Christa Fittschen, Kaito Takahashi, Lu Yu, Jim J. Lin, Wen Chao, Yoshizumi Kajii, Coralie Schoemaecker, Sebastien Batut, Alexandre Tomas, Centre for Energy and Environment (CERI EE), Ecole nationale supérieure Mines-Télécom Lille Douai (IMT Lille Douai), Institut Mines-Télécom [Paris] (IMT)-Institut Mines-Télécom [Paris] (IMT), Institut Mines-Télécom [Paris] (IMT), Hebei University, Physicochimie des Processus de Combustion et de l’Atmosphère - UMR 8522 (PC2A), Université de Lille-Centre National de la Recherche Scientifique (CNRS), Université de Lille, CNRS, Academia Sinica, Ecole nationale supérieure Mines-Télécom Lille Douai [IMT Lille Douai], Kyoto University, Physicochimie des Processus de Combustion et de l’Atmosphère - UMR 8522 [PC2A], Centre for Energy and Environment (CERI EE - IMT Nord Europe), and Ecole nationale supérieure Mines-Télécom Lille Douai (IMT Nord Europe)
International audience; Recent works [Jara-Toro et al., Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. 2017, 56, 2166 and PCCP 2018, 20, 27885] suggest that the rate coefficient of OH reactions with alcohols would increase by up to 2 times from dry to high humidity. This finding would have an impact on the budget of alcohols in the atmosphere and that it may explain differences in measured and modeled methanol concentrations. The results were based on a relative technique carried out in a small Teflon bag, which might suffer from wall reactions. We have re-investigated this effect using a direct fluorescence probe of OH radicals, and no catalytic effect of H2O could be found. Experiments in a Teflon bag were also carried out, but we were not able to reproduce the results of Jara-Toro et al. Further theoretical calculations show that the water-mediated reactions have negligible rates compared to the bare reaction and that even though water molecules can lower the barriers of reactions, it cannot make up for the entropy cost. Methanol (CH3OH) is one of the most abundant oxygenated volatile organic compounds (OVOC) in the atmosphere [1, [2]. Direct emissions are the main source, but some oxidation pathways of methane also contribute to its abundance, especially in the remote troposphere [3, [4, [5]. Concentrations range from 1-15 ppbv in the continental boundary layer and up to 1 ppbv in the remote troposphere [6, [7]. Despite numerous efforts, global atmospheric chemical models are presently unable to reconcile the modeled and measured methanol concentrations [7, [8, [9]. The atmospheric degradation of CH3OH is governed by its reaction with OH radicals, which proceeds by abstraction of H-atoms from either the methyl or the hydroxyl site [10]. The rate coefficient shows a non-Arrhenius behavior and increases at temperatures below 200 K, due to enhanced stabilization of a pre-reactive H-bonded complex that can undergo tunneling [10]. The rate coefficient at room temperature (298 K) has been measured many times [11, [12] and is recommended [13] to be k1 = 9.0 × 10-13 cm 3 s-1. Very recently, Jara-Toro et al. [14] reported that the reaction of OH with CH3OH is significantly catalyzed by water (enhanced by a factor of 2 between 20 to 95% of relative humidity) even at 294 K. The same group also reported the water catalysis effect on reactions of OH with ethanol and n-propanol [15]. Their results are based on a well-known relative method, where the consumption of the alcohol is measured relative to the consumption of a reference compound (C5H12) following their simultaneous reactions with OH radicals. The reactions took place in a 80 liter Teflon bag, and OH radicals were generated continuously from the 254 nm photolysis of H2O2. The ratio of the consumption of CH3OH versus the consumption of C5H12 gives the ratio of the rate coefficients, kCH 3 OH+OH / kRef+OH. This type of experiments was carried out at different relative humidity (RH) up to 95%, and it was found that the ratio increased with increasing RH. Under the assumption that the rate of the OH reaction with unpolar C5H12 is independent on RH, this increased ratio was assigned to an increased rate of OH reaction with CH3OH due to water catalysis. More surprisingly, they found a quadratic dependence of the rate enhancement with RH, and speculated that this effect was dismissed in earlier works, because earlier experiments were commonly carried out under low RH, where the water effect would be too weak to observe. Accompanying theoretical work proposed a mechanism of reaction barrier lowering by adding H2O. However, no rate coefficient has been calculated to estimate the impact of this lowering in the reaction barrier heights. Using the rate coefficients taking into account the water catalytic effect could decrease the atmospheric lifetime of CH3OH by a factor of 2 in tropical region with high RH, which would have a non-negligible effect on the global CH3OH budget. It is therefore important to verify this new finding by using different methods. Indeed, the experiments of Jara-Toro et al. have been carried out in a relatively small Teflon bag, where heterogeneous consumption of CH3OH on the walls may take place. This effect may increase with RH and may become complicated when photochemistry occurs (which produces radicals and radical reactions may change the wall property). They did not vary the surface to volume ratio to quantify this effect. In this work, we have reinvestigated the influence of H2O on the rate coefficient of OH reaction with CH3OH using a direct method: laser photolysis coupled to a time-resolved detection of OH radicals by laser induced fluorescence (LIF) after gas expansion (FAGE-Fluorescence Assay by Gas Expansion) [12, [16]. We have also repeated experiments using the same relative method as Jara-Toro et al., and in addition to varying RH, we [a]