Aaron Ciechanover, Eric H. Baehrecke, Josef M. Penninger, Moshe Oren, Marja Jäättelä, Cecília M. P. Rodrigues, Seamus J. Martin, Lorenzo Galluzzi, Dale E. Bredesen, Stuart A. Aaronson, Donald W. Nicholson, Frank Madeo, Mikhail V. Blagosklonny, Gabriel Núñez, Hans-Uwe Simon, Adi Kimchi, Karen H. Vousden, Yoshihide Tsujimoto, David W. Andrews, Simone Fulda, J. Tschopp, John M. Abrams, Hinrich Gronemeyer, Nicolas G. Bazan, Michael O. Hengartner, Richard A. Flavell, Beth Levine, Thomas Rudel, Ilio Vitale, Eugenia Morselli, Rosario Rizzuto, Boris Zhivotovsky, Douglas R. Green, J. M. Hardwick, Maria Castedo, Guido Kroemer, Pierluigi Nicotera, Christoph Borner, David C. Rubinsztein, Junying Yuan, Jan Paul Medema, Oliver Kepp, Carmen Garrido, V De Laurenzi, Jean-Christophe Marine, Richard J. Youle, Hidenori Ichijo, Daniel J. Klionsky, Hamsa Puthalakath, Ute M. Moll, Shigekazu Nagata, R De Maria, Pierre Golstein, Marie-Lise Gougeon, Mohanish Deshmukh, Enrico Lugli, Brian David Dynlacht, Emad S. Alnemri, John A. Cidlowski, Luca Scorrano, Stuart A. Lipton, Hermann Steller, Sally Kornbluth, Gerry Melino, György Hajnóczky, Gabriel A. Rabinovich, Peter Vandenabeele, Gerald M. Cohen, Shazib Pervaiz, Marcus E. Peter, Richard A. Knight, Jochen H. M. Prehn, Sharad Kumar, Klas Blomgren, Walter Malorni, Wafik S. El-Deiry, Patrick Mehlen, Mauro Piacentini, Catherine Brenner, Apoptose, cancer et immunité (U848), Université Paris-Sud - Paris 11 (UP11)-Institut Gustave Roussy (IGR)-Institut National de la Santé et de la Recherche Médicale (INSERM), Department of Oncological Sciences, Icahn School of Medicine at Mount Sinai [New York] (MSSM), Department of Cell Biology, University of Texas Southwestern Medical Center [Dallas], Department of Biochemistry and Molecular Biology, Thomas Jefferson University-Sidney Kimmel Cancer Center, Jefferson (Philadelphia University + Thomas Jefferson University)-Jefferson (Philadelphia University + Thomas Jefferson University), Department of Biochemistry and Biomedical Sciences, McMaster University [Hamilton, Ontario], Department of Cancer Biology, University of Massachusetts Medical School [Worcester] (UMASS), University of Massachusetts System (UMASS)-University of Massachusetts System (UMASS), Neuroscience Center of Excellence, LSU Health Sciences Center, Roswell Park Cancer Institute [Buffalo] (RPCI), Center for Brain Repair and Rehabilitation, Institute of Neuroscience and Physiology [Göteborg]-University of Gothenburg (GU), Department of Pediatric Oncology, The Queen Silvia Children's Hospital, Institute of Molecular Medicine and Cell Research (ZBMZ), University of Freiburg [Freiburg], Buck Institute for Age Research, Laboratoire de génétique et biologie cellulaire (LGBC), Université de Versailles Saint-Quentin-en-Yvelines (UVSQ)-École Pratique des Hautes Études (EPHE), Université Paris sciences et lettres (PSL)-Université Paris sciences et lettres (PSL), National Institutes of Environmental Health Sciences, National Institutes of Health [Bethesda] (NIH), Vascular and Tumor Biology Research Center, Israel Institute of Technology, Toxicology Unit, University of Leicester, Dipartimento di Scienze Biomediche, Università degli studi 'G. d'Annunzio' Chieti-Pescara [Chieti-Pescara] (Ud'A), Department of Hematology, Oncology and Molecular Medicine, Istituto Superiore di Sanità (ISS), Mediterranean Institute of Oncology, Department of Cell and Developmental Biology, University of North Carolina [Chapel Hill] (UNC), University of North Carolina System (UNC)-University of North Carolina System (UNC), Department of Pathology, New York University School of Medicine, NYU System (NYU)-NYU System (NYU), Hematology-Oncology