Search

Supplemental material, sj-pdf-1-jou-10.1177_14648849211032427 for Gendering in the electoral run: A media monitoring study of women politicians’ representation in Belgian news by Joke D’Heer, Sara De Vuyst and Sarah Van Leuven in Journalism

Wie maakt onze informatie? Hoe ziet de loopbaan van een journalist eruit? Wat vinden ze van hun verloning en werkomstandigheden? En hoe kijken ze naar de recente verschuivingen in het medialandschap? Een team van onderzoekers van de Universiteit Gent (Center for Journalism Studies), de Université Libre de Bruxelles (ReSICULB), en de Université de Mons sloeg voor een tweede maal de handen in elkaar om, na de succesvolle samenwerking in 2013, een beeld te vormen van ‘Het profiel van de Belgische journalist’. Ze namen ruim de tijd om vele facetten die typisch zijn voor het journalistenberoep in 2018 te bevragen bij de Belgische journalisten om zo een gedetailleerd beeld te kunnen schetsen. Ze analyseerden niet enkel de werkomstandigheden en het socio-demografische profiel, maar stonden ook stil bij de opvattingen van journalisten ten aanzien van aspecten zoals de snelle evolutie en digitalisering in het beroep, en een aantal ethische kwesties. De resultaten van de bevraging leveren een boeiende inkijk in de leefwereld van de beroepsgroep die dagelijks ons venster op de wereld opent, die dagelijks de nieuwsagenda mee bepaalt, het nieuws becommentarieert en analyseert.

The current research focuses on the role of frame sponsors, more specifically politicians of the six main Flemish political parties (N-VA, Open Vld, CD&V, sp.a, Groen or Vlaams Belang), in framing the public debate about migration in the news as well as on social media. More specifically, we investigated the presence of four frames: the intruder frame, the victim frame, the wealth gap frame and the win-win frame (Van Gorp et al., 2018). We collected statements on migration or migrants made by Flemish politicians between 1 January 2016 and 30 June 2018 in four different types of media. We selected the five most read national newspapers: Het Laatste Nieuws, Het Nieuwsblad, De Standaard, De Morgen, and De Tijd. The television news items were collected from the 19h daily newscast VTM Nieuws (commercial broadcaster) and 19h daily newscast Het Journaal (public broadcaster VRT, Eén). On Twitter and Facebook, we included the official accounts of the political parties as well as the official accounts of their most important politicians (party leaders, Ministers and State Secretaries in the Federal and Flemish government, party experts on migration). In each of the four media, the units of registration are the statements by Flemish politicians containing at least one of the keywords “migration” or “migrant”. We only selected the verbatim quotes by politicians. The newspaper data were collected through the GoPress database, the TV items through the ENA (Elektronisch Nieuwsarchief) database, the Twitter data using the Twitter API, and the Facebook data by means of a manual scraping (due to practical limitations only the 50 most recent posts). The study was conducted by two independent coders. The intercoder reliability test resulted in strong kappa values (ranging from 0.617 to 1). We collected 1528 statements of 82 politicians representing the six parties; 47.9% (732) from N-VA, 27.1% (414) Vlaams Belang, 8.2% (125) Open Vld, 6.0% (91) CD&V, 5.9% (90) sp.a, and 5.0% (76) Groen. Importantly, only 245 of these statements contain one of the four researched frames (16.0%). This is not a surprise, since a lot of quotes are just factual and too short to contain framing or reasoning devices. The intruder frame is by far the most used frame (73.1%), followed by the victim frame (22.0%), wealth gap frame (3.7%), and win -win frame (1.2%). Vlaams Belang (38.8%) had the most framed statements, shortly followed by N-VA (35.9%). Both parties used the intruder frame the most. In contrast, the other four parties used the victim frame the most. We also found differences in frame use depending on the media type. The overrepresentation of the intruder frame on Twitter and television is related to the dominance of N -VA and Vlaams Belang accounts in these platforms. We also compared the framed statements in the media to the official views as carried out in the parties’ election programs (2014) which turn out to be more neutral, less emotional and comprise more alternatively framed statements about migration.