Search

Living cells are crowded. The presence of so many macromolecules packed into a confined environment affects the structure and function of biological components, and the kinetics and thermodynamics of biochemical reactions. In fact, crowding studies have already led to important biological insights, such as the existence of metabolons and other temporary protein complexes that play essential roles in metabolism, cell signaling, and organization of the intracellular environment. Even so, this important topic is rarely addressed in chemistry and biochemistry curricula. This review brings readers up to date on developments in the field of macromolecular crowding, with a special emphasis on distinguishing between the two major components of crowding: excluded volume effects (hard interactions) and chemical effects (soft interactions). Interestingly, because attractive soft interactions and repulsive hard interactions oppose each other, the net effects of crowding in vivo are often surprisingly small. We present some background and theory, while summarizing recent literature. Finally, we include suggestions on how this topic might be incorporated into the biochemistry classroom or laboratory setting.

In order to better understand how the complex, densely packed, heterogeneous milieu of a cell influences enzyme kinetics, we exposed opposing reactions catalyzed by yeast alcohol dehydrogenase (YADH) to both synthetic and protein crowders ranging from 10 to 550 kDa. The results reveal that the effects from macromolecular crowding depend on the direction of the reaction. The presence of the synthetic polymers, Ficoll and dextran, decrease Vmax and Km for ethanol oxidation. In contrast, these crowders have little effect or even increase these kinetic parameters for acetaldehyde reduction. This increase in Vmax is likely due to excluded volume effects, which are partially counteracted by viscosity hindering release of the NAD+ product. Macromolecular crowding is further complicated by the presence of a depletion layer in solutions of dextran larger than YADH, which diminishes the hindrance from viscosity. The disparate effects from 25 g/L dextran or glucose compared to 25 g/L Ficoll or sucrose reveals that soft interactions must also be considered. Data from binary mixtures of glucose, dextran, and Ficoll support this “tuning” of opposing factors. While macromolecular crowding was originally proposed to influence proteins mainly through excluded volume effects, this work compliments the growing body of evidence revealing that other factors, such as preferential hydration, chemical interactions, and the presence of a depletion layer also contribute to the overall effect of crowding., Highlights • Yeast alcohol dehydrogenase reduction of acetaldehyde is enhanced by crowding. • Crowding effects on YADH kinetics depend on the direction of the reaction. • Crowders like dextran can be used as a tool to elucidate enzyme mechanism. • Excluded volume optimizes YADH hydride transfer; viscosity hinders product release. • The presence of a depletion layer with large crowders mitigates their effects.

Although it is well-known that the environment of mitochondria is a densely packed network of macromolecules, the kinetics of the essential metabolic enzyme, citrate synthase, has been studied only under dilute conditions. To understand how this crowded environment impacts the behavior of citrate synthase, Michaelis-Menten kinetics were measured spectrophotometrically in the presence of synthetic crowders as a function of size, concentration, and identity. The largest factor contributing to crowding effects was the overlap concentration (c*), the concentration above which polymers begin to interact. The presence of the crowder dextran decreased the maximum rate of the reaction by ∼20% in the dilute regime ( c*) regardless of polymer size. The disparate effects observed from different crowding agents of similar size also reveal the importance of transient interactions from crowding.

Enzymes operate in a densely packed cellular environment that rarely matches the dilute conditions under which they are studied. To better understand the ramifications of this crowding, the Michaelis-Menten kinetics of yeast alcohol dehydrogenase (YADH) were monitored spectrophotometrically in the presence of high concentrations of dextran. Crowding decreased the maximal rate of the reaction by 40% for assays with ethanol, the primary substrate of YADH. This observation was attributed to slowed release of the reduced β-nicotinamide adenine dinucleotide product, which is rate-limiting. In contrast, when larger alcohols were used as the YADH substrate, the rate-limiting step becomes hydride transfer and crowding instead increased the maximal rate of the reaction by 20-40%. This work reveals the importance of considering enzyme mechanism when evaluating the ways in which crowding can alter kinetics.

To understand the consequences of macromolecular crowding, studies have largely employed in vitro experiments with synthetic polymers assumed to be both pure and "inert". These polymers alter enzyme kinetics by excluding volume that would otherwise be available to the enzymes, substrates, and products. Presented here is evidence that other factors, in addition to excluded volume, must be considered in the interpretation of crowding studies with synthetic polymers. Dextran has a weaker effect on the Michaelis-Menten kinetic parameters of yeast alcohol dehydrogenase (YADH) than its small molecule counterpart, glucose. For glucose, the decreased Vmax values directly correlate with slower translational diffusion and the decreased Km values likely result from enhanced substrate binding due to YADH stabilization. Because dextran is unable to stabilize YADH to the same extent as glucose, this polymer's ability to decrease Km is potentially due to the nonideality of the solution, a crowding-induced conformational change, or both. Chronoamperometry reveals that glucose and dextran have surprisingly similar ferricyanide diffusion coefficients. Thus, the reduction in Vmax values for glucose is partially offset by an additional macromolecular crowding effect with dextran. Finally, this is the first report that supplier-dependent impurities in dextran affect the kinetic parameters of YADH. Taken together, our results reveal that caution should be used when interpreting results obtained with inert synthetic polymeric agents, as additional effects from the underlying monomer need to be considered.

To understand how macromolecular crowding affects enzyme activity, we quantified the Michaelis-Menten kinetics of mitochondrial malate dehydrogenase (MDH) in the presence of hen egg white (HEW), lysozyme, bovine serum albumin (BSA), gum arabic, poly(vinylpyrrolidone) (PVP), and dextrans of various molecular weights. Although crowding tended to decrease Km and Vmax values, the magnitude depended on the crowding agent, reaction direction, and isozyme (mitochondrial porcine heart or thermophlic TaqMDH from Thermus flavus). Crowding slowed oxaloacetate reduction more significantly than malate oxidation, which may suggest that mitochondrial enzymes have evolved to function optimally under the crowded constraints in which they are immersed. Since direct comparisons of neutral to charged crowders are underrepresented in the literature, we performed these studies and found that neutral crowding agents lowered Vmax values more than charged crowders of similar size. The exception was hen egg white, a mixture of charged proteins that caused the largest observed decreases in both Km and Vmax. Finally, the data provide insight about the mechanism by corroborating MDH subunit dependence.

Fibrils of the intrinsically disordered protein alpha-synuclein are hallmarks of Parkinson's disease. The fluorescent dye thioflavin T is often used to characterize fibrillation, but this assay may not provide quantitative information about structure and mechanism. To gain such information, we incorporated the 19F-labeled amino acid, 3-fluorotyrosine, into recombinant human alpha-synuclein at its endogenous tyrosine residues. Tyrosine 39 is in the positively charged N-terminal region of this 140-residue protein. The other three tyrosines, 125, 133, and 136, are near the C-terminus. 19F nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy was used to study several properties of labeled alpha-synuclein, including its conformation, conformational changes induced by urea, spermine, and sodium dodecyl sulfate (SDS), its interaction with SDS micelles, and the kinetics of fibril formation. The results show that the tyrosines are in disordered regions but that there is some structure near position 39 that is disrupted by urea. SDS binding alters the conformation near position 39, but the C-terminal tyrosines are disordered under all conditions. The NMR data also indicate that SDS-micelle-bound alpha-synuclein and the free protein exchange on the 10 ms time scale. Studies of fibrillation show the utility of 19F-labeled NMR. The data indicate that fibrillation is not accompanied by the formation of large quantities of low molecular weight intermediates. Although dye binding and 19F NMR data show that 1 mM SDS and 1 mM spermine accelerate aggregation compared to buffer alone, only the NMR data indicate that the species formed in SDS are smaller than those formed in buffer or buffer plus spermine. We conclude that 19F NMR spectroscopy is useful for obtaining residue-level, quantitative information about the structure, binding, and aggregation of alpha-synuclein.

Fluorescence recovery after photobleaching and fluorescence correlation spectroscopy are the primary means for studying translational diffusion in biological systems. Both techniques, however, present numerous obstacles for measuring translational mobility in structures only slightly larger than optical resolution. We report a new method using through-prism total internal reflection fluorescence microscopy with continuous photobleaching (TIR-CP) to overcome these obstacles. Small structures, such as prokaryotic cells or isolated eukaryotic organelles, containing fluorescent molecules are adhered to a surface. This surface is continuously illuminated by an evanescent wave created by total internal reflection. The characteristic length describing the decay of the evanescent intensity with distance from the surface is smaller than the structures. The fluorescence decay rate resulting from continuous evanescent illumination is monitored as a function of the excitation intensity. The data at higher excitation intensities provide apparent translational diffusion coefficients for the fluorescent molecules within the structures because the decay results from two competing processes (the intrinsic photobleaching propensity and diffusion in the small structures). We present the theoretical basis for the technique and demonstrate its applicability by measuring the diffusion coefficient, 6.3 ± 1.1 µm2/sec, of green fluorescent protein (GFP) in Escherichia coli cells.

Cells are densely packed with proteins, DNA, RNA and other macromolecules that account for up to 40% (400 mg/mL) of the cellular space. However, most biophysical studies have been performed in dilute solution with macromolecule concentrations of 1-10 mg/mL. Both theoretical and experimental evidence suggests that proteins behave differently under crowded conditions resulting in changes to structure, stability and kinetics. In order to understand the role of macromolecular crowding on the kinetics of alcohol dehydrogenase, we have used absorbance to determine Michaelis-Menten parameters in the absence and presence of crowding agents. These crowding agents are inert polymers and globular proteins, such as Dextran and Bovine Serum Albumin (BSA). We have found that increasing concentrations of Dextran have resulted in a concentration-dependant decrease in binding affinity (increased Km) with no change to the maximum reaction rate. In contrast, crowding with BSA at comparable concentrations has less of an effect on binding affinity, but the concentration-dependent trends on the kinetic parameters are not as discernible. While the diverse effect of crowding agents requires further exploration the current study provides new insight regarding polymer and protein crowding agents as mimics for cellular conditions.View Large Image | View Hi-Res Image | Download PowerPoint Slide

BackgroundThe NAD+-dependent histone deacetylases, known as "sirtuins", participate in a variety of processes critical for single- and multi-cellular life. Recent studies have elucidated the importance of sirtuin activity in development, aging, and disease; yet, underlying mechanistic pathways are not well understood. Specific sirtuins influence chromatin structure and gene expression, but differences in their pathways as they relate to distinct chromatin functions are just beginning to emerge. To further define the range of global chromatin changes dependent on sirtuins, unique biological features of the ciliated protozoanTetrahymena thermophilacan be exploited. This system offers clear spatial and temporal separation of multiple whole genome restructuring events critical for the life cycle.ResultsInhibition with nicotinamide revealed that sirtuin deacetylase activity inTetrahymenacells promotes chromatin condensation during meiotic prophase, differentiation of heterochromatin from euchromatin during development, and chromatin condensation/degradation during programmed nuclear death. We identified a class I sirtuin, called Thd14, that resides in mitochondria and nucleoli during vegetative growth, and forms a large sub-nuclear aggregate in response to prolonged cell starvation that may be peripherally associated with nucleoli. During sexual conjugation and development Thd14 selectively concentrates in the parental nucleus prior to its apoptotic-like degradation.ConclusionsSirtuin activity is important for several functionally distinct events requiring global chromatin condensation. Our findings suggest a novel role for sirtuins in promoting programmed pycnosis by acting on chromatin destined for degradation. The sirtuin Thd14, which displays physiological-dependent differential localization within the nucleus, is a candidate for a chromatin condensation enzyme that is coupled to nuclear degradation.

Although overexpression and (15)N enrichment facilitate the observation of resonances from disordered proteins in Escherichia coli, (15)N enrichment alone is insufficient for detecting most globular proteins. Here, we explain this dichotomy and overcome the problem while extending the capability of in-cell NMR by using (19)F-labeled proteins. Resonances from small (approximately 10 kDa) globular proteins containing the amino acid analogue 3-fluoro-tyrosine can be observed in cells, but for larger proteins the (19)F resonances are broadened beyond detection. Incorporating the amino acid analogue trifluoromethyl-L-phenylalanine allows larger proteins (up to 100 kDa) to be observed in cells. We also show that site-specific structural and dynamic information about both globular and disordered proteins can be obtained inside cells by using (19)F NMR.

Fluorescence recovery after photobleaching was used to measure the diffusion coefficient of green fluorescent protein (GFP, 27 kDa) in Escherichia coli in the presence or absence of four coexpressed proteins: cytoplasmic maltose binding protein (42 kDa), tau-40 (45 kDa), alpha-synuclein (14 kDa), or calmodulin (17 kDa). The GFP diffusion coefficient remains constant regardless of the type of coexpresseed protein and whether or not the coexpressed protein was induced. We conclude that expression of these soluble proteins has little to no effect on the diffusion of GFP. These results have implications for the utility of in-cell nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy.

Almost everything we know about protein biophysics comes from studies on purified proteins in dilute solution. Most proteins, however, operate inside cells where the concentration of macromolecules can be >300 mg/mL. Although reductionism-based approaches have served protein science well for more than a century, biochemists now have the tools to study proteins under these more physiologically relevant conditions. We review a part of this burgeoning postreductionist landscape by focusing on high-resolution protein nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) spectroscopy, the only method that provides atomic-level information over an entire protein under the crowded conditions found in cells.