419 results on '"Brownell, Sara E."'
Search Results
2. Systemic advantage has a meaningful relationship with grade outcomes in students’ early STEM courses at six research universities
- Author
-
Castle, Sarah D., Byrd, W. Carson, Koester, Benjamin P., Pearson, Meaghan I., Bonem, Emily, Caporale, Natalia, Cwik, Sonja, Denaro, Kameryn, Fiorini, Stefano, Li, Yangqiuting, Mead, Chris, Rypkema, Heather, Sweeder, Ryan D., Valdivia Medinaceli, Montserrat B., Whitcomb, Kyle M., Brownell, Sara E., Levesque-Bristol, Chantal, Molinaro, Marco, Singh, Chandralekha, McKay, Timothy A., and Matz, Rebecca L.
- Published
- 2024
- Full Text
- View/download PDF
3. Evaluating the current state of evolution acceptance instruments: a research coordination network meeting report
- Author
-
Barnes, M. Elizabeth, Aini, Rahmi Q., Collins, James P., Dunk, Ryan D. P., Holt, Emily A., Jensen, Jamie, Klein, Joanna R., Misheva, Taya, Nadelson, Louis S., Reiss, Michael J., Romine, William L., Shtulman, Andrew, Townley, Amanda L., Wiles, Jason R., Zheng, Yi, and Brownell, Sara E.
- Published
- 2024
- Full Text
- View/download PDF
4. New Online Accommodations Are Not Enough: The Mismatch between Student Needs and Supports Given for Students with Disabilities during the COVID-19 Pandemic
- Author
-
Gin, Logan E., Pais, Danielle C., Parrish, Kristen D., Brownell, Sara E., and Cooper, Katelyn M.
- Abstract
The COVID-19 pandemic resulted in nearly all universities transitioning their in-person courses to online instruction. Recent work from our research team conducted in Spring 2020 established that the immediate transition to online learning presented novel challenges for students with disabilities: students were unable to access previously established accommodations and there was a lack of information from Disability Resource Centers (DRCs) about adapting accommodations to online environments. In this study, we aimed to determine the extent to which these issues still were present 1 year later. In Spring 2021, we conducted a survey of 114 students with disabilities who were registered with the DRC and taking online science courses at a public research-intensive institution. We used our previous interviews with students to develop closed- and open-ended questions to assess the extent to which students with disabilities were being properly accommodated in their courses, document any new accommodations they were using, and elicit any recommendations they had for improving their experiences in online science courses. We used logistic regression to analyze the closed-ended data and inductive coding to analyze the open-ended data. We found that more than half of students with disabilities reported not being properly accommodated, and this was more likely to be reported by students who experienced new challenges related to online learning. When students were asked what accommodations they would have wanted, students often described accommodations that were being offered to some students but were not universally implemented. This study summarizes recommendations for making online science learning environments more inclusive for students with disabilities.
- Published
- 2022
5. Instructor Perceptions of Student Incivility in the Online Undergraduate Science Classroom
- Author
-
Abraham, Anna E., Busch, Carly A., Brownell, Sara E., and Cooper, Katelyn M.
- Abstract
Student incivility, defined as a student behavior perceived to be disrespectful or disruptive to the overall learning environment in a course, can negatively affect the science learning environment and instructors. The transition to online science courses during the COVID-19 pandemic created a unique environment for student incivility to take place in undergraduate courses. There are few studies that examine student incivility in online synchronous courses, and we know of no studies that have investigated student incivility during the COVID-19 pandemic. In this study, we surveyed 283 instructors across U.S. institutions who taught undergraduate science courses with synchronous online components. We probed their experiences with student incivility during the fall 2020 term. Over half of instructors surveyed reported experiencing student incivility, with women being more likely than men to report student incivility. Compared with white instructors, people of color were more likely to perceive an increase in student incivility in fall 2020 relative to previous in-person terms. This work indicates that student incivility is perceived in the online synchronous learning environment and that the negative impacts of perceived student incivility during COVID-19 online instruction were not distributed equally among instructors, disproportionately burdening women and people of color.
- Published
- 2022
6. A Comparison of Online and In-Person Evolution Instruction That Includes Religious Cultural Competence
- Author
-
Bowen, Chloe D., Summersill, Alexa R., Jensen, Jamie L., Brownell, Sara E., and Barnes, M. Elizabeth
- Abstract
Evolution is one of the most important concepts in biology, but it is rejected by a substantial percentage of religious students due to a perceived conflict with their religious beliefs. The use of religious cultural competence in evolution education (ReCCEE) has been shown to effectively increase evolution acceptance among religious students during in-person instruction, but there is no research that we know of that indicates the effectiveness of these practices during online instruction. In this study, we explored the efficacy of online culturally competent practices for religious students on students' evolution understanding, evolution acceptance, and comfort learning evolution at a religious university. Before and after evolution instruction, we surveyed 178 students in online introductory biology courses and compared these student outcomes to 201 students in the same instructor's in-person introductory biology courses. We found that evolution acceptance and understanding increased in online classes with culturally competent practices, and these gains were similar to those observed in the in-person courses. Despite these similarities, we found that students were more comfortable learning evolution in person than online, but this difference was small. Our findings suggest that the use of culturally competent practices online can be as effective as their use for in-person instruction for improving students' attitudes toward evolution, but in-person instruction may be more effective for cultivating students' comfort while learning evolution.
- Published
- 2022
7. Research Anxiety Predicts Undergraduates' Intentions to Pursue Scientific Research Careers
- Author
-
Cooper, Katelyn M., Eddy, Sarah L., and Brownell, Sara E.
- Abstract
Undergraduate research is lauded as a high-impact practice owing to the array of benefits that students can reap from participating. One unexplored construct that may affect student intent to persist in research is research anxiety, defined as the sense of worry or apprehension associated with conducting research. In this study, we surveyed 1272 undergraduate researchers across research-intensive, master's-granting, and primarily undergraduate institutions to assess the relationship among student demographics, research anxiety, and intent to pursue a research career. Using structural equation modeling, we identified that women and students with higher grade point averages (GPAs) were more likely to report higher levels of research anxiety compared with men and students with lower GPAs, respectively. Additionally, research anxiety was significantly and negatively related to student intent to pursue a research-related career. We coded students' open-ended responses about what alleviates and exacerbates their anxiety and found that experiencing failure in the context of research and feeling underprepared increased their research anxiety, while a positive lab environment and mentor--mentee relationships decreased their anxiety. This is the first study to examine undergraduate anxiety in the context of research at scale and to establish a relationship between research anxiety and students' intent to persist in scientific research careers.
- Published
- 2023
- Full Text
- View/download PDF
8. Should I Write about Mental Health on My Med School App? Examining Medical School Admissions Committee Members' Biases Regarding Mental Health Conditions
- Author
-
Abraham, Anna E., Busch, Carly A., Brownell, Sara E., and Cooper, Katelyn M.
- Abstract
Mental health conditions can impact college students' academic achievements and experiences. As such, students may choose to disclose mental illnesses on medical school applications. Yet, no recent studies have investigated to what extent disclosure of a mental health condition may impact whether an applicant is accepted to medical school. We conducted an audit study to address this gap and surveyed 99 potential medical school admissions committee members from over 40 M.D.-granting schools in the United States. Participants rated a fictitious portion of a single medical school application on acceptability, competence, and likeability. They were randomly assigned to a condition: an application that explained a low semester grade-point average due to (1) a mental health condition, (2) a physical health condition, or (3) offered no explanation. After rating their respective application, all committee members were asked about when revealing a mental health condition would be beneficial and when it would be detrimental. Using ANOVAs, multinomial regression, and open coding, we found that medical school admissions committee members do not rate applications lower when a mental health condition is revealed. Committee members highlighted that revealing a mental health condition to demonstrate resiliency could be beneficial, but if the reference is vague or the condition is not being managed, it could be detrimental to a student's application. This work indicates that medical school admissions committee members do not exhibit a bias against mental health conditions and provides recommendations on how to discuss mental illness on medical school applications.
