102 results on '"Melisa Stevanovic"'
Search Results
2. Healthcare providers’ narratives about interactionally troubling patient exchanges: Accounting for and against an active patient role
- Author
-
Elina Weiste, Melisa Stevanovic, Nanette Ranta, and Henri Nevalainen
- Subjects
Patient involvement ,patient-provider interaction ,interview ,narratives ,narrative positioning analysis ,Medicine (General) ,R5-920 - Abstract
The current trend in healthcare is to actively involve patients in their own treatment; however, in practice, healthcare providers may adhere to paternalistic views, which may not align with ideals related to patient involvement. This tension may become visible when providers talk about service encounters that they experienced as being interactionally troubling. In this empirical qualitative study, we utilize Bamberg’s narrative positioning analysis to explore how healthcare providers construct patients’ roles in narratives about such troubling exchanges. Data consist of 20 audio-recorded interviews with healthcare providers. We found two types of narratives in which healthcare providers’ perceptions of interactionally troubling patient exchanges were consistently related to their implicit evaluations of patients along a continuum of activeness versus passiveness. In the first, an active patient was considered ideal, and the problematic patient was one who is passive. In the second, a patient’s over-activeness was thought to interfere with the healthcare delivery. While providers’ complaints about patient passiveness were unproblematically presented from the perspective of the patient participation ideal, complaints about patient over-activeness were difficult to account for due to their inherent connotations with paternalism. Thus, we conclude that there is a need for training and interventions aiming to develop healthcare providers’ critical awareness of shifting cultural models, including patient involvement ideals and providers’ capacity to reflect paternalistic tendencies.
- Published
- 2024
- Full Text
- View/download PDF
3. Recognition in interaction: theoretical and empirical observations
- Author
-
Emmi Koskinen, Arto Laitinen, and Melisa Stevanovic
- Subjects
conversation analysis ,recognition ,misrecognition ,interaction ,sociological theory ,solidarity ,Sociology (General) ,HM401-1281 - Abstract
In the current paper we aim to combine the theoretical ideas of recognition theory to conversation analytical, empirical observations. We ask what recognition theories can give to conversation analysis, and vice versa. We operate on a model of recognition that consists of three different modes: respect, esteem, and love/care, and which distinguishes the levels of conversational actions and the attitudes of recognition manifested in such actions. In this study we examine data examples from various conversational settings (institutional, quasi-experimental, family interaction) and activities (decision-making, storytelling), focusing on the more complex cases of (mis)recognition. We show how recognition can appear both explicitly and implicitly in conversational sequences, and demonstrate how the levels of conversational actions and recognition can be either congruent or incongruent with each other. At the end of the article, we discuss the implications of this view for the interface of conversation analysis and sociological theory, arguing that it can inform and promote the development of interactionally based social and societal critique.
- Published
- 2024
- Full Text
- View/download PDF
4. Mental health rehabilitees’ agency construction and promotion in community-based transitional work programme
- Author
-
Miira Niska, Melisa Stevanovic, Henri Nevalainen, Elina Weiste, and Camilla Lindholm
- Subjects
agency ,clubhouse ,conversation analysis ,discursive psychology ,mental illness ,transitional work ,Medicine (General) ,R5-920 - Abstract
Purpose The integration of mental health rehabilitees into the labour market is an important policy objective everywhere in the world. The international Clubhouse organization is a third-sector actor that offers community-based psychosocial rehabilitation and supports and promotes rehabilitees’ state of acting and exerting power over their lives, including their (re)employment. In this article, we adopt the perspective of discursive psychology and ask how mental health rehabilitees’ agency is constructed and ideally also promoted in the Clubhouse-based Transitional Employment (TE) programme. Methods The data consisted of 26 video-recorded TE meetings in which staff and rehabilitees of one Finnish Clubhouse discussed ways to further their contacts with potential employers. The analysis was informed by discursive psychology, which has been heavily influenced by conversation analysis. Results The analysis demonstrated how rehabilitees adopt agentic positions in respect to TE-related future activities, and how Clubhouse staff promote and encourage but also discourage and invalidate these agentic positionings. The analysis demonstrated the multifaceted nature of agency and agency promotion in the TE programme. Conclusions Although ideally, Clubhouse activities are based on equal opportunities, in everyday interaction practices, the staff exercise significant power over the question whose agency is promoted and validated in the TE programme.
- Published
- 2023
- Full Text
- View/download PDF
5. Accountability and interactional inequality: the management of problems of interaction as a matter of cultural ideals and ideologies
- Author
-
Melisa Stevanovic
- Subjects
conversation analysis ,accountability ,interactional violations ,problems of interaction ,interactional inequality ,Sociology (General) ,HM401-1281 - Abstract
In the existing sociological literature, the notion of accountability is seen both as a tool of sense-making (intelligibility side of accountability) and as a way of maintaining larger social order (normativity side of accountability). This paper points to drastically different ways of treating an interactional violation, depending on the precise framework within which the accountabilities associated with the violation are interpreted. The normative side of accountability involves the idea of interactional inequality—that is, the notion that people are not equally held accountable for their interactional violations. I suggest that such inequalities are strengthened by the prevailing cultural ideals and ideologies of interaction according to which a competent participant can solve interactional problems as they emerge. Problems of interaction are therefore commonly let pass, and if addressed, likely to be interpreted within the framework of intelligibility. This means that the violators are likely to get away from being held accountable in the normative sense of the term. As a result, I argue, many interactional problems are commonly beyond effective intervention. In its focus on the intelligibility side of accountability CA has, not only trouble addressing interactional inequalities, but it may also inherently undermine the severity of the inequalities to be addressed. A more critical, socially and societally relevant CA would thus benefit from a more explicit engagement with the normative side of the notion.
- Published
- 2023
- Full Text
- View/download PDF
6. Conversation analysis and power: examining the descendants and antecedents of social action
- Author
-
Mats Ekström and Melisa Stevanovic
- Subjects
conversation analysis ,power ,deontics ,authority ,social interaction ,Sociology (General) ,HM401-1281 - Abstract
Conversation Analysis (CA) tends to adopt an ambivalent attitude to the concept of power. The concept is fundamental in sociology but secondary or even disregarded in CA. A closer look at research and the conceptual foundations of CA however demonstrate significant contributions to theories of power. In this paper we aim to demonstrate and discuss these contributions, however, also arguing for an expansion of the CA approach in dialogue with sociological theories to engage in the sociological analysis of power as an essential feature of social relationships and social organization. Based on a general definition of power, as the transformative capacities of social agents in virtue of their social relationships, we discuss how power is interactionally achieved and negotiated, but also conditioned by social institutions and structures that extend beyond the contexts of situated encounters. The paper is divided into two main sections. The first section presents central contributions of CA in relation to the distinctions between power over and power to, authority as a legitimate form of power, and deontics as a key concept in the analysis of power. The second section critically considers the tendency in CA to localize power solely to actions in interaction, and to conflate structure and action, which constraints the analysis and explanations of power. We present examples of how analyses of power, grounded in CA, can be extended to account for the dynamics of social structures and realities beyond the interactional encounters.
- Published
- 2023
- Full Text
- View/download PDF
7. Challenges of client participation in the co-development of social and health care services: Imbalances of control over action and the management of the interactional agenda
- Author
-
Melisa Stevanovic, Elina Weiste, and Lise-Lotte Uusitalo
- Subjects
Agenda management ,Client participation ,Conversation analysis ,Online interaction ,Co-development ,Social and health care services ,Public aspects of medicine ,RA1-1270 - Abstract
Client participation is not only about deciding on one's own treatment, but it may also be conceived more generally as the right of the client to influence the planning and development of social and health care services. In this paper, we examine participants' rights to control and influence action in workshops in which social and health care professionals and clients co-develop the social and health care services provided by their municipality. Drawing on conversation analysis as a method, we investigate the interwovenness of the participants' rights to control interaction in the encounter (proximal deontic rights) and their right to decide about those future actions that can have concrete health consequences for them (distal deontic rights). Maintaining that it is the clients' distal deontic rights that underlie the motivation and legitimacy for their participation in the co-development workshops, we ask about the extent to which the clients' distal deontic rights are underpinned and constrained by who has the proximal deontic rights in the situation. The data set involves both face-to-face and online workshops. Our analysis shows that, in the face-to-face workshops, the agenda management by professionals involved control over both proximal and distal action. In the online workshops, the professionals seemed to have technical difficulties that momentarily disrupted the fluency of interaction. Despite these problems, which in principle might have given the clients more space to participate, this did not seem to happen. In contrast, the clients had great difficulties managing the interactional agenda, losing control over both proximal and distal action. Promoting ethical and more balanced client participation in the co-development processes in the future necessitates heightened awareness of the nuanced practices of interaction by which power imbalances are realized.
