1. Influences of orientation on the Ponzo, contrast, and Craik-O’Brien-Cornsweet illusions
- Author
-
Leo Poom
- Subjects
Adult ,Male ,Linguistics and Language ,Brightness ,media_common.quotation_subject ,Cornsweet illusion ,Illusion ,Experimental and Cognitive Psychology ,Article ,050105 experimental psychology ,Language and Linguistics ,Contrast Sensitivity ,Ponzo illusion ,Young Adult ,03 medical and health sciences ,0302 clinical medicine ,Orientation ,Humans ,Psychology ,0501 psychology and cognitive sciences ,Orientation, Spatial ,Aged ,media_common ,Adjustment method ,Psykologi ,Craik-O'Brien-Cornsweet illusion ,Optical Illusions ,05 social sciences ,Craik-O’Brien-Cornsweet illusion ,Middle Aged ,Sensory Systems ,Form Perception ,Subjective constancy ,Female ,Simultaneous contrast ,Photic Stimulation ,030217 neurology & neurosurgery ,Cognitive psychology - Abstract
Explanations of the Ponzo size illusion, the simultaneous contrast illusion, and the Craik-O’Brien-Cornsweet brightness illusions involve either stimulus-driven processes (assimilation, enhanced contrast, and anchoring) or prior experiences. Real-world up-down asymmetries for typical direction of illumination and ground planes in our physical environment should influence these illusions if they are experience based, but not if they are stimulus driven. Results presented here demonstrate differences in illusion strengths between upright and inverted versions of all three illusions. A left-right asymmetry of the Cornsweet illusion was produced by manipulating the direction of illumination, providing further support for the involvement of an experience-based explanation. When the inducers were incompatible with the targets being located at the different distances, the Ponzo illusion persisted and so did the influence from orientation, providing evidence for involvement of processes other than size constancy. As defined here, upright for the brightness illusions is consistent with an interpretation of a shaded bulging surface and a 3D object resulting from a light-from-above assumption triggering compensation for varying illumination. Upright for the Ponzo illusion is consistent with the inducers in the form of converging lines being interpreted as railway tracks receding on the ground triggering size constancy effects. The implications of these results, and other results providing evidence against experience-based accounts of the illusions, are discussed.
- Published
- 2020