- Published
- 2022
- Full Text
- View/download PDF
9. Community College Student Understanding and Perceptions of Evolution
- Author
-
Barnes, M. Elizabeth, Riley, Rebekkah, Bowen, Chloe, Cala, Jacqueline, and Brownell, Sara E.
- Abstract
Learning about evolution is a foundational part of biology education, but most current studies that explore college student evolution education are conducted at universities. However, community college students tend to be more diverse in characteristics shown to be related to evolution education outcomes. To explore how studies involving university students may generalize to community college students, we surveyed students from seven community college (n = 202) and nine university (n = 2288) classes. We measured students' evolution interest, acceptance, and understanding, and for religious students, we measured their perceived conflict between their religions and evolution. Controlling for state and major, we found that community college students had similar levels of evolution interest as university students but perceived greater conflict between their religions and evolution. Further, community college students had lower evolution understanding and acceptance compared with university students. Religiosity was a strong factor predicting community college and university students' evolution acceptance. However, unique to community college students, evolution understanding was not related to their macroevolution or human evolution acceptance. This indicates that, although some results between community college and university students are similar, there are differences that have implications for evolution instruction that warrant the need for more evolution education research at community colleges.
- Published
- 2022
- Full Text
- View/download PDF
10. Chronicling the Journey of the Society for the Advancement in Biology Education Research (SABER) in its Effort to Become Antiracist: From Acknowledgement to Action
- Author
-
Segura-Totten, Miriam, Dewsbury, Bryan, Lo, Stanley M, Bailey, Elizabeth Gibbons, Beaster-Jones, Laura, Bills, Robert J, Brownell, Sara E, Caporale, Natalia, Dunk, Ryan, Eddy, Sarah L, García-Ojeda, Marcos E, Gardner, Stephanie M, Green, Linda E, Hartley, Laurel, Harrison, Colin, Imad, Mays, Janosik, Alexis M, Jeong, Sophia, Josek, Tanya, Kadandale, Pavan, Knight, Jenny, Ko, Melissa E, Kukday, Sayali, Lemons, Paula, Litster, Megan, Lom, Barbara, Ludwig, Patrice, McDonald, Kelly K, McIntosh, Anne CS, Menezes, Sunshine, Nadile, Erika M, Newman, Shannon L, Ochoa, Stacy D, Olabisi, Oyenike, Owens, Melinda T, Price, Rebecca M, Reid, Joshua W, Ruggeri, Nancy, Sabatier, Christelle, Sabel, Jaime L, Sato, Brian K, Smith-Keiling, Beverly L, Tatapudy, Sumitra D, Theobald, Elli J, Tripp, Brie, Pradhan, Madhura, Venkatesh, Madhvi J, Wilton, Mike, Warfa, Abdi M, Wyatt, Brittney N, and Raut, Samiksha A
- Subjects
Quality Education ,Peace ,Justice and Strong Institutions ,inclusion ,diversity ,antiracism ,biology professional societies ,professional development - Abstract
The tragic murder of Mr. George Floyd brought to the head long-standing issues of racial justice and equity in the United States and beyond. This prompted many institutions of higher education, including professional organizations and societies, to engage in long-overdue conversations about the role of scientific institutions in perpetuating racism. Similar to many professional societies and organizations, the Society for the Advancement of Biology Education Research (SABER), a leading international professional organization for discipline-based biology education researchers, has long struggled with a lack of representation of People of Color (POC) at all levels within the organization. The events surrounding Mr. Floyd’s death prompted the members of SABER to engage in conversations to promote self-reflection and discussion on how the society could become more antiracist and inclusive. These, in turn, resulted in several initiatives that led to concrete actions to support POC, increase their representation, and amplify their voices within SABER. These initiatives included: a self-study of SABER to determine challenges and identify ways to address them, a year-long seminar series focused on issues of social justice and inclusion, a special interest group to provide networking opportunities for POC and to center their voices, and an increase in the diversity of keynote speakers and seminar topics at SABER conferences. In this article, we chronicle the journey of SABER in its efforts to become more inclusive and antiracist. We are interested in increasing POC representation within our community and seek to bring our resources and scholarship to reimagine professional societies as catalyst agents towards an equitable antiracist experience. Specifically, we describe the 12 concrete actions that SABER enacted over a period of a year and the results from these actions so far. In addition, we discuss remaining challenges and future steps to continue to build a more welcoming, inclusive, and equitable space for all biology education researchers, especially our POC members. Ultimately, we hope that the steps undertaken by SABER will enable many more professional societies to embark on their reflection journeys to further broaden scientific communities.
- Published
- 2021
11. Students with Disabilities in Life Science Undergraduate Research Experiences: Challenges and Opportunities
- Author
-
Gin, Logan E., Pais, Danielle, Cooper, Katelyn M., and Brownell, Sara E.
- Abstract
Individuals with disabilities are underrepresented in postsecondary science education and in science careers, yet few studies have explored why this may be. A primary predictor of student persistence in science is participating in undergraduate research. However, it is unclear to what extent students with disabilities are participating in research and what the experiences of these students in research are. To address this gap in the literature, in study 1, we conducted a national survey of more than 1200 undergraduate researchers to determine the percent of students with disabilities participating in undergraduate research in the life sciences. We found that 12% of undergraduate researchers we surveyed self-identified as having a disability, which indicates that students with disabilities are likely underrepresented in undergraduate research. In study 2, we conducted semistructured interviews with 20 undergraduate researchers with disabilities. We identified unique challenges experienced by students with disabilities in undergraduate research, as well as some possible solutions to these challenges. Further, we found that students with disabilities perceived that they provide unique contributions to the research community. This work provides a foundation for creating undergraduate research experiences that are more accessible and inclusive for students with disabilities.
- Published
- 2022
- Full Text
- View/download PDF
12. An Exploration of How Gender, Political Affiliation, or Religious Identity Is Associated with Comfort and Perceptions of Controversial Topics in Bioethics
- Author
-
Edwards, Baylee A., Roberts, Julie A., Bowen, Chloe, Brownell, Sara E., and Barnes, M. Elizabeth
- Abstract
Bioethics is an important aspect of understanding the relationship between science and society, but studies have not yet examined undergraduate student experiences and comfort in bioethics courses. In this study, we investigated undergraduate bioethics students' support of and comfort when learning three controversial bioethics topics: gene editing, abortion, and physician-assisted suicide (PAS). Furthermore, student identity has been shown to influence how students perceive and learn about controversial topics at the intersection of science and society. So, we explored how students' religious affiliation, gender, or political affiliation was associated with their support of and comfort when learning about gene editing, abortion, and PAS. We found that most students entered bioethics with moderated viewpoints on controversial topics but that there were differences in students' tendency to support each topic based on their gender, religion, and political affiliation. We also saw differences in student comfort levels based on identity: women reported lower comfort than men when learning about gene editing, religious students were less comfortable than nonreligious students when learning about abortion and PAS, and nonliberal students were less comfortable than liberal students when learning about abortion. Students cited that the controversy surrounding these topics and a personal hesitancy to discuss them caused discomfort. These findings indicate that identity impacts comfort and support in a way similar to that previously shown in the public. Thus, it may be important for instructors to consider student identity when teaching bioethics topics to maximize student comfort, ultimately encouraging thoughtful consideration and engagement with these topics.
