Search

In this issue of ACS Nano, Chen et al. provide in vitro and in vivo evidence for monoclonal anti-poly(ethylene glycol) (anti-PEG) antibody-triggered, complement terminal complex-mediated damage to PEGylated liposomal doxorubicin, entailing the release of the encapsulated drug from the vesicles. These results reveal a new dimension of the potential damage of anti-PEG antibody-mediated complement activation on PEGylated nanomedicines in addition to previous observations on infusion hypersensitivity reactions and the accelerated blood clearance effect. The possibility of a destructive attack of the complement system on the liposome drug carrier may have safety implications in patients displaying high levels of preformed anti-PEG antibodies. In this Perspective, we summarize the experimental and clinical data highlighting the relationships among the above adverse immune phenomena and the options available for reducing the risk of immune damage caused by PEGylated nanomedicines.

Polyethylene glycol (PEG)-coated nanopharmaceuticals can cause mild to severe hypersensitivity reactions (HSRs), which can occasionally be life threatening or even lethal. The phenomenon represents an unsolved immune barrier to the use of these drugs, yet its mechanism is poorly understood. This study showed that a single i.v. injection in pigs of a low dose of PEGylated liposomes (Doxebo) induced a massive rise of anti-PEG IgM in blood, peaking at days 7–9 and declining over 6 weeks. Bolus injections of PEG-liposomes during seroconversion resulted in anaphylactoid shock (pseudo-anaphylaxis) within 2–3 min, although similar treatments of naı̈ve animals led to only mild hemodynamic disturbance. Parallel measurement of pulmonary arterial pressure (PAP) and sC5b-9 in blood, taken as measures of HSR and complement activation, respectively, showed a concordant rise of the two variables within 3 min and a decline within 15 min, suggesting a causal relationship between complement activation and pulmonary hypertension. We also observed a rapid decline of anti-PEG IgM in the blood within minutes, increased binding of PEGylated liposomes to IgM+ B cells in the spleen of immunized animals compared to control, and increased C3 conversion by PEGylated liposomes in the serum of immunized pigs. These observations taken together suggest rapid binding of anti-PEG IgM to PEGylated liposomes, leading to complement activation via the classical pathway, entailing anaphylactoid shock and accelerated blood clearance of liposome–IgM complexes. These data suggest that complement activation plays a causal role in severe HSRs to PEGylated nanomedicines and that pigs can be used as a hazard identification model to assess the risk of HSRs in preclinical safety studies. This is an open access article published under a Creative Commons Attribution (CC-BY) License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution and reproduction in any medium, provided the author and source are cited.

The increasing use in the last decade of PEGylated nanodrugs such as Doxil® has seen a rise in the number of associated occurrences of hypersensitivity reactions (HSRs). These reactions (also called infusion reactions or IR), can range from harmless symptoms to life-threatening reactions. Current means to prevent IR include the prophylactic use of antihistamines and steroids, but they cannot ensure total prevention. We previously showed that an intravenous injection of doxorubicin-free Doxil-like PEGylated nano-liposomes (Doxebo) prior to Doxil treatment suppresses Doxil-induced complement activation-related pseudoallergy (CARPA) in pigs, a model of human hypersensitivity reactions to Doxil. However, in order to use Doxebo to prevent Doxil-induced IR, we have to prove its safety and that it does not affect Doxil's performance. Here we show that Doxebo itself does not have toxic effects on the host or tumor, and it does not interfere with Doxil's antitumor activity in mice. Blood, microscopic and macroscopic organ evaluation of rats after repeated administration confirm the lack of intrinsic adverse effect of Doxebo. Likewise, the repeated injection of Doxebo before Doxil did not impact Doxil's pharmacokinetics in plasma and therefore does not cause accelerated blood clearance (ABC). Taken together with our previous publications, these data suggest that the injection of Doxebo prior to Doxil administration can help protect against Doxil-induced IR without adversely affecting treatment efficacy and safety.

A commonly held view is that nanocarriers conjugated to polyethylene glycol (PEG) are non-immunogenic. However, many studies have reported that unexpected immune responses have occurred against PEG-conjugated nanocarriers. One unanticipated response is the rapid clearance of PEGylated nanocarriers upon repeat administration, called the accelerated blood clearance (ABC) phenomenon. ABC involves the production of antibodies toward nanocarrier components, including PEG, which reduces the safety and effectiveness of encapsulated therapeutic agents. Another immune response is the hypersensitivity or infusion reaction referred to as complement (C) activation-related pseudoallergy (CARPA). Such immunogenicity and adverse reactivities of PEGylated nanocarriers may be of potential concern for the clinical use of PEGylated therapeutics. Accordingly, screening of the immunogenicity and CARPA reactogenicity of nanocarrier-based therapeutics should be a prerequisite before they can proceed into clinical studies. This review presents PEGylated liposomes, immunogenicity of PEG, the ABC phenomenon, C activation and lipid-induced CARPA from a toxicological point of view, and also addresses the factors that influence these adverse interactions with the immune system., GRAPHICAL ABSTRACT

