Luisa Pinto, Vincent Regard, Reynaldo Charrier, Gérard Hérail, Stéphanie Brichau, Violeta Tolorza, Stéphane Bonnet, Sébastien Carretier, Joseph Martinod, E. Pepin, Germán Aguilar, Jean-Loup Guyot, María Pía Rodríguez, Rodrigo Riquelme, and Marcelo Farías
The effect of mean precipitation rate on erosion is debated. Three hypotheses may explain why the current erosion rate and runoff may be spatially uncorrelated: (1) the topography has reached a steady state for which the erosion rate pattern is determined by the uplift rate pattern; (2) the erosion rate only depends weakly on runoff; or (3) the studied catchments are experiencing different transient adjustments to uplift or to climate variations. In the Chilean Andes, between 278S and 398S, the mean annual runoff rates increase southwards from 0.01 to 2.6 m a but the catchment averaged rates of decadal erosion (suspended sediment) and millennial erosion (Be in river sand) peak at c. 0.25 mm a for runoff c. 0.5 m a and then decrease while runoff keeps increasing. Erosion rates increase non-linearly with the slope and weakly with the square root of the runoff. However, sediments trapped in the subduction trench suggest a correlation between the current runoff pattern and erosion over millions of years. The third hypothesis above may explain these different erosion rate patterns; the patterns seem consistent with, although not limited to, a model where the relief and erosion rate have first increased and then decreased in response to a period of uplift, at rates controlled by the mean precipitation rate. To what extent does the mean precipitation rate or tectonic uplift rate control the erosion rate in mountain ranges? Recent models suggest that climate, through its effect on erosion, plays a determinant role in localizing deformation, and in controlling mountain elevation and uplift rate (Whipple 2009). In addition, variations in palaeoerosion rates (Charreau et al. 2011) and in palaeosedimentation rates (e.g. Metivier et al. 1999; Clift 2006; Uba et al. 2007) potentially record variations in the mean precipitation rate (Castelltort & van den Driessche 2003). The role of climate in driving mountain erosion has become a central question in tectonics, geomorphology and sedimentology (Allen 2008). Because it is difficult to reconstruct the evolution of the erosion rate in mountains over 100 ka to Ma, the evolution of the sediment outflux from mountain ranges has been studied using numerical and physical modeling (e.g. Kooi & Beaumont 1994; Tucker & Slingerland 1996; Bonnet & Crave 2003; Whipple & Meade 2006; Stolar et al. 2007). A tectonic uplift is predicted to generate erosion, the amplitude of which varies according to a timescale called the response time (Kooi & Beaumont 1996; Whipple 2009). The response time is thought to be modulated by climatic conditions (Bonnet & Crave 2003; Stolar et al. 2006; Whipple & Meade 2006; Tucker & vanderBeek 2013). Consequently, the relationship between erosion and precipitation rates is predicted to depend on the timescale over which the erosion rate is analysed. In the simplest ideal case of non-glaciated mountain ranges where the uplift is held constant, the cumulative erosion at a given time (the time integral of the erosion rate since the onset of the uplift) is greater where the climate is wetter simply because the response time is less and the slopes are smaller in this case (Bonnet & Crave 2003). In some circumstances, decadal or millennial erosion rates can be greater where the climate is drier. This is predicted when the drainage network grows slowly, leading to steep hillslopes, deep valleys (high fluvial relief or From: Sepulveda, S. A., Giambiagi, L. B., Moreiras, S. M., Pinto, L., Tunik, M., Hoke, G. D. & Farias, M. (eds) Geodynamic Processes in the Andes of Central Chile and Argentina. Geological Society, London, Special Publications, 399, http://dx.doi.org/10.1144/SP399.16 # The Geological Society of London 2014. Publishing disclaimer: www.geolsoc.org.uk/pub_ethics at Universidad de Chile on May 14, 2014 http://sp.lyellcollection.org/ Downloaded from