- Published
- 2022
- Full Text
- View/download PDF
8. Beyond Utterances: Embodied Creativity and Compliance in Dance and Dementia
- Author
-
An Kosurko and Melisa Stevanovic
- Subjects
arts-based research ,ethnomethodology and conversation analysis ,instructed action ,directive–response sequences ,dementia ,multimodality ,Social Sciences - Abstract
Practices of creativity and compliance intersect in interaction when directing local dances remotely for people living with dementia and their carers in institutional settings. This ethnomethodological study focused on how artistic mechanisms are understood and structured by participants in response to on-screen instruction. Video data were collected from two long-term care facilities in Canada and Finland in a pilot study of a dance program that extended internationally from Canada to Finland at the onset of COVID-19. Fourteen hours of video data were analyzed using multimodal conversation analysis of initiation–response sequences. In this paper, we identify how creative instructed actions are produced in compliance with multimodal directives in interaction when mediated by technology and facilitated by copresent facilitators. We provide examples of how participants’ variably compliant responses in relation to dance instruction, from following a lead to coordinating with others, produce different creative actions from embellishing to improvising. Our findings suggest that cocreativity may be realized at intersections of compliance and creativity toward reciprocity. This research contributes to interdisciplinary discussions about the potential of arts-based practices in social inclusion, health, and well-being by studying how dance instruction is understood and realized remotely and in copresence in embodied instructed action and interaction.
- Published
- 2023
- Full Text
- View/download PDF
9. Making Food Decisions Together: Physiological and Affective Underpinnings of Relinquishing Preferences and Reaching Decisions
- Author
-
Melisa Stevanovic, Samuel Tuhkanen, Milla Järvensivu, Emmi Koskinen, Camilla Lindholm, Jenny Paananen, Enikö Savander, Taina Valkeapää, and Kaisa Valkiaranta
- Subjects
History of scholarship and learning. The humanities ,AZ20-999 ,Social Sciences - Abstract
We used a novel interdisciplinary experimental paradigm where two types of dyads—15 dyads with one depressed and one non-depressed participant and 15 dyads with two non-depressed participants—engaged in a series of food-decision-making tasks. We examined how different communicative events during the decision-making process were reflected in the affective responses of the interacting participants, as indicated in their skin conductance (SC) response rates. The participants’ SC response rates were found to be higher during the emergence of the final decision, compared to the other segments during the process. Furthermore, relinquishing one’s initially expressed preferences was associated with SC response rates higher than the baseline. However, during the relinquishment segments, there was a negative interaction between depression diagnosis and SC response rates, which suggests that, compared to their non-depressed comparisons, it is affectively less arousing for the participants with depression to give up their previously expressed preferences.
- Published
- 2022
- Full Text
- View/download PDF
10. Narratives about Negative Healthcare Service Experiences: Reported Events, Positioning, and Normative Discourse of an Active Client
- Author
-
Elina Weiste, Nanette Ranta, Melisa Stevanovic, Henri Nevalainen, Annika Valtonen, and Minna Leinonen
- Subjects
activeness ,client’s role ,experience ,narrative positioning analysis ,service satisfaction ,service feedback ,Medicine - Abstract
Narratives about clients’ service experiences in healthcare organizations constitute a crucial way for clients to make sense of their illness, its treatment, and their role in the service process. This is important because the client’s role has recently changed from that of a passive object of care into an active responsible agent. Utilizing Bamberg’s narrative positioning analysis as a method, and 14 thematic interviews of healthcare clients with multiple health-related problems as data, we investigated the expectations of the client’s role in their narratives about negative service experiences. All the narratives addressed the question of the clients’ “activeness” in some way. We identified three narrative types. In the first, the clients actively sought help, but did not receive it; in the second, the clients positioned themselves as helpless and inactive, left without the care they needed; and in the third, the clients argued against having to fight for their care. In all these narrative types, the clients either demonstrated their own activeness or justified their lack of it, which—despite attempts to resist the ideal of an “active client”—ultimately just reinforced it. Attempts to improve service experiences of clients with considerable service needs require a heightened awareness of clients’ moral struggles.
- Published
- 2022
- Full Text
- View/download PDF
11. Three Multimodal Action Packages in Responses to Proposals During Joint Decision-Making: The Embodied Delivery of Positive Assessments Including the Finnish Particle Ihan 'Quite'
- Author
-
Melisa Stevanovic
- Subjects
multimodal action packages ,joint decision-making ,conversation analysis ,proposals ,body movements ,participation ,Communication. Mass media ,P87-96 - Abstract
Joint decision-making is a thoroughly collaborative interactional endeavor. To construct the outcome of the decision-making sequence as a “joint” one necessitates that the participants constantly negotiate their shared activity, not only with reference to the content of the decisions to be made, but also with reference to whether, when, and upon what exactly decisions are to be made in the first place. In this paper, I draw on a dataset of video-recorded dyadic planning meetings between two church officials as data, investigating a collection of 35 positive assessments with the Finnish particle ihan “quite” occurring in response to a proposal (e.g., tää on ihan kiva “this is quite nice”). The analysis focuses on the embodied delivery of these assessments in combination with their other features: their sequential location and immediate interactional consequences (i.e., accounts, decisions, abandoning of the proposal), their auxiliary verbal turn-design features (i.e., particles), and the “agent” of the proposals that they are responsive to (i.e., who has made the proposal and whether it is based on some written authoritative material). Three multimodal action packages are described, in which the assessment serves 1) to accept an idea in principle, which is combined with no speaker movement, 2) to concede to a plan, which is associated with notable expressive speaker movement (e.g., head gestures, facial expressions) and 3) to establish a joint decision, which is accompanied by the participants’ synchronous body movements. The paper argues that the relative decision-implicativeness of these three multimodal action packages is largely based on the management and distribution of participation and agency between the two participants, which involves the participants using their bodies to position themselves toward their co-participants and toward the proposals “in the air” in distinct ways.
- Published
- 2021
- Full Text
- View/download PDF
12. The Psychophysiological Experience of Solving Moral Dilemmas Together: An Interdisciplinary Comparison Between Participants With and Without Depression
- Author
-
Emmi Koskinen, Samuel Tuhkanen, Milla Järvensivu, Enikö Savander, Taina Valkeapää, Kaisa Valkia, Elina Weiste, and Melisa Stevanovic
- Subjects
social interaction ,experimentation ,interdisciplinary research ,gaze ,depression ,psychophysiology ,Communication. Mass media ,P87-96 - Abstract
Dyads with a depressed and a non-depressed participant (N = 15) and two non-depressed participants (N = 15) discussed a moral dilemma, during which the participants’ gaze direction and skin conductance (SC) were measured. Partner gazing occurred most frequently when a speaker took a strong stance toward saving a person in the dilemma, depressed participants however looking at their co-participants less often than non-depressed participants. The participants’ SC response rates were higher during responsive utterances expressing disagreement (vs. agreement) with co-participant ideas or suggesting that a person be sacrificed (vs. saved). We argue that a better understanding of the affective corollaries of human social interaction necessitates a balanced consideration of both contents of talk and behavioral patterns.
- Published
- 2021
- Full Text
- View/download PDF
13. Physiological responses to proposals during dyadic decision-making conversations.
- Author
-
Melisa Stevanovic, Samuel Tuhkanen, Milla Järvensivu, Emmi Koskinen, Enikö Savander, and Kaisa Valkia
- Subjects
Medicine ,Science - Abstract
A novel conversation-analytically informed paradigm was used to examine how joint decision-making interaction, with its various types of proposal sequences, is reflected in the physiological responses of participants. Two types of dyads-dyads with one depressed and one non-depressed participant (N = 15) and dyads with two non-depressed participants (N = 15)-engaged in a series of conversational joint decision-making tasks, during which we measured their skin conductance (SC) responses. We found that the participants' SC response rates were higher and more synchronized during proposal sequences than elsewhere in the conversation. Furthermore, SC response rates were higher when the participant was in the role of a proposal speaker (vs. a proposal recipient), and making a proposal was associated with higher SC response rates for participants with depression (vs. participants without depression). Moreover, the SC response rates in the proposal speaker were higher when the recipient accepted (vs. not accepted) the proposal. We interpret this finding with reference to accepting responses suggesting a commitment to future action, for which the proposal speaker may feel specifically responsible for. A better understanding of the physiological underpinnings of joint decision-making interaction may help improve democratic practices in contexts where certain individuals experience challenges in this regard.
- Published
- 2021
- Full Text
- View/download PDF
14. Physiological responses to affiliation during conversation: Comparing neurotypical males and males with Asperger syndrome.
