The volume of XML data exchange is explosively increasing, and the need for efficient mechanisms of XML data management is vital. Many XML storage models have been proposed for storing XML DTD-independent documents in relational database systems. Benchmarking is the best way to highlight pros and cons of different approaches. In this study, we use a common benchmarking scheme, known as XMark to compare the most cited and newly proposed DTD-independent methods in terms of logical reads, physical I/O, CPU time and duration. We show the effect of Label Path, extracting values and storing in another table and type of join needed for each method-s query answering., {"references":["M. Fernndez, Y. Kadiyska, D. Suciu, A. Morishima and W. C. Tan,\n\"Silkroute: A framework for publishing relational data in xml,\". ACM\nTrans. Database Syst. Vol .27, No. 4, pp. 438-493, 2002.","F. Yergeau, T. Bray, J. Paoli, C. M. Sperberg-McQueen and E. Maler,\n\"Extendible Markup Language (XML),\". W3C Recommendation, 2004.\nAvailable at http://www.w3.org/XML/","P. O-Neil, E. O-Neil, S. Pal, I. Cseri and G. Schaller, \"ORDPATHs:\nInsert-Friendly XML Node Labels,\". Proc. ACM SIGMOD. France pp.\n903-908, 2004.","T. Böhme and E. Rahm, \"Supporting Efficient Streaming and Insertion\nof XML Data in RDBMS,\". Proc. DIWeb. Latvia, pp. 70-81, 2004.","H. Lu, J. Xu Yu, G. Wang, S. Zheng, H. Jiang, G. Yu and A. Zhou,\n\"What makes the differences: benchmarking XML database\nimplementations,\". ACM Trans. Internet Techn. Vol. 5, No. 1, pp 154-\n194, 2005.","D. Florescu and D. Kossmann, \"Storing and Querying XML Data using\nan RDMBS,\". IEEE Data Eng. Bull. Vol. 22, No. 3, pp. 27-34, 1999.","M. Yoshikawa, T. Amagasa, T. Shimura, and S. Uemura, \"XRel: a pathbased\napproach to storage and retrieval of XML documents using\nrelational databases,\". ACM Trans. Internet Techn. Vol. 1, No. 1, pp.\n110-141, 2001.","H. Jiang, H. Lu, W. Wang and J. Xu Yu, \"Path Materialization\nRevisited: An Efficient Storage Model for XML Data,\". Proc. of ACM\nAustralasian Database Tech. Conf. Australia, pp. 85-94, 2002.","H. Jiang, H. Lu, W. Wang and J. Xu Yu, \"XParent: An Efficient\nRDBMS-Based XML Database System,\". Proc. of IEEE ICDE. USA,\npp. 335-336, 2002.\n[10] E. Cohen, H. Kaplan and T. Milo, \"Labeling Dynamic XML Trees,\".\nProc. of ACM PODS. USA, pp. 271-281, 2002.\n[11] S. Pal, I. Cseri, O. Seeliger, G. Schaller, L. Giakoumakis and V. Zolotov,\n\"Indexing XML Data Stored in a Relational Database,\". Proc. of VLDB.\nCanada, pp. 1134-1145, 2004.\n[12] S. Abiteboul, D. Quass, J. McHugh, J. Widom, J. Wiener, \"The Lorel\nQuery Language for Semistructured Data,\". Int. J. on Digital Libraries.\nVol. 1, No. 1, pp. 68-88, 1997.\n[13] A. Deutsch, M. Fernandez, D. Florescu, A. Levy and D. Suciu \"A Query\nLanguage for XML,\". Proc. of WWW. Canada, pp. 1155-1169, 1999.\n[14] D. Chamberlin, J. Robie and D. Florescu, \"Quilt: An XML Query\nLanguage for Heterogeneous Data Sources,\". Proc of WebDB (LNCS).\nUSA, pp. 53-62, 2000.\n[15] J. Clark and S. DeRose, \"XML Path Language (XPath) Version 1.0,\".\nW3C Recommendation, 1999. Available at\nhttp://www.w3.org/TR/xpath.\n[16] A. Bonifati and S. Ceri, \"Comparative Analysis of Five XML Query\nLanguages,\". ACM SIGMOD Record. Vol. 29, No. 1, pp. 68-79, 2000.\n[17] D. Lee and W. W. Chu, \"Comparative Analysis of Six XML Schema\nLanguages,\". ACM SIGMOD Record. Vol 29, No. 3, pp. 76-87, 2000.\n[18] A. Schmidt, M. Kersten, M. Windhouwer and F. Waas, \"Efficient\nRelational Storage and Retrieval of XML Documents,\". Proc. of WebDB\n(LNCS). USA, pp. 137-150, 2000.\n[19] T. Böhme and E. Rahm, \"Multi-User Evaluation of XML Data\nManagement Systems with XMach-1,\". Proc. of EEXTT (LNCS).\nGermany, pp. 148-159, 2003.\n[20] A. Schmidt, F. Waas, M. Kersten, M. Carey, I. Manolescu, and R. Busse,\n\"Xmark: A Benchmark for XML Data Management,\". Proc. of VLDB\nChina, pp. 974-985, 2002.\n[21] S. Boag, D. Chamberlin, M. F. Fern├índez , D. Florescu, J. Robie, J.\nSiméon, \"W3C XML Query (XQuery),\". W3C Candidate\nRecommendation. 2005. Available at http://www.w3.org/XML/Query/\n[22] M. Emadi, M. Rahgozar, A. Ardalan, A. Kazerani and M.M. Arian, \"A\nComparative Study of DTD-Independent XML Data Storage\nApproaches,\". 11th International CSI Computer Conference (CSICC'06).\nIran, pp. 624-628, 2006."]}