoots, but stimulated compensatory growth with an increased growth rate and biomass. Only a second year cutting treatment significantly reduced above- and below-ground biomass, despite an increased growth rate. 4. The number of flower heads was strongly reduced by both cutting and combined treatments. The proportion of fertile flower heads was increased by cutting, whereas the combination treatment strongly reduced it. 5. Analysing storage nutrients, starch concentrations did not differ among treatments. Cutting reduced sugar concentrations, but pathogen infection tended to increase concentrations, resulting in significant interaction effects. Cutting also reduced below-ground carbon concentrations, but the carbon : nitrogen ratio was not influenced. 6. Synthesis and applications. The traditional mechanical technique of cutting was shown to be effective in reducing plant reproductive success and concentration of storage nutrients. Additional infection with a plant pathogen further restricted sexual reproduction, indicating that combined treatments may be more effective for biological control of perennial weed species. Whilst further studies are needed to establish P. punctiformis as a mycoherbicide, some synergism between repeated... [ABSTRACT FROM AUTHOR]

Interactions between plants and their herbivores and pathogens are mostly analysed separately, thereby neglecting mutualistic or antagonistic interactions between these antagonists and possible joint effects on the host. We studied interactions between the weed Cirsium arvense, the rust fungus Puccinia punctiformis and three herbivorous insects, the aphids Aphis fabae ssp. cirsiiacanthoidis and Uroleucon cirsii, and the beetle Cassida rubiginosa. All three insect species mechanically transported spore material and significantly increased rates of P. punctiformis infection in healthy thistles. The interaction between C. rubiginosa and the fungus was antagonistic. Although C. rubiginosa transferred spores, biomass of adults was significantly reduced, development of adults tended to be prolonged and mortality increased when feeding on plants infected with P. punctiformis. In contrast, the relationship between the aphid U. cirsii and P. punctiformis was mutualistic: U. cirsii profited by fungal infection and formed significantly larger colonies on fungus-infected plants. Although the differences in insect performance suggest that aphids may be better vectors than the beetle, infection rates were similar. This is the first study to demonstrate that the relationship between herbivores, which increase the dispersal of a pathogen, and the pathogen itself can be mutualistic or antagonistic, depending on the species. [ABSTRACT FROM AUTHOR]

We present a mutualism between a stem-boring weevil, Apion onopordi Kirby (Coleoptera: Apionidae), and a rust fungus, Puccinia punctiformis (Str.) Röhl. (Uredinales), both parasites of the creeping thistle, Cirsium arvense (L.) Scop. (Asteraceae). Females, but not males, of A. onopordi induced systemic rust infections of thistle shoots in the season after they were attacked by the weevil, indicating that insect oviposition is a crucial stage in pathogen transmission. Adult weevils emerged from systemically infected thistle shoots were heavier than weevils from healthy C. arvense shoots. Heavier females had a higher fecundity and laid larger eggs. The weevil preferred to deposit eggs in systemically rust-infected over healthy thistle shoots, which seemed to be a sub-optimal host. This is to our knowledge the first report of a mutualistic interaction between an herbivorous insect and a biotrophic plant pathogen. The mechanism responsible for the advantage of rust-infected shoots for A. onopordi causes a different outcome in other thistle herbivores, and therefore can not be explained by a general enhancement of nutritional quality in rust-infected tissue. This mutualism likely has evolved from a competitive relationship. Unlike other thistle herbivores A. onopordi seems to be better suited as mutualist for P. punctiformis because of its small impact on the host plant and its feeding niche on plant parts not directly associated with pathogen reproduction. [ABSTRACT FROM AUTHOR]

The infection cycle of the autoecious rust fungus Puccinia punctiformis on the clonal plant Cirsium arvense was described in terms of intensity (amount of pathogen per unit area and used for systemic infection) and extent (area occupied by the pathogen and used for local lesion infection) at four grassland sites in The Netherlands. The incidence of systemic infection was relatively low and systemically infected shoots were typically concentrated at a few locations within a site. Incidence of local lesion infection was relatively high and widespread in ail sites. Spatial and temporal distribution of teliospores, the inoculum for systemic infection, were quantified in order to explain the relatively low and spatially unequal incidence of systemic infection. Because of the large impact of systemic infection on C. arvense shoots, it is concluded that a spatially homogeneous distribution of teliospores may be a prerequisite for the biological control of C. arvense by P. punctiformis.