Numerous studies demonstrate frequent mutations in the genome of SARS-CoV-2. Our goal was to statistically link mutations to severe disease outcome. We used an automated machine learning approach where 1594 viral genomes with available clinical follow-up data were used as the training set (797 ‘severe’ and 797 ‘mild’). The best algorithm, based on random forest classification combined with the LASSO feature selection algorithm, was employed to the training set to link mutation signatures and outcome. The performance of the final model was estimated by repeated, stratified, 10-fold cross validation (CV) and then adjusted for multiple testing with Bootstrap Bias Corrected CV. We identified 26 protein and Untranslated Region (UTR) mutations significantly linked to severe outcome. The best classification algorithm uses a mutation signature of 22 mutations as well as the patient’s age as the input and shows high classification efficiency with an area under the curve (AUC) of 0.94 [confidence interval (CI): [0.912, 0.962]] and a prediction accuracy of 87% (CI: [0.830, 0.903]). Finally, we established an online platform (https://covidoutcome.com/) that is capable to use a viral sequence and the patient’s age as the input and provides a percentage estimation of disease severity. We demonstrate a statistical association between mutation signatures of SARS-CoV-2 and severe outcome of COVID-19. The established analysis platform enables a real-time analysis of new viral genomes.

After over a billion of vaccinations with messenger RNA-lipid nanoparticle (mRNA-LNP) based SARS-CoV-2 vaccines, anaphylaxis and other manifestations of hypersensitivity can be considered as very rare adverse events. Although current recommendations include avoiding a second dose in those with first-dose anaphylaxis, the underlying mechanisms are unknown; therefore, the risk of a future reaction cannot be predicted. Given how important new mRNA constructs will be to address the emergence of new viral variants and viruses, there is an urgent need for clinical approaches that would allow a safe repeated immunization of high-risk individuals and for reliable predictive tools of adverse reactions to mRNA vaccines. In many aspects, anaphylaxis symptoms experienced by the affected vaccine recipients resemble those of infusion reactions to nanomedicines. Here we share lessons learned over a decade of nanomedicine research and discuss the current knowledge about several factors that individually or collectively contribute to infusion reactions to nanomedicines. We aim to use this knowledge to inform the SARS-CoV-2 lipid-nanoparticle-based mRNA vaccine field.

IntroductionNumerous studies demonstrate frequent mutations in the genome of SARS-CoV-2. Our goal was to statistically link mutations to severe disease outcome.MethodsWe used an automated machine learning approach where 1,594 viral genomes with available clinical follow-up data were used as the training set (797 “severe” and 797 “mild”). The best algorithm, based on random forest classification combined with the LASSO feature selection algorithm was employed to the training set to link mutation signatures and outcome. The performance of the final model was estimated by repeated, stratified, 10-fold cross validation (CV), then adjusted for multiple testing with Bootstrap Bias Corrected CV.ResultsWe identified 26 protein and UTR mutations significantly linked to severe outcome. The best classification algorithm uses a mutation signature of 22 mutations as well as the patient’s age as the input and shows high classification efficiency with an AUC of 0.94 (CI: [0.912, 0.962]) and a prediction accuracy of 87% (CI: [0.830, 0.903]). Finally, we established an online platform (https://covidoutcome.com/) which is capable to use a viral sequence and the patient’s age as the input and provides a percentage estimation of disease severity.DiscussionWe demonstrate a statistical association between mutation signatures of SARS-CoV-2 and severe outcome of COVID-19. The established analysis platform enables a real-time analysis of new viral genomes.KEY MESSAGESA statistical link between SARS-Cov-2 mutation status and severe COVID outcome was established using automated machine learning techniques based on random forest and logistic regression combined with feature selection algorithms.A mutation signature based on 3,779 protein coding and 36 UTR mutations capable to identify severe outcome cases was established.The trained model showed high classification performance (AUC=0.94 (CI: [0.912, 0.962]), accuracy=0.87 (CI: [0.830, 0.903])).A registration-free web-server for automated classification of new samples was set up and is accessible at http://www.covidoutcome.com.The established pipeline provides a quick assessment of future patients warranting a prospective clinical validation.

Intravenous administration of lipid-based nanodrugs can cause hypersensitivity, also known as infusion reactions (IRs), that can be attenuated by slow infusion in adult patients. We studied the role of infusion rate and complement (C) activation in IRs in pediatric patients treated with Abelcet, and also in anesthetized rats. IRs were observed in 6 out of 10 (60%) patients who received Abelcet infusion in 4 h or less, while no patients who received the infusion in 6 h showed C activation or IRs. The rat model indicated an inverse relationship between infusion speed and Abelcet-induced hypotension, taken as an experimental endpoint of IRs, while the rise of C3a in blood, an index of C activation, directly correlated with hypotension. The results suggest that pediatric patients are more prone to produce IRs, and that the optimal infusion time of Abelcet may be much longer than the presently recommended 2 h.

