Search

Background Next-generation sequencing of Mycobacterium tuberculosis, the infectious agent causing tuberculosis, is improving the understanding of genomic diversity of circulating lineages and strain-types, and informing knowledge of drug resistance mutations. An increasingly popular approach to characterizing M. tuberculosis genomes (size: 4.4 Mbp) and variants (e.g., single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs)) involves the de novo assembly of sequence data. Methods We compared the performance of genome assembly tools (Unicycler, RagOut, and RagTag) on sequence data from nine drug resistant M. tuberculosis isolates (multi-drug (MDR) n = 1; pre-extensively-drug (pre-XDR) n = 8) generated using Illumina HiSeq, Oxford Nanopore Technology (ONT) PromethION, and PacBio platforms. Results Our investigation found that Unicycler-based assemblies had significantly higher genome completeness (~98.7%; p values = 0.01) compared to other assembler tools (RagOut = 98.6%, and RagTag = 98.6%). The genome assembly sizes (bp) across isolates and sequencers based on RagOut was significantly longer (p values < 0.001) (4,418,574 ± 8,824 bp) than Unicycler and RagTag assemblies (Unicycler = 4,377,642 ± 55,257 bp, and RagTag = 4,380,711 ± 51,164 bp). RagOut-based assemblies had the fewest contigs (~32) and the longest genome size (4,418,574 bp; vs. H37Rv reference size 4,411,532 bp) and therefore were chosen for downstream analysis. Pan-genome analysis of Illumina and PacBio hybrid assemblies revealed the greatest number of detected genes (4,639 genes; H37Rv reference contains 3,976 genes), while Illumina and ONT hybrid assemblies produced the highest number of SNPs. The number of genes from hybrid assemblies with ONT and PacBio long-reads (mean: 4,620 genes) was greater than short-read assembly alone (4,478 genes). All nine RagOut hybrid genome assemblies detected known mutations in genes associated with MDR-TB and pre-XDR-TB. Conclusions Unicycler software performed the best in terms of achieving contiguous genomes, whereas RagOut improved the quality of Unicycler’s genome assemblies by providing a longer genome size. Overall, our approach has demonstrated that short-read and long-read hybrid assembly can provide a more complete genome assembly than short-read assembly alone by detecting pan-genomes and more genes, including IS6110, and SNPs.

Multidrug-resistant tuberculosis (MDR-TB) and extensively drug-resistant tuberculosis (XDR-TB) make TB difficult to control. Global susceptibility data for six newly recommended anti-TB drugs against M/XDR-TB are still limited. Using publicly available whole-genome sequences, we determined the proportion of 513 phenotypically XDR-TB isolates that carried mutations associated with resistance against these drugs (bedaquiline, clofazimine, linezolid, delamanid, pretomanid and cycloserine). Mutations of Rv0678 and Rv1979c were detected in 69/513 isolates (13.5%) for bedaquiline resistance and 79/513 isolates (15.4%) for clofazimine resistance with additional mmpL5 mutations. Mutations conferring resistance to delamanid were detected in fbiB and ddn genes for 11/513 isolates (2.1%). For pretomanid, a mutation was detected in the ddn gene for 3/513 isolates (0.6%). Nineteen mutations of pykA, cycA, ald, and alr genes, conferring resistance to cycloserine, were found in 153/513 isolates (29.8%). No known mutations associated with linezolid resistance were detected. Cluster analysis showed that 408/513 isolates fell within 99 clusters and that 354 of these isolates were possible primary drug-resistant TB (292 XDR-TB, 57 pre-XDR-TB and 5 MDR-TB). Clonal transmission of primary XDR isolates might contribute significantly to the high prevalence of DR-TB globally.