Search

Biotinidase deficiency (BTD) is an autosomal recessive disorder characterized by impaired recycling of the water-soluble vitamin biotin which leads to a spectrum of clinical manifestations ranging from mild to severe, including mainly neurological and cutaneous symptoms. Biotin supplementation is a cornerstone of treatment, but diagnosis often relies on measuring serum enzyme activity, which needs to be confirmed by genetic analysis. Thus, molecular methods become necessary in the differential diagnosis of BTD. Accordingly, countries with a high-incidence have implemented next-generation sequencing (NGS) techniques to newborn screening programs for BT. Nevertheless, NGS platforms, while well-established, present challenges in cost, labor, accessibility, and duration for newborn screening programs targeting BTD, therefore these limitations necessitate the exploration of alternative systems to ensure efficient and widespread screening. Here, third-generation sequencing platforms, notably Oxford Nanopore Technology (ONT), present promising solutions to the associated challenges. Hence, in the present study, we aimed to develop an ONT-based assay for the screening of BTD gene. After designing and optimizing primers for long-PCR using reference DNA, we assessed the performance of the ONT assay in BTD patients previously diagnosed by enzyme assay and confirmed using Illumina-based sequencing. The results demonstrate a strong correlation between the two methods, indicating the reliability of the ONT-based assay. Moreover, this first in-house single gene testing specifically tailored for BTD successfully detected previously known genetic variants with high sequencing depths, affirming the effectiveness of ONT-based sequencing in human genetics., Competing Interests: Declaration of competing interest The authors declare that they have no known competing financial interests or personal relationships that could have appeared to influence the work reported in this paper., (Copyright © 2024 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.)

Background: Biotin is a water-soluble vitamin that plays a key role in carboxylation. The formation of free biotin is impaired in biotinidase deficiency (BD), resulting in impaired biotin-dependent carboxylase functions. Based on the percentage of residual serum enzyme activity, BD is classified as partial and profound., Methods: Retrospective data including gender, age, parental consanguinity, family history, biotinidase activity analyses, type of deficiency (partial-profound), physical examination, treatment, and genotypes were evaluated in patients diagnosed with biotinidase deficiency in a single center in the eastern region of Türkiye. Patients whose biotinidase enzyme activity was below 30% with biallelic variants in the BTD gene were diagnosed as BD., Results: A total of 302 patients were included in the study. Parental consanguinity was present in 135 (44.7%) of them. Two hundred eighty-six (94.7%) were diagnosed by neonatal screening, 14 (4.6%) by family screening and two (0.06%) by clinical symptoms. Ninety-two (30.5%) of the patients were followed-up with profound deficiency and 210 (69.5%) with partial deficiency. A total of 306 variants were detected. Twenty different variants (3 novel - 3 rare) and 31 different genotypes were detected. The 3 most frequently detected variants were c.410G>A (p.Arg137His; 47.3%), c.1270G>C (p.Asp424His; 29.7%), and c.38_44delGCGGCTGinsTCC (p.Cys13Phefs*36; 15.3%). The 3 most frequently identified genotypes were c.410G>A (p.Arg137His) / c.1270G>C (p.Asp424His) compound heterozygous (32.4%), c.410G>A (p.Arg137His) homozygous (24.8%), and c.38_44delGCGGCTGinsTCC (p.Cys13Phefs*36) / c.1270G>C (p.Asp424His) compound heterozygous (12.2%). Patients with c.410G>A (p.Arg137His) homozygous variant, c.38_44delGCGGCTGinsTCC (p.Cys13Phefs*36) homozygous variant and c.38_44delGCGGCTGinsTCC (p.Cys13Phefs*36) / c.410G>A (p.Arg137His) compound heterozygous variant were statistically significantly associated with profound deficiency. Compound heterozygosity of c.410G>A (p.Arg137His) / c.1270G>C (p.Asp424His) variants were significantly associated with partial deficiency., Conclusions: The association between the BTD genotype and biochemical phenotype is not always consistent. Our study provides valuable data by adding variants with genotype-phenotype correlations to the literature and three novel variants, which can provide significant guidance in clinical follow-up., Competing Interests: The authors declare that there is no conflict of interest.