Division, Perelman School of Medicine, University of Pennsylvania-University of Pennsylvania, Section of Immunobiology, Yale School of Medicine [New Haven, Connecticut] (YSM), Howard Hughes Medical Institute [Chevy Chase] (HHMI), Howard Hughes Medical Institute (HHMI), University Children's Hospital, Lipides - Nutrition - Cancer (U866) (LNC), Université de Bourgogne (UB)-Institut National de la Santé et de la Recherche Médicale (INSERM)-AgroSup Dijon - Institut National Supérieur des Sciences Agronomiques, de l'Alimentation et de l'Environnement-Ecole Nationale Supérieure de Biologie Appliquée à la Nutrition et à l'Alimentation de Dijon (ENSBANA), Centre d'Immunologie de Marseille - Luminy (CIML), Aix Marseille Université (AMU)-Institut National de la Santé et de la Recherche Médicale (INSERM)-Centre National de la Recherche Scientifique (CNRS), Immunité Antivirale, Biothérapie et Vaccins, Institut Pasteur [Paris] (IP)-Institut National de la Santé et de la Recherche Médicale (INSERM), Department of Immunology, St Jude Children's Research Hospital, Institut de Génétique et de Biologie Moléculaire et Cellulaire (IGBMC), Université de Strasbourg (UNISTRA)-Institut National de la Santé et de la Recherche Médicale (INSERM)-Centre National de la Recherche Scientifique (CNRS), Department of Pathology, Anatomy and Cell Biology, Thomas Jefferson University, Department of Pharmacology and Molecular Sciences, Johns Hopkins University (JHU), Institute of Molecular Biology, Universität Zürich [Zürich] = University of Zurich (UZH), Graduate School of Medecine, The University of Tokyo (UTokyo), Danish Cancer Society, Institute of Cancer Biology, Department of Molecular Genetics, Weizmann Institute of Science [Rehovot, Israël], Life Sciences Institute and Department of Molecular, Cellular, and Developmental Biology and Biological Chemistry, University of Michigan [Ann Arbor], University of Michigan System-University of Michigan System, Institute of Child Health [London], University College of London [London] (UCL), Duke University School of Medicine, Centre for Cancer Biology, Hanson Institute, Adelaide, Burnham Institute for Medical Research, The Salk Institute for Biological Studies, The Scripps Research Institute [La Jolla, San Diego], University of California [San Diego] (UC San Diego), University of California (UC), Immunotechnology Section, Vaccine Research Center, National Institutes of Health [Bethesda] (NIH)-National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Diseases, Institute of Molecular Biosciences, Karl-Franzens-Universität Graz, Department of Therapeutic Research and Medicines Evaluation, Laboratory for Molecular Cancer Biology, VIB-UGent, Department for Molecular Biology, Universiteit Gent = Ghent University (UGENT), Department of Genetics, Trinity College Dublin, Center for Experimental and Molecular Medicine, Academic Medical Center - Academisch Medisch Centrum [Amsterdam] (AMC), University of Amsterdam [Amsterdam] (UvA)-University of Amsterdam [Amsterdam] (UvA), University of Amsterdam [Amsterdam] (UvA), Apoptosis, Cancer, and Development Laboratory, Centre Léon Bérard [Lyon], Apoptose Cancer et Développement, Université Claude Bernard Lyon 1 (UCBL), Université de Lyon-Université de Lyon-Centre National de la Recherche Scientifique (CNRS), Department of Experimental Medicine and Biochemical Sciences, Università degli Studi di Roma Tor Vergata [Roma], Stony Brook University [SUNY] (SBU), State University of New York (SUNY)-State University of New York (SUNY), Department of Molecular Oncology, Göttingen Center of Molecular Biosciences, Faculty of Medicine, Georg-August-University = Georg-August-Universität