1. Social Aspects of the Planning State
- Author
-
Lewis L. Lorwin
- Subjects
Proletariat ,Hegemony ,Sociology and Political Science ,media_common.quotation_subject ,Socialist mode of production ,New Deal ,Environmental design and planning ,Dictatorship of the proletariat ,State (polity) ,Political economy ,Capital (economics) ,Political science ,Political Science and International Relations ,media_common - Abstract
We are witnessing today in both Europe and America the breakdown of what may be called the nineteenth-century equilibrium, and at the same time the effort to work out a new equilibrium as a basis of life for the twentieth century. The New Deal is the American phase of this movement. We can understand it better if we view it with the search-light of the movements in other countries, and if we make clear to ourselves what is driving them, how they are being driven, and what problems are in their path. The key to recent social developments seems to me to lie in the resurgence of the middle classes. This is a development of the last decade or so, and is largely the result of the failure of the two other major social groups-the capitalists and the workers-to give Western society, especially Western European society, leadership and direction. On the one hand, the capitalistic groups, while concentrating industrial and financial resources, showed a sad incapacity to establish a leadership based on social needs and moral values. On the other, the working classes, after having reached a position-not here, but in Western Europe-of great strength and influence, proved unable either to achieve enough numerical or social predominance to assume the hegemony of the state or to impose by force the program of socialism which they had preached for half a century. It was in this social impasse that the transformation in the character of the middle classes showed itself. These classes had already been given their first rude jolt by the World War and its aftermath. They had already been made to realize that they were extremely vulnerable, that they could be wiped out by inflation, expropriated by proletarians, and socially devaluated by everybody. For a while it looked as if they were done for in Germany, Italy, and elsewhere. What seemed to loom up before them was a Hobson's choice of either a proletarian dictatorship after the pattern of Soviet Russia or a super-capitalism based on monopolistic cartels in which also they ultimately would be crushed. It was in reaction to both these alternatives that the middle classes began again to bid for national leadership as they had done during the French Revolution and in the early part of the nineteenth century. They defied with new energy the challenge of the proletariat and the mastery of big capital. This, as I see it, is the essential factor in
- Published
- 1934
- Full Text
- View/download PDF