Giles, Andrew E., Godzisz, Sydney, Nenshi, Rahima, Forbes, Shawn, Farrokhyar, Forough, Lee, Jennie, and Eskicioglu, Cagla
Background: The Tokyo Guidelines were published in 2007 and updated in 2013 and 2018, with recommendations for the diagnosis and management of acute cholecystitis. We assessed guideline adherence at our academic centre and its impact on patient outcomes. Methods: This is a retrospective chart review of patients with acute calculous cholecystitis who underwent cholecystectomy at our institution between November 2013 and March 2015. Severity of cholecystitis was graded retrospectively if it had not been documented preoperatively. Compliance with the Tokyo Guidelines' recommendations on antibiotic use and time to operation was recorded. Cholecystitis severity groups were compared statistically, and logistic regression was used to determine predictors of complications. Results: One hundred and fifty patients were included in the study. Of these, 104 patients were graded as having mild cholecystitis, 45 as having moderate cholecystitis, and 1 as having severe cholecystitis. Severity was not documented preoperatively for any patient. Compliance with antibiotic recommendations was poor (18.0%) and did not differ by cholecystitis severity (p = 0.90). Compliance with the recommendation on time to operation was 86.0%, with no between-group differences (p = 0.63); it improved when an acute care surgery team was involved (91.0% v. 76.0%, p = 0.025). On multivariable analysis, comorbidities (odds ratio [OR] 1.47, 95% confidence interval [CI] 1.19-1.85, p < 0.001) and conversion to laparotomy (OR 13.45, 95% CI 2.16125.49, p = 0.01) predicted postoperative complications, while severity of cholecystitis, antibiotic compliance and time to operation had no effect. Conclusion: In this study, compliance with the Tokyo Guidelines was acceptable only for time to operation. Although the poor compliance with recommendations relating to documentation of severity grading and antibiotic use did not have a negative affect on patient outcomes, these recommendations are important because they facilitate appropriate antibiotic use and patient risk stratification. Contexte : Les Tokyo Guidelines, publiees en 2007, puis mises a jour en 2013 et en 2018, contiennent des recommandations sur le diagnostic et la prise en charge de la cholecystite aigue. Nous avons evalue le respect de ces lignes directrices dans notre centre universitaire et son incidence sur les issues pour les patients. Methodes : Ce document est une revue retrospective de dossiers des patients atteints de cholecystite aigue calculeuse qui ont subi une cholecystectomie dans notre etablissement entre novembre 2013 et mars 2015. La gravite de la cholecystite a ete etablie de maniere retrospective si elle n'avait pas ete documentee avant l'operation. Le respect des recommandations des Tokyo Guidelines concernant le recours a des antibiotiques et la duree de l'operation a ete etudie. Nous avons compare statistiquement les groupes de gravite de la cholecystite, et avons utilise une regression logistique pour determiner les predicteurs de complications. Resultats : Au total, 150 patients ont ete inclus dans l'etude. Parmi eux, 104 avaient une cholecystite legere, 45, une cholecystite moderee et 1, une cholecystite grave. La gravite de la maladie n'avait ete documentee avant l'operation pour aucun patient. Le respect des recommandations sur les antibiotiques etait faible (18,0 %) et ne variait pas selon la gravite de la cholecystite (p = 0,90). Le respect des recommandations sur la duree de l'operation etait de 86,0 %, sans difference entre les groupes (p = 0,63); il etait toutefois plus eleve lorsqu'une equipe de soins chirurgicaux aigus participait aux soins (91,0 % c. 76,0 %, p = 0,025). L'analyse multivariee a permis de determiner que les comorbidites (rapport des cotes [RC] 1,47, intervalle de confiance [IC] de 95 % 1,19-1,85, p < 0,001) et la conversion en laparotomie (RC 13,45, IC de 95 % 2,16-125,49, p = 0,01) etaient des predicteurs de complications postoperatoires, alors que la gravite de la cholecystite et le respect des recommandations sur les antibiotiques et la duree de l'operation n'avaient pas d'effet. Conclusion : Dans cette etude, le respect des Tokyo Guidelines etait acceptable seulement pour la duree de l'operation. Bien qu'un faible respect des recommandations quant a la documentation de la gravite et a l'utilisation d'antibiotiques n'ait pas eu d'effets negatifs sur les issues pour les patients, ces recommandations sont importantes parce qu'elles favorisent l'utilisation appropriee des antibiotiques et une bonne stratification du risque pour le patient., Acute calculous cholecystitis is a common illness requiring surgery, and it is the reason for approximately 120 000 cholecystectomies performed annually in the United States. (1) In spite of the [...]