Passias PG, Mir JM, Dave P, Smith JS, Lafage R, Gum J, Line BG, Diebo B, Daniels AH, Hamilton DK, Buell TJ, Scheer JK, Eastlack RK, Mullin JP, Mundis GM, Hosogane N, Yagi M, Schoenfeld AJ, Uribe JS, Anand N, Mummaneni PV, Chou D, Klineberg EO, Kebaish KM, Lewis SJ, Gupta MC, Kim HJ, Hart RA, Lenke LG, Ames CP, Shaffrey CI, Schwab FJ, Lafage V, Hostin RA Jr, Bess S, and Burton DC
Study Design: Retrospective cohort., Objective: To evaluate factors associated with the long-term durability of cost-effectiveness (CE) in ASD patients., Background: A substantial increase in costs associated with the surgical treatment for adult spinal deformity (ASD) has given precedence to scrutinize the value and utility it provides., Methods: We included 327 operative ASD patients with 5-year (5 Y) follow-up. Published methods were used to determine costs based on CMS.gov definitions and were based on the average DRG reimbursement rates. Utility was calculated using quality-adjusted life-years (QALY) utilizing the Oswestry Disability Index (ODI) converted to Short-Form Six-Dimension (SF-6D), with a 3% discount applied for its decline with life expectancy. The CE threshold of $150,000 was used for primary analysis., Results: Major and minor complication rates were 11% and 47% respectively, with 26% undergoing reoperation by 5 Y. The mean cost associated with surgery was $91,095±$47,003, with a utility gain of 0.091±0.086 at 1Y, QALY gained at 2 Y of 0.171±0.183, and at 5 Y of 0.42±0.43. The cost per QALY at 2 Y was $414,885, which decreased to $142,058 at 5 Y.With the threshold of $150,000 for CE, 19% met CE at 2 Y and 56% at 5 Y. In those in which revision was avoided, 87% met cumulative CE till life expectancy. Controlling analysis depicted higher baseline CCI and pelvic tilt (PT) to be the strongest predictors for not maintaining durable CE to 5 Y (CCI OR: 1.821 [1.159-2.862], P=0.009) (PT OR: 1.079 [1.007-1.155], P=0.030)., Conclusions: Most patients achieved cost-effectiveness after four years postoperatively, with 56% meeting at five years postoperatively. When revision was avoided, 87% of patients met cumulative cost-effectiveness till life expectancy. Mechanical complications were predictive of failure to achieve cost-effectiveness at 2 Y, while comorbidity burden and medical complications were at 5 Y., Competing Interests: Conflicts of Interest: Peter Gust Passias, MD: Cerapedics: Other financial or material support. Cervical Scoliosis Research Society: Research support. Globus Medical: Paid presenter or speaker. Medtronic: Paid consultant. Royal Biologics: Paid consultant. Spine: Editorial or governing board. Spinevision: Other financial or material support. SpineWave: Paid consultant. JNS Spine: Editorial Board. JCM: Editorial Board. Justin S Smith, MD: Alphatec Spine: Stock or stock Options. Carlsmed: Paid consultant. Cerapedics: Paid consultant. DePuy: Research support. DePuy, A Johnson & Johnson Company: Paid consultant. Journal of Neurosurgery Spine: Editorial or governing board. Neurosurgery: Editorial or governing board. Nuvasive: IP royalties; Paid consultant; Research support. Operative Neurosurgery: Editorial or governing board. Scoliosis Research Society: Board or committee member. Spine Deformity: Editorial or governing board. Stryker: Paid consultant. Thieme: Publishing royalties, financial or material support. Zimmer: IP royalties; Paid consultant. Renaud Lafage, MS: Nemaris: Stock or stock Options. Jeffrey Gum, MD: Acuity: IP royalties; Paid consultant. Alan L. & Jacqueline B. Stuart Spine Research: Research support. Cerapedics: Research support. Cingulate Therapeutics: Stock or stock Options. DePuy, A Johnson & Johnson Company: Paid presenter or speaker. Global Spine Journal - Reviewer: Editorial or governing board. Intellirod Spine Inc.: Research support. K2M /Stryker: Board or committee member. MAZOR Surgical Technologies: Paid consultant. Medtronic: Board or committee member; Paid consultant; Research support. Norton Healthcare: Research support. Nuvasive: IP royalties; Paid consultant. Pfizer: Research support. Scoliosis Research