Abstract: A 19-year-old man presented with 3 years of gradually progressive, painless vision loss in both eyes. The ophthalmic examination showed bilateral diminished visual acuity, dyschromatopsia, and temporal optic nerve pallor. The neurological examination was consistent with a mild myelopathy with decreased pin-prick sensation starting at T6-T7 and descending through the lower extremities. Hyperreflexia was also present in the lower more than upper extremities. Infectious, inflammatory, and nutritional serum workup and cerebrospinal fluid analysis were both unrevealing. MRI of the brain and spinal cord showed abnormal T2 hyperintensity of the fornix, corpus callosum, optic nerves, and lateral columns of the cervical and thoracic spine, with diffusion restriction in the inferior-posterior corpus callosum and fornix. Biotinidase serum enzyme activity was tested and showed a decreased level of activity. Biotinidase gene testing showed a homozygous pathogenic variant, c.424C>A (p.P142T), confirming the diagnosis of biotinidase deficiency and prompting oral biotin supplementation. Three months after starting treatment, the patient's visual acuity, color vision, visual fields, and MRI spine abnormalities all improved significantly. Biotinidase deficiency is an important diagnostic consideration in patients with unexplained optic neuropathy and/or myelopathy., Competing Interests: The authors report no conflicts of interest., (Copyright © 2024 by North American Neuro-Ophthalmology Society.)

Background: Biotinidase (BTD, encoded by the BTD gene) deficiency is an autosomal recessive neurometabolic disease caused by abnormal BTD activity in the biotin cycle. The clinical symptoms of patients, which are mainly neurocutaneous, range from mild to severe based on the enzyme activity level. This study aimed to identify BTD gene mutations in suspected BTD deficiency patients for the first time in the southwest of Iran and evaluate their genotype-phenotype correlations., Methods: 11 clinically and biochemically suspected patients from nine unrelated families and their available family members were subjected to Sanger sequencing. Segregation analysis was performed for novel mutation. The effect of each mutation on protein stability and hydropathicity, as well as the pathogenicity prediction of all detected mutations were assessed using various in silico analysis tools., Results: Six mutations including a novel and five previously reported mutations were identified in patients with different ethnicities. Three out of five known mutations were reported for the first time in Iran. Various common clinical manifestations and a rarely reported coexistence of celiac disease in biotinidase deficiency patients were observed. The novel missense variant c.787G > A (p.Glu263Lys) was detected in exon 4 of the BTD gene, within the biotinidase-like domain of the BTD protein. This variation was found in two cousins of a family, both developed the same initial clinical presentation. In silico analyses revealed that this missense substitution decreased protein stability and increased protein hydrophilicity. Additionally, the known frameshift mutation c.1264delG (p.val422serfster59), was the most frequent allele in the studied population. We also predicted and visualized the effects of the novel and frameshift mutations on protein structure., Conclusion: Our findings expanded the mutational spectrum of the BTD gene and provided valuable data on genotype-phenotype correlations, which helps in genetic counseling. Furthermore, the necessity of performing molecular analysis along with enzymatic analysis was highlighted by this study., Competing Interests: Declaration of competing interest The authors declare that they have no known competing financial interests or personal relationships that could have appeared to influence the work reported in this paper., (Copyright © 2024 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.)

