1. Role of prolonged packing in postoperative anorectal abscess management: a systematic review and meta-analysis
- Author
-
Kim, Dain, Verhoeff, Kevin, Jogiat, Uzair, Miles, Alex, Kung, Janice Y., and Mocanu, Valentin
- Subjects
Anus -- Abnormalities ,Anorectal disorders -- Diagnosis -- Care and treatment -- Patient outcomes ,Pain, Postoperative -- Care and treatment -- Risk factors -- Development and progression ,Abscess -- Risk factors -- Care and treatment -- Development and progression - Abstract
Background: Prolonged packing of anorectal abscess cavities with internal dressings after incision and drainage is frequently used, but the efficacy of this practice remains controversial. Some studies highlight its use in hemostasis and preventing fistula and abscess recurrence, whereas others describe its economic burden and increase in pain. In this systematic review, we examine current evidence on the impact of packing after incision and drainage for anorectal abscesses. Methods: The medical librarian conducted a comprehensive literature search on January 5, 2023. We conducted the meta-analysis using RevMan 5.4.1 software with a Mantel-Haenszel random-effects model. Results: We identified 3 randomized controlled trials, comprising 490 patients. Of those, 241 patients (49%) received postoperative packing; most patients were male (n =158, 65.6%), with a median age of 40.5 years and a follow-up of 6 months. Meta-analysis showed that prolonged wound packing was associated with delayed wound healing and increased pain, but no difference in abscess recurrence or fistula formation. Conclusion: In this systematic review of current evidence highlighting the impact of packing after incision and drainage for anorectal abscesses, we found that the practice is not associated with significant differences in abscess recurrence and fistula formation, but is associated with increased postoperative pain and delayed wound healing. Contexte : On a souvent recours un m chage prolong des cavit s d'abc s anorectaux apr s l'incision et drainage, mais son efficacit n'a pas t tablie. Certaines tudes mentionnent son utilisation pour l'h mostase et la pr vention des fistules et des r currences d'abc s, tandis que d'autres soulignent son co t et un accroissement de la douleur. Dans cette revue syst matique, nous analysons les donn es r centes sur l'impact du m chage apr s l'incision et drainage des abc s anorectaux. M thodes : La biblioth que m dicale a t charg e de proc der une interrogation globale de la litt rature le 5 janvier 2023. Nous avons effectu une m ta-analyse l'aide du logiciel RevMan 5.4.1 et d'un mod le effets al atoires de Mantel-Haenszel. R sultats : Nous avons retenu 3 essais randomis s et contr l s regroupant 490 personnes, dont 241 (49%) chez qui une m che a t install e apr s l'intervention; la plupart des participants taient de sexe masculin (n = 158, 65,6%), l' ge moyen tait de 40,5 ans et le suivi a dur 6 mois. Selon la m ta-analyse, un m chage prolong de la cavit de l'abc s a t associ un ralentissement de la cicatrisation et une douleur plus marqu e, et n'a rien chang la r currence des abc s ou la formation de fistules. Conclusion : Lors de notre revue syst matique des donn es r centes sur l'impact du m chage apr s l'incision et drainage des abc s anorectaux, nous avons constat que cette pratique n'est pas associ e des diff rences significatives aux plans de la r currence des abc s et de la formation de fistules, mais qu'elle est plut t associ e une augmentation de la douleur postop ratoire et une cicatrisation plus lente de la plaie., Suppurative cryptoglandular anorectal disease refers to a spectrum of anorectal infections involving blockage of the base of the anal crypts of Morgagni responsible for drainage of secretory anal glands. (1-3) [...]
- Published
- 2024
- Full Text
- View/download PDF