1. Stories theology lives by: a narrative and phronetic theology of liberation
- Author
-
Buck, RA and Ward, G
- Subjects
Liberation theology ,Cognitive science ,Hermeneutics ,Knowledge, Sociology of ,Virtue epistemology ,Theology ,Narrative theology ,Knowledge, Theory of ,Theology, Doctrinal - Abstract
What if, far from being a centre or force of liberation, academic theology itself needs liberation? Considering this requires theological reflexivity concerning theology’s purpose and praxis and sociological reflexivity concerning how the field of theology functions as a system. Pierre Bourdieu’s method of sociological analysis is especially suited to facilitating this reflexivity. Employing a pioneering Bourdieusien analysis through a case study of the Yale School of Narrative Theology, this interdisciplinary thesis explores how in allowing a set of reductive and non-inclusive epistemic assumptions to control the mode theologising, the field of theology has perpetuated symbolic violence, namely a legitimation of the status quo of theological mode. In this analysis, those from marginalised communities suffer most, either by being forced to theologise according to the dictates of the dominant or by being disregarded in or disenfranchised from participation. However, the assumption of an abstractionist discursive mode for theological epistemology also renders it epistemically reductive: both of the modes of theological production and knowledge and of the sociological dimensions of doing theology. So, building upon our Bourdieusien analysis and synthesis of the Yale School’s theological insights, we construct a truly productive narrative and phronetic theology of liberation through love that removes symbolic violence from theology without resorting to it. Through dialogue with Gustavo Gutiérrez, Hans Urs von Balthasar, Bourdieu, Cognitive Science of Narrative, and Christian Scripture we construct a dialectic and phronetic epistemology of love in which one loves in order to know. This removes symbolic violence from academic theological epistemology by embracing creative dialectical subjectivity and objectivity in knowing through love. Inseparable from this, we uncover the fundamentally existential origins of symbolic violence and narrate an alternative to legitimation-through-power in Christ incarnate and crucified expressing a radical embodied solidarity with God and humanity in love.
- Published
- 2023