1. Regulatory Issues in Electronic Health Records for Adolescent HIV Research: Strategies and Lessons Learned
- Author
-
Green, Sara Shaw, Lee, Sung-Jae, Chahin, Samantha, Pooler-Burgess, Meardith, Green-Jones, Monique, Gurung, Sitaji, Outlaw, Angulique Y, and Naar, Sylvie
- Subjects
Health Services and Systems ,Biomedical and Clinical Sciences ,Health Sciences ,HIV/AIDS ,Networking and Information Technology R&D (NITRD) ,Sexually Transmitted Infections ,Patient Safety ,Women's Health ,Pediatric ,Prevention ,Comparative Effectiveness Research ,Clinical Research ,Behavioral and Social Science ,Clinical Trials and Supportive Activities ,Infectious Diseases ,Pediatric AIDS ,Good Health and Well Being ,electronic health record ,HIV ,pragmatic trial ,regulatory ,EHR ,pre-exposure prophylaxis ,retention ,attrition ,dropout ,legal ,regulation ,adherence ,ethic ,review board ,implementation ,data use ,privacy ,Biomedical and clinical sciences ,Health sciences - Abstract
BackgroundElectronic health records (EHRs) are a cost-effective approach to provide the necessary foundations for clinical trial research. The ability to use EHRs in real-world clinical settings allows for pragmatic approaches to intervention studies with the emerging adult HIV population within these settings; however, the regulatory components related to the use of EHR data in multisite clinical trials poses unique challenges that researchers may find themselves unprepared to address, which may result in delays in study implementation and adversely impact study timelines, and risk noncompliance with established guidance.ObjectiveAs part of the larger Adolescent Trials Network (ATN) for HIV/AIDS Interventions Protocol 162b (ATN 162b) study that evaluated clinical-level outcomes of an intervention including HIV treatment and pre-exposure prophylaxis services to improve retention within the emerging adult HIV population, the objective of this study is to highlight the regulatory process and challenges in the implementation of a multisite pragmatic trial using EHRs to assist future researchers conducting similar studies in navigating the often time-consuming regulatory process and ensure compliance with adherence to study timelines and compliance with institutional and sponsor guidelines.MethodsEight sites were engaged in research activities, with 4 sites selected from participant recruitment venues as part of the ATN, who participated in the intervention and data extraction activities, and an additional 4 sites were engaged in data management and analysis. The ATN 162b protocol team worked with site personnel to establish the necessary regulatory infrastructure to collect EHR data to evaluate retention in care and viral suppression, as well as para-data on the intervention component to assess the feasibility and acceptability of the mobile health intervention. Methods to develop this infrastructure included site-specific training activities and the development of both institutional reliance and data use agreements.ResultsDue to variations in site-specific activities, and the associated regulatory implications, the study team used a phased approach with the data extraction sites as phase 1 and intervention sites as phase 2. This phased approach was intended to address the unique regulatory needs of all participating sites to ensure that all sites were properly onboarded and all regulatory components were in place. Across all sites, the regulatory process spanned 6 months for the 4 data extraction and intervention sites, and up to 10 months for the data management and analysis sites.ConclusionsThe process for engaging in multisite clinical trial studies using EHR data is a multistep, collaborative effort that requires proper advanced planning from the proposal stage to adequately implement the necessary training and infrastructure. Planning, training, and understanding the various regulatory aspects, including the necessity of data use agreements, reliance agreements, external institutional review board review, and engagement with clinical sites, are foremost considerations to ensure successful implementation and adherence to pragmatic trial timelines and outcomes.
- Published
- 2024