Göttingen, Fujitsu Laboratories LTD., Fujitsu Laboratories Ltd., Department of Medical Chemistry, Kyoto University-Graduate School of Medicine, Merck & Co. Inc, University of Michigan Medical School [Ann Arbor], Department of Molecular Cell Biology [Rehovot], Institute of Molecular Biotechnology, Austrian Academy of Sciences (OeAW), Department of Physiology, National University of Singapore (NUS)-Yong Loo Lin School of Medicine-Graduate School for Integrative Sciences and Engineering, Singapore-MIT Alliance for Research and Technology (SMART), Massachusetts Institute of Technology (MIT), Duke-NUS Medical School [Singapore], Ben May Department for Cancer Research, University of Chicago-Ben May Department for Cancer Research, Laboratory of Cell Biology, National Institute for Infectious Diseases IRCCS 'L. Spallanzani', Department of Biology, Department of Physiology and Medical Physics, Royal College of Surgeons in Ireland (RCSI), Department of Biochemistry, La Trobe University [Melbourne], Laboratorie de Inmunopatologia, Instituto de Biología y Medicina Experimental [Buenos Aires] (IBYME), Consejo Nacional de Investigaciones Científicas y Técnicas [Buenos Aires] (CONICET)-Consejo Nacional de Investigaciones Científicas y Técnicas [Buenos Aires] (CONICET), Department of Biomedical Sciences, Università degli Studi di Padova = University of Padua (Unipd), iMed.UL, Universidade de Lisboa = University of Lisbon (ULISBOA), Cambridge Institute for Medical Research (CIMR), University of Cambridge [UK] (CAM), Biocenter, Julius-Maximilians-Universität Würzburg (JMU), Department of Cell Physiology and Metabolism, University of Geneva Medical School, Dulbecco-Telethon Institute, Venetian Institute Molecular Medicine (VIMM), University of Bern, Laboratory of Apoptosis and Cancer Biology, Rockefeller University [New York], Department of Biochemistry [Lausanne], Université de Lausanne = University of Lausanne (UNIL), Department of Medical Genetics, Osaka University Medical School, Department for Molecular Biomedical Research, The Beatson Institute for Cancer Research, University of Glasgow, Biochemistry Section, Surgical Neurology Branch, National Institutes of Health [Bethesda] (NIH)-National Institute of Neurological Disorders and Stroke, Department of cell biology, Harvard Medical School [Boston] (HMS), Division of Toxicology, karolinska institute-Institute of Environmental Medicine, Scorrano, Luca, Tschopp, Jean-Marie, Apoptose, cancer et immunité ( U848 ), Université Paris-Sud - Paris 11 ( UP11 ) -Institut Gustave Roussy ( IGR ) -Institut National de la Santé et de la Recherche Médicale ( INSERM ), Mount Sinai School of Medicine, Thomas Jefferson University-Kimmel Cancer Institute, University of Massachusetts Medical School [Worcester] ( UMASS ), Roswell Park Cancer Institute [Buffalo], Institute of Neuroscience and Physiology [Göteborg]-University of Gothenburg ( GU ), Institute of Molecular Medicine and Cell Research ( ZBMZ ), Albert-Ludwigs University, Laboratoire de génétique et biologie cellulaire ( LGBC ), Université de Versailles Saint-Quentin-en-Yvelines ( UVSQ ) -École pratique des hautes études ( EPHE ) -Centre National de la Recherche Scientifique ( CNRS ), National Institutes of Health ( NIH ), Università degli studi 'G. d'Annunzio' Chieti-Pescara [Chieti-Pescara] ( Ud'A ), Istituto Superiore di Sanita [Rome], The University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill, University of Pennsylvania School of Medicine, Yale School of Medicine, Howard Hughes Medical Institute, Howard Hugues Medical Institute, Lipides - Nutrition - Cancer (U866) ( LNC ), Université de Bourgogne ( UB ) -Institut National