1. Rebuttal From Drs Levy, Rhodes, and Evans
- Author
-
Levy, Mm, Rhodes, A, Evans, Le, Antonelli, Massimo, Bailey, H, Kesecioglu, J, Zimmerman, Jj, Beale, R, De Backer, D, Roca, Rf, Kleinpell, Rm, Kissoon, T, Sakr, Y, Schorr, C, Tissieres, P, Townsend, Sr, Antonelli, M (ORCID:0000-0003-3007-1670), Levy, Mm, Rhodes, A, Evans, Le, Antonelli, Massimo, Bailey, H, Kesecioglu, J, Zimmerman, Jj, Beale, R, De Backer, D, Roca, Rf, Kleinpell, Rm, Kissoon, T, Sakr, Y, Schorr, C, Tissieres, P, Townsend, Sr, and Antonelli, M (ORCID:0000-0003-3007-1670)
- Abstract
In their piece suggesting the Surviving Sepsis Campaign (SSC) guidelines be retired, Marik et al make several misleading statements. First, it is important to understand the differences between guidelines, bundles, clinical protocols, and performance measures, which are conflated as equivalent. Clinical practice guidelines follow a clearly defined methodology to make evidence-based recommendations. Bundles, which are derived from guidelines, are tools to facilitate implementation at the bedside with defined targets. Protocols are tools for putting guidelines or bundles into operation. Measures are ways to track and report performance. All are important quality improvement tools. Second, it was stated that SSC has not been responsive to new evidence. SSC has responded to new, published evidence with each iteration of the guidelines: tight glucose control, drotrecogin alfa, and the recommendation for central lines for protocol-based resuscitation were all removed in response to strong published evidence that failed to confirm earlier trials. The cornerstone of the SSC guidelines has always been the evidence-based review of the literature that supports guideline development. Because the bundles are derived from the guideline recommendations, they are also evidence-based. There are robust and consistent published studies and meta-analyses supporting the association between implementation of sepsis bundles and improved survival. Furthermore, there has never been harm demonstrated with bundle implementation. Nothing in the SSC bundles “pressures physicians to administer treatments despite their best medical judgment.” If a physician, based on his or her bedside assessment, feels an element of the bundle is inappropriate, that physician should document that assessment and decision and act accordingly. Regarding specific elements of the SSC bundle, additional statements require rebuttal. The claim that the administration of 30 mL/kg of crystalloid fluid for patients with hy
- Published
- 2019