Background: Biotinidase deficiency (BD) is a rare, autosomal recessive metabolic disorder characterized by neurocutaneous symptoms. This study investigates a case of profound BD in an Indian infant and the underlying genetic basis., Methods: A 10-month-old male presenting with seizures, hypotonia, ataxia, visual impairments, and developmental delay underwent biochemical and genetic analysis. Biotinidase activity was measured using an ELISA kit. Sanger sequencing of the biotinidase (BTD) gene was performed to identify genetic variations. In silico analysis was employed to assess the potential impact of the identified variants., Results: The infant biotinidase activity was undetectable and its suggest profound biotinidase deficiency. Novel biallelic loss-of-function variations (c.903G > A and c.946 C > T) in the BTD gene were identified, leading to premature stop codons and truncated, non-functional protein fragments., Conclusion: This case expands our knowledge of BD genetic diversity and underscores the critical role of early diagnosis and newborn screening programs in managing this treatable condition., (© 2024. The Author(s), under exclusive licence to Springer Nature B.V.)

Biotinidase deficiency (BTD) is a treatable, inherited metabolic disorder commonly characterised by alopecia, dermatitis, seizures and developmental delay. It can also manifest as optic neuritis and myelitis; however, these are infrequently described in the literature. We report three cases who presented with quadriplegia and vision loss, initially managed as neuromyelitis optica spectrum disorder (NMOSD), based on neuroimaging findings. Two of them initially responded to immune therapy but relapsed after a few months, while one case showed no clinical improvement with immune therapy. The clinical presentation and neuroimaging findings in all three cases were consistent with NMOSD, leading to a delayed diagnosis of BTD. Antiaquaporin4 and antimyelin oligodendrocyte glycoprotein antibodies were negative in all patients. Urine organic acids reported raised markers of biotinidase or holocarboxylase synthase deficiency. Two of them had a dramatic response to biotin supplementation, showing significant improvement in motor function and vision., Competing Interests: Competing interests: None declared., (© BMJ Publishing Group Limited 2024. No commercial re-use. See rights and permissions. Published by BMJ.)

We report a case of a boy in his middle childhood who presented with inspiratory stridor and lactic acidosis and was subsequently diagnosed with partial biotinidase deficiency. Fibreoptic laryngoscope showed paradoxical vocal fold mobility.Partial biotidinase deficiency is an inherited disorder in which the body is unable to recycle the vitamin biotin. It may result in clinical consequences and can be easily treated with biotin but need a high index of suspicion to diagnose. The main symptoms include ataxia, seizures, hypotonia, psychomotor retardation, alopecia, skin rash, progressive deafness, optic atrophy and life-threatening episodes of metabolic acidosis. Laryngeal stridor is an uncommon presentation, but it is reversible in case of biotinidase deficiency. Invasive procedure like tracheostomy has not been shown to enhance outcomes., Competing Interests: Competing interests: None declared., (© BMJ Publishing Group Limited 2024. No commercial re-use. See rights and permissions. Published by BMJ.)

Biotin (vitamin B7, or vitamin H) is a water-soluble B-vitamin that functions as a cofactor for carboxylases, i.e., enzymes involved in the cellular metabolism of fatty acids and amino acids and in gluconeogenesis; moreover, as reported, biotin may be involved in gene regulation. Biotin is not synthesized by human cells, but it is found in food and is also produced by intestinal bacteria. Biotin status/homeostasis in human individuals depends on several factors, including efficiency/deficiency of the enzymes involved in biotin recycling within the human organism (biotinidase, holocarboxylase synthetase), and/or effectiveness of intestinal uptake, which is mainly accomplished through the sodium-dependent multivitamin transporter. In the last years, administration of biotin at high/"pharmacological" doses has been proposed to treat specific defects/deficiencies and human disorders, exhibiting mainly neurological and/or dermatological symptoms and including biotinidase deficiency, holocarboxylase synthetase deficiency, and biotin-thiamine-responsive basal ganglia disease. On the other hand, according to warnings of the Food and Drug Administration, USA, high biotin levels can affect clinical biotin-(strept)avidin assays and thus lead to false results during quantification of critical biomarkers. In this review article, recent findings/advancements that may offer new insight in the abovementioned research fields concerning biotin will be presented and briefly discussed.

