Search

In October 1976 a randomized, paired, prospective study comparing the compression sliding hip screw with Ender's pins in the treatment of extracapsular hip fractures was begun on the orthopaedic service at San Francisco General Hospital. The results in 100 patients with a minimum follow-up of six months showed that Ender's procedure required less operative time, had less blood loss, and had a lower postoperative incidence of medical complications. A 26 per cent incidence of technical problems with Ender's pins (such as postoperative backing-out of the pin) required reoperation in 16 per cent of the patients compared with an 8 per cent rate of reoperation in patients treated with the compression screw. The majority of these complications occurred in unstable fractures. There were no deep infections in the patients with Ender's pins but a 6 per cent incidence of deep infection was seen in those with the hip screws. There were no non-unions in either group. Although hip function at follow-up was equal in both groups, there was a 41 per cent incidence of postoperative pain and stiffness of the knee in the group with Ender's pins. It is our opinion that Ender's pins are a valuable addition to the armamentarium of surgeons treating extracapsular fractures of the hip and are ideally suited for elderly patients with stable fractures, particularly if the surgical risk is high. They must be used with caution in unstable fractures and postoperative protection in traction may be necessary. However, the occasional external rotation deformity and the high incidence of problems with the knee makes their use in younger, more active patients less desirable than the compression hip screw unless their unique advantages justify their use.

Desmoid tumors are benign neoplasms, arising from musculoaponeurotic tissues, which tend to be locally infiltrative, resulting in a high rate of local recurrence following surgical resection. Nineteen patients with desmoid tumors underwent radiation therapy at the University of California, San Francisco, between 1970 and 1980. Fifteen patients were referred with local recurrence following one or more surgical resections. Three patients were referred for initial radiation therapy with unresectable tumors, and one patient received planned postoperative irradiation following subtotal tumor resection. At the time of treatment, 8 patients had nonresectable disease measuring greater than 10 cm. Five patients had residual tumor masses measuring 4 to 6 cm, and six had only microscopic disease following resection. The majority of patients were treated to a tumor dose of 50-55 Gy at 1.6 to 1.8 Gy per fraction. With a median follow-up of 8 years, 13 patients remained free of recurrent disease following radiation therapy. The 5 year relapse free survival was 72% with 10 patients continuing to be free of disease 5 to 11 years following therapy. Local control was not related to the amount of disease present at the time of treatment. Of the 6 patients who developed recurrent disease, only 1 patient had a true in-field recurrence. Four patients recurred at the margin of the radiation field 1 to 5 years following therapy. Of these four patients, 3 were successfully salvaged while 1 died as a result of tumor extension into a major vessel. One patient with an extensive mesenteric mass did not respond to therapy and died 1 month post irradiation. The patient with the in-field recurrence and 1 patient with a marginal recurrence were successfully treated with combination chemotherapy. Moderate dose radiation therapy to desmoid tumors can result in lasting local control when surgical resection is not possible. Post operative radiation can improve the rate of local control for patients with a high risk of recurrence. As desmoid tumors tend to be locally infiltrative, fields must be very generous to prevent marginal recurrence. Systemic chemotherapy offers an alternative to ablative surgery in the event of local failure following radiation therapy.

Malignant tumors around fracture fixation implants have been reported sporadically for many years. Recently, however, reports of sarcomatous degeneration around a standard cemented hip arthroplasty and around cobalt-chromium-bearing hip arthroplasties raise new questions of the malignant potential of metallic ends prostheses. Sarcomatous changes around aluminum oxide ceramics seem not to have been reported in the literature. The present report may be the first documented case of an aggressive soft tissue sarcoma detected 15 months after the patient had an uncemented ceramic total hip arthroplasty. If a causal relationship exists, the incidence of this phenomenon in the United States is 250 times greater than would be expected from statistics on soft tissue sarcoma at the hip. Because of the similarity on plane roentgenograms of this tumor to lesions known to be caused by wear debris, tumors should be included in the differential diagnosis of cases of total hip loosening.

The utility of computed tomography (CT) in evaluation of musculoskeletal disorders was assessed in 55 selected patients. CT provided unique information leading to a correct diagnosis in 45% of cases. In 78% the extent of a lesion was more clearly defined than on conventional imaging procedures, and in the same percentage the CT findings were used to plan optimal therapy. CT was most useful in demonstrating absence of a suspected mass lesion and in defining the full extent of a lesion involving the soft tissues.

The value of computed tomography in the diagnosis and management of lesions of the musculoskeletal system is being determined. Illustrative cases including a lipoma of the thigh, osteochondroma of the hip, simple cyst of the ilium, recurrent liposarcoma of the lumbar spine, desmoid tumor in the gluteal region, and postoperative interspace infection of the lumbar spine are presented to indicate the potential value of this procedure in the diagnosis and planning of treatment of musculoskeletal lesions.

In a retrospective review of 119 intracapsular hip fractures treated by the Deyerle method (seventy-nine patients treated at San Francisco General Hospital and forty at Brookside Community Hospital), fifty-nine patients were available for follow-up after two or more years or were rated as failures before that time. In the San Francisco General series the incidence of avascular necrosis was 43 per cent and of non-union, 23 per cent, while in the Brookside series the incidences were 12.5 per cent and 12.5 per cent, respectively. The functional end results in the San Francisco General series were rated excellent or satisfactory in 40 per cent and failures in 60 per cent, and in the Brookside series there were 75 per cent excellent or satisfactory results and 25 per cent failures.

Kenya is a country of marked environmental and ethnic diversity. A study of osteogenic sarcoma occurring in Kenya from 1968 to 1978 revealed 251 cases, representing between 89% and 100% of the predicted number. Variations in age, sex and anatomical location were within classical limits. However, the incidence of osteogenic sarcoma amongst the Central Bantu was significantly higher than predicted (P less than 0.0001), whilst the incidence among the Western Bantu was significantly lower (P less than 0.002), despite their similar ethnic origins. Two geographically dissimilar areas likewise exhibited significant differences in incidence. The Eastern province showed a higher incidence (P less than 0.02), whereas the Nyanza Province (P less than 0.001) and the adjacent Western Province (P less than 0.005) showed a lower than predicted incidence. These observations suggest that in Kenya a geomedical variable affects the incidence of osteogenic sarcoma and that genetic variation has no effect on incidence.

MRI is a complementary technique to CT in the examination of the spine, the hip, and musculoskeletal tumors. In some cases, it provides diagnostic information not available with any other modality, including CT. MRI has the potential to be very useful in the assessment of various marrow-based disorders and may someday obviate the need for contrast-aided studies of ligaments, tendons, and cartilage.

Seventy patients received primary surgical or radiotherapeutic treatment for osteosarcoma at the University of California-San Francisco between 1950 and 1974. Twenty-two received surgery alone and 27 received preoperative irradiation followed at varying intervals by surgery. Twenty-one patients received irradiation alone because of tumor location, refusal of recommended surgery, or development of metastatic disease. The results are analyzed and the role of radiation therapy in the primary management of osteosarcoma is discussed. The authors believe that irradiation without chemotherapy offers little in terms of palliation or enhanced survival in patients who are able to undergo radical surgery.