- Published
- 2022
- Full Text
- View/download PDF
13. Unveiling Concealable Stigmatized Identities in Class: The Impact of an Instructor Revealing Her LGBTQ+ Identity to Students in a Large-Enrollment Biology Course
- Author
-
Busch, Carly A., Supriya, K., Cooper, Katelyn M., and Brownell, Sara E.
- Abstract
Sharing personal information can help instructors build relationships with students, and instructors revealing concealable stigmatized identities (CSIs) may be particularly impactful. One CSI is the LGBTQ+ identity, but there has been no research on the student-perceived impact of an instructor revealing this identity. In this exploratory study conducted at an institution in the U.S. Southwest, an instructor revealed that she identifies as LGBTQ+ to her undergraduate biology course in less than 3 seconds. We surveyed students (n = 475) after 8 weeks to assess whether they remembered this, and if so, how they perceived it affected them. We used regression models to assess whether students with different identities perceived a disproportionate impact of the reveal. Most students perceived the instructor revealing her LGBTQ+ identity positively impacted them; regression results showed LGBTQ+ students and women perceived greater increased sense of belonging and confidence to pursue a science career. Students overwhelmingly agreed that instructors revealing their LGBTQ+ identities to students is appropriate. This study is the first to indicate the perceived impact of an instructor revealing her LGBTQ+ identity to students in the United States and suggests that a brief intervention could positively affect students.
- Published
- 2022
- Full Text
- View/download PDF
14. Anatomical Self-Efficacy of Undergraduate Students Improves during a Fully Online Biology Course with At-Home Dissections
- Author
-
Youngblood, Jacob P., Webb, Emily A., Gin, Logan E., van Leusen, Peter, Henry, Joanna R., VandenBrooks, John M., and Brownell, Sara E.
- Abstract
Student enrollments in online college courses have grown steadily over the past decade, and college administrators expect this trend to continue or accelerate. Despite the growing popularity of online education, one major critique in the sciences is that students are not trained in the hands-on skills they may need for the workforce, graduate school, or professional school. For example, the Association of American Medical Colleges has recommended that medical schools evaluate applicants on their motor skills and observation skills, yet many online biology programs do not offer opportunities for students to develop these skills. In on-campus biology programs, students commonly develop these skills through hands-on animal dissections, but educators have struggled with how to teach dissections in an online environment. We designed a fully online undergraduate biology course that includes at-home, hands-on dissections of eight vertebrate specimens. Over three course offerings, we evaluated changes in four student outcomes: anatomical self-efficacy, confidence in laboratory skills, perceptions of support, and concerns about dissections. Here, we describe how we implemented at-home dissections in the online course and show that students taking the course gained anatomical self-efficacy and confidence in multiple laboratory skills. Based on open-ended responses, the students perceived that their experiences with the at-home dissections facilitated these gains. These results demonstrate that at-home, hands-on laboratories are a viable approach for teaching practical skills to students in fully online courses. We encourage science instructors to introduce at-home laboratories into their online courses, and we provide recommendations for instructors interested in implementing at-home laboratories.
- Published
- 2022
- Full Text
- View/download PDF
15. A Revised Measure of Acceptance of the Theory of Evolution: Introducing the MATE 2.0
- Author
-
Barnes, M. Elizabeth, Misheva, Taya, Supriya, K., Rutledge, Michael, and Brownell, Sara E.
- Abstract
Hundreds of articles have explored the extent to which individuals accept evolution, and the Measure of Acceptance of the Theory of Evolution (MATE) is the most often used survey. However, research indicates the MATE has limitations, and it has not been updated since its creation more than 20 years ago. In this study, we revised the MATE using information from cognitive interviews with 62 students that revealed response process errors with the original instrument. We found that students answered items on the MATE based on constructs other than their acceptance of evolution, which led to answer choices that did not fully align with their actual acceptance. Students answered items based on their understanding of evolution and the nature of science and different definitions of evolution. We revised items on the MATE, conducted 29 cognitive interviews on the revised version, and administered it to 2881 students in 22 classes. We provide response process validity evidence for the new measure through cognitive interviews with students, structural validity through a Rasch dimensionality analysis, and concurrent validity evidence through correlations with other measures of evolution acceptance. Researchers can now measure student evolution acceptance using this new version of the survey, which we have called the MATE 2.0.
- Published
- 2022
- Full Text
- View/download PDF
16. Infrastructuring to Scale Multi-Institutional Equity and Inclusion Innovations
- Author
-
Hammond, J. W., Brownell, Sara E., Byrd, W. Carson, Cheng, Susan J., McKay, Timothy A., and Tarchinski, Nita A.
- Abstract
In order for multi-institutional STEM education collaborations to scale justice-oriented change, the infrastructures they depend on must be designed--or redesigned--with equity and inclusion in mind. This article focuses on one interinstitutional collaboration as an example: the Sloan Equity and Inclusion in STEM Introductory Courses (SEISMIC) Project, which assembles 10 large public research-intensive institutions to study and promote equitable, inclusive STEM education. Referencing early lessons from SEISMIC, the authors discuss three domains where infrastructural design considerations shape how (and how well) interinstitutional collaborations advance equity and inclusion: people, voices, and data. Each domain involves design tensions and tradeoffs, highlighting the importance of understanding justice-oriented organizational (re)design as an ongoing process.
- Published
- 2022
- Full Text
- View/download PDF
17. Aspects of Large-Enrollment Online College Science Courses That Exacerbate and Alleviate Student Anxiety
- Author
-
Mohammed, Tasneem F., Nadile, Erika M., Busch, Carly A., Brister, Danielle, Brownell, Sara E., Claiborne, Chade T., Edwards, Baylee A., Wolf, Joseph Gazing, Lunt, Curtis, Tran, Missy, Vargas, Cindy, Walker, Kobe M., Warkina, Tamiru D., Witt, Madison L., Zheng, Yi, and Cooper, Katelyn M.
- Abstract
Anxiety is the top mental health concern for undergraduates. While researchers have identified ways that in-person science courses can affect anxiety, little is known about how online science courses affect anxiety. In this study, 2111 undergraduates at a large research-intensive institution completed survey questions about their anxiety in large-enrollment online science courses. Specifically, we assessed students' anxiety in the context of online science courses and asked what aspects of online science courses increase and decrease their anxiety. Students also identified what instructors can do to lessen anxiety in online classrooms. We used open coding and logistic regression to analyze student responses. More than 50% of students reported at least moderate anxiety in the context of online college science courses. Students commonly reported that the potential for personal technology issues (69.8%) and proctored exams (68.0%) increased their anxiety, while being able to access content at a later time (79.0%) and attending class from where they want (74.2%) decreased their anxiety. The most common ways that students suggested that instructors could decrease student anxiety is to increase test-taking flexibility (25.0%) and be understanding (23.1%). This study provides insight into how instructors can create more inclusive online learning environments for students with anxiety.
- Published
- 2021
- Full Text
- View/download PDF
18. Exploring Differences in Decisions about Exams among Instructors of the Same Introductory Biology Course
- Author
-
Wright, Christian D., Huang, Austin L., Cooper, Katelyn M., and Brownell, Sara E.