Purpose Undesirable complement (C) activation by nanomedicines can entail an adverse immune reaction known as C activation-related pseudoallergy (CARPA) in sensitive patients. The syndrome includes cardiopulmonary, hemodynamic, and a variety of other physiological changes that have been well described in man, pigs, dogs, and rats. However, the information on CARPA is scarce and ambiguous in mice, a species widely used in preclinical studies. The present study aimed to fill this gap by exploring signs of CARPA in mice following i.v. administration of AmBisome and Abelcet, which are nano-formulations of Amphotericin B with high risk to cause CARPA. Materials and methods Anesthetized NMRI mice were intravenously injected with liposomal amphotericin B (Abelcet and AmBisome; 30-300 mg phospholipid/kg), drug-free high cholesterol multilamellar vesicles (HC-MLV), and positive controls, cobra venom factor (CVF) and zymosan, followed by the measurement of blood pressure (BP), heart rate, white blood cell, and platelet counts and plasma thromboxane B2 (TXB2) levels. C activation was assessed by C3a ELISA, a C3 consumption assay (PAN-C3) and a modified sheep red blood cell hemolytic assay. Results All test agents, except HC-MLV, caused transient hypertension, thrombocytopenia, and elevation of plasma TXB2, which were paralleled by significant rises of plasma C3a in CVF and zymosan-treated animals, wherein the initial hypertension turned into hypotension and shock. Abelcet and AmBisome caused minor, delayed rise of C3a that was not associated with hypertension. The C3a receptor inhibitor SB-290157 attenuated the hypertension caused by Abelcet and decreased the BP thereafter. Conclusion The parallelism between C3a anaphylatoxin production and severity of physiological changes caused by the different agents is consistent with CARPA underlying these changes. Although the reactive dose of liposomal phospholipids was substantially higher than that in other species (pigs, dogs), the mouse seems suitable for studying the mechanism of hypersensitivity reactions to liposomal formulations of amphotericin B, a frequent side effect of these drugs.

Complement activation can be evaluated in vitro using plasma or serum from animals and human donors, and in vivo using animal models. Despite many years of research, there is no harmonized approach for the selection of matrix and animal models. Herein, we present an in vitro study investigating intra- and inter-species variability in the complement activation. We used the liposomal formulation of amphotericin, Ambisome, as a model particle to assess the magnitude of the complement activation in plasma derived from various mouse strains and individual human donors. We demonstrated that mouse strains differ in the magnitude of the complement activation by liposomes and cobra venom factor (CVF) in vitro. Inter-individual variability in complement activation by Ambisome and CVF was also observed when plasma from individual human donors was analyzed. Such variability in both mouse and human plasma could not be explained by the levels of complement regulatory factors H and I. Moreover, even though mouse plasma was less sensitive to the complement activation by CVF than human plasma, it was equally sensitive to the activation by Ambisome. Our study demonstrates the importance of mouse strain selection for in vitro complement activation analysis. It also shows that traditional positive controls (e.g., CVF) are not predictive of the degree of complement activation by nanomedicines. The study also suggests that besides complement inhibitory factors, other elements contribute to the inter- and intra-species variability in complement activation by nanomedicines.

Nanotechnology provides many solutions to improve conventional drug delivery and has a unique niche in the areas related to the specific targeting of the immune system, such as immunotherapies and vaccines. Preclinical studies in this field rely heavily on the combination of in vitro and in vivo methods to assess the safety and efficacy of nanotechnology platforms, nanoparticle-formulated drugs, and vaccines. While certain types of toxicities can be evaluated in vitro and good in vitro-in vivo correlation has been demonstrated for such tests, animal studies are still needed to address complex biological questions and, therefore, provide a unique contribution to establishing nanoparticle safety and efficacy profiles. The genetic, metabolic, mechanistic, and phenotypic diversity of currently available animal models often complicates both the animal choice and the interpretation of the results. This review summarizes current knowledge about differences in the immune system function and immunological responses of animals commonly used in preclinical studies of nanomaterials. We discuss challenges, highlight current gaps, and propose recommendations for animal model selection to streamline preclinical analysis of nanotechnology formulations.

The enhanced permeability and retention (EPR) effect increases tumor accumulation of liposomal chemotherapy and should, in theory, increase anticancer effects and lower toxicity. Unfortunately, liposomal chemotherapy has generally not met the expected potential, perhaps because the EPR effect is not ubiquitous. PET imaging using radiolabeled liposomes can identify cancers positive for the EPR effect. In the current study, we show in clinical canine cancer patients that repeated imaging with radiolabeled liposomes (64Cu-liposome) induces the accelerated blood clearance (ABC) phenomenon. This was observed even with very long intervals between PEGylated liposome injections, which contradict previous reporting in experimental animal models. The induction of ABC may be devastating for the theranostic use of liposomal imaging, as this could vaccinate patients against therapeutic efficacy. To investigate and solve this important problem, an additional study part was designed in which rats were subjected to repeated liposomal administrations, including stealth 64Cu-liposome PET imaging and Caelyx chemotherapy. Most importantly, it was found that, by increasing the lipid dose at the first injection or by supplying a small predose before the second 64Cu-liposome injection, ABC could be prevented. Importantly, signs of liposome tracer breakdown with subsequent renal excretion were observed. These findings highlight the importance of the ABC phenomenon for liposomal predictive imaging in a clinically relevant setting and show that carefully planned application is central to avoid potential detrimental effects on patient benefit.

Cardiovascular diseases (CVD) account for nearly half of all deaths in Europe and almost 30% of global deaths. Despite the improved clinical management, cardiovascular mortality is predicted to rise in the next decades due to the increasing impact of aging, obesity, and diabetes. The goal of emerging cardiovascular nanomedicine is to reduce the burden of CVD using nanoscale medical products and devices. However, the development of novel multicom-ponent nano-sized products poses multiple technical, ethical, and regulatory challenges, which often obstruct their road to successful approval and use in clinical practice. This review discusses the rational design of nanoparticles, including safety considerations and regulatory issues, and highlights the steps needed to achieve efficient clinical translation of promising nanomedicinal products for cardiovascular applications.

