1. Stories of reading: Inside and outside the texts of portfolios
- Author
-
Marjorie Roemer, Lucille M. Schultz, and Russel K. Durst
- Subjects
Linguistics and Language ,Higher education ,business.industry ,Mathematics education ,Portfolio ,Persona ,business ,Psychology ,Grading (education) ,Language and Linguistics ,Linguistics ,Education - Abstract
This essay employs Barbara Herrnstein Smith's notion of “contingencies of value,” the idea that evaluations of text vary because our readings take place in specific contexts and are shaped by cultural and historical exigencies. In this study, we apply this notion to the reading of student texts in a college composition portfolio assessment. Through an analysis of taped teacher discussions of students' writing and an examination of student responses to the grading process, we conclude that in every reading of a text (but especially in the reading of the multiple texts of a portfolio) readers posit an “implied author.” That is, based on their reading of a single text or portfolio, teacher-readers construct a persona that represents the author, and this projection can strongly influence the reader's evaluation of student work. Group discussions of portfolios allow teachers to expose and explore the value-laden nature of these judgments.
- Published
- 1997