- Abstract
College instructors in the United States usually make their own decisions about how to design course exams. Even though summative course exams are well known to be important to student success, we know little about the decision making of instructors when designing course exams. To probe how instructors design exams for introductory biology, we conducted an exploratory interview study with seven instructors teaching the same introductory biology course at a large university. We found that despite designing exams for the same course, instructor exam decisions differed with regard to what content was assessed, the exam format, the cognitive difficulty of exam questions, the resources used when crafting exams, and how exams were administered. We hope that this work can initiate conversations about how college instructors should design exams and lead to more uniformity in how student learning is assessed across the same courses taught by different instructors.
- Published
- 2018
19. Fourteen Recommendations to Create a More Inclusive Environment for LGBTQ+ Individuals in Academic Biology
- Author
-
Cooper, Katelyn M, Auerbach, Anna Jo J, Bader, Jordan D, Beadles-Bohling, Amy S, Brashears, Jacqueline A, Cline, Erica, Eddy, Sarah L, Elliott, Deanna B, Farley, Elijah, Fuselier, Linda, Heinz, Heather M, Irving, Madison, Josek, Tanya, Lane, A Kelly, Lo, Stanley M, Maloy, Jeffrey, Nugent, Michelle, Offerdahl, Erika, Palacios-Moreno, Juan, Ramos, Jorge, Reid, Joshua W, Sparks, Rachel A, Waring, Ashley L, Wilton, Mike, Gormally, Cara, and Brownell, Sara E
- Subjects
Quality Education ,Biology ,Bisexuality ,Curriculum ,Female ,Gender Identity ,Homosexuality ,Female ,Humans ,Publications ,Sexual and Gender Minorities ,Surveys and Questionnaires ,Transgender Persons ,Vocabulary ,Curriculum and Pedagogy ,Education - Abstract
Individuals who identify as lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgender, queer, and otherwise nonstraight and/or non-cisgender (LGBTQ+) have often not felt welcome or represented in the biology community. Additionally, biology can present unique challenges for LGBTQ+ students because of the relationship between certain biology topics and their LGBTQ+ identities. Currently, there is no centralized set of guidelines to make biology learning environments more inclusive for LGBTQ+ individuals. Rooted in prior literature and the collective expertise of the authors who identify as members and allies of the LGBTQ+ community, we present a set of actionable recommendations to help biologists, biology educators, and biology education researchers be more inclusive of individuals with LGBTQ+ identities. These recommendations are intended to increase awareness of LGBTQ+ identities and spark conversations about transforming biology learning spaces and the broader academic biology community to become more inclusive of LGBTQ+ individuals.
- Published
- 2020
20. COVID-19 and Undergraduates with Disabilities: Challenges Resulting from the Rapid Transition to Online Course Delivery for Students with Disabilities in Undergraduate STEM at Large-Enrollment Institutions
- Author
-
Gin, Logan E., Guerrero, Frank A., Brownell, Sara E., and Cooper, Katelyn M.
- Abstract
The COVID-19 pandemic caused nearly all colleges and universities to transition in-person courses to an online format. In this study, we explored how the rapid transition to online instruction during the COVID-19 pandemic affected students with disabilities. We interviewed 66 science, technology, engineering, and math (STEM) undergraduates with disabilities at seven large-enrollment institutions during Spring 2020. We probed to what extent students were able to access their existing accommodations, to what extent the online environment required novel accommodations, and what factors prevented students from being properly accommodated in STEM courses. Using inductive coding, we identified that students were unable to access previously established accommodations, such as reduced-distraction testing and note-takers. We also found that the online learning environment presented novel challenges for students with disabilities that may have been lessened with the implementation of accommodations. Finally, we found that instructors making decisions about what accommodations were appropriate for students and disability resource centers neglecting to contact students after the transition to online instruction prevented students from receiving the accommodations that they required in STEM courses during the COVID-19 pandemic. This study illuminates current gaps in the support of students with disabilities and pinpoints ways to make online STEM learning environments more inclusive for students with disabilities.
- Published
- 2021
- Full Text
- View/download PDF
21. An Exploration across Institution Types of Undergraduate Life Sciences Student Decisions to Stay in or Leave an Academic-Year Research Experience
- Author
-
Gin, Logan E., Clark, Carolyn E., Elliott, Deanna B., Roderick, Travis B., Scott, Rachel A., Arellano, Denisse, Ramirez, Diana, Vargas, Cindy, Velarde, Kimberly, Aeschliman, Allyson, Avalle, Sarah T., Berkheimer, Jessica, Campos, Rachel, Gerbasi, Michael, Hughes, Sophia, Roberts, Julie A., White, Quinn M., Wittekind, Ehren, Zheng, Yi, Cooper, Katelyn M., and Brownell, Sara E.
- Abstract
Undergraduate research is one of the most valuable activities an undergraduate can engage in because of its benefits, and studies have shown that longer experiences are more beneficial. However, prior research has illuminated that undergraduates encounter challenges that may cause them to exit research prematurely. These studies have been almost exclusively conducted at research-intensive (R1) institutions, and it is unclear whether such challenges are generalizable to other institution types. To address this, we extended a study previously conducted at public R1 institutions. In the current study, we analyze data from 1262 students across 25 public R1s, 12 private R1s, 30 master's-granting institutions, and 20 primarily undergraduate institutions (PUIs) to assess: (1) to what extent institution type predicts students' decisions to persist in undergraduate research; and (2) what factors affect students' decisions to either stay in or consider leaving their undergraduate research experiences (UREs) at different institution types. We found students at public R1s are more likely to leave their UREs compared with students at master's-granting institutions and PUIs. However, there are few differences in why students enrolled at different institution types consider leaving or choose to stay in their UREs. This work highlights the importance of studying undergraduate research across institutions.
- Published
- 2021
- Full Text
- View/download PDF
22. A New Measure of Students' Perceived Conflict between Evolution and Religion (PCoRE) Is a Stronger Predictor of Evolution Acceptance than Understanding or Religiosity
- Author
-
Barnes, M. Elizabeth, Supriya, K., Zheng, Yi, Roberts, Julie A., and Brownell, Sara E.
- Abstract
Evolution is controversial among students and religiosity, religious affiliation, understanding of evolution, and demographics are predictors of evolution acceptance. However, quantitative research has not explored the unique impact of student perceived conflict between their religion and evolution as a major factor influencing evolution acceptance. We developed an instrument with validity evidence called "Perceived Conflict between Evolution and Religion" (PCoRE). Using this measure, we find that, among students in 26 biology courses in 11 states, adding student perceived conflict between their religion and evolution to linear mixed models more than doubled the capacity of the models to predict evolution acceptance compared with models that only included religiosity, religious affiliation, understanding of evolution, and demographics. Student perceived conflict between evolution and their religion was the strongest predictor of evolution acceptance among all variables and mediated the impact of religiosity on evolution acceptance. These results build upon prior literature that suggests that reducing perceived conflict between students' religious beliefs and evolution can help raise evolution acceptance levels. Further, these results indicate that including measures of perceived conflict between religion and evolution in evolution acceptance studies in the future is important.
- Published
- 2021
- Full Text
- View/download PDF
23. It's in the Syllabus ... or Is It? How Biology Syllabi Can Serve as Communication Tools for Creating Inclusive Classrooms at a Large-Enrollment Research Institution
- Author
-
Gin, Logan E., Scott, Rachel A., Pfeiffer, Leilani D., Zheng, Yi, Cooper, Katelyn M., and Brownell, Sara E.