The unique magnetic properties of superparamagnetic iron oxide nanoparticles (SPIONs) have led to their increasing use in drug delivery and imaging applications. Some polymer-coated SPIONs, however, share with many other nanoparticles the potential of causing hypersensitivity reactions (HSRs) known as complement (C) activation-related pseudoallergy (CARPA). In order to explore the roles of iron core composition and particle surface coating in SPION-induced CARPA, we measured C activation by 6 different SPIONs in a human serum that is known to react to nanoparticles (NPs) with strong C activation. Remarkably, only the carboxymethyldextran-coated (ferucarbotran, Resosvist®) and dextran-coated (ferumoxtran-10, Sinerem®) SPIONs caused significant C activation, while the citric acid, phosphatidylcholine, starch and chitosan-coated SPIONs had no such effect. Focusing on Resovist and Sinerem, we found Sinerem to be a stronger activator of C than Resovist, although the individual variation in 15 different human sera was substantial. Further analysis of C activation by Sinerem indicated biphasic dose dependence and significant production of C split product Bb but not C4d, attesting to alternative pathway C activation only at low doses. Consistent with the strong C activation by Sinerem and previous reports of HSRs in man, injection of Sinerem in a pig led to dose-dependent CARPA, while Resovist was reaction-free. Using nanoparticle tracking analysis, it was further determined that Sinerem, more than Resovist, displayed multimodal size distribution and significant fraction of aggregates - factors which are known to promote C activation and CARPA. Taken together, our findings offer physicochemical insight into how key compositional factors and nanoparticle size distribution affect SPION-induced CARPA, a knowledge that could lead to the development of SPIONs with improved safety profiles. NRF (Natl Research Foundation, S’pore)

Complement activation-related pseudoallergy (CARPA) is a hypersensitivity reaction occurring upon intravenous administration of numerous liposomal therapeutics, other nonbiological complex drugs and biologicals. It has a complex molecular and cellular mechanism that involves the production, actions and interactions of numerous vasoactive mediators in blood, including thromboxane A2 (TXA2). This short review focuses on the latter eicosanoid: Its role in CARPA, effects underlying some of the symptoms and experimental evidence for its rate-limiting role in pulmonary hypertension in pigs. Animal experiments and recent clinical observations suggest that the cyclooxygenase blocker indomethacin may represent an effective new approach to prevent liposome-induced CARPA, lending clinical relevance to better understand the involvement of TXA2 and other eicosanoids in this adverse immune effect.

Complement (C) activation can underlie the infusion reactions to liposomes and other nanoparticle-based medicines, a hypersensitivity syndrome that can be partially reproduced in animal models. However, the sensitivities and manifestations substantially differ in different species, and C activation may not be the only cause of pathophysiological changes. In order to map the species variation of C-dependent and -independent pseudoallergy (CARPA/CIPA), here we used known C activators and C activator liposomes to compare their acute hemodynamic, hematological, and biochemical effects in rats. These C activators were cobra venom factor (CVF), zymosan, AmBisome (at 2 doses), its amphotericin B-free vehicle (AmBisombo), and a PEGylated cholesterol-containing liposome (PEG-2000-chol), all having different powers to activate C in rat blood. The pathophysiological endpoints measured were blood pressure, leukocyte and platelet counts, and plasma thromboxane B2, while C activation was assessed by C3 consumption using the Pan-Specific C3 assay. The results showed strong linear correlation between C activation and systemic hypotension, pointing to a causal role of C activation in the hemodynamic changes. The observed thrombocytopenia and leukopenia followed by leukocytosis also correlated with C3 conversion in case of C activators, but not necessarily with C activation by liposomes. These findings are consistent with the double hit hypothesis of hypersensitivity reactions (HSRs), inasmuch as strong C activation can fully account for all symptoms of HSRs, but in case of no-, or weak C activators, the pathophysiological response, if any, is likely to involve other activation pathways.

There is substantial effort in modern pharmacotherapy to use nanoparticle-based drug delivery systems (nDDS) for improving the oral absorption of drugs. An often neglected circumstance regarding this approach is that the gut is a major part of the immune system that may be vulnerable for immune-cell toxicity, or mediate humoral immune response against various components of nDDS, recognized as foreign. This review recapitulates the structure and function of gut-associated lymphoid tissue (GALT), i.e., the enteral section of mucosa-associated lymphoid tissue (MALT) and reminds how virus-like nDDS may potentially induce immunogenicity just as attenuated or killed viruses do in oral vaccines. Furthermore, we present examples for immune toxicities of emulsifiers and polymer-containing micelles, manifested in complement activation-related pseudoallergy (CARPA). A major message of the review is that early testing of immunogenicity or other adverse immune effects of nDDS in appropriate test systems or models may be prudent to recognize the risk of rare immune problems that may surface in late-stage clinical trials or after marketing of nDDS.

Introduction Licorice root ( Glycyrrhiza glabra L.) extract and its main active component glycyrrhizin, as well as derivates are well known hepatoprotective and gastroprotective agents. Liposomal applications of these compounds may prevent low bioavailability and side-effects, e.g. pseudoaldosteronism and has further benefits, because the nanoparticles with glycyrrhizin and glycyrrhetinic acid have enhanced uptake into the liver. Our aim was to study the hepatoprotective effect of liposomal glycyrrhizin treatment during long-term alcohol consumption in rats. Methods Harlan-Wistar (175–200 g) rats were randomly allocated into three groups: control, alcoholic, ethanol and liposomal glycyrrhizin-treated. The redox status of the liver was studied with the measurement of free sulfhydryl-group concentration and hydrogen-donor ability. Transmethylation capacity was measured in dimedone adduct form. Histological examination was carried out as well. Results Data showed mild elevation in the hydrogen-donor ability and slightly lowered free sulfhydryl level, although transmethylation capacity was significantly lowered (p Conclusions Liposomal glycyrrhizin treatment moderated the alcohol-related negative changes, therefore glycyrrhizin and/or its derivatives may have further impact in the treatment of alcoholic liver diseases.

