The blue crab Callinectes sapidus has the potential for sperm to be limiting, with consequent reduction in the life-time fecundity of females. First, females only mate once, at their terminal molt to maturity. Secondly, they rely on sperm stored from that mating to produce multiple broods. Thirdly, the numbers of large male crabs is reduced in blue crab populations that are heavily fished. To investigate sperm limitation, we need to know how much sperm females receive and store. However, methods developed for other species, relying on direct counts of sperm, or spermathecal weight, have not been readily applied to blue crabs. Soon after mating, the seminal fluids transmitted at mating harden into a sperm plug so rubbery that the sperm cannot be separated for direct counting. Over a period of months, the plug is resorbed, and the walls of the spermathecae also lose mass. Thus, the number of sperm may remain constant while spermathecal weight changes ten-fold. We will describe methods that now permit direct counting of sperm in both male and female reproductive tracts at all stages, and reveal substantial variation in numbers of sperm per unit weight of seminal material transferred at mating.