- Abstract
Syllabi are usually required by institutions of higher education and often are the first exposure that students have to a particular course. Instructors can use syllabi as a mechanism to convey important information to students. Moreover, a syllabus can be considered a tool to create inclusive biology courses by transmitting information to all students equitably. In this study, we examined 75 biology course syllabi collected from a research-intensive institution to examine what content instructors include. We reviewed the syllabi to determine the presence or absence of elements and assessed to what extent there were differences in the presence or absence of certain syllabus elements based on course level and course size. We found that instructors are most likely to include content about course expectations and least likely to include content about creating positive classroom climate on their course syllabi. Despite university requirements, many instructors did not include the university-mandated criteria and they did not include elements that could increase how inclusive students perceive the course to be. However, instructors more often included inclusive content when it was required by the university. We also found that students enrolled in upper level courses and small enrollment courses are provided with less content on their syllabi, which we would then interpret as a less inclusive syllabus. We discuss the implications of how these results may differentially impact students in these courses and how the syllabus can be a tool for creating more inclusive college biology courses.
- Published
- 2021
- Full Text
- View/download PDF
24. The scientific rules, roles, and values that life sciences doctoral students want to see upheld by undergraduate researchers
- Author
-
Busch, Carly A., primary, Nadile, Erika M., additional, Mohammed, Tasneem F., additional, Gin, Logan E., additional, Brownell, Sara E., additional, and Cooper, Katelyn M., additional
- Published
- 2024
- Full Text
- View/download PDF
25. Who is Represented in the Research on Undergraduate Research Experiences in the Natural Sciences? A Review of Literature
- Author
-
Goodwin, Emma C., primary, Gin, Logan E., additional, Aeschliman, Allyson, additional, Afoakwa, Adwoa Kumi, additional, Allred, Bryttani A., additional, Avalle, Sarah T., additional, Bell, Amanda, additional, Berkheimer, Jessica, additional, Brzezinski, Hannah, additional, Campos, Rachel, additional, Emerson, Hozhoo, additional, Hess, Savage Cree, additional, Montelongo, Arron M., additional, Noshirwani, Nereus, additional, Shelton, W. Levi, additional, Valdez, Emma M., additional, White, Jennifer, additional, White, Quinn, additional, Wittekind, Ehren, additional, Cooper, Katelyn M., additional, and Brownell, Sara E., additional
- Published
- 2024
- Full Text
- View/download PDF
26. Perspectives from Undergraduate Life Sciences Faculty: Are We Equipped to Effectively Accommodate Students With Disabilities in Our Classrooms?
- Author
-
Goodwin, Emma C., primary, Pais, Danielle, additional, He, Jingyi, additional, Gin, Logan E., additional, and Brownell, Sara E., additional
- Published
- 2024
- Full Text
- View/download PDF
27. Beyond Gender and Race: The Representation of Concealable Identities Among College Science Instructors at Research Institutions
- Author
-
Busch, Carly A., primary, Araghi, Tala, additional, He, Jingyi, additional, Cooper, Katelyn M., additional, and Brownell, Sara E., additional
- Published
- 2024
- Full Text
- View/download PDF
28. Christianity as a Concealable Stigmatized Identity (CSI) among Biology Graduate Students
- Author
-
Barnes, M. Elizabeth, Maas, Samantha A., Roberts, Julie A., and Brownell, Sara E.
- Abstract
Recent research has begun to explore the experiences of Christian undergraduates and faculty in biology to illuminate reasons for their underrepresentation. In this study, we focused on the experiences of graduate students and explored Christianity as a concealable stigmatized identity (CSI) in the biology community. We constructed interview questions using this CSI framework, which originates in social psychology, to research the experiences of those with stigmatized identities that could be hidden. We analyzed interviews from 33 Christian graduate students who were enrolled in biology programs and found that many Christian graduate students believe the biology community holds strong negative stereotypes against Christians and worry those negative stereotypes will be applied to them as individuals. We found that students conceal their Christian identities to avoid negative stereotypes and reveal their identities to counteract negative stereotypes. Despite these experiences, students recognize their value as boundary spanners between the majority secular scientific community and majority Christian public. Finally, we found that Christian students report that other identities they have, including ethnicity, gender, nationality, and LGBTQ+ identities, can either increase or decrease the relevance of their Christian identities within the biology community.
- Published
- 2021
- Full Text
- View/download PDF
29. Learning from Error Episodes in Dialogue-Videos: The Influence of Prior Knowledge
- Author
-
Ding, Lu, Cooper, Katelyn M., Stephens, Michelle D., Chi, Michelene T. H., and Brownell, Sara E.
- Abstract
In laboratory study environments, dialogue-videos, or videos of a tutor and a tutee solving problems together, have been shown to more effectively improve student learning than monologue-videos, or videos of tutors solving problems alone. Yet, few studies have replicated these findings in the context of authentic university classrooms. Here, we investigate the impact of dialogue-videos, and more specifically the effect of errors made by tutees in dialogue-videos, on student learning in the context of an undergraduate biology course. To understand why, we investigated students' effort spent on watching videos, perceived influence of dialogue-videos, and worksheet completion rates. We found that higher-performing students perceived that they used the dialogue-videos to review content. We also found that higher-performing, but not lower-performing, students learned better from dialogue videos where tutees made errors. We also discuss the complexities of replicating laboratory studies in the classroom and implications of our findings.
- Published
- 2021
- Full Text
- View/download PDF
30. Cultural Capital in Undergraduate Research: An Exploration of How Biology Students Operationalize Knowledge to Access Research Experiences at a Large, Public Research-Intensive Institution
- Author
-
Cooper, Katelyn M., Cala, Jacqueline M., and Brownell, Sara E.
- Abstract
Background: Undergraduate research experiences are becoming essential for pursuing future opportunities in science, but little has been done to identify what factors predict which students get to participate in research and which students do not. In this manuscript, we propose "scientific research capital" and specifically "scientific research cultural capital" as constructs to explain what students may need to know and do in order to successfully engage in an undergraduate research experience. We begin to articulate what comprises one component of scientific research cultural capital, embodied cultural capital, by identifying the knowledge that students may need to have in order to obtain an undergraduate research experience at a large, research-intensive institution where there are many more undergraduates vying for research positions than opportunities available. We interviewed 43 researchers, defined as undergraduates who had participated in research, and 42 non-researchers, defined as undergraduates who were interested in participating in research but had not yet successfully obtained a position, in a biology department at an R1 institution. We analyzed the data using inductive coding. Results: We identified 10 "rules of research" or aspects of scientific research cultural capital that undergraduates reported about finding and securing undergraduate research. We used logistic regression to test whether undergraduate researchers were more likely than non-researchers to know particular rules. Researchers were more likely than non-researchers to know rules about securing research opportunities. Conclusions: Since researchers were more likely than non-researchers to know rules related to securing research, educating students about how to secure research experiences and encouraging faculty to re-examine the criteria they use to admit students into their labs may be a key step in leveling the playing field for students who are vying for research positions. We propose that the construct of scientific research cultural capital can help publicize the hidden curriculum of undergraduate research so that students can more equitably gain access to undergraduate research.
- Published
- 2021
- Full Text
- View/download PDF
31. Relationships between the Religious Backgrounds and Evolution Acceptance of Black and Hispanic Biology Students
- Author
-
Barnes, M. Elizabeth, Supriya, K., Dunlop, Hayley M., Hendrix, Taija M., Sinatra, Gale M., and Brownell, Sara E.