- Author
-
Melisa Stevanovic, Pentti Henttonen, Emmi Koskinen, Anssi Peräkylä, Taina Nieminen von-Wendt, Elina Sihvola, Pekka Tani, Niklas Ravaja, and Mikko Sams
- Subjects
Medicine ,Science - Abstract
We examined the emotional and psychophysiological underpinnings of social interaction in the context of autism spectrum disorder, more specifically, involving participants diagnosed with Asperger syndrome (AS). We recorded participants' autonomic nervous system (ANS) activation (electrodermal activity, heart rate, and heart rate variability) and facial muscle activation during conversations in two different types of male dyads: (1) ten dyads where one participant has been diagnosed with AS (AS/NT dyads) and (2) nine dyads where both participants are neurotypical (NT/NT dyads). Afterwards, three independent raters assessed continuously each participant's affiliative and dominant behaviors during the first and last 10 minutes of the conversations. The relationship between the assessed data and ANS responses was examined. We found that, in the NT/NT dyads, a high level of affiliation displayed by the conversational partner calms down the participant when they are actively dominating the interaction. In contrast, when the participants themselves expressed affiliation, their psychophysiological responses indicated increase in arousal, which suggests that the giving of affiliation is physiologically "hard work." The affiliation-related ANS responses were similar in those NT participants whose conversational partner had AS, while some differences in facial muscle activation did occur in comparison to NT/NT dyads. In the AS participants, in contrast, a high level of affiliation provided by the conversational partner was associated with increase in arousal, suggesting heightened alertness and stress. As for their own affiliative behavior, the AS participants exhibited similar indicators of alertness and stress as the NT participants, but only when their own level of dominance was low. Our results increase understanding of how individuals with AS experience social interaction at the physiological level, and how this experience differs from that in NT individuals. Moreover, our results confirm and further specify our earlier results, where we proposed that affiliation involves the type of "sharing of the burden" that also reverberates in the participants' bodies.
- Published
- 2019
- Full Text
- View/download PDF
15. Observing Social Connectedness in a Digital Dance Program for Older Adults: An EMCA Approach.
- Author
-
An Kosurko, Ilkka Arminen, Rachel Herron, Mark Skinner, and Melisa Stevanovic
- Published
- 2021
- Full Text
- View/download PDF
16. Joint Decision Making in Mental Health: An Interactional Approach
- Author
-
Camilla Lindholm, Melisa Stevanovic, Elina Weiste, Camilla Lindholm, Melisa Stevanovic, Elina Weiste
- Published
- 2020
17. Power Differentials in the Counseling Relationship: A Conversation Analytic Study on Goal-Setting Meetings in a Clubhouse Mental Health Rehabilitation Community
- Author
-
Melisa Stevanovic, Henri Nevalainen, Miira Niska, and Elina Weiste
- Subjects
Clinical Psychology ,General Psychology - Published
- 2023
18. On the Ideals of Interaction and Why and How They Fail
- Author
-
Melisa Stevanovic
- Subjects
Sociology and Political Science ,Social Psychology ,Communication ,General Social Sciences ,General Nursing ,Education - Published
- 2023
19. Sexual consent as an interactional achievement: Overcoming ambiguities and social vulnerabilities in the initiations of sexual activities
- Author
-
Simon Magnusson, Tuire Melisa Stevanovic, Tampere University, and Unit of Social Research
- Subjects
Linguistics and Language ,Social Psychology ,Anthropology ,Communication ,5141 Sociology ,Language and Linguistics - Abstract
Sexual consent is advocated around the world to reduce sexual assault. The widespread affirmative consent model emphasizes a need for unambiguous consent. In this paper, we contribute to a deeper understanding of how ambiguities in the initiations of sexual activities are routinely solved to achieve consent. Drawing on conversation analytic research on joint decision-making, and a dataset of 80 cases of sexual initiation in contemporary TV-series and movies, we investigate the interactional practices by which sexual activities are presented as consensual and how consent is achieved across sequences of interaction. We found there to be social advantages of synchronous initiation, compared to sequential verbal initiations, which were associated with various social vulnerabilities. These vulnerabilities could however be circumvented by two practices, each of which made use of a distinct combination of verbal and embodied resources. While ambiguities exist, our results oppose the idea of sexual consent as a practically hopeless and awkward endeavor. Instead, consent consists of joint action that is achieved through recognizable and systematic ways. publishedVersion
- Published
- 2022
20. Requests for concrete actions in interaction
- Author
-
Camilla Lindholm, Jenny Paananen, Melisa Stevanovic, Elina Weiste, and Taina Valkeapää
- Subjects
Linguistics and Language ,Philosophy ,Language and Linguistics - Abstract
In this study, we examine how support workers produce requests for concrete actions and, in this way, manage client participation in mental health rehabilitation. Drawing on Finnish rehabilitation group meetings as data and on conversation analysis, we examine how support workers design their requests for concrete action from clients, how clients respond, and how support workers deal with clients’ responses. The results reveal that support workers tend to use verbs indicating willingness when implementing their requests, whereas clients resort to the modality of possibility. By orienting to willingness, the support workers invoke clients’ sense of responsibility to contribute to group activities and simultaneously avoid questioning their capabilities. On the other hand, clients orient toward the underlying assumptions of social responsibility rather than to their own personal preferences. To conclude, our study demonstrates how support workers address the dilemma of increasing client participation and showing respect for client self-determination.
- Published
- 2023
21. Technological glitches and creative interactions in Sharing Dance
- Author
-
An Kosurko, Ilkka Arminen, Melisa Stevanovic, Herron, Rachel, Bar, Rachel, Skinner, Mark, Tampere University, and Unit of Social Research
- Subjects
515 Psychology ,520 Other social sciences ,5141 Sociology - Abstract
publishedVersion
- Published
- 2023
22. Prosodic Linking in Apology Sequences in Finnish Elementary School Mediations
- Author
-
Rosa Korpela, Melisa Stevanovic, and Salla Kurhila
- Published
- 2023
23. Epistemic calibration
- Author
-
Emmi Koskinen, Melisa Stevanovic, Tampere University, Unit of Social Research, Sociology, and Facing Narcissism
- Subjects
060201 languages & linguistics ,Linguistics and Language ,conversation analysis ,TOKEN ,epistemic access ,Computer science ,Calibration (statistics) ,05 social sciences ,ORGANIZATION ,06 humanities and the arts ,TALK ,050105 experimental psychology ,Language and Linguistics ,atypical interaction ,Philosophy ,storytelling ,5141 Sociology ,0602 languages and literature ,0501 psychology and cognitive sciences ,AUTISM ,affiliation ,Mathematical economics - Abstract
Sometimes a division has been made between expressions of knowledge and expressions of emotion, but in the actual instances of interaction, they are deeply intertwined. In this paper we investigate the relationship between these expressions through the notions of affiliation and epistemics. More specifically, we analyze the phenomenon of ‘epistemic calibration’ in response to tellings of personal experience, where recipients fine-tune the strength of their access claims and the degree of their generalizations to be in line with their epistemic statuses in relation to those of the tellers. Drawing on a dataset of Finnish quasi-natural conversations with neurotypical participants and participants diagnosed with Asperger syndrome, we explore how such calibration is done in practice. Our analysis points to different challenges in epistemic calibration, which, we argue, play an important role in influencing the hearing of these responses as less than fully affiliative. Sometimes a division has been made between expressions of knowledge and expressions of emotion, but in the actual instances of interaction, they are deeply intertwined. In this paper we investigate the relationship between these expressions through the notions of affiliation and epistemics. More specifically, we analyze the phenomenon of ‘epistemic calibration’ in response to tellings of personal experience, where recipients fine-tune the strength of their access claims and the degree of their generalizations to be in line with their epistemic statuses in relation to those of the tellers. Drawing on a dataset of Finnish quasi-natural conversations with neurotypical participants and participants diagnosed with Asperger syndrome, we explore how such calibration is done in practice. Our analysis points to different challenges in epistemic calibration, which, we argue, play an important role in influencing the hearing of these responses as less than fully affiliative.
