1. Improving surgical skills with feedback: directly-observed versus video-recorded practice
- Author
-
Kasaya Tantiphlachiva, Cherdsak Iramaneerat, and Tripop Lertbunnaphong
- Subjects
Surgical skill ,Skill teaching ,Feedback ,Motivation ,Video-feedback ,Special aspects of education ,LC8-6691 ,Medicine - Abstract
Abstract Objective This study aimed to compare two methods of feedback: verbal face-to-face feedback after direct observation (F2F-feedback) versus electronic-written feedback after observation of recorded-VDO of student’s performance (VDO-feedback), in terms of effectiveness in improving skill, effects on motivation and satisfaction. Background Medical schools are responsible for teaching and ensuring proficiency of basic surgical skills. Feedback is effective in developing psychomotor skills; by providing information of learner’s current performance, how to improve, and enhancing motivation. Materials and method Fifty-eight medical students (3rd– 4th year) were trained to perform vertical mattress suture in small groups. Then, during 6-week period of self-directed practice, students were randomized into group1 VDO-feedback (male:female = 21:8) and group 2 F2F-feedback (male:female = 20:9). Feedbacks were provided once every 2 weeks (Week2, Week4). End-of-rotation OSCE was at Week6, and retention tested was at Week8. Performance checklist (Cronbach’s Alpha 0.72) was used to assess skill at 4 timepoints; pre- and post- small group learning, OSCE, and retention phase. Questionnaire was used to assess motivation, learning strategies and satisfaction (Cronbach’s Alpha 0.83). Result After in-class learning, further significant improvement of skills could be gained by both F2F- and VDO- feedbacks (p
- Published
- 2023
- Full Text
- View/download PDF