Society: Research support. Spine Deformity - Reviewer: Editorial or governing board. Stryker: Paid consultant; Paid presenter or speaker. Texas Scottish Rite Hospital: Research support. The Spine Journal - Reviewer: Editorial or governing board. Breton G Line, BS: ISSGF: Paid consultant. Alan H Daniels, MD: EOS: Paid consultant. Medicrea: Paid consultant. Medtronic Sofamor Danek: Paid consultant. Novabone: Paid consultant. Orthofix, Inc.: Paid consultant; Research support. Southern Spine: IP royalties. Spineart: IP royalties; Paid consultant. Springer: Publishing royalties, financial or material support. Stryker: Paid consultant. D. Kojo Hamilton: European Spine Journal: Editorial or governing board. Nuvasive: Research support. Robert Kenneth Eastlack, MD: Aesculap/B.Braun: Paid consultant. Alphatec Spine: Stock or stock Options. Baxter: Paid consultant. Biedermann-Motech: Paid consultant. Carevature: Paid consultant; Stock or stock Options. Globus Medical: IP royalties. Invuity: Stock or stock Options. Medtronic: Paid consultant. Nocimed: Stock or stock Options. Nuvasive: IP royalties; Paid consultant; Research support; Stock or stock Options. Radius: Paid presenter or speaker. San Diego Spine Foundation: Board or committee member. Scoliosis Research Society: Board or committee member. Seaspine: IP royalties; Paid consultant; Stock or stock Options. SI Bone: IP royalties; Paid consultant. Society of Lateral Access Surgery: Board or committee member. Spine Innovations: Stock or stock Options. Stryker: Paid consultant. Gregory Michael Mundis Jr, MD: Carlsmed: Paid consultant. ISSGF: Research support. K2M: IP royalties. Nuvasive: IP royalties; Paid consultant; Research support. Scoliosis Research Society: Board or committee member. SeaSpine: Paid consultant. Stryker: Paid consultant. Viseon: Paid consultant. Andrew J Schoenfeld, MD: AAOS: Board or committee member. Journal of Bone and Joint Surgery - American: Editorial or governing board. North American Spine Society: Board or committee member. Spine: Editorial or governing board. Springer: Publishing royalties, financial or material support. Wolters Kluwer Health - Lippincott Williams & Wilkins: Publishing royalties, financial or material support. Eric O Klineberg, MD: AO Spine: Paid presenter or speaker; Research support. DePuy, A Johnson & Johnson Company: Paid consultant. Medicrea: Paid consultant. Medtronic: Paid consultant. Stryker: Paid consultant. Khaled M Kebaish, MD: DePuy, A Johnson & Johnson Company: IP royalties; Paid consultant; Paid presenter or speaker; Research support. Orthofix, Inc.: IP royalties; Paid consultant. Orthofix, Inc., K2 medical Inc: Paid presenter or speaker. Scoliosis Research Society: Board or committee member. Stryker: IP royalties. Munish C Gupta, MD: AO Spine Faculty, travel: Board or committee member. DePuy, A Johnson & Johnson Company: IP royalties; Paid consultant; Paid presenter or speaker. European Spine Journal-Advisory Board: Editorial or governing board. Global Spine Journal-Reviewer: Editorial or governing board. Globus Medical: IP royalties; Paid consultant. honorarium for faculty: Board or committee member. Innomed: IP royalties. Johnson & Johnson: Stock or stock Options. Medtronic: Paid consultant. Procter & Gamble: Stock or stock Options. Spine Deformity, Associate Editor: Editorial or governing board. SRS-IMAST & Education committee: Board or committee member. travel: Board or committee member. Wolters Kluwer Health - Lippincott Williams & Wilkins: Publishing royalties, financial or material support. Han Jo Kim, MD: AAOS: Board or committee member. Alphatec Spine: Paid consultant. AO SPINE: Board or committee member. Cervical Spine Research Society: Board or committee member. HSS Journal, Asian Spine Journal: Editorial or governing board. ISSGF: Research support. K2M: IP royalties. Scoliosis Research Society: Board or committee member. Zimmer: IP royalties. Robert A Hart, MD, FAAOS: American Orthopaedic Association: Board or committee member. Cervical Spine Research Society: Board or committee member. DePuy, A Johnson & Johnson Company: IP