1. The Particularist Challenge to Kantian Ethics.
- Author
-
Schumski, Irina
- Subjects
- *
KANTIAN ethics , *MORAL relativism , *PROBLEM solving , *DUTY - Abstract
Critics often accuse Kant and Kantians of rigorism: of advocating highly general exceptionless principles of duty that strictly prohibit action kinds like lying or breaking promises. In this article, I draw on arguments from the generalism-particularism debate to show that the way in which Kantians usually understand universality prevents them from solving this problem and leaves them stuck in a trilemma. I then argue that they should abandon this common conception—the "strict conception," on which universal principles don't permit any exceptions—in favor of a "relaxed conception," on which universal principles do permit certain exceptions, namely principled exceptions. [ABSTRACT FROM AUTHOR]
- Published
- 2024
- Full Text
- View/download PDF