- Abstract
The evolution education experiences of students of color represent an emerging area of research, because past inquiries indicate these students have differential outcomes, such as lower evolution acceptance and severe underrepresentation in evolutionary biology. Religion is often an important support for students of color who are navigating a science, technology, engineering, and mathematics culture that privileges White nonreligious students. For instance, religion helps mitigate the negative effects of racism, but religious students are also more likely to experience conflict when learning evolution. In this nationwide study, we examined the extent to which strong religiosity among students of color can explain their lower evolution acceptance. We surveyed students in 77 college biology courses across 17 states and found that Black/African American students tend to be more religious and less accepting of evolution than any other racial/ethnic identity group and that Hispanic students tend to be slightly more religious and slightly less accepting of evolution than White students. Importantly, we find that religious background is an important factor associated with Black and Hispanic students' lower levels of evolution acceptance. This study suggests that the biology community should become more inclusive of Christian religious students if it wishes to foster inclusive evolution education for Black and Hispanic students.
- Published
- 2020
- Full Text
- View/download PDF
32. Is Active Learning Accessible? Exploring the Process of Providing Accommodations to Students with Disabilities
- Author
-
Gin, Logan E., Guerrero, Frank A., Cooper, Katelyn M., and Brownell, Sara E.
- Abstract
On average, active learning improves student achievement in college science courses, yet may present challenges for students with disabilities. In this essay, we review the history of accommodating students with disabilities in higher education, highlight how active learning may not always be inclusive of college science students with disabilities, and articulate three questions that could guide research as the science community strives to create more inclusive environments for undergraduates with disabilities: (1) To what extent do stakeholders (disability resource center [DRC] directors, instructors, and students) perceive that students with disabilities encounter challenges in active learning? (2) What accommodations, if any, do stakeholders perceive are being provided for students with disabilities in active learning? and (3) What steps can stakeholders take to enhance the experiences of students with disabilities in active learning? To provide an example of how data can be collected to begin to answer these questions, we interviewed 37 DRC directors and reported what challenges they perceive that students with disabilities experience in active learning and the extent to which accommodations are used to alleviate challenges. We conclude the essay with a suite of recommendations to create more inclusive active-learning college science classes for students with disabilities.
- Published
- 2020
- Full Text
- View/download PDF
33. Design and implementation of an asynchronous online course-based undergraduate research experience (CURE) in computational genomics.
- Author
-
Plaisier, Seema B., Alarid, Danielle O., Denning, Joelle A., Brownell, Sara E., Buetow, Kenneth H., Cooper, Katelyn M., and Wilson, Melissa A.
- Subjects
CAREER development ,MEDICAL sciences ,BIOLOGY students ,COMPUTER training ,OVERPRESSURE (Education) ,COMPUTATIONAL biology - Abstract
As genomics technologies advance, there is a growing demand for computational biologists trained for genomics analysis but instructors face significant hurdles in providing formal training in computer programming, statistics, and genomics to biology students. Fully online learners represent a significant and growing community that can contribute to meet this need, but they are frequently excluded from valuable research opportunities which mostly do not offer the flexibility they need. To address these opportunity gaps, we developed an asynchronous course-based undergraduate research experience (CURE) for computational genomics specifically for fully online biology students. We generated custom learning materials and leveraged remotely accessible computational tools to address 2 novel research questions over 2 iterations of the genomics CURE, one testing bioinformatics approaches and one mining cancer genomics data. Here, we present how the instructional team distributed analysis needed to address these questions between students over a 7.5-week CURE and provided concurrent training in biology and statistics, computer programming, and professional development. Scores from identical learning assessments administered before and after completion of each CURE showed significant learning gains across biology and coding course objectives. Open-response progress reports were submitted weekly and identified self-reported adaptive coping strategies for challenges encountered throughout the course. Progress reports identified problems that could be resolved through collaboration with instructors and peers via messaging platforms and virtual meetings. We implemented asynchronous communication using the Slack messaging platform and an asynchronous journal club where students discussed relevant publications using the Perusall social annotation platform. The online genomics CURE resulted in unanticipated positive outcomes, including students voluntarily discussing plans to continue research after the course. These outcomes underscore the effectiveness of this genomics CURE for scientific training, recruitment and student-mentor relationships, and student successes. Asynchronous genomics CUREs can contribute to a more skilled, diverse, and inclusive workforce for the advancement of biomedical science. Author summary: As technology advances, there is a growing demand for research scientists trained in computational biology but it can be difficult to introduce computer programming and statistics to biology students. One way to meet this demand in an inclusive way is to provide more research opportunities for online students, a significant and growing community which includes many groups underrepresented in the science workforce. We present a course designed for fully online undergraduate biology students where they can work asynchronously to address a novel research question. We show how we divided research projects among the students of the class, leveraged remotely accessible computational tools and online messaging platforms, and created custom learning materials and assessments to teach the students the necessary biology, computer programming, and communication skills needed for each research project. We demonstrate that students were able to learn the course objectives and cope with academic stresses. Research can be designed around questions in many topics, so we hope that our design can help others to create remote computational research courses in their field. [ABSTRACT FROM AUTHOR]
- Published
- 2024
- Full Text
- View/download PDF
34. Fourteen Recommendations to Create a More Inclusive Environment for LGBTQ+ Individuals in Academic Biology
- Author
-
Cooper, Katelyn M., Auerbach, Anna Jo J., Bader, Jordan D., Beadles-Bohling, Amy S., Brashears, Jacqueline A., Cline, Erica, Eddy, Sarah L., Elliott, Deanna B., Farley, Elijah, Fuselier, Linda, Heinz, Heather M., Irving, Madison, Josek, Tanya, Lane, A. Kelly, Lo, Stanley M., Maloy, Jeffrey, Nugent, Michelle, Offerdahl, Erika, Palacios-Moreno, Juan, Ramos, Jorge, Reid, Joshua W., Sparks, Rachel A., Waring, Ashley L., Wilton, Mike, Gormally, Cara, and Brownell, Sara E.
- Abstract
Individuals who identify as lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgender, queer, and otherwise nonstraight and/or non-cisgender (LGBTQ+) have often not felt welcome or represented in the biology community. Additionally, biology can present unique challenges for LGBTQ+ students because of the relationship between certain biology topics and their LGBTQ+ identities. Currently, there is no centralized set of guidelines to make biology learning environments more inclusive for LGBTQ+ individuals. Rooted in prior literature and the collective expertise of the authors who identify as members and allies of the LGBTQ+ community, we present a set of actionable recommendations to help biologists, biology educators, and biology education researchers be more inclusive of individuals with LGBTQ+ identities. These recommendations are intended to increase awareness of LGBTQ+ identities and spark conversations about transforming biology learning spaces and the broader academic biology community to become more inclusive of LGBTQ+ individuals.
- Published
- 2020
- Full Text
- View/download PDF
35. Resources for Teaching and Assessing the 'Vision and Change Biology' Core Concepts
- Author
-
Branchaw, Janet L., Pape-Lindstrom, Pamela A., Tanner, Kimberly D., Bissonnette, Sarah A., Cary, Tawnya L., Couch, Brian A., Crowe, Alison J., Knight, Jenny K., Semsar, Katharine, Smith, Julia I., Smith, Michelle K., Summers, Mindi M., Wienhold, Caroline J., Wright, Christian D., and Brownell, Sara E.