Introduction: Biotinidase deficiency (BD) is an inherited autosomal recessive metabolic disorder. BD has been associated with optic nerve atrophy, eye infections, and retinopathy. The most prevalent ophthalmic manifestation of BD is optic atrophy, which might be misdiagnosed as multiple sclerosis or neuromyelitis optica, especially in late-onset BD cases., Methods: In this article, we report a 9-year-old boy with gradual vision loss. Ophthalmologic examination, Brain MRI, and several laboratory tests such as Aquaporin-4 IgG level and biotinidase level were done on the patient., Results: Bilateral optic atrophy and impaired visual acuity were detected on examination. The patient had a biotin level of 1.25 U/min/ml (normal range 3-9 U/min/ml), favoring the BD., Conclusion: In this study, we report a 9-year-old boy with vision loss diagnosed with BD. We also reviewed the literature to highlight the ophthalmic manifestations of BD. Ophthalmologists must consider BD in children with unexplained ophthalmologic complaints, especially when other characteristic signs of BD (e.g., developmental delay, seizure) are present. Also, patients with BD should undergo regular annual ophthalmologic examinations to be checked for any signs of eye involvement.

Biotinidase deficiency (BD) is an autosomal recessive inherited metabolic disorder which results from the inability of biotin-dependent carboxylase enzymes to function due to the release and absorption of biotin, leading to neurological and cutaneous findings. In the present study, evaluation of demographic characteristics, clinical findings, laboratory results, molecular genetic characteristics, and genotype-phenotype correlations of cases with BD. Two hundred forty-seven cases were included in the study who were admitted to the Department of Pediatric Metabolism of Ankara Bilkent City Hospital after being identified with potential BD through the Newborn Screening Program (NBS), during family screening or based on suspicious clinical findings, or following the detection of a pathogenic variant in a BTD genetic analysis during the period of October 2020 and February 2022. The medical files of the cases were reviewed retrospectively. An analysis of the admission routes of all cases to our clinic revealed 89.5% NBS, 5.7% family screening, and 4.9% suspicious clinical findings suggestive of BD. Complete enzyme deficiency was identified in 19.8%, partial enzyme deficiency in 55.1%, and heterogenous enzyme deficiency in 9.7%. The most common pathogenic variants were c.1270G > C (p.Asp424His), c.410G > A (p.Arg137His), and c.38_44delGCGCTGinsTCC (p.Cys13Phefs*36) in BTD gene. The c.1270G > C variant was most common in patients with cutaneous symptoms. The c.410G > A and c.38_44delGCGCTGinsTCC variants were more common in the patients with neurological symptoms. The mean activity level in patients with the c.1270G > C homozygous variant was statistically significantly higher than the mean activity level in the c.1270G > C compound heterozygous patients and the activity level of patients without the c.1270G > C variant. The mean activity level in c.410G > A homozygous patients was statistically significantly lower than the mean activity level of the c.410G > A compound heterozygous patients and the activity level of patients without the c.410G > A variant. In the course of our study, four new pathogenic variants were detected, namely: c.190G > A (p.Glu64Lys), c.249 + 5G > T, c.228delA (p.Val77*), and c.682A > G (p.Ile228Val).     Conclusions: The present study has determined the clinical and genetic spectrum of a large group of patients with BD in a single center. The frequent mutations in our study were similar to those reported in literature, and four novel variants were also described. What is Known: • Biotinidase deficiency is an autosomal recessive, treatable inborn error of metabolism. Two hundred ninety-four pathogenic variants in the BTD gene have been identified and the c.1270G > C variant is the most frequent BTD gene mutation in both Turkey and around the world. What is New: • Four new pathogenic variants (c.190G > A, p.Glu64Lys; c.249 + 5G > T; c.228delA, p.Val77*; and c.682A > G, p.Ile228Val) have been identified. It is believed that the c.38_44delGCGGCTGinsTCC variant is more commonly seen in individuals with ocular issues; however, further genotype-phenotype correlations are needed., (© 2023. The Author(s), under exclusive licence to Springer-Verlag GmbH Germany, part of Springer Nature.)