Hypersensitivity reactions to particulate drugs can partly be caused by complement activation and represent a major complication during intravenous application of nanomedicines. Several liposomal and micellar drugs and carriers, and therapeutic antibodies, were shown to activate complement and induce complement activation-related pseudoallergy (CARPA) in model animals. To explore the possible use of the natural complement inhibitor factor H (FH) against CARPA, we examined the effect of FH on complement activation induced by CARPAgenic drugs. Exogenous FH inhibited complement activation induced by the antifungal liposomal Amphotericin-B (AmBisome), the widely used solvent of anticancer drugs Cremophor EL, and the anticancer monoclonal antibody rituximab in vitro. An engineered form of FH (mini-FH) was more potent inhibitor of Ambisome-, Cremophor EL- and rituximab-induced complement activation than FH. The FH-related protein CFHR1 had no inhibitory effect. Our data suggest that FH or its derivatives may be considered in the pharmacological prevention of CARPA. From the Clinical Editor Although liposomes and micelles are already in use in the clinical setting as drug carriers, there remains the potential problem of hypersensitivity due to complement activation. In this article, the authors investigated the use of complement inhibitor factor H (FH) on complement activation and showed good efficacy. The results would therefore suggest the potential application of complement inhibitor in the future.

Nanocarriers, such as liposomes and nanoparticles, have been widely explored as promising delivery vehicles in modern pharmacotechnology. The interaction of liposomes with the immune system has contributed to the challenges in translation to clinical use. Complement activation per se cannot solely explain liposome-induced pseudoallergy; instead, it may be a trigger or contributing factor, but not the sole cause of hypersensitivity reactions in sensitive individuals. Surface functionalization of liposomes with methoxy-terminated Polyethylene glycol is supposed to substantially suppress/inhibit complement activation. Complement activation and hypersensitivity reactions (CARPA) and accelerated blood clearance phenomenon are considered two sides of the same coin, both being spin-off phenomena of a vicious cycle of complement activation by nanoparticles, antibody formation and antibody binding to the activator-accelerating complement activation. Patient pretreatment with anti-inflammatory and anti-allergic agents has been considered one of the most commonly applied approaches to prevent and/or reduce CARPA.

International audience; Nanostructured lipid carriers (NLC) might represent an interesting approach for the identification and targeting of rupture-prone atherosclerotic plaques. In this study, we evaluated the biodistribution, targeting ability and safety of 64Cu-fonctionalized NLC in atherosclerotic mice. 64Cu-chelating-NLC (51.8±3.1 nm diameter) with low dispersity index (0.066±0.016) were produced by high pressure homogenization at tens-of-grams scale. 24 h after injection of 64Cu-chelated particles in ApoE-/- mice, focal regions of the aorta showed accumulation of particles on autoradiography that colocalized with Oil Red O lipid mapping. Signal intensity was significantly greater in aortas isolated from ApoE-/- mice compared to wild type (WT) control (8.95 [7.58, 10.16]×108 vs 4.59 [3.11, 5.03]×108 QL/mm2, P < 0.05). Moreover, NLC seemed safe in relevant biocompatibility studies. NLC could constitute an interesting platform with high clinical translation potential for targeted delivery and imaging purposes in atherosclerosis.

Tamás Mészáros,1,2,* Gergely Tibor Kozma,2,* Taro Shimizu,3 Koga Miyahara,3 Keren Turjeman,4 Tatsuhiro Ishida,3 Yechezkel Barenholz,4 Rudolf Urbanics,1,2 János Szebeni1,2,5 1Nanomedicine Research and Education Center, Department of Pathophysiology, Semmelweis University, Budapest, Hungary; 2SeroScience Ltd, Budapest, Hungary; 3Department of Pharmacokinetics and Biopharmaceutics, Institute of Biomedical Sciences, Tokushima University, Tokushima, Japan; 4Laboratory of Membrane and Liposome Research, Department of Biochemistry and Molecular Biology, Institute for Medical Research Israel-Canada (IMRIC), The Hebrew University-Hadassah Medical School, Jerusalem, Israel; 5Department of Nanobiotechnology and Regenerative Medicine, Faculty of Health, Miskolc University, Miskolc, Hungary *These authors contributed equally to this work Background: It has been proposed that many hypersensitivity reactions to nanopharmaceuticals represent complement (C)-activation-related pseudoallergy (CARPA), and that pigs provide a sensitive animal model to study the phenomenon. However, a recent study suggested that pulmonary hypertension, the pivotal symptom of porcine CARPA, is not mediated by C in cases of polystyrene nanoparticle (PS-NP)-induced reactions.Goals: To characterize PS-NPs and reexamine the contribution of CARPA to their pulmonary reactivity in pigs.Study design: C activation by 200, 500, and 750 nm (diameter) PS-NPs and their opsonization were measured in human and pig sera, respectively, and correlated with hemodynamic effects of the same NPs in pigs in vivo.Methods: Physicochemical characterization of PS-NPs included size, ζ-potential, cryo-transmission electron microscopy, and hydrophobicity analyses. C activation in human serum was measured by ELISA and opsonization of PS-NPs in pig serum by Western blot and flow cytometry. Pulmonary vasoactivity of PS-NPs was quantified in the porcine CARPA model.Results: PS-NPs are monodisperse, highly hydrophobic spheres with strong negative surface charge. In human serum, they caused size-dependent, significant rises in C3a, Bb, and sC5b-9, but not C4d. Exposure to pig serum led within minutes to deposition of C5b-9 and opsonic iC3b on the NPs, and opsonic iC3b fragments (C3dg, C3d) also appeared in serum. PS-NPs caused major hemodynamic changes in pigs, primarily pulmonary hypertension, on the same time scale (minutes) as iC3b fragmentation and opsonization proceeded. There was significant correlation between C activation by different PS-NPs in human serum and pulmonary hypertension in pigs.Conclusion: PS-NPs have extreme surface properties with no relevance to clinically used nanomedicines. They can activate C via the alternative pathway, entailing instantaneous opsonization of NPs in pig serum. Therefore, rather than being solely C-independent reactivity, the mechanism of PS-NP-induced hypersensitivity in pigs may involve C activation. These data are consistent with the “double-hit” concept of nanoparticle-induced hypersensitivity reactions involving both CARPA and C-independent pseudoallergy. Keywords: adverse drug reactions, immunotoxicity, nanoparticles, pseudoallergy, anaphylatoxins, PIM cells, phagocytosis

Infusion reactions (IRs) are complex, immune-mediated side effects that mainly occur within minutes to hours of receiving a therapeutic dose of intravenously administered pharmaceutical products. These products are diverse and include both traditional pharmaceuticals (for example biological agents and small molecules) and new ones (for example nanotechnology-based products). Although IRs are not unique to nanomedicines, they represent a hurdle for the translation of nanotechnology-based drug products. This Perspective offers a big picture of the pharmaceutical field and examines current understanding of mechanisms responsible for IRs to nanomedicines. We outline outstanding questions, review currently available experimental evidence to provide some answers and highlight the gaps. We review advantages and limitations of the in vitro tests and animal models used for studying IRs to nanomedicines. Finally, we propose a roadmap to improve current understanding, and we recommend a strategy for overcoming the problem.

Intravenous (IV) iron therapy is widely used in iron deficiency anaemias when oral iron is not tolerated or ineffective. Administration of IV-iron is considered a safe procedure, but severe hypersensitivity reactions (HSRs) can occur at a very low frequency. Recently, new guidelines have been published by the European Medicines Agency with the intention of making IV-iron therapy safer; however, the current protocols are still non-specific, non-evidence-based empirical measures which neglect the fact that the majority of IV-iron reactions are not IgE-mediated anaphylactic reactions. The field would benefit from new specific and effective methods for the prevention and treatment of these HSRs, and the main goal of this review was to highlight a possible new approach based on the assumption that IV-iron reactions represent complement activation-related pseudo-allergy (CARPA), at least in part. The review compares the features of IV-iron reactions to those of immune and non-immune HSRs caused by a variety of other infused drugs and thus make indirect inferences on IV-iron reactions. The process of comparison highlights many unresolved issues in allergy research, such as the unsettled terminology, multiple redundant classifications and a lack of validated animal models and lege artis clinical studies. Facts and arguments are listed in support of the involvement of CARPA in IV-iron reactions, and the review addresses the mechanism of low reactogenic administration protocols (LRPs) based on slow infusion. It is suggested that consideration of CARPA and the use of LRPs might lead to useful new additions to the management of high-risk IV-iron patients.

Factor H (FH) is a natural inhibitor of the alternative pathway (AP) of complement (C) activation, an abundant protein in blood whose reduced level has been associated with proneness for increased C activation. There are also 5 FH-related proteins (FHR), which have different impacts on C function. After brief outlines of the C system and its activation via the AP, this review focuses on FH and FHR, collecting data from the literature that suggest that reduced levels or function of FH is associated with C activation-related hypersensitivity reactions (HSRs), called C activation related pseudoallergy (CARPA). Based on such observations we initiated the measurement of FH in the blood of patients with inflammatory bowel disease (IBD) and rheumatoid arthritis (RA), and examined the correlation between FH levels and HSRs following i.v. administration of PEGylated liposomal prednisolone phosphate (PLPP). ELISA assay of FH was conducted on plasma samples before treatment, immediately after treatment and at follow-up visits up to 7 weeks, and an attempt was made to correlate the FH levels obtained with the presence or absence of HSR that occurred in five of twenty patients. However, the initial data presented here on three reactive and three non-reactive patients showed FH levels >600 μg/mL, while the normal range of FH is 2–300 μg/mL. This unexpected outcome of the test led us to realize that the ELISA we used was based on antibodies raised against the short consensus repeats (SCR) in FH, which are also present in FHR. Thus the kit cannot distinguish these proteins and we most likely measured the combined levels of FH and FHR. These initial data highlighted an unforeseen technical problem in assessing FH function when using a FH ELISA that cross reacts with FHR, information that helps in further studies exploring the role of FH in CARPA.

A recent study on nanoparticle-induced hypersensitivity reactions in pigs showed robust pulmonary intravascular macrophage clearance of Polybead® carboxylate microspheres in mediating the adverse cardiopulmonary distress, irrespective of the ability of these particles to activate the complement (C) system in vitro. Focusing on this observation, this article highlights the controversies in projecting in vitro C assay data to in vivo conditions and applying data on polystyrene particles to therapeutic nanopharmaceuticals. Based on overwhelming evidence of a role of anaphylatoxins in hypersensitivity reactions, the need to further explore the role of C activation in the reported and other reactions is highlighted. C-activation-related and C-independent pseudoallergies (CARPA and CIPA) can proceed simultaneously, as outlined by the 'double-hit' hypothesis.

Liposomes formulated from the 1,3-diamidophospholipid Pad-PC-Pad are shear- responsive and thus promising nano-containers to specifically release a vasodilator at stenotic arteries. The recommended preclinical safety tests for therapeutic liposomes of nanometer size include the in vitro assessment of complement activation and the evaluation of the associated risk of complement activation-related pseudo-allergy (CARPA) in vivo. For this reason, we measured complement activation by Pad-PC- Pad formulations in human and porcine sera, along with the nanopharmaceutical- mediated cardiopulmonary responses in pigs. The evaluated formulations comprised of Pad-PC-Pad liposomes, with and without polyethylene glycol on the surface of the liposomes, and nitroglycerin as a model vasodilator. The nitroglycerin incorporation efficiency ranged from 25% to 50%. In human sera, liposome formulations with 20 mg/mL phospholipid gave rise to complement activation, mainly via the alternative pathway, as reflected by the rises in SC5b-9 and Bb protein complex concentrations. Formulations having a factor of ten lower phospholipid content did not result in measurable complement activation. The weak complement activation induced by Pad- PC-Pad liposomal formulations was confirmed by the results obtained by performing an in vivo study in a porcine model, where hemodynamic parameters were monitored continuously. Our study suggests that, compared to FDA-approved liposomal drugs, Pad-PC-Pad exhibits less or similar risks of CARPA.

For natural scientists and engineers, learning from nature has tradition and is often driven by bio-inspired processes and materials. For example, engineers have designed multifunctional materials with hierarchical structures. Lipid bilayers, the principal components of cell membranes, can form vesicles, termed liposomes. Such liposomes are usually recognized as foreign by the immune system of a patient, which makes it challenging to use liposomes as containers for targeted drug delivery. There are, however, promising non-spherical, mechano-sensitive, artificial liposomes about 100 nm in diameter, which were recently identified. These bio-inspired containers offer a wide range of applications. In particular, the targeted release at critically stenosed arteries formed as a result of atherosclerosis significantly reduces the undesired side effects such as a drop of blood pressure. It is well known that FDA-approved liposomal drugs, currently on the market, often induce adverse immune responses. Therefore, to exclude the hypersensitivity of the recently discovered mechano-sensitive liposomes, we have performed in vitro complement activation experiments and related animal studies with pigs. Recently, it has been shown that the drug-free Pad-PC-Pad liposomes surprisingly lack any complement activation. In this study, we demonstrate that nitroglycerin-loaded liposomes with relevant human therapeutic dosage exhibit low complement activation compared to the FDA-approved phospholipid drugs, including Abelcet. Furthermore, the liposomal suspensions applied are stable for a period of more than two months. Consequently, the non-spherical liposomes of nanometer size we have developed are promising containers for physically triggered, targeted drug delivery.

Submitted manuscript version. Published version available at https://doi.org/10.1038/NNANO.2017.47. Intravenously injected nanopharmaceuticals, including PEGylated nanoparticles, induce adverse cardiopulmonary reactions in sensitive human subjects, and these reactions are highly reproducible in pigs. Although the underlying mechanisms are poorly understood, roles for both the complement system and reactive macrophages have been implicated. Here, we show the dominance and importance of robust pulmonary intravascular macrophage clearance of nanoparticles in mediating adverse cardiopulmonary distress in pigs irrespective of complement activation. Specifically, we show that delaying particle recognition by macrophages within the first few minutes of injection overcomes adverse reactions in pigs using two independent approaches. First, we changed the particle geometry from a spherical shape (which triggers cardiopulmonary distress) to either rod- or disk-shape morphology. Second, we physically adhered spheres to the surface of erythrocytes. These strategies, which are distinct from commonly leveraged stealth engineering approaches such as nanoparticle surface functionalization with poly(ethylene glycol) and/or immunological modulators, prevent robust macrophage recognition, resulting in the reduction or mitigation of adverse cardiopulmonary distress associated with nanopharmaceutical administration.

There are direct and indirect indications that PEGylated liposomal doxorubicin (Doxil), a widely used anticancer nanomedicine, has a subclinical immune suppressive effect. As an example of a seemingly bad pharmacological property turning out to be “not-so-ugly”, but actually beneficial, the authors highlight the potential benefits of Doxil's immune suppressive effect. These include (1) the decreased uptake of the drug by the MPS which may entail enhanced tumor uptake, and, hence, improved therapeutic efficacy; (2) the use of slow infusion protocols in reducing the risk of hypersensitivity (infusion) reactions; and (3), possible protection against hypersensitivity reactions to co-administered reactogenic drugs. To consider immune suppression as useful represents a paradigm shifts in nanotoxicology and anticancer chemotherapy.

Complement activation-related pseudoallergy (CARPA) is a frequent side effect of intravenous therapies with nanoparticle-containing drugs and biologicals that are recognized by the immune system as foreign. It is an acute infusion reaction dominated by cutaneous and hemodynamic changes, most significantly a cardiopulmonary distress involving major pulmonary hypertension, systemic hypotension and arrhythmias. Because CARPA is unpredictable by conventional allergy tests and it may be life threatening, it can represent a major barrier to the safe therapeutic application of many modern medicines, including liposomal drugs and monoclonal antibodies. This review summarizes and updates the facts and opens questions regarding this phenomenon, with particular focus on its porcine model.