- Abstract
The "Vision and Change" report called for the biology community to mobilize around teaching the core concepts of biology. This essay describes a collection of resources developed by several different groups that can be used to respond to the report's call to transform undergraduate education at both the individual course and departmental levels. First, we present two frameworks that help articulate the "Vision and Change" core concepts, the "BioCore Guide" and the Conceptual Elements (CE) Framework, which can be used in mapping the core concepts onto existing curricula and designing new curricula that teach the biology core concepts. Second, we describe how the "BioCore Guide" and the CE Framework can be used alongside the Partnership for Undergraduate Life Sciences Education curricular rubric as a way for departments to self-assess their teaching of the core concepts. Finally, we highlight three sets of instruments that can be used to directly assess student learning of the core concepts: the Biology Card Sorting Task, the Biology Core Concept Instruments, and the Biology-Measuring Achievement and Progression in Science instruments. Approaches to using these resources independently and synergistically are discussed.
- Published
- 2020
- Full Text
- View/download PDF
36. 'Accepting Evolution Means You Can't Believe in God': Atheistic Perceptions of Evolution among College Biology Students
- Author
-
Barnes, M. Elizabeth, Dunlop, Hayley M., Sinatra, Gale M., Hendrix, Taija M., Zheng, Yi, and Brownell, Sara E.
- Abstract
Although many scientists agree that evolution does not make claims about God/god(s), students might assume that evolution is atheistic, and this may lead to lower evolution acceptance. In study 1, we surveyed 1081 college biology students at one university about their religiosity and evolution acceptance and asked what religious ideas someone would have to reject if that person were to accept evolution. Approximately half of students wrote that a person cannot believe in God/religion and accept evolution, indicating that these students may have atheistic perceptions of evolution. Religiosity was not related to whether a student wrote that evolution is atheistic, but writing that evolution is atheistic was associated with lower evolution acceptance among the more religious students. In study 2, we collected data from 1898 students in eight states in the United States using a closed-ended survey. We found that 56.5% of students perceived that evolution is atheistic even when they were given the option to choose an agnostic perception of evolution. Further, among the most religious students, those who thought evolution is atheistic were less accepting of evolution, less comfortable learning evolution, and perceived greater conflict between their personal religious beliefs and evolution than those who thought evolution is agnostic.
- Published
- 2020
- Full Text
- View/download PDF
37. An Exploratory Study of Students with Depression in Undergraduate Research Experiences
- Author
-
Cooper, Katelyn M., Gin, Logan E., Barnes, M. Elizabeth, and Brownell, Sara E.
- Abstract
Depression is a top mental health concern among undergraduates and has been shown to disproportionately affect individuals who are underserved and underrepresented in science. As we aim to create a more inclusive scientific community, we argue that we need to examine the relationship between depression and scientific research. While studies have identified aspects of research that affect graduate student depression, we know of no studies that have explored the relationship between depression and undergraduate research. In this study, we sought to understand how undergraduates' symptoms of depression affect their research experiences and how research affects undergraduates' feelings of depression. We interviewed 35 undergraduate researchers majoring in the life sciences from 12 research-intensive public universities across the United States who identify with having depression. Using inductive and deductive coding, we identified that students' depression affected their motivation and productivity, creativity and risk-taking, engagement and concentration, and self-perception and socializing in undergraduate research experiences. We found that students' social connections, experiencing failure in research, getting help, receiving feedback, and the demands of research affected students' depression. Based on this work, we articulate an initial set of evidence-based recommendations for research mentors to consider in promoting an inclusive research experience for students with depression.
- Published
- 2020
- Full Text
- View/download PDF
38. Fear of Negative Evaluation and Student Anxiety in Community College Active-Learning Science Courses
- Author
-
Downing, Virginia R., Cooper, Katelyn M., Cala, Jacqueline M., Gin, Logan E., and Brownell, Sara E.
- Abstract
Student anxiety is a growing concern for colleges and universities. As science classrooms transition from traditional lecture to active learning, researchers have sought to understand how active learning affects undergraduate anxiety. However, although community colleges educate nearly half of all undergraduates, no studies have explored the relationship between anxiety and active learning in the context of community college science courses. In this study, we interviewed 29 students enrolled across nine community colleges in the southwestern United States to probe factors that increase and decrease their anxiety in active-learning science courses. Using inductive coding, we identified a set of common factors that affect community college student anxiety in active learning. We found that community college student anxiety decreased when students perceived that active-learning activities enhanced their learning by providing them with multiple ways of learning or the opportunity to learn from others. We also identified fear of negative evaluation as the primary construct underlying student anxiety in active learning and described factors that mediated students' fear of negative evaluation in the community college science classroom. This work highlights how instructors can create more inclusive active-learning science classrooms by reducing student anxiety during active-learning instruction.
- Published
- 2020
- Full Text
- View/download PDF
39. Differential Impacts of Religious Cultural Competence on Students' Perceived Conflict with Evolution at an Evangelical University
- Author
-
Barnes, M. Elizabeth, Werner, Ruth, and Brownell, Sara E.
- Abstract
Evolution remains a controversial issue in the United States, particularly for evangelical Christians, who as a group have been a key player in anti-evolution education legislation. Religious cultural competence can be effective in decreasing undergraduate biology students' perceived conflict between religion and evolution. However, the impact on student populations who are particularly resistant to evolution is unknown. We explored the efficacy of culturally competent evolution education practices adapted for biology students in a genetics course at an evangelical Christian university. This included the presence of an instructor as a religious scientist role model who accepts evolution, and the use of the book "The Language of God." We explored how this curriculum affected students' conceptions of religion and evolution using pre- and post-surveys. We found a differential impact of the curriculum: 31% of the students who indicated that there was a conflict between their religious beliefs and evolution changed their conceptions to be more in line with scientific evidence, but the remaining 69% did not. We describe reasons why, including students' perceptions of "The Language of God." This research indicates the challenges of implementing culturally competent evolution education for evangelical students, given their strong commitment to biblical literalism and their lower likelihood of being convinced by scientific evidence for evolution.
- Published
- 2020
- Full Text
- View/download PDF
40. Depression as a Concealable Stigmatized Identity: What Influences Whether Students Conceal or Reveal Their Depression in Undergraduate Research Experiences?
- Author
-
Cooper, Katelyn M., Gin, Logan E., and Brownell, Sara E.
- Abstract
Background: Concealable stigmatized identities (CSIs) are identities that can be kept hidden or invisible and that carry negative stereotypes. Depression is one of the most common CSIs among undergraduates. However, to our knowledge, no studies have explored how students manage depression as a CSI in the context of undergraduate research, a high-impact practice for undergraduate science students. Concealing CSIs can cause psychological distress and revealing CSIs can be beneficial; however, it is unknown whether these findings extend to students with depression in the context of undergraduate research experiences. In this study, we interviewed 35 life sciences majors with depression from 12 research-intensive institutions across the United States who participated in undergraduate research. We sought to understand to what extent students reveal their depression in research and to describe the challenges of concealing depression and the benefits of revealing depression in this specific context. Additionally, we explored whether students knew scientists with depression and how knowing a scientist with depression might affect them. Results: Most students did not reveal their depression in their undergraduate research experiences. Those who did typically revealed it to another undergraduate researcher and few revealed it to a faculty mentor. Students who concealed their depression feared the potential consequences of revealing their identity, such as being treated negatively by others in the lab. Students who revealed their depression highlighted a set of benefits that they experienced after revealing their depression, such as receiving support and flexibility from their research mentor. We found that few students knew a specific scientist with depression. However, students perceived that knowing a scientist with depression would help them realize that they are not the only one experiencing depression in science and that people with depression can be successful in science. Conclusions: This study illustrates that students with depression would benefit from research environments that are supportive of students with depression so that they can feel comfortable revealing their depression if they would like to. We also identified that students may benefit from knowing successful scientists with depression. We hope this study encourages undergraduate research mentors to support students with depression and ultimately reduces the stigma around CSIs such as depression.