royalties; Paid consultant; Paid presenter or speaker. Globus Medical: IP royalties; Paid consultant; Paid presenter or speaker. International Spine Study Group: Board or committee member. ISSLS Textbook of the Lumbar Spine: Editorial or governing board. Medtronic: Paid consultant; Paid presenter or speaker. North American Spine Society: Board or committee member. Orthofix, Inc.: Paid consultant; Paid presenter or speaker. Scoliosis Research Society: Board or committee member. SeaSpine: IP royalties. Spine Connect: Stock or stock Options. Western Ortho Assn: Board or committee member. Christopher Ames, MD: Biomet Spine: IP royalties. DePuy, A Johnson & Johnson Company: IP royalties; Paid consultant; Research support. Global Spine Analytics - Director: Other financial or material support. International Spine Study Group (ISSG): Research support. International Spine Study Group (ISSG) - Executive Committee: Other financial or material support. K2M: IP royalties; Paid consultant. Medicrea: IP royalties; Paid consultant. Medtronic: Paid consultant. Next Orthosurgical: IP royalties. Nuvasive: IP royalties. Operative Neurosurgery - Editorial Board: Other financial or material support. Scoliosis Research Society (SRS) - Grant Funding: Other financial or material support. Stryker: IP royalties. Titan Spine: Research support. Christopher I Shaffrey, MD: AANS: Board or committee member. Cervical Spine Research Society: Board or committee member. DePuy, A Johnson & Johnson Company: Paid presenter or speaker; Research support. Globus Medical: Research support. Medtronic: Other financial or material support; Paid consultant. Medtronic Sofamor Danek: IP royalties; Paid presenter or speaker; Research support. Neurosurgery RRC: Board or committee member. Nuvasive: IP royalties; Paid consultant; Paid presenter or speaker; Research support; Stock or stock Options. Proprio: Paid consultant. Scoliosis Research Society: Board or committee member. SI Bone: IP royalties. Spinal Deformity: Editorial or governing board. Spine: Editorial or governing board. Frank J Schwab, MD: DePuy, A Johnson & Johnson Company: Research support. Globus Medical: Paid consultant; Paid presenter or speaker. K2M: IP royalties; Paid consultant; Paid presenter or speaker. Medicrea: Paid consultant. Medtronic: Paid consultant. Medtronic Sofamor Danek: IP royalties; Paid presenter or speaker. Nuvasive: Research support. Scoliosis Research Society: Board or committee member. spine deformity: Editorial or governing board. Stryker: Research support. VP of International Spine Society Group (ISSG): Board or committee member. Zimmer: IP royalties; Paid consultant; Paid presenter or speaker. Virginie Lafage, PhD: DePuy, A Johnson & Johnson Company: Paid presenter or speaker. European Spine Journal: Editorial or governing board. Globus Medical: Paid consultant. International Spine Study Group: Board or committee member. Nuvasive: IP royalties. Scoliosis Research Society: Board or committee member. The Permanente Medical Group: Paid presenter or speaker. Richard A Hostin, MD: DePuy, A Johnson & Johnson Company: Paid consultant. Robert Shay Bess, MD: allosource: Paid consultant; Research support. Biomet: Research support. DePuy, A Johnson & Johnson Company: Paid consultant; Research support. EOS: Research support. Globus Medical: Research support. k2 medical: IP royalties; Paid consultant; Paid presenter or speaker; Research support. Medtronic Sofamor Danek: Research support. North American Spine Society: Board or committee member. Nuvasive: IP royalties; Research support. Orthofix, Inc.: Research support. Scoliosis Research Society: Board or committee member. Stryker: IP royalties; Paid presenter or speaker. Douglas C Burton, MD, FAAOS: Bioventus: Research support. DePuy, A Johnson & Johnson Company: IP royalties; Paid consultant; Research support. Pfizer: Research support. Progenerative Medical: Stock or stock Options. Scoliosis Research Society: Board or committee member. Spine Deformity: Editorial or governing board. Other Authors: None., (Copyright © 2024 Wolters Kluwer Health, Inc. All rights reserved.)