de la Santé et de la Recherche Médicale ( INSERM ) -AgroSup Dijon - Institut National Supérieur des Sciences Agronomiques, de l'Alimentation et de l'Environnement-Ecole Nationale Supérieure de Biologie Appliquée à la Nutrition et à l'Alimentation de Dijon ( ENSBANA ), Centre d'Immunologie de Marseille - Luminy ( CIML ), Aix Marseille Université ( AMU ) -Institut National de la Santé et de la Recherche Médicale ( INSERM ) -Centre National de la Recherche Scientifique ( CNRS ), Institut Pasteur [Paris]-Institut National de la Santé et de la Recherche Médicale ( INSERM ), St. Jude Children's Research Hospital, Institut de Génétique et de Biologie Moléculaire et Cellulaire ( IGBMC ), Université de Strasbourg ( UNISTRA ) -Institut National de la Santé et de la Recherche Médicale ( INSERM ) -Centre National de la Recherche Scientifique ( CNRS ), Johns Hopkins University ( JHU ), University of Zürich [Zürich] ( UZH ), The University of Tokyo, Weizmann Institute of Science, University College of London [London] ( UCL ), The Scripps Research Institute, University of California [San Diego] ( UC San Diego ), National Institutes of Health ( NIH ) -National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Diseases, University of Graz, Ghent University [Belgium] ( UGENT ), Academic Medical Center [Amsterdam] ( AMC ), University of Amsterdam [Amsterdam] ( UvA ) -University of Amsterdam [Amsterdam] ( UvA ), University of Amsterdam [Amsterdam] ( UvA ), Université Claude Bernard Lyon 1 ( UCBL ), Université de Lyon-Université de Lyon-Centre National de la Recherche Scientifique ( CNRS ), Stony Brook University [The State University of New York] ( SBU ), University of Göttingen, Kyoto University [Kyoto]-Graduate School of Medicine, Merck and Co [Rahway], University of Michigan Medical School, Austrian Academy of Sciences ( OeAW ), National University of Singapore ( NUS ) -Yong Loo Lin School of Medicine-Graduate School for Integrative Sciences and Engineering, Singapore-MIT Alliance, National University of Singapore ( NUS ), Duke-NUS Graduate Medical School, Royal College of Surgeons in Ireland, Instituto de Biología y Medicina Experimental (IBYME- CONICET), Universita degli Studi di Padova = University of Padua = Université de Padoue, University of Lisbon, Cambridge Institute for Medical Research, University of Würzburg, Venetian Institute of Molecular Medicine, The Rockefeller University, Université de Lausanne ( UNIL ), Vib Ghent University, National Institutes of Health ( NIH ) -National Institute of Neurological Disorders and Stroke, Harvard Medical School [Boston] ( HMS ), Université de Versailles Saint-Quentin-en-Yvelines (UVSQ), University of Pennsylvania [Philadelphia]-University of Pennsylvania [Philadelphia], Yale University School of Medicine, Institut Pasteur [Paris]-Institut National de la Santé et de la Recherche Médicale (INSERM), Institut National de la Santé et de la Recherche Médicale (INSERM)-Centre National de la Recherche Scientifique (CNRS)-Université de Strasbourg (UNISTRA), University of California, Karl-Franzens-Universität [Graz, Autriche], Universiteit Gent = Ghent University [Belgium] (UGENT), Georg-August-University [Göttingen], Universita degli Studi di Padova, Universidade de Lisboa (ULISBOA), Julius-Maximilians-Universität Würzburg [Wurtzbourg, Allemagne] (JMU), Université de Lausanne (UNIL), Université de Versailles Saint-Quentin-en-Yvelines (UVSQ)-École pratique des hautes études (EPHE), Peney, Maité, Galluzzi, L, Aaronson, SA, Abrams, J, Alnemri, ES, Kumar, Sharad, and Kroemer, Guido
