1. Barriers and facilitators to implementation and sustainment of guideline-recommended depression screening for patients with breast cancer in medical oncology: a qualitative study
- Author
-
Hahn, Erin E, Munoz-Plaza, Corrine E, Lyons, Lindsay Joe, Lee, Janet S, Pounds, Dana, La Cava, Shannon, Brasfield, Farah M, Durna, Lara N, Kwan, Karen W, Beard, David B, Ferreira, Alexander, and Gould, Michael K
- Subjects
Health Services and Systems ,Nursing ,Health Sciences ,Clinical Research ,Cancer ,Health Services ,Prevention ,Dissemination and Implementation Research ,Breast Cancer ,Women's Health ,Clinical Trials and Supportive Activities ,Good Health and Well Being ,Breast Neoplasms ,Depression ,Adaptation ,Psychological ,Humans ,Female ,Adult ,Middle Aged ,Qualitative Research ,Mass Screening ,Practice Guidelines as Topic ,Adaptation ,Depression screening ,Implementation strategies ,Qualitative research ,Medical and Health Sciences ,Psychology and Cognitive Sciences ,Oncology & Carcinogenesis ,Biomedical and clinical sciences ,Health sciences ,Psychology - Abstract
ObjectivesImplementation of guideline-recommended depression screening in oncology presents numerous challenges. Implementation strategies that are responsive to local context may be critical elements of adoption and sustainment. We evaluated barriers and facilitators to implementation of a depression screening program for breast cancer patients in a community medical oncology setting as part of a cluster randomized controlled trial.MethodsGuided by the Consolidated Framework for Implementation Research, we employed qualitative methods to evaluate clinician, administrator, and patient perceptions of the program using semi-structured interviews. We used a team-coding approach for the data; thematic development focused on barriers and facilitators to implementation using a grounded theory approach. The codebook was refined through open discussions of subjectivity and unintentional bias, coding, and memo applications (including emergent coding), and the hierarchical structure and relationships of themes.ResultsWe conducted 20 interviews with 11 clinicians/administrators and 9 patients. Five major themes emerged: (1) gradual acceptance and support of the intervention and workflow; (2) compatibility with system and personal norms and goals; (3) reinforcement of the value of and need for adaptability; (4) self-efficacy within the nursing team; and (5) importance of identifying accountable front-line staff beyond leadership "champions."ConclusionsFindings suggest a high degree of acceptability and feasibility due to the selection of appropriate implementation strategies, alignment of norms and goals, and a high degree of workflow adaptability. These findings will be uniquely helpful in generating actionable, real-world knowledge to inform the design, implementation, and sustainment of guideline-recommended depression screening programs in oncology.Trial registrationClinicalTrials.gov #NCT02941614.
- Published
- 2023