- Published
- 2021
24. Expressing thinking in institutional interaction: Stancetaking in mental health rehabilitation group discussions
- Author
-
Jenny Paananen, Melisa Stevanovic, Taina Valkeapää, Tampere University, Unit of Social Research, Academic Disciplines of the Faculty of Social Sciences, Helsinki Inequality Initiative (INEQ), Facing Narcissism, Faculty Common Matters (Faculty of Social Sciences), University of Helsinki, and Faculty of Arts
- Subjects
Thought expression ,Linguistics and Language ,CLUBHOUSE ,Conversation analysis ,Interactional linguistics ,515 Psychology ,medicine.medical_treatment ,POWER ,DECISION-MAKING ,Institutional interaction ,Language and Linguistics ,Epistemics ,Power (social and political) ,03 medical and health sciences ,0302 clinical medicine ,Artificial Intelligence ,EMOTION ,medicine ,6121 Languages ,060201 languages & linguistics ,Rehabilitation ,06 humanities and the arts ,16. Peace & justice ,Mental health ,030227 psychiatry ,Wonder ,Stancetaking ,Dynamics (music) ,5141 Sociology ,0602 languages and literature ,Psychology ,Social psychology - Abstract
This paper focuses on the stancetaking formats used to express personal thoughts, namely Finnish mä aattelen/aattelin ‘I think/thought’, mä mietin ‘I think/wonder’, and mun mielestä/musta ‘I think/in my opinion’. We study how these first-person formats are used in mental health rehabilitation group meetings, which aim to promote joint decision-making. In particular, we analyze whether the institutional asymmetry between support workers and clients is reflected in the use of these thought expressions. Our data comprise 23 video-recorded rehabilitation meetings, and the adopted methods are conversation analysis and interactional linguistics. Most of the stancetaking formats in our data are produced by support workers (106/129). The results of a sequential analysis conducted in this study demonstrate that support workers' thought expressions are embedded in their institutional actions, which are beyond the clients' authority. Moreover, our data suggest that support workers' and rehabilitants' thought expressions generate different participation dynamics. Although previous research has considered I think-formats typically as calls for other views, in institutional settings such as ours, these formats can also be interpreted as highlighting an institutional agent's controlling position. Acknowledging the existence of such differences in stancetaking practices can advance the design of new protocols to facilitate client participation. publishedVersion
- Published
- 2021
25. Deontic authority and the maintenance of lay and expert identities during joint decision making: Balancing resistance and compliance
- Author
-
Melisa Stevanovic, Tampere University, and Unit of Social Research
- Subjects
Linguistics and Language ,Social Psychology ,515 Psychology ,Communication ,Deontic logic ,Field (Bourdieu) ,Professional development ,Socialization ,Resistance (psychoanalysis) ,Language and Linguistics ,Compliance (psychology) ,Anthropology ,5141 Sociology ,Joint (building) ,Engineering ethics ,Psychology ,Competence (human resources) - Abstract
Expertise is commonly viewed as a professionalized competence in a specific field. Expert professional identities are produced and reproduced through professional training and other socialization mechanisms, which work to generate for a specific group of individuals a specific set of expert skills and knowledge. In this paper, I examine participants’ orientations to their distinct expert professional identities from the perspective of deontic authority. Drawing on 15 video-recorded church workplace meetings between pastors and cantors as data, and conversation analysis as a theoretical and methodological framework, I analyze situations where a non-expert participant makes a proposal that the expert participant orients to as reasonable to comply with. Specifically, I demonstrate how the expert participants respond to these proposals with displays of deontic authority, arguably in an attempt to maintain their expert identities in the face of their de facto compliance with the proposals. In these situations, the expert participants are shown to invoke (1) a past decision of their own, (2) a future decision of their own, or (3) a pattern that is beyond both participants’ control. Each of these practices involves the expert participant balancing resistance and compliance by minimally acknowledging the content of the non-expert participant’s proposal, while excluding the non-expert from those who have deontic authority in the matter. In so doing, the expert speaker implies that the non-expert proposal speaker lacks (1) procedural knowledge about the specific matters about which it is relevant to make proposals to experts and (2) access to the distinct experiential perspective that characterizes expert perception of things. It is thus argued that, in this context, the mere claims of deontic authority, produced without any substantial displays of expert knowledge, can serve the maintenance of expert professional identities. acceptedVersion
- Published
- 2021
26. Affiliation, topicality, and Asperger’s
- Author
-
Emmi Koskinen, Melisa Stevanovic, Anssi Peräkylä, Sociology, and Facing Narcissism
- Subjects
Linguistics and Language ,topicality ,autism spectrum disorder ,Language and Linguistics ,Developmental psychology ,Speech and Hearing ,storytelling ,Asperger syndrome ,GIRL ,COHERENCE ,medicine ,REPETITION ,Relevance (law) ,0501 psychology and cognitive sciences ,affiliation ,Set (psychology) ,060201 languages & linguistics ,05 social sciences ,06 humanities and the arts ,medicine.disease ,Conversation analysis ,HIGH-FUNCTIONING CHILDREN ,Action (philosophy) ,Autism spectrum disorder ,5141 Sociology ,0602 languages and literature ,Psychology ,GAZE ,story reception ,Neurotypical ,050104 developmental & child psychology ,Storytelling - Abstract
Objective: In storytelling environments, recipients' questions have mainly been described as non-affiliative. This article examines how the topicality of story-responsive questions relates to the recipients' displays of affiliation. Furthermore, we investigate whether there are differences between the practices of neurotypical participants (NT) and participants diagnosed with Asperger syndrome (AS) in this regard. While aiming to uncover the practices of story-responsive questions in general, we also seek to shed light on the specific interactional features associated with AS. Method: Our method is qualitative conversation analysis. Drawing on a dataset of Finnish quasi-natural conversations, we compare the interactional consequences of story-responsive questions asked by NT-and AS-participants. Results: We show how the NT-participants in our data use a specific set of practices to manage the topical relevance of their questions, while the AS-participants' production of otherwise very similar questions differs precisely with reference to these practices. Discussion: We argue that the different ways in which the NT-and AS-participants treat the topicality of their questions influence the relative affiliative import of the questions in subtle, but yet significant ways. Conclusions: The affiliative import of story-responsive questions can only really be seen in retrospect, since, in their subsequent turns, the questioner can cast their action as having prepared the ground for affiliation. Objective: In storytelling environments, recipients' questions have mainly been described as non-affiliative. This article examines how the topicality of story-responsive questions relates to the recipients' displays of affiliation. Furthermore, we investigate whether there are differences between the practices of neurotypical participants (NT) and participants diagnosed with Asperger syndrome (AS) in this regard. While aiming to uncover the practices of story-responsive questions in general, we also seek to shed light on the specific interactional features associated with AS. Method: Our method is qualitative conversation analysis. Drawing on a dataset of Finnish quasi-natural conversations, we compare the interactional consequences of story-responsive questions asked by NT- and AS-participants. Results: We show how the NT-participants in our data use a specific set of practices to manage the topical relevance of their questions, while the AS-participants' production of otherwise very similar questions differs precisely with reference to these practices. Discussion: We argue that the different ways in which the NT- and AS-participants treat the topicality of their questions influence the relative affiliative import of the questions in subtle, but yet significant ways. Conclusions: The affiliative import of story-responsive questions can only really be seen in retrospect, since, in their subsequent turns, the questioner can cast their action as having prepared the ground for affiliation.
- Published
- 2021
27. Interactional use of compliments in mental health rehabilitation
- Author
-
Taina Valkeapää, Camilla Lindholm, Elina Weiste, Melisa Stevanovic, Tampere University, Language Studies, Unit of Social Research, Department of Finnish, Finno-Ugrian and Scandinavian Studies, and Faculty of Arts
- Subjects
050101 languages & linguistics ,Linguistics and Language ,Conversation analysis ,Process (engineering) ,medicine.medical_treatment ,Context (language use) ,Positive assessment ,050105 experimental psychology ,Language and Linguistics ,Professional interaction ,Compliment ,Artificial Intelligence ,medicine ,Group interaction ,6121 Languages ,0501 psychology and cognitive sciences ,ENGLISH ,Rehabilitation ,SEQUENCES ,05 social sciences ,Mental health ,Social relation ,5141 Sociology ,Mental health care ,Psychology ,Social psychology - Abstract
Complimenting is a valuable skill in mental health care. Today, several clinical models view positive reinforcement as beneficial for the client's process of change; however, they ignore the ambiguous nature of complimenting in social interaction. Drawing on a data set of 29 video-recorded mental health rehabilitation group meetings, and using conversation analysis as the method, we qualitatively analyzed the range of purposes served by positive assessments doing complimenting. Our results showed that compliments were used for 1) encouraging members to participate in the community, 2) increasing the pressure on members to respond, 3) closing down topics that were not relevant for discussion at that moment, and 4) generating exclusion and preparing a member for a negative decision. Our findings demonstrate that not all compliments serve straightforwardly positive interactional goals, as they are used for advancing mental-health professionals' own agendas. Moreover, due to the positive nature of the compliments per se, it is difficult for compliment recipients to resist the functions that compliments are designed to serve. The study contributes to a more nuanced understanding of what might constitute genuinely positive reinforcement in the continually changing context of moment-by-moment social interaction. Complimenting is a valuable skill in mental health care. Today, several clinical models view positive reinforcement as beneficial for the client's process of change; however, they ignore the ambiguous nature of complimenting in social interaction. Drawing on a data set of 29 video-recorded mental health rehabilitation group meetings, and using conversation analysis as the method, we qualitatively analyzed the range of purposes served by positive assessments doing complimenting. Our results showed that compliments were used for 1) encouraging members to participate in the community, 2) increasing the pressure on members to respond, 3) closing down topics that were not relevant for discussion at that moment, and 4) generating exclusion and preparing a member for a negative decision. Our findings demonstrate that not all compliments serve straightforwardly positive interactional goals, as they are used for advancing mental-health professionals' own agendas. Moreover, due to the positive nature of the compliments per se, it is difficult for compliment recipients to resist the functions that compliments are designed to serve. The study contributes to a more nuanced understanding of what might constitute genuinely positive reinforcement in the continually changing context of moment-by-moment social interaction.
