Cecilia Griselda Guzman, Jennifer Boutelier, Caroline Janette Souza Gomes, Cristian Cavozzi, Yannick Guillot, Andy Take, Hemin Koyi, Matthias Rosenau, Wouter P. Schellart, Gabriela Da Poian, Daniel Leonardo Yagupsky, Guido Schreurs, Rodrigo Portillo, Chia-Yu Lu, Susanne Buiter, Jean-Paul Callot, Leonardo Cruz, Bruno C. Vendeville, Jean Marc Daniel, Roy W. Schlische, Matthias Klinkmüller, Caroline M. Burberry, Alexander R. Cruden, Shih Hsien Wang, Martha Oliver Withjack, Catherine Anne Marie Dominique Meriaux, Triyani Nur Hidayah, Daniel Pillot, Ernesto Osvaldo Cristallini, George E. Hilley, Jian Hong Chen, Chang Chih Pan, Yasuhiro Yamada, Faramarz Nilfouroushan, Mariano Cerca, Bertrand Maillot, Céline Grall, M. Vettori, Marine Vergnaud, Víctor H. García, Geology and Geochemistry, Institute of Geological Sciences [Bern], University of Bern, Centre for Earth Evolution and Dynamics [Oslo] (CEED), Department of Geosciences [Oslo], Faculty of Mathematics and Natural Sciences [Oslo], University of Oslo (UiO)-University of Oslo (UiO)-Faculty of Mathematics and Natural Sciences [Oslo], University of Oslo (UiO)-University of Oslo (UiO), Geological Survey of Norway (NGU), University of Toronto, Department of Earth Sciences - Palaeobiology [Uppsala], Uppsala University, IFP Energies nouvelles (IFPEN), Université de Pau et des Pays de l'Adour (UPPA), Università degli studi di Parma = University of Parma (UNIPR), Universidad Nacional Automa de Mexico, National Taiwan University [Taiwan] (NTU), Universidad de Buenos Aires [Buenos Aires] (UBA), Universidade Federal de Ouro Preto, Morro do Cruzeiro, Université Lille Nord de France (COMUE), Department of Earth and Planetary Sciences [Piscataway], Rutgers, The State University of New Jersey [New Brunswick] (RU), Rutgers University System (Rutgers)-Rutgers University System (Rutgers), Stanford University, Université de Cergy Pontoise (UCP), Université Paris-Seine, Monash University [Melbourne], German Research Centre for Geosciences - Helmholtz-Centre Potsdam (GFZ), Queen's University [Kingston, Canada], Laboratoire d’Océanologie et de Géosciences (LOG) - UMR 8187 (LOG), Institut national des sciences de l'Univers (INSU - CNRS)-Université du Littoral Côte d'Opale (ULCO)-Université de Lille-Centre National de la Recherche Scientifique (CNRS)-Institut de Recherche pour le Développement (IRD [France-Nord]), Kyoto University, University of Parma = Università degli studi di Parma [Parme, Italie], Géosystèmes, Université de Lille, Sciences et Technologies-Centre National de la Recherche Scientifique (CNRS)-Centre National de la Recherche Scientifique (CNRS), Kyoto University [Kyoto], Laboratoire des Fluides Complexes et leurs Réservoirs (LFCR), TOTAL FINA ELF-Université de Pau et des Pays de l'Adour (UPPA)-Centre National de la Recherche Scientifique (CNRS), University of Parma, School of Geosciences, Monash University [Clayton], Medical Department, Pfizer Oncology, Stanford University [Stanford], Hans Ramberg Tectonic Laboratory, Department of Geosciences, National Taiwan University, Department of Geosciences, Laboratoire de tectonique (LT), Centre National de la Recherche Scientifique (CNRS)-Université de Cergy Pontoise (UCP), Université Paris-Seine-Université Paris-Seine-Institut national des sciences de l'Univers (INSU - CNRS)-Université Pierre et Marie Curie - Paris 6 (UPMC), Department of Industrial Development, IT and Land Management, University of Gävle, GeoForschungsZentrum - Helmholtz-Zentrum Potsdam (GFZ), Queen's University [Kingston], Processus et bilan des domaines sédimentaires (PBDS), Université de Lille, Sciences et Technologies-Institut national des sciences de l'Univers (INSU - CNRS)-Centre National de la Recherche Scientifique (CNRS), Université de Bordeaux (UB), and Université de Lorraine (UL)