Intravenous administration of low (milligram) doses of nanoparticulate materials in pigs can lead to acute cardiopulmonary, hemodynamic, hematological, biochemical and dermatological changes within minutes, mimicking the human infusion (or anaphylactoid) reactions to many state-of-the‐art (nano)medicines and biologicals. Because of the causal role of complement (C) activation, the phenomenon was called C activation-related pseudoallergy (CARPA). This review summarizes the available information on porcine CARPA caused by different liposomes and polymers. It provides methodical details of the model and addresses the quantitation, sensitivity, specificity, reproducibility and variability of symptoms caused by different reactogenic drugs. We describe a unique feature of the model: the rise of tachyphylaxis (self-induced tolerance) as a function of structural properties of reactogenic agents. For drugs that cause tachyphylactic CARPA, such as liposomal doxorubicin (Doxil), the review recapitulates a recently reported method of desensitization, which may prevent this, as well as many similar hypersensitivity reactions. In explaining the underlying mechanism of tachyphylactic CARPA, a new theory on “double hit” is outlined, wherein the pulmonary intravascular macrophages (PIM cells) of pigs give aggravated response to simultaneous stimulation of their anaphylatoxin and other surface receptors (e.g., toll-like, PAMP, DAMP or mannose) that recognize vesicle surface molecular patterns. The porcine CARPA model might provide unique advantages in studying the mechanism of severe hypersensitivity reactions in man to i.v. drugs, as well as in identifying drugs and drug carriers that may cause such reactions.

A panel of in vitro tests intended for evaluation of the nano-sized drug delivery systems' compliance with human blood was applied to liposomal formulations of anticancer lipophilic prodrugs incorporated into the lipid bilayer. Liposomes on the basis of natural phosphatidylcholine (PC) and phosphatidylinositol (PI), 8:1 (mol) were loaded with 10 mol% of either methotrexate or melphalan 1,2-dioleoylglyceride esters (MTX-DOG and Mlph-DOG respectively) and either decorated with 2 mol% of sialyl Lewis X/A (SiaLe(X/A)) tetrasaccharide ligand or not. Hemolysis rate, red blood cells and platelets integrity and size distribution, complement (C) activation, and coagulation cascade functioning were analyzed upon the material incubation with whole blood. Both formulations were negatively charged with the zeta potential value being higher in the case of MTX-DOG liposomes, which also were larger than Mlph-DOG liposomes and more prone to aggregation. Accordingly, in hemocompatibility tests Mlph-DOG liposomes did not provoke any undesirable effects, while MTX-DOG liposomes induced significant C activation and abnormal coagulation times in a concentration-dependent manner. Reactivity of the liposome surface was not affected by the presence of SiaLe(X/A) or PI. Decrease in liposome loading with MTX-DOG from 10 to 2.5% resulted in lower surface charge density, smaller liposome size and considerably reduced impact on C activation and coagulation cascades.

In an attempt to develop a quantitative assay for supravesicular structures (SVS) – such as aggregates, fused liposomes or solid lipid particles – in liposome preparations, forward vs. side scattering of liposomal doxorubicin (Doxil/Caelyx) was analyzed by flow cytometry. Based on calibration with fluorescent latex beads, the size resolution was between about 500 and 1000 nm. Caelyx, just as structurally matched empty liposomes (Doxebo) produced dot plots clearly distinguishable from background, suggesting the presence of SVS in the above size region. A comparison of gated areas on the scattergrams obtained for different Caelyx preparations showed differences between current and expired samples, implying that SVS formation may be storage-time-dependent. Incubation of doxorubicin with Doxebo in a free drug and lipid concentration range that corresponds to that in Caelyx also led to varying SVS patterns, raising the possibility that free doxorubicin in Caelyx might contribute to SVS formation. Dynamic light scattering and transmission electron microscopic analysis of liposomes following gaiting and sorting of >500 nm particles from Caelyx confirmed the presence of SVS, providing independent evidence for their stable existence. Based on a rough estimation, the amount of SVS in Caelyx is some 60 billionth part of all liposomes. These observations raise the possibility that the presence of an exceedingly small fraction of >500 nm particles may be an intrinsic property of PEGylated small unilamellar liposomes, and that the described FACS analysis may be developed further as a quality assay for liposomal homogeneity.

Immunosafety analysis of pharmaceutical surfactants is an important step in understanding the complex mechanisms by which they induce side effects in susceptible patients. This paper provides experimental evidences that polyethoxylated surfactants, Cremophor-EL and Tween-80, also known as Polysorbate-80, activate the complement system in vitro, in normal human serum and plasma. They appeared to be more efficient reactogens than their structural homolog, Tween-20. Cremophor-EL and Tween-80 promoted the generation of biologically active complement products, C3a, C5a and C5b-9. Consistently, Paclitaxel and Taxotere (Docetaxel), pharmaceuticals formulated in Cremophor-EL and Tween-80, activated the complement system in similar extent. Moreover, comparison of serum reactivity against the drug-loaded and drug-free formulations exhibited a significant linear correlation. Taken together, these results are consistent with the hypothesis that therapeutic side effects, such as acute hypersensitivity and systemic immunostimulation, caused by intravenous nanomedicines containing polyethoxylated detergents such as Cremophor-EL and Tween-80, can be attributed to complement activation-derived inflammatory mediators.