- Published
- 2021
28. Interactional means of teaming up: enacting the features of contemporary working life in a theater performance
- Author
-
Riikka Nissi, Melisa Stevanovic, Tampere University, and Unit of Social Research
- Subjects
collective action ,050101 languages & linguistics ,Linguistics and Language ,media_common.quotation_subject ,0507 social and economic geography ,Collective action ,Multimodality ,representaatio ,teatteritaide ,0501 psychology and cognitive sciences ,työelämä ,multimodality ,multimodaalisuus ,media_common ,Teamwork ,Working life ,työelämän suhteet ,Communication ,enacting ,05 social sciences ,kollektiivinen toiminta ,tiimityö ,näytelmät ,theater ,5142 Social policy ,Engineering ethics ,teamwork ,Psychology ,050703 geography - Abstract
The article examines how the aspects of the social world are enacted in a theater play. The data come from a videotaped performance of a professional theater, portraying a story about a workplace organization going through a personnel training program. The aim of the study is to show how the core theme of the play – the teaming up of the personnel – is constructed in the live performance through a range of interactional means. By focusing on four core episodes of the play, the study on the one hand points out to the multiple changes taking place both within and between the different episodes of the play. On the other hand, the episodes of collective action involving the semiotic resources of singing and dancing are shown to represent the ideals of teamwork in distinct ways. The study contributes to the understanding of socially and politically oriented theater as a distinct, pre-rehearsed social setting and the means and practices that it deploys when enacting the aspects of the contemporary societal issues.
- Published
- 2021
29. Conversation Analysis in Research on Children's Ethical and Moral Decision-Making in ECEC
- Author
-
Melisa Stevanovic and Arniika Kuusisto
- Published
- 2022
30. The Routledge International Handbook of the Place of Religion in Early Childhood Education and Care
- Author
-
Arniika Kuusisto, Saila Poulter, and Tuire Melisa Stevanovic
- Published
- 2022
31. Challenges of trust in atypical interaction
- Author
-
Camilla Lindholm, Tuire Melisa Stevanovic, Tampere University, Language Studies, and Unit of Social Research
- Subjects
Linguistics and Language ,515 Psychology ,5141 Sociology ,6121 Languages ,Language and Linguistics - Abstract
All effective communication is based on the participants trusting that they share their basic orientations to the world – that is, they have a common ground. In this paper, however, we examine situations in which such trust is lacking. Drawing on conversation–analytic methodology and on 30 hours of video data featuring persons with dementia and their caregivers in a Swedish-language daycare center in Finland, we consider some of the social consequences resulting from a lack of trust. Our analysis focused on three different interactional contexts, highlighting the relevance of different facets of the participants’ common ground. These facets are anchored in the deontic, epistemic, and emotional orders, respectively. We show that, with regard to each order, a lack of trust in the existence of common ground has drastic consequences, leading to (1) problems related to getting one’s will acknowledged, (2) a scarcity of conversational partners, and (3) a lack of resources to maintain affection.
- Published
- 2022
32. Vuorovaikutus, osallistuminen ja tekstin yhteinen tuottaminen
- Author
-
Melisa Stevanovic, Esa Lehtinen, Riikka Nissi, Elina Weiste, Camilla Lindholm, and Taina Valkeapää
- Subjects
General Medicine ,General Chemistry - Abstract
Osallistumiseen kasvattaminen on keskeinen, läpi elämän jatkuva sosialisaation haaste. Konkreettinen osallistumiseen kasvattamisen keino on tekstin yhteinen tuottaminen kasvokkaisessa vuorovaikutuksessa, mitä tässä tapaustutkimuksessa tarkastelemme kahdessa ryhmässä: 1) uusiin työkäytänteisiin keskittyvässä henkilöstökoulutuksessa ja 2) työelämään valmentavassa mielenterveyskuntoutuksessa. Tutkimusmenetelmänä on keskustelunanalyysi, jonka avulla yhtäältä selvitämme, miten osallistumista pyritään edistämään tekstin yhteisen tuottamisen avulla. Toisaalta tarkastelemme tämän tavoitteen toteutumista käytännössä kysyen, millaisia osallistumisen mahdollisuuksia ja rajoitteita tekstin avulla osallistaminen faktuaalisesti tuo vuorovaikutukseen. Analyysimme viittaa osallistamispyrkimysten ja todellisen osallistumisen väliseen jännitteeseen. Henkilöstökoulutuksessa tekstin yhteinen tuottaminen näyttää edistävän osallistumista, mikä ilmenee osallistujien tavassa jatkaa toistensa aloittamia lauseita sisällöllisesti ja syntaktisesti sekä pyrkiä yhteistoiminnassa saattamaan ajatukset dokumentointikelpoiseen muotoon. Kirjoittamistoiminnan kannalta tuotettavan tekstin yhteisen omistajuuden säilyttäminen on silti haasteellista, mikä asettaa osallistumiselle myös rajoitteita. Mielenterveyskuntoutuksessa tavoitteiden ja käytännön välinen jännite on erityisen selkeä, mikä haastaakin kehittämään tässä kontekstissa paremmin toimivia yhteiskirjoittamisen käytäntöjä. Yhteisöllisten tekstikäytänteiden hallinta ei synny vain kirjoitusmahdollisuuden tarjoamisesta, vaan sitä on tuettava pedagogisin ratkaisuin.
- Published
- 2020
33. Prosody and grammar of other-repetitions in Finnish: Repair initiations, registerings, and affectivity
- Author
-
Anna Vatanen, Melisa Stevanovic, Auli Hakulinen, Helsinki Inequality Initiative (INEQ), Facing Narcissism, Faculty of Social Sciences, Sociology, and Department of Finnish, Finno-Ugrian and Scandinavian Studies
- Subjects
050101 languages & linguistics ,Linguistics and Language ,Matching (statistics) ,Sociology and Political Science ,Repetition (rhetorical device) ,Grammar ,media_common.quotation_subject ,05 social sciences ,050105 experimental psychology ,Language and Linguistics ,Linguistics ,Feature (linguistics) ,Conversation analysis ,REPEATS ,6121 Languages ,0501 psychology and cognitive sciences ,Psychology ,Prosody ,media_common - Abstract
We examine how other-repetitions in Finnish are used for repairing interactional problems in hearing and understanding and for registering what another has just said, describing how prosody and grammar interact in accomplishing these goals. In the repair-initiating repetitions, the pitch contours build a continuum of different degrees of falling pitch from moderate to steep, the latter being associated with some type of an affective stance. In the registering repetitions, the pitch fall is generally narrower than in the repair-initiations, the pitch span of the repetition turn typically matching that of the original turn. A notable feature of other-repetitions in Finnish is the use of particles (mostlyaiandvai), which deal specifically with the informational aspects of other-repetitions, thus contributing to the design of both repair-initiating and registering repetitions. The article illustrates the complex layering of actions that Finnish as a ‘particle language’ affords. (Conversation analysis, other-repetition, prosody, grammar, Finnish, repair, registering, affectivity, response particle)
- Published
- 2020
34. Apologizing in Elementary School Peer Conflict Mediation
- Author
-
Rosa Korpela, Salla Kurhila, Tuire Melisa Stevanovic, Department of Finnish, Finno-Ugrian and Scandinavian Studies, Tampere University, and Unit of Social Research
- Subjects
SORRY ,Linguistics and Language ,Social Psychology ,5142 Social policy ,515 Psychology ,Communication ,IDENTITY ,6121 Languages ,ORGANIZATION ,DISPUTE RESOLUTION - Abstract
We analyze apologizing as part of the institutional agenda of school mediation in Finland. When primary school teachers intervene to mediate a dispute, the children orient to apologizing as a ritualized, expected, and recognizable action that resolves the matter. Teachers build, step by step, a sequence that, when preconditions are met, results in the parties involved in the dispute producing the uniquely explicit apology exchange “I apologize”—“apology accepted.” We discuss the action of apologizing as involving an interdependence and tension between sincerity and rituality. Data are in Finnish with English translation. publishedVersion
- Published
- 2022
35. Joint decision making in a mental health rehabilitation community : the impact of support workers’ proposal design on client responsiveness
- Author
-
Melisa Stevanovic, Camilla Lindholm, Taina Valkeapää, Elina Weiste, Faculty of Social Sciences, Department of Social Research (2010-2017), Helsinki Inequality Initiative (INEQ), Facing Narcissism, Sociology, Faculty of Arts, Department of Finnish, Finno-Ugrian and Scandinavian Studies, Informaatioteknologian ja viestinnän tiedekunta - Faculty of Information Technology and Communication Sciences, Tampere University, and Language Studies
- Subjects
INVOLVEMENT ,050103 clinical psychology ,Sosiologia - Sociology ,responsiveness ,conversation analysis ,520 Other social sciences ,medicine.medical_treatment ,Applied psychology ,päätöksenteko ,PARTICIPATION ,vastaaminen ,ORGANIZATION ,QUESTIONS ,Muut yhteiskuntatieteet - Other social sciences ,PSYCHOTHERAPY ,SCHIZOPHRENIA ,medicine ,participation ,0501 psychology and cognitive sciences ,6121 Languages ,Applied Psychology ,osallistuminen ,Mielenterveyskuntoutus ,OUTCOMES ,Rehabilitation ,keskustelunanalyysi ,CONSULTATIONS ,05 social sciences ,Kielitieteet - Languages ,Mental health rehabilitation ,RECOVERY ,Mental health ,ehdotukset ,050106 general psychology & cognitive sciences ,Psychiatry and Mental health ,Clinical Psychology ,Conversation analysis ,PERSPECTIVES ,joint decision making ,5141 Sociology ,proposals ,Joint (building) ,Psychology - Abstract
Using both statistical methods and conversation analysis, we examined how support workers in a mental health rehabilitation community encourage clients to participate in joint decision-making processes. Drawing on video-recordings of 29 community meetings as data, we considered support workers’ proposals (N = 449) and clients’ responsiveness to them. Support workers’ proposals were coded for their linguistic and other features and clients’ responsiveness was assessed by three independent raters. Multiple linear regression (MLR) analysis was carried out. A significant regression equation with seven predictor variables accounted for 24% of the variance in the data. Four variables predicted a higher level of client responsiveness: the use of explicit recipient address term, “quasi open” proposal form, support worker’s long work experience, and the average level of client participation during a session. Three variables predicted a lower level of client responsiveness: grammatical complexity of proposal form, modal declarative proposal form, and the presence of only one support worker in a session. The qualitative conversation-analytic investigation highlighted the advantages of the careful fine-tuning of openness vs. closedness of proposal form, the reflexive awareness of which, we argue, may help mental health professionals to encourage clients’ responsiveness in joint decision-making processes and thereby their participation in communal life. Using both statistical methods and conversation analysis, we examined how support workers in a mental health rehabilitation community encourage clients to participate in joint decision-making processes. Drawing on video-recordings of 29 community meetings as data, we considered support workers’ proposals (N = 449) and clients’ responsiveness to them. Support workers’ proposals were coded for their linguistic and other features and clients’ responsiveness was assessed by three independent raters. Multiple linear regression (MLR) analysis was carried out. A significant regression equation with seven predictor variables accounted for 24% of the variance in the data. Four variables predicted a higher level of client responsiveness: the use of explicit recipient address term, “quasi-open” proposal form, support worker’s long work experience, and the average level of client participation during a session. Three variables predicted a lower level of client responsiveness: grammatical complexity of proposal form, modal declarative proposal form, and the presence of only one support worker in a session. The qualitative conversation-analytic investigation highlighted the advantages of the careful fine-tuning of openness vs. closedness of proposal form, the reflexive awareness of which, we argue, may help mental health professionals to encourage clients’ responsiveness in joint decision-making processes and thereby their participation in communal life.
