1. ROUTINE PELVIC X-RAY STUDIES IN AWAKE BLUNT TRAUMA PATIENTS
- Author
-
David J. Dries, Michael Flisak, Richard L. Gamelli, Thomas J. Esposito, Dan Smith, Christopher K. Salvino, and Wendy J. Marshall
- Subjects
Adult ,Resuscitation ,medicine.medical_specialty ,Adolescent ,Cost-Benefit Analysis ,Pain ,Physical examination ,Wounds, Nonpenetrating ,Critical Care and Intensive Care Medicine ,Hospitals, University ,Fractures, Bone ,Injury Severity Score ,Clinical Protocols ,Predictive Value of Tests ,medicine ,Humans ,Mass Screening ,Glasgow Coma Scale ,In patient ,Prospective Studies ,Child ,Medical History Taking ,Pelvic Bones ,Physical Examination ,Pelvis ,Aged ,medicine.diagnostic_test ,business.industry ,Pelvic pain ,Clinical course ,Middle Aged ,Organizational Policy ,Surgery ,Radiography ,medicine.anatomical_structure ,Traumatology ,Fees and Charges ,Blunt trauma ,Illinois ,medicine.symptom ,business - Abstract
To evaluate the usefulness of routine pelvic x-ray films in the resuscitation of blunt trauma victims, 1395 patients were prospectively evaluated over a 13-month period. Of these, 810 (58%) were awake with Glasgow Coma Scale scores greater than or equal to 13 and were enrolled into the study. A history, with directed questions regarding pelvic pain, a clinical examination of the pelvis, and an anterior-posterior pelvic x-ray film (APPX) were obtained for each patient. Thirty-nine patients (5%) had fractures identified on the x-ray films. Of these patients with radiographically identified fractures, 34 (87%) complained of pain and had positive results on clinical examination, two (5%) either complained of pain or had positive results on examination and three (8%) had neither complaint of pain nor positive examination results. Of the 771 patients without fractures 743 (96%) lacked pain complaints or positive examination results. The likelihood of fracture was greatest in patients with complaints of pain and positive examination results (65%) followed by patients with either complaint of pain or positive examination results (16%). Only three (0.4%) of the 743 patients having no complaints of pain and a negative clinical examination had fractures diagnosed roentgenographically. These were minor fractures that did not affect the clinical course. Total charges incurred to diagnose pelvic fractures in this low-yield patient group were $88,028. We conclude that the practice of obtaining a screening APPX is not necessary or cost-effective in the management of awake blunt trauma patients who do not complain of pain and who have normal pelvic physical examination results.
- Published
- 1992