We performed a quantitative comparison of brittle thrust wedge experiments to evaluate the variability among analogue models and to appraise the reproducibility and limits of model interpretation. Fifteen analogue modeling laboratories participated in this benchmark initiative. Each laboratory received a shipment of the same type of quartz and corundum sand and all laboratories adhered to a stringent model building protocol and used the same type of foil to cover base and sidewalls of the sandbox. Sieve structure, sifting height, filling rate, and details on off-scraping of excess sand followed prescribed procedures. Our analogue benchmark shows that even for simple plane-strain experiments with prescribed stringent model construction techniques, quantitative model results show variability, most notably for surface slope, thrust spacing and number of forward and backthrusts. One of the sources of the variability in model results is related to slight variations in how sand is deposited in the sandbox. Small changes in sifting height, sifting rate, and scraping will result in slightly heterogeneous material bulk densities, which will affect the mechanical properties of the sand, and will result in lateral and vertical differences in peak and boundary friction angles, as well as cohesion values once the model is constructed. Initial variations in basal friction are inferred to play the most important role in causing model variability. Our comparison shows that the human factor plays a decisive role, and even when one modeler repeats the same experiment, quantitative model results still show variability. Our observations highlight the limits of up-scaling quantitative analogue model results to nature or for making comparisons with numerical models. The frictional behavior of sand is highly sensitive to small variations in material state or experimental set-up, and hence, it will remain difficult to scale quantitative results such as number of thrusts, thrust spacing, and pop-up width from model to nature. Fil: Schreurs, Guido. University of Bern; Suiza Fil: Buiter, Susanne J. H.. University of Oslo; Noruega. Norges Geologiske Undersekelse; Noruega Fil: Boutelier, Jennifer. University of Toronto; Canadá Fil: Burberry, Caroline. Uppsala Universitet; Suecia Fil: Callot, Jean-Paul. Ifp Energies Nouvelles; Francia Fil: Cavozzi, Cristian. Università di Parma; Italia Fil: Cerca, Mariano. Universidad Nacional Autónoma de México; México Fil: Chen, Jian-Hong. National Taiwan University; República de China Fil: Cristallini, Ernesto Osvaldo. Universidad de Buenos Aires. Facultad de Ciencias Exactas y Naturales. Departamento de Ciencias Geológicas; Argentina. Comisión Nacional de Investigación Científica y Tecnológica; Chile Fil: Cruden, Alexander R.. University of Toronto; Canadá Fil: Cruz, Leonardo. University of Stanford; Estados Unidos Fil: Daniel, Jean-Marc. Ifp Energies Nouvelles; Francia Fil: Da Poian, Gabriela. Universidad de Buenos Aires; Argentina Fil: Garcia, Victor H.. Universidad de Buenos Aires. Facultad de Ciencias Exactas y Naturales. Departamento de Ciencias Geológicas; Argentina Fil: Gomes, Caroline J. S.. Universidade Federal de Ouro Preto; Brasil Fil: Grall, Céline. Ifp Energies Nouvelles; Francia Fil: Guillot, Yannick. University Of Lille; Francia Fil: Guzman, Cecilia Griselda. Consejo Nacional de Investigaciones Científicas y Técnicas. Oficina de Coordinación Administrativa Ciudad Universitaria. Instituto de Estudios Andinos ; Argentina Fil: Hidayah, Triyani Nur. State University of New Jersey; Estados Unidos Fil: Hilley, George. University of Stanford; Estados Unidos Fil: Klinkmüller, Matthias. University of Bern; Suiza Fil: Koyi, Hemin A.. Uppsala Universitet; Suecia Fil: Lu, Chia-Yu. National Taiwan University; República de China Fil: Maillot, Bertrand. Universite de Cergy-Pontoise; Francia Fil: Meriaux, Catherine. Monash University; Australia Fil: Nilfouroushan, Faramarz. Uppsala Universitet; Suecia Fil: Pan, Chang-Chih. National Taiwan University; Suecia Fil: Pillot, Daniel. Ifp Energies Nouvelles; Francia Fil: Portillo, Rodrigo. Universidad Nacional Autónoma de México; México Fil: Rosenau, Matthias. German Research Centre for Geosciences; Alemania Fil: Schellart, Wouter P.. Monash University; Australia Fil: Schlische, Roy W.. State University of New Jersey; Estados Unidos Fil: Take, Andy. Queens University; Canadá Fil: Vendeville, Bruno. Laboratoire D'oceanologie Et de Geosciences; Francia Fil: Vergnaud, Marine. Ifp Energies Nouvelles; Francia Fil: Vettori, Matteo. Università di Parma; Italia Fil: Wang, Shih-Hsien. National Taiwan University; República de China Fil: Withjack, Martha O.. State University of New Jersey; Estados Unidos Fil: Yagupsky, Daniel Leonardo. Universidad de Buenos Aires. Facultad de Ciencias Exactas y Naturales. Departamento de Ciencias Geológicas; Argentina. Consejo Nacional de Investigaciones Científicas y Técnicas; Argentina Fil: Yamada, Yasuhiro. Kyoto University; Japón