1. A Hybrid Account of Harm.
- Author
-
Unruh, Charlotte Franziska
- Subjects
HARM (Ethics) ,COMPARATIVE accounting ,COUNTERFACTUALS (Logic) ,EXTENSION (Philosophy) ,PHILOSOPHICAL research - Abstract
When does a state of affairs constitute a harm to someone? Comparative accounts say that being worse off constitutes harm. The temporal version of the comparative account is seldom taken seriously, due to apparently fatal counterexamples. I defend the temporal version against these counterexamples, and show that it is in fact more plausible than the prominent counterfactual version of the account. Noncomparative accounts say that being badly off constitutes harm. However, neither the temporal comparative account nor the non-comparative account can correctly classify all harms. I argue that we should combine them into a hybrid account of harm. The hybrid account is extensionally adequate and presents a unified view on the nature of harm. [ABSTRACT FROM AUTHOR]
- Published
- 2023
- Full Text
- View/download PDF