- Published
- 2022
36. Goal Setting in Mental Health Rehabilitation : References to Competence and Interest as Resources for Negotiating Goals
- Author
-
Elina Weiste, Miira Niska, Taina Valkeapää, Melisa Stevanovic, Tampere University, and Unit of Social Research
- Subjects
515 Psychology ,5141 Sociology - Abstract
Goal setting is at the heart of mental health rehabilitation, but its joint negotiation by clinicians and clients has proven to be a challenging endeavor. This paper investigates goal setting decision-making in the context of Clubhouse Communities: non-profit organizations designed to pave the way for the recovery of individuals diagnosed with mental illnesses. Using the method of conversation analysis, we demonstrate how clinicians make and account for proposals to involve clients in the discussion as more equal partners. In these accounts, clinicians highlight the client’s potential in terms of either competence or interest. Clients, in turn, resist clinicians’ proposals by invoking the opposing factor: when clinicians highlight clients’ competence, clients appeal to their lack of interest and vice versa. In this way, clients are able to reject clinicians’ goal-proposals without disagreeing with the rationalizations of their competence or interest. By contrast, jointly formulated decisions are best reached when clinicians focus the talk on the characteristics of the desired activity rather than on the characteristics of the client. In so doing, clients are able to claim personal ownership of the goal.
- Published
- 2022
37. Peer support for accepting distressing reality: Expertise and experience-sharing in psychiatric peer-to-peer group discussions
- Author
-
Elina Weiste, Melisa Stevanovic, Lise-Lotte Uusitalo, Hanna Toiviainen, Tampere University, Unit of Social Research, and Education
- Subjects
Health (social science) ,515 Psychology ,5141 Sociology ,516 Educational sciences - Abstract
Peer-based interventions are increasingly used for delivering mental health services to help people with an illness re-examine their situation and accept their illness as part of their life story. The role of the peer supporter in these interventions, known as experts-by-experience (EbE), is situated between mutual peer support and semi-professional service delivery, and they face the challenge of balancing an asymmetric, professional relationship with a reciprocal, mutuality-based, equal relationship. This article investigates how EbEs tackle this challenge when responding to clients’ stories about their personal, distressing experiences in peer-based groups in psychiatric services. The results show how the EbEs responded to their clients’ experience-sharing with two types of turns of talk. In the first response type, the EbEs highlighted reciprocal experience-sharing, nudging the clients toward accepting their illness. This invoked mutual affiliation and more problem-talk from the clients. In the second response type, the EbEs compromised reciprocal experience-sharing and advised clients on how to accept their illness in their everyday lives. This was considered less affiliative in relation to the client’s problem description, and the sequence was brought to a close. Both response types involved epistemic asymmetries that needed to be managed in the interaction. Based on our analysis, semi-professional, experience-based expertise involves constant epistemic tensions, as the participants struggle to retain the mutual orientation toward peer-based experience-sharing and affiliation. publishedVersion
- Published
- 2023
38. University teaching development workshops as sites of joint decision-making: Negotiations of authority in academic cultures
- Author
-
Leena Ripatti-Torniainen, Tuire Melisa Stevanovic, Tampere University, Communication Sciences, and Unit of Social Research
- Subjects
518 Media and communications ,5141 Sociology ,516 Educational sciences ,Education - Abstract
This study analyzed interactional practices in the strategic development of teaching at a research university in Finland. Drawing on a novel combination of conversation analysis and cultural discourse analysis, the study investigated how participants negotiate decision-making power and authority when developing new interdisciplinary teaching in workshop groups. Specific attention was paid to the participants' ways of making and responding to each other's proposals and invoking disciplinary and pedagogical knowledge as a basis for steering joint decision-making interaction. The study made use of the distinction between epistemic authority (i.e., expertise in a field of knowledge) and deontic authority (i.e., power to determine action), as well as the notion of academic cultures. The study identified three different academic cultures of negotiating authority, each associated with a workshop group: the collegial, developmental, and managerial cultures. Furthermore, the study showed that both disciplinary and pedagogical mastery can occasionally prevent inclusive dialogue that plays an elementary role in enabling joint decision-making in the development of teaching at universities. publishedVersion
- Published
- 2023
39. Experiential expertise in the co-development of social and health-care services: Self-promotion and self-dismissal as interactional strategies
- Author
-
Elina Weiste, Melisa Stevanovic, Lise‐Lotte Uusitalo, Tampere University, and Unit of Social Research
- Subjects
Employment ,Health (social science) ,5142 Social policy ,Health Policy ,Communication ,5141 Sociology ,Public Health, Environmental and Occupational Health ,Humans ,Health Services ,3142 Public health care science, environmental and occupational health - Abstract
Increasing client involvement in the development of social and health-care services has resulted in clients being invited to present their experiential knowledge in service co-development groups. Nevertheless, research has shown that their opportunities to really contribute to actual decision-making are limited. This article investigates how client representatives initiate turns-at-talk in the decision-making context and the way in which professionals respond to them. Using conversation analysis, we analyzed 15 h of recorded interactions in five co-development workshops. Our data exhibited a systematic pattern that linked client representatives’ self-promoting and self-dismissive turns-at-talk to specific types of responses from professionals. When the client representatives highlighted the relevance of their experiential knowledge for making decisions, the professionals disregarded their contributions. However, if instead, the client representatives cast their experiential knowledge as irrelevant to the decision-making activity at hand, the professionals subsequently appreciated this knowledge. Thus, paradoxically, in order to establish the relevance of their views, client representatives diminished their positions as experiential experts. publishedVersion
- Published
- 2021
40. Movement synchrony as a topic of empirical social interaction research
- Author
-
Tommi Himberg, Melisa Stevanovic, Lindström, Jan, Laury, Ritva, Peräkylä, Anssi, Sorjonen, Marja-Leena, Tampere University, and Unit of Social Research
- Subjects
515 Psychology ,Movement (music) ,5141 Sociology ,Psychology ,Social relation ,Cognitive psychology - Abstract
In this chapter, we consider movement synchrony from two different perspectives. On the one hand, we report a small-scale empirical study to test the hypothesis that movement synchrony is a sequential phenomenon, which serves as a demonstration of how conversation analytically informed research on participants’ unconscious tendencies to synchronize their body movements could proceed in practice. On the other hand, we consider movement synchrony through three closely related, yet essentially different, conceptual lenses: conditional relevance, dialogic resonance, and affordance. We suggest that a specific combination of the insights provided by these three conceptual tools would make conversation analytically informed study of movement synchrony both possible and fruitful. acceptedVersion
- Published
- 2021
41. Discussing mental health difficulties in a 'diagnosis free zone'
- Author
-
Elina Weiste, Kaisa Valkiaranta, Melisa Stevanovic, Camilla Lindholm, Taina Valkeapää, Tampere University, Language Studies, Unit of Social Research, Department of Finnish, Finno-Ugrian and Scandinavian Studies, and Faculty of Social Sciences
- Subjects
Health (social science) ,Conversation analysis ,515 Psychology ,media_common.quotation_subject ,medicine.medical_treatment ,Applied psychology ,Social Stigma ,518 Media and communications ,Stigma (botany) ,050109 social psychology ,Affect (psychology) ,TALK ,3124 Neurology and psychiatry ,History and Philosophy of Science ,MEDICATION ,Mentally Ill Persons ,Diagnosis ,SCHIZOPHRENIA ,medicine ,DECISIONS ,Humans ,0501 psychology and cognitive sciences ,6121 Languages ,Medical diagnosis ,Normality ,Finland ,media_common ,060201 languages & linguistics ,Rehabilitation ,Mental Disorders ,05 social sciences ,06 humanities and the arts ,Mental illness ,medicine.disease ,Mental health ,3. Good health ,Normalization ,Stigma ,0602 languages and literature ,5141 Sociology ,Psychology ,RESPONSES - Abstract
Publisher Copyright: © 2021 The Authors Being identified as “mentally ill” is a complicated social process that may be stigmatizing and socially problematic, as a mental illness diagnosis determines the criteria for what is considered normal. This has given rise to a number of anti-stigma campaigns designed to create awareness of the way stigmas affect people with mental health difficulties and to normalize those difficulties in society. One such campaign is the “diagnosis-free zone”, which declares that those with mental health difficulties should not be categorized on the basis of their diagnosis; rather, they should be encountered as full individuals. In this paper, we investigate how mental health difficulties are discussed in Clubhouse communities, which adhere to the “diagnosis free zone” programme. The findings are based on conversation analysis of 29 video-recorded rehabilitation group meetings, in one Finnish Clubhouse, intended to advance clients' return to the labour market. The analysis demonstrated that members referred to their mental health difficulties to explain the misfortunes in their lives, especially interruptions and stoppages in their careers. By contrast, staff members disattended members’ explanations and normalized their situations as typical of all humans and thus unrelated to their mental health difficulties as such. In this way, the discussion of mental health difficulties at the Clubhouse meetings was implicitly discouraged. We propose that the standards of normality expected of a person not suffering from a mental health difficulty may well be different from the expectations levelled at participants with a history of mental problems. Therefore, instead of considering cultural expectations of normality to be a unified domain, effective anti-stigma work might sometimes benefit from referring to mental-health diagnoses as a means of explicitly tailoring expectations of normality.