Background: Biotinidase deficiency is caused by absent activity of the biotinidase, encoded by the biotinidase gene (BTD). Affected individuals cannot recycle the biotin, leading to heterogeneous symptoms that are primarily neurological and cutaneous. Early treatment with biotin supplementation can prevent irreversible neurological damage and is recommended for patients with profound deficiency, defined as enzyme activity <10% mean normal (MN). Molecular testing has been utilized along with biochemical analysis for diagnosis and management. In this study, our objective was to correlate biochemical phenotype/enzyme activity to BTD genotype in patients for whom both enzyme and molecular testing were performed at our lab, and to review how the correlations inform on variant severity., Methods: We analyzed results of biotinidase enzyme analysis and BTD gene sequencing in 407 patients where samples were submitted to our laboratory from 2008 to 2020., Results: We identified 84 BTD variants; the most common was c.1330G>C, and 19/84 were novel BTD variants. A total of 36 patients had enzyme activity <10% of MN and the most common variant found in this group was c.528G>T. No variant was reported in one patient in the profound deficiency group. The most common variant found in patients with enzyme activity more than 10% MN was c.1330G>C., Conclusions: Although enzyme activity alone may be adequate for diagnosing profound biotinidase deficiency, molecular testing is necessary for accurate carrier screening and in cases where the enzyme activity falls in the range where partial deficiency and carrier status cannot be discriminated., (© 2024 Quest Diagnostics. Pediatrics International published by John Wiley & Sons Australia, Ltd on behalf of Japan Pediatric Society.)

Background: Biotinidase deficiency (BTD) is a rare autosomal recessive metabolic disease, which develops neurological symptoms because of the impaired biotin recycling. Pathogenic mutations on BTD gene cause BTD deficiency. The clinical features and mutation analysis of Pakistani children with BTD deficiency have rarely been described. Herein, for the first time, we report the clinical features, BTD gene mutations and biochemical analysis of seven symptomatic children with BTD deficiency from Pakistan., Methods: Seven suspected BTD-deficient patients who presented abnormal organic acid profiles and clinical features were subjected to Sanger sequencing to identify pathogenic mutations in the BTD gene. The results were analyzed by Mutation Surveyor Software., Results: All seven patients exhibited common biotinidase deficiency symptoms including hypotonia, developmental delay and seizures. Biochemical analysis shows marked excretion of 3-hydroxy isovalerate in all cases, followed by 3-hydroxy propionate and methyl citrate. Sanger sequencing revealed one frame-shift mutation, c.98&#95;104delinsTCC (p.Cys33Phefs), and two missense mutations, c.1612C>A (p.Arg538Ser) and c.1330G>C (p.Asp444His). All mutations were in the homozygous state and classified as pathogenic in published studies and mutation databases., Conclusions: This study has validated the BTD variants as the underlying cause of biotinidase deficiency in which molecular testing of BTD is supported by urinary organic acid analysis and clinical diagnosis. Secondly, the strength of the local availability of this test in Pakistan will paved the way for the neonatal screening of biotinidase deficiency., (© 2023 John Wiley & Sons Ltd.)

Objectives: In the present study, we aimed to evaluate the genotype-phenotype relation in patients with biotinidase enzyme deficiency based on repeated biotinidase enzyme measurements., Methods: The hospital file information of patients with biotinidase, enzyme deficiency was assessed retrospectively, and the relationship between the BTD gene mutations analysis results and biotinidase enzyme activity following the first and repeated enzyme activity assessments was analyzed., Results: One-hundred-ten patients were included. In the first enzyme evaluation, profound biotinidase enzyme deficiency was identified in 15 (13.6 %), partial biotinidase enzyme deficiency in 63 (57.3 %), and heterozygous biotinidase enzyme deficiency in 32 (29.1 %) