1. A controlled study of the effect of deviations from symmetry of the potential energy surface (PES) on the accuracy of the vibrational spectrum computed with collocation.
- Author
-
Manzhos, Sergei and Ihara, Manabu
- Subjects
- *
POTENTIAL energy surfaces , *VIBRATIONAL spectra , *SYMMETRY , *POINT set theory , *GRAPH labelings , *WAVE functions - Abstract
Symmetry, in particular permutational symmetry, of a potential energy surface (PES) is a useful property in quantum chemical calculations. It facilitates, in particular, state labelling and identification of degenerate states. In many practically important applications, however, these issues are unimportant. The imposition of exact symmetry and the perception that it is necessary create additional methodological requirements narrowing or complicating algorithmic choices that are thereby biased against methods and codes that by default do not incorporate symmetry, including most off-the-shelf machine learning methods that cannot be directly used if exact symmetry is demanded. By introducing symmetric and unsymmetric errors into the PES of H2CO in a controlled way and computing the vibrational spectrum with collocation using symmetric and nonsymmetric collocation point sets, we show that when the deviations from an ideal PES are random, imposition of exact symmetry does not bring any practical advantages. Moreover, a calculation ignoring symmetry may be more accurate. We also compare machine-learned PESs with and without symmetrization and demonstrate that there is no advantage of imposing exact symmetry for the accuracy of the vibrational spectrum. [ABSTRACT FROM AUTHOR]
- Published
- 2023
- Full Text
- View/download PDF