- Published
- 2021
42. Kohtaamisia kentällä: Soveltava keskusteluntutkimus ammatillisissa ympäristöissä
- Author
-
Camilla Wide, Riku Laakkonen, Niina Lilja, Tuire Melisa Stevanovic, Riikka Nissi, Elina Weiste, Marjo Savijärvi, and Camilla Lindholm
- Subjects
4. Education - Abstract
Encounters in the field Applied conversation analysis in professional contexts Societal impact is an integral part of academic research today and researchers are expected to share their findings with research participants. Efforts to develop scientific research and science communication from one-way communication towards different forms of co-creation where the researcher and research participants produce knowledge and negotiate about its meaning and applicability through joint actions are in great demand. For the researcher, such developments have brought a new kind of access into the world of research participants and also novel reflections on one’s professional knowledge and identity and their boundaries. This book focuses on the human and social sciences and draws particular attention to the diverse encounters that occur between researchers and research participants at all stages of the research process when studying human subjects and activities. The book presents case studies of applied conversation analysis in a variety of professional contexts. The aim of the book is to shed light on the practices, possibilities, and challenges of applied research within the conversation analytic framework where the research participants’ authentic social situations become the target of the researcher’s detailed analysis. The articles of the book investigate social interaction in occupational health care, mental health rehabilitation, elderly care, welfare education, theatre rehearsals, social circus, military organization, software development, and workplace community break taking. These articles represent applied conversation analysis in different ways. The results of the research have been used in some of the articles, for example, in developing the professional practices of the workplace community whereas in some other articles the whole study has been undertaken collaboratively between researchers and professionals. Each article is divided into two parts: a conventional research report that analyses the patterns of social interaction in a particular professional setting is followed by a story where the authors reflect on how their study originated, how it progressed, and what kinds of encounters and choices it involved. The stories highlighting reciprocal interactions of the researcher and the research participants across the research process bring forth various voices and perspectives that conventionally are not considered as part of the research report. The book brings important information not only on the interactional phenomena examined in the articles but also on the diverse issues of conducting and applying research in professional contexts. It also discusses the practices and definitions of applied conversation analysis within the broader framework of applied research, universities’ third mission, and forms of knowledge and expertise in contemporary society.
- Published
- 2021
43. Monitoring and evaluating body knowledge: metaphors and metonymies of body position in children’s music instrument instruction
- Author
-
Melisa Stevanovic, Helsinki Inequality Initiative (INEQ), Facing Narcissism, Faculty Common Matters (Faculty of Social Sciences), and University of Helsinki
- Subjects
050101 languages & linguistics ,Linguistics and Language ,conversation analysis ,Metaphor ,media_common.quotation_subject ,LANGUAGE ,ORGANIZATION ,TALK ,metaphor ,050105 experimental psychology ,Language and Linguistics ,Multimodality ,6121 Languages ,0501 psychology and cognitive sciences ,body knowledge ,media_common ,Metonymy ,SEQUENCES ,music instruction ,05 social sciences ,Body position ,Cognition ,LEARNABLES ,Linguistics ,Conversation analysis ,5141 Sociology ,COGNITION ,metonymy ,MULTIMODALITY ,Psychology - Abstract
This paper examines music instrument teachers’ instructive use of noun metaphors and metonymies of behaviors related to the playing and handling of a musical instrument. Drawing on 10 video-recorded 30–40 min-long instrument lessons as data, and conversation analysis as a method, the paper examines the temporal location of these figurative turns (i.e., instruction turns including a noun metaphor or metonymy) within the instructional activities and in relation to the student’s behaviors. At the beginning of a new instructional sequence, a figurative turn allows the teacher to test and monitor the level of student’s knowledge, while the student orients to a need to demonstrate that knowledge. Figurative turns also enable the teacher to initiate correction in complex movement sequences, its organization as a series of metaphors or metonymies enabling an easy return to an earlier point in a sequence. Furthermore, the flexibility of metaphors and metonymies as interactional resources is evidenced by the ease by which a figurative instruction turn may be transformed into an affirmative evaluation of student conduct. The paper thus suggests that instructing body knowledge through metaphors and metonymies has significant pedagogical advantages, also providing a detailed account for why and how this is the case.
- Published
- 2021
44. Keskustelunanalyysi ja fokusryhmien diskursiivinen tutkimus
- Author
-
Elina Weiste, Tuire Melisa Stevanovic, Sosiologia, Henkilöstöpalvelut, and Suomalais-ugrilainen ja pohjoismainen osasto
- Subjects
General Energy ,fokusryhmät, keskustelunanalyysi, diskursiivinen tutkimus ,focus groups, conversation analysis, discursive research ,education ,6121 Kielitieteet ,Artikkelit ,5141 Sosiologia - Abstract
We introduce a focus-group approach where we draw on a combination of discursive focus-group research and conversation analysis. We explore how the analysis of focus-group talk may attend equally to the content of the group members’ talk and to the interactional dynamics of that talk. Essentially, we propose that the notions of social praxis and action allow researchers to consider focus-group data as a window to the social world that pre-exists the focus-group encounter. However, this world is accessible to the researcher only through the local organization of action in the encounter, which needs to be taken as the priority of analysis. In eliciting maximally spontaneous and minimally interview-led talk around the research topic, we demonstrate the fruitfulness of using stimulus material in the research encounters. The end part of the paper consists of examples of data analysis, through which we illustrate our approach.
- Published
- 2018
45. Self-Disclosure and Non-Communication: Stigma Management in Third-Sector Transitional Employment
- Author
-
Miira, Niska, Melisa, Stevanovic, Elina, Weiste, Tommi, Ostrovskij, Taina, Valkeapää, Camilla, Lindholm, Tampere University, Language Studies, and Unit of Social Research
- Subjects
Self Disclosure ,515 Psychology ,Mental Disorders ,Social Stigma ,Disclosure ,discursive social psychology ,mental illness ,Article ,3142 Public health care science, environmental and occupational health ,rehabilitation ,stigma management ,stigma ,employment ,5141 Sociology ,non-communication ,self-disclosure ,Humans ,Medicine - Abstract
People who are recovering from a mental illness often have difficulties finding and maintaining employment. One of the main reasons for these difficulties is the negative label, or stigma, attached to mental illnesses. People who possess stigmatizing characteristics may use compensatory stigma management strategies to reduce discrimination. Due to mental illnesses’ invisible characteristics, information control is an important stigma management strategy. People can often choose whether they disclose or non-communicate their illness. Nevertheless, it might be difficult to decide when and to whom to disclose or non-communicate the stigma. Since stigma management is a dilemmatic process, workers in mental health services play an important role in informing their clients of when it is best to disclose or non-communicate their illness. In this article, we adopt the perspective of discursive social psychology to investigate how workers of one mental health service programme evaluate and construct self-disclosure and non-communication as stigma management strategies. We demonstrate how these workers recommend non-communication and formulate strict stipulations for self-disclosure. At the same time, they differentiate non-communication from lying or providing false information. The study contributes to an improved understanding of stigma management in contemporary mental health services. publishedVersion
- Published
- 2021
46. Observing Social Connectedness in a Digital Dance Program for Older Adults : An EMCA Approach
- Author
-
Rachel V. Herron, An Kosurko, Melisa Stevanovic, Ilkka Arminen, Mark W. Skinner, Gao, Qin, Zhou, Jia, Tampere University, and Unit of Social Research
- Subjects
Conceptualization ,Dance ,Social connectedness ,Applied psychology ,Loneliness ,Social engagement ,New media ,03 medical and health sciences ,0302 clinical medicine ,Conversation analysis ,5142 Social policy ,030502 gerontology ,medicine ,030212 general & internal medicine ,Social isolation ,medicine.symptom ,0305 other medical science ,10. No inequality ,Psychology - Abstract
Sustainable societies require healthy populations that are inclusive of all ages in meaningful social engagement. Given the digital nature of contemporary social life, there is substantial interest in how older adults interact with information communication technology (ICT) and new media. For ageing rural populations, ICT is considered opportune to address increasing social isolation and loneliness by connecting older people in digital society. Understanding how older adults experience and achieve social connectedness through ICT is important to inform the development of programs and services designed for their meaningful engagement in social activities. More data is needed, particularly for people living with cognitive challenges, and in rural areas. But there are methodological challenges for this type of research involving this demographic. People living with dementia, for example, may depend on third party support to participate in programs and to articulate experience using verbal language. This paper introduces an international expansion of a study “Improving social inclusion for Canadians with dementia and their carers through Sharing Dance,” [1] a digitally-delivered dance program. The expansion study will examine the impact of the program for social connectedness in an international context, using similar data collection methods to the Canadian study, while adding an additional layer of analysis using ethnomethodology and conversation analysis (EM/CA). This paper will both share findings from the Canadian study and introduce the conceptualization of the international study that builds on its foundation. A sample EM/CA analysis is provided, illustrating observable behaviour for comparison in different contexts, reducing dependence upon verbal language. acceptedVersion
- Published
- 2021
47. Emotion, psychophysiology, and intersubjectivity
- Author
-
Anssi Peräkylä, Liisa Voutilainen, Melisa Stevanovic, Pentti Henttonen, Mikko Kahri, Maari Kivioja, Emmi Koskinen, Mikko Sams, Niklas Ravaja, Lindström, Jan, Laury, Ritva, Peräkylä, Anssi, Sorjonen, Marja-Leena, Tampere University, Unit of Social Research, Sociology, Facing Narcissism, Faculty Common Matters (Faculty of Social Sciences), Department of Psychology and Logopedics, Faculty of Social Sciences, Helsinki Institute for Information Technology, and Doctoral Programme in Human Behaviour
- Subjects
6162 Cognitive science ,Affiliation ,515 Psychology ,6164 Speech communication ,5141 Sociology ,Autonomic nervous system ,3124 Neurology and psychiatry ,Psychophysiology - Abstract
Publisher Copyright: © 2021 John Benjamins Publishing Company. Conversation analytical studies on emotion show how expression of emotion is part of the intersubjective experience. Emotions, however, are as much physiological as experiential events. Physiological processes pertaining to emotion involve changes in cardiovascular activity, in the activation of sweat glands, and in muscular activity. The dyadic systems theory by Beebe and Lachmann (2002) suggests that actions that regulate social interaction also serve in the regulation of internal emotional states of interacting subjects. Drawing from this theory, our overall research questions was: how is the expression of emotion in social interaction linked to physiological responses in the participants? Our main result was that thorough conversational affiliation, the participants share the emotional load in the interaction.
- Published
- 2021
48. Tarinan vastaanotto ja affiliaatio autismikirjon häiriössä
- Author
-
Emmi Koskinen, Melisa Stevanovic, Tampere University, Yhteiskuntatutkimus, Sosiologia, and Narsismin kasvot
- Subjects
Egocentrism ,media_common.quotation_subject ,515 Psykologia ,medicine.disease ,Developmental psychology ,Focus (linguistics) ,Autism spectrum disorder ,medicine ,General Earth and Planetary Sciences ,Conversation ,Narrative ,5141 Sosiologia ,Psychology ,Neurotypical ,General Environmental Science ,media_common ,Storytelling - Abstract
Autismikirjon henkilöiden tarinankerrontaa on tutkittu sekä kokeellisin menetelmin että keskustelunanalyyttisesti, mutta tarinan vastaanottoon liittyvien käytänteiden erittely on jäänyt vähemmälle. Tässä tutkimuksessa paikataan tätä tutkimuksellista aukkoa keskittymällä erityisesti autismikirjon henkilöiden tarinan vastaanottoon ja affiliaatioon. Aineistona on kymmenen videoitua keskustelua kahden mieshenkilön välillä, joista toisella on todettu Aspergerin oireyhtymä (AS) ja toinen on neurotyypillinen. Esittelemme keskustelunanalyyttisen tapaustutkimuksen avulla, miten kolme autismikirjon häiriöön ja sen vuorovaikutukseen liittyvää erityispiirrettä (sääntökeskeisyys, paikallissuuntautuneisuus ja egosentrisyys) heijastuvat AS-henkilöiden tapoihin ottaa vastaan vuorovaikutuskumppaninsa kertomia tarinoita ja millaisilta nämä tavat näyttävät affiliaation näkökulmasta. Lisääntynyt ymmärrys vuorovaikutuksen käytänteiden merkityksestä osallistujien toiminnan ja heidän välisensä suhteen rakentumiselle voi auttaa autismikirjoon liittyvien vuorovaikutuksen erityispiirteiden kuvaamisessa, sekä rakentaa ymmärrystä erilaisten ihmisten ja vuorovaikutustyylien välille. publishedVersion
- Published
- 2021
49. Kohti voimaantumista vai normaaliutta? : Positiointi työelämään valmentavassa mielenterveyskuntoutuksessa
- Author
-
Tuire Melisa Stevanovic, Kaisa Valkiaranta, Elina Weiste, Anni Lassila, Camilla Lindholm, Taina Valkeapää, Tampere University, Kielet, Yhteiskuntatutkimus, Helsinki Inequality Initiative (INEQ), Narsismin kasvot, Suomalais-ugrilainen ja pohjoismainen osasto, Tiedekunnan yhteiset (Humanistinen tiedekunta), and Humanistinen tiedekunta
- Subjects
mielenterveys ,keskustelunanalyysi ,positiointi ,toipumisorientaatio ,education ,identiteetti ,mielenterveyskuntoutus ,kuntoutus ,Artikkelit ,yhteisöllinen kuntoutusideologia ,positionti ,5141 Sosiologia - Abstract
Artikkelissa tarkastelemme, kuinka mielenterveyskuntoutujat rakentavat käsitystä itsestään Klubita- lon yhteisöllisen mielenterveyskuntoutuksen ryhmävuorovaikutustilanteissa. Tutkimuksen aineisto koostuu 35 videotallennetusta mielenterveyskuntoutusryhmän tapaamiskerrasta, joissa oli läsnä 2–10 kuntoutujaa ja 1–3 ohjaajaa. Aineiston analyysissa hyödynnetään Rom Harrén, Michael Bambergin ja muiden positiointiteoreetikoiden työtä suhteuttaen ja yhdistäen tätä lähestymistapaa keskustelunanalyysiin ja jäsenyyskategorisoinnin analyysiin. Analyysin pohjana toimiva aineistokokoelma koostuu vuorovaikutussekvensseistä (N=96), joiden alussa kuntoutujajäsen tekee tietoisen itsensä positioin- nin yksikön ensimmäisessä persoonassa. Analyysimme osoitti, että jäsenyyskategorioita ”kuntoutujayhteisön jäsen”, ”pätevä työntekijä” ja ”sairas” koskevat kuntoutujien itsen positioinnit eivät saaneet Klubitalon ryhmätapaamisissa paljoakaan tukea ryhmän ohjaajilta. Tulkitsemme ohjaajien toimintaa Klubitalolla vaikuttavien kuntoutusideologioiden – toipumisorientaation ja yhteisöllisen ideologian – valossa. Näihin ideologioihin ankkuroituvien institutionaalisten tehtäviensä ohella ohjaajat kuitenkin osallistuvat asiakkaidensa identiteetinrakennustyöhön myös heidän voimaantumisensa kannalta mahdollisesti ongelmallisilla tavoilla.
- Published
- 2021
50. Chapter 5. Mobilizing student compliance
- Author
-
Melisa Stevanovic
- Subjects
060201 languages & linguistics ,Violin ,Interrogative word ,First person ,0602 languages and literature ,05 social sciences ,Applied psychology ,0501 psychology and cognitive sciences ,06 humanities and the arts ,Directive ,Psychology ,050105 experimental psychology ,Compliance (psychology) - Published
- 2020
Catalog
Discovery Service for Jio Institute Digital Library
For full access to our library's resources, please sign in.