1. Do Ion Levels In Hip Resurfacing Differ From Metal-on-metal THA at Midterm?
- Author
-
Martha Hoque, Matteo Cadossi, Lucia Savarino, Antonio Moroni, Nicola Baldini, Moroni A., Savarino L., Hoque M., Cadossi M., Baldini N., Moroni, Antonio, Savarino, L., Hoque, M., Cadossi, M., and Baldini, N.
- Subjects
Adult ,Chromium ,Male ,musculoskeletal diseases ,medicine.medical_specialty ,Time Factors ,Arthroplasty, Replacement, Hip ,medicine.medical_treatment ,Treatment outcome ,Prosthesis Design ,Risk Assessment ,Young Adult ,Sex Factors ,ion level ,Clinical Research ,Risk Factors ,Sex factors ,medicine ,Humans ,Prosthesis design ,Orthopedics and Sports Medicine ,hip arthoplasty ,Aged ,Retrospective Studies ,Molybdenum ,business.industry ,Cobalt ,General Medicine ,Middle Aged ,Arthroplasty ,Hip resurfacing ,metal-on-metal THA ,Surgery ,Cross-Sectional Studies ,Treatment Outcome ,Italy ,Metals ,Orthopedic surgery ,Female ,Hip Prosthesis ,business ,Total hip arthroplasty - Abstract
BACKGROUND: Metal-on-metal Birmingham hip resurfacing (MOM-BHR) is an alternative to metal-on-metal total hip arthroplasty (MOM-THA), especially for young and/or active patients. However, wear resulting in increased serum ion levels is a concern. QUESTIONS/PURPOSES: We asked whether (1) serum chromium (Cr), cobalt (Co), and molybdenum (Mo) concentrations would differ between patients with either MOM-BHR or MOM-THA at 5 years, (2) confounding factors such as gender would influence ion levels; and (3) ion levels would differ at 2 and 5 years for each implant type. PATIENTS AND METHODS: Ions were measured in two groups with either MOM-BHR (n = 20) or MOM-THA (n = 35) and a mean 5-year followup, and two groups with either MOM-BHR (n = 15) or MOM-THA (n = 25) and a mean 2-year followup. Forty-eight healthy blood donors were recruited for reference values. RESULTS: At 5 years, there were no differences in ion levels between patients with MOM-BHR or MOM-THA. Gender was a confounding factor, and in the MOM-BHR group at 5 years, Cr concentrations were greater in females compared with those of males. Mean ion levels were similar in patients with 2 and 5 years of followup for each implant type. Ion levels in patients were sevenfold to 10-fold higher than in controls. CONCLUSIONS: As the metal ion concentrations in the serum at 5 years were in the range reported in the literature, we do not believe concerns regarding excessive metal ion levels after MOM-BHR are justified. LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: Level III, therapeutic study. See the Guidelines for Authors for a complete description of level of evidence
- Published
- 2011