- Published
- 2020
- Full Text
- View/download PDF
41. The Impact of Broadly Relevant Novel Discoveries on Student Project Ownership in a Traditional Lab Course Turned CURE
- Author
-
Cooper, Katelyn M., Blattman, Joseph N., Hendrix, Taija, and Brownell, Sara E.
- Abstract
Course-based undergraduate research experiences (CUREs) have been shown to lead to multiple student benefits, but much is unknown about how CUREs lead to specific student outcomes. In this study, we examined the extent to which students making "broadly relevant novel discoveries" impacted student project ownership by comparing the experiences of students in a CURE and a traditional lab course. The CURE and traditional lab were similar in most aspects; students were exposed to an identical curriculum taught by the same instructor. However, there was one major difference between the two types of courses: the type of data that the students produced. Students in the traditional lab characterized the immune system of wild-type mice, thereby confirming results already known to the scientific community, while students in the CURE characterized the immune system of a mutant strain of mice, which produced broadly relevant novel discoveries. Compared with traditional lab students, CURE students reported higher cognitive and emotional ownership over their projects. Students' perceptions of collaboration and making broadly relevant novel discoveries were significantly and positively related to their cognitive and emotional ownership. This work provides insight into the importance of integrating opportunities for broadly relevant novel discoveries in lab courses.
- Published
- 2019
- Full Text
- View/download PDF
42. Student Anxiety and Fear of Negative Evaluation in Active Learning Science Classrooms
- Author
-
Cooper, Katelyn M., Brownell, Sara E., Mintzes, Joel J., editor, and Walter, Emily M., editor
- Published
- 2020
- Full Text
- View/download PDF
43. EvMedEd : A Teaching Resource for Integrating Medical Examples into Evolution Education
- Author
-
GRUNSPAN, DANIEL Z., NESSE, RANDOLPH M., and BROWNELL, SARA E.
- Published
- 2020
44. Diagnosing Differences in What Introductory Biology Students in a Fully Online and an In-Person Biology Degree Program Know and Do Regarding Medical School Admission
- Author
-
Cooper, Katelyn M., Gin, Logan E., and Brownell, Sara E.
- Abstract
Increasingly, institutions of higher education are adopting fully online degree programs to provide students with cost-effective, accessible postsecondary education. A concern these degrees raise is: Will students be prepared for the next step of their career paths after completing their Bachelor's degree online? Biology undergraduates often begin their degrees wanting to become medical doctors, but no studies have explored whether students in a fully online biology degree program are being prepared to be admitted to medical school. In this study, we surveyed Introductory Biology students at one institution who were pursuing Bachelor of Science degrees in Biological Sciences, either in an online or an in-person program. The most prevalent career goal for both in-person students (65.2%) and online students (39.7%) was a medical doctor. Online students were more confident in their intentions to become doctors than their in-person peers. However, online students knew fewer criteria that medical schools consider when admitting students than in-person students [in-person: mean = 3.7 (SD 1.6); online: mean = 2.7 (SD 1.7)] and were less likely to plan to become involved in premedical activities, such as undergraduate research. Finally, compared with in-person students, fewer online students were able to name at least one science student (in-person: 76.7%; online: 9.7%), academic advisor (in-person: 21.3%; online: 6.5%), and faculty member (in-person: 33.7%; online: 6.5%) with whom they could talk about pursuing a career in medicine. This work highlights knowledge gaps between students enrolled in a fully online biology degree and an in-person biology degree that are important for developers of online biology degree programs to understand and rectify to better prepare online biology students for admission to medical school.
- Published
- 2019
- Full Text
- View/download PDF
45. GenBio-MAPS: A Programmatic Assessment to Measure Student Understanding of 'Vision and Change' Core Concepts across General Biology Programs
- Author
-
Couch, Brian A., Wright, Christian D., Freeman, Scott, Knight, Jennifer K., Semsar, Katharine, Smith, Michelle K., Summers, Mindi M., Zheng, Yi, Crowe, Alison J., and Brownell, Sara E.
- Abstract
The "Vision and Change" report provides a nationally agreed upon framework of core concepts that undergraduate biology students should master by graduation. While identifying these concepts was an important first step, departments also need ways to measure the extent to which students understand these concepts. Here, we present the General Biology--Measuring Achievement and Progression in Science (GenBio-MAPS) assessment as a tool to measure student understanding of the core concepts at key time points in a biology degree program. Data from more than 5000 students at 20 institutions reveal that this instrument distinguishes students at different stages of the curriculum, with an upward trend of increased performance at later time points. Despite this trend, we identify several concepts that advanced students find challenging. Linear mixed-effects models reveal that gender, race/ethnicity, English-language status, and first-generation status predict overall performance and that different institutions show distinct performance profiles across time points. GenBio-MAPS represents the first programmatic assessment for general biology programs that spans the breadth of biology and aligns with the "Vision and Change" core concepts. This instrument provides a needed tool to help departments monitor student learning and guide curricular transformation centered on the teaching of core concepts.
- Published
- 2019
- Full Text
- View/download PDF
46. Few LGBTQ+ Science and Engineering Instructors Come Out to Students, Despite Potential Benefits.
- Author
-
Busch, Carly A., Bhanderi, Parth B., Cooper, Katelyn M., and Brownell, Sara E.
- Published
- 2024
- Full Text
- View/download PDF
47. “It's More Of A Me-Thing Than An Evolution Thing”: Exploring The Validity Of Evolution Acceptance Measures Using Student Interviews
- Author
-
Misheva, Taya, primary, Brownell, Sara E., additional, and Barnes, M. Elizabeth, additional
- Published
- 2023
- Full Text
- View/download PDF
48. Reply to Salzer: A rebuttal to “A critical review of conclusions about disclosure of a mental illness on medical school applications”
- Author
-
Brownell, Sara E., primary and Cooper, Katelyn M., additional
- Published
- 2023
- Full Text
- View/download PDF
49. A comparison study of human examples vs. non-human examples in an evolution lesson leads to differential impacts on student learning experiences in an introductory biology course
- Author
-
Grunspan, Daniel Z., Dunk, Ryan D. P., Barnes, M. Elizabeth, Wiles, Jason R., and Brownell, Sara E.
- Published
- 2021
- Full Text
- View/download PDF
50. The Lecture Machine: A Cultural Evolutionary Model of Pedagogy in Higher Education
- Author
-
Grunspan, Daniel Z., Kline, Michelle Ann, and Brownell, Sara E.
- Abstract
The benefits of student-centered active-learning approaches are well established, but this evidence has not directly translated into instructors adopting these evidence-based methods in higher education. To date, promoting and sustaining pedagogical change through different initiatives has proven difficult, but research on pedagogical change is advancing. To this end, we examine pedagogical behaviors through a cultural evolutionary model that stresses the global nature of the issue, the generational time that change requires, and complications introduced by academic career trajectories. We first provide an introduction to cultural evolutionary theory before describing our model, which focuses on how cultural transmission processes and selection events at different career phases shape not only who teaches in higher education, but also how they choose to teach. We leverage our model to make suggestions for expediting change in higher education. This includes reforming pedagogy in departments that produce PhD students with the greatest chance of obtaining tenure-track positions.
- Published
- 2018
- Full Text
- View/download PDF
Catalog
Discovery Service for Jio Institute Digital Library
For full access to our library's resources, please sign in.