Cell death is essential for a plethora of physiological processes, and its deregulation characterizes numerous human diseases. Thus, the in-depth investigation of cell death and its mechanisms constitutes a formidable challenge for fundamental and applied biomedical research, and has tremendous implications for the development of novel therapeutic strategies. It is, therefore, of utmost importance to standardize the experimental procedures that identify dying and dead cells in cell cultures and/or in tissues, from model organisms and/or humans, in healthy and/or pathological scenarios. Thus far, dozens of methods have been proposed to quantify cell death-related parameters. However, no guidelines exist regarding their use and interpretation, and nobody has thoroughly annotated the experimental settings for which each of these techniques is most appropriate. Here, we provide a nonexhaustive comparison of methods to detect cell death with apoptotic or nonapoptotic morphologies, their advantages and pitfalls. These guidelines are intended for investigators who study cell death, as well as for reviewers who need to constructively critique scientific reports that deal with cellular demise. Given the difficulties in determining the exact number of cells that have passed the point-of-no-return of the signaling cascades leading to cell death, we emphasize the importance of performing multiple, methodologically unrelated assays to quantify dying and dead cells. Fil: Galluzzi, L.. Inserm; Francia. Universite Paris Sud; Francia. Institut Gustave Roussy; Francia Fil: Aaronson, S. A.. Mount Sinai School of Medicine; Estados Unidos Fil: Abrams, J.. University of Texas. Southwestern Medical Center; Estados Unidos Fil: Alnemri, E. S.. Thomas Jefferson University; Estados Unidos Fil: Andrews, D. W.. McMaster University; Canadá Fil: Baehrecke, E. H.. University of Massachussets; Estados Unidos Fil: Bazan, N. G.. Louisiana State University Health Sciences Center; Estados Unidos Fil: Blagosklonny, M. V.. Roswell Park Cancer Institute; Estados Unidos Fil: Blomgren, K.. Universityt of Gothenburg; Suecia. The Queen Silvia Children; Suecia Fil: Borner, C.. Albert-Ludwigs Universität Freiburg; Alemania Fil: Bredesen, E.. Buck Institute for Age Research; Estados Unidos. University of California; Estados Unidos Fil: Brenner, C.. univeristy of Versailles ; Francia Fil: Castedo, M.. Inserm; Francia. Universite Paris Sud; Francia Fil: Cidlowski, J. A.. National Institutes of Health; Estados Unidos Fil: Ciechanover, A.. The Rappaport Faculty of Medicine; Israel Fil: Cohen, G. M.. University of Leicester; Reino Unido Fil: De Laurenzi, V.. Università ‘G. d’Annunzio’ Chieti Pescara; Italia Fil: De Maria, R.. Istituto Superiore di Sanità; Italia. Mediterranean Institute of Oncology; Italia Fil: Deshmukh, M.. University of North Carolina; Estados Unidos Fil: Dynlacht, B. D.. University of New York; Estados Unidos Fil: El Deiry, W. S.. University of Pennsylvania; Estados Unidos Fil: Flavell, R. A.. University of Yale; Estados Unidos Fil: Fulda, S.. University Children; Alemania Fil: Garrido, C.. Inserm; Francia. University of Burgundy; Francia Fil: Golstein, P.. Inserm; Francia. Aix Marseille Université; Francia Fil: Gougeon, M. L.. Instituto Pasteur; Francia Fil: Green, D. R.. St. Jude Children′s Research Hospital; Estados Unidos Fil: Gronemeyer, H.. Institut de Génétique et de Biologie Moléculaire et Cellulaire; Francia. Inserm; Francia Fil: Hajnóczky, G.. Thomas Jefferson University; Estados Unidos Fil: Hardwick, J. M.. Johns Hopkins University; Estados Unidos Fil: Hengartner, M.O.. University Johns Hopkins; Estados Unidos Fil: Ichijo, H.. University of Tokyo; Japón Fil: Jäättelä, M.. Institute of Cancer Biology; Dinamarca Fil: Kepp, O.. Inserm; Francia. Universite Paris Sud; Francia. Institut Gustave Roussy; Francia Fil: Kimchi, A.. Weizmann Institute of Science; Israel Fil: Klionsky, D. J.. University of Michigan; Estados Unidos Fil: Knight, R. A.. University College London; Estados Unidos Fil: Kornbluth, S.. University of Duke; Estados Unidos Fil: Kumar, S.. Hanson Institute; Australia Fil: Levine, B.. Howard Hughes Medical Institute; Estados Unidos. University of Texas; Estados Unidos Fil: Lipton, S. A.. Burnham Institute for Medical Research; Estados Unidos. The Salk Institute for Biological Studies; Estados Unidos. The Scripps Research Institute; Estados Unidos. University of California at San Diego; Estados Unidos Fil: Lugli, E.. National Institutes of Health; Estados Unidos Fil: Madeo, F.. university of Graz; Austria Fil: Malorni, W.. Istituto Superiore di Sanità; Italia Fil: Marine, J. C.. VIB; Bélgica. Ghent University; Bélgica Fil: Martin, S. J.. Trinity College; Irlanda Fil: Medema, J. P.. Academic Medical Center; Países Bajos. University of Amsterdam; Países Bajos Fil: Mehlen, P.. Centre Léon Berard; Francia. Centre National de la Recherche Scientifique; Francia. Universite Lyon 2; Francia Fil: Melino, G.. University of Leicester; Reino Unido. Göttingen Center of Molecular Biosciences; Alemania Fil: Moll, U. M.. Stony Brook University; Estados Unidos. Göttingen Center of Molecular Biosciences; Alemania. University of Göttingen; Alemania Fil: Morselli, E.. Inserm; Francia. Universite Paris Sud; Francia. Institut Gustave Roussy; Francia Fil: Nagata, S.. University of Kyoto; Japón Fil: Nicholson, D. W.. Merck Research Laboratories; Estados Unidos Fil: Nicotera, P.. University of Leicester; Reino Unido Fil: Nuñez, G.. University of Michigan; Estados Unidos Fil: Oren, M.. Weizmann Institute of Science; Israel Fil: Penninger, J.. Institute of Molecular Biotechnology of the Austrian Academy of Science; Austria Fil: Pervaiz, S.. National University of Singapore; Singapur. Duke-NUS Graduate Medical School; Singapur Fil: Peter, M. E.. University of Chicago; Estados Unidos Fil: Piacentini, M.. National Institute for Infectious Diseases IRCCS "L. Spallanzani"; Italia. University of Rome "Tor Vergata"; Italia Fil: Prehn. J. H.. Royal College of Surgeons in Ireland; Irlanda Fil: Puthalakath, H.. La Trobe University; Australia Fil: Rabinovich, Gabriel Adrián. Consejo Nacional de Investigaciones Científicas y Técnicas. Instituto de Biología y Medicina Experimental. Fundación de Instituto de Biología y Medicina Experimental. Instituto de Biología y Medicina Experimental; Argentina Fil: Rizzuto, R.. Università di Padova; Italia Fil: Rodrigues, C. M.. Universidade de Lisboa; Portugal Fil: Rubinsztein, D. C.. Cambridge Institute for Medical Research; Reino Unido Fil: Rudel, T.. University of Würzburg; Alemania Fil: Scorrano, L.. University of Geneva ; Suiza. Venetian Institute of Molecular Medicine; Italia Fil: Simon, H. U.. University of Bern; Suiza Fil: Steller, H.. Howard Hughes Medical Institute; Estados Unidos. The Rockefeller University; Estados Unidos Fil: Tschoop, J.. University of Lausanne; Suiza Fil: Tsujimoto, Y.. Osaka University Medical School; Japón Fil: Vandenabeele, P.. Ghent University; Bélgica. VIB; Bélgica Fil: Vitale, I.. Inserm; Francia. Universite Paris Sud; Francia. Institut Gustave Roussy; Francia Fil: Vousden, K. H.. The Beatson Institute for Cancer Research; Reino Unido Fil: Youle, J. R.. National Institutes of Health; Estados Unidos Fil: Yuan, J.. Harvard Medical School; Estados Unidos Fil: Zhivotovsky, B.. Karolinska Huddinge Hospital. Karolinska Institutet; Suecia Fil: Kroemer, G.. Inserm; Francia. Universite Paris Sud; Francia. Institut Gustave Roussy; Francia