1. Is Calling Conceptualized Equivalently across Cultures? A Comparative Study across Six Countries
- Author
-
Michelangelo Vianello, Anna Dalla Rosa, Brittany Buis, Nelson A. D'Silva, Jince Gomez, Serdar Karabati, Evgenia Lysova, and Jingzhou Pan
- Abstract
The concept of calling is deeply rooted in western culture, but research in other cultures is increasing. Yet, whether calling is conceptualized equivalently across cultures is an open and pressing question. In this paper, we draw on a unified multidimensional conceptualization of calling to investigate the cross-cultural generalizability of this construct across six nations (N = 2491): India, Turkey, China, Italy, the United States, and The Netherlands. We observed that the multidimensional structure of calling and the relative importance of the different dimensions of calling in defining the construct are the same across cultures, and that the overall level of calling is surprisingly higher in non-western countries. We also observed small cross-cultural differences in the intensity with which people from different countries approach their calling domain. Comparisons conducted at the level of facets indicated that Italian and Dutch participants scored lower in Transcendent Summons and Pervasiveness, while Chinese participants scored the highest. Callings in India are especially high in the Purpose and Identity components. Overall, these results are compatible with the notion that calling is a universal human experience, and that culture differently influences the levels of calling’s dimensions but not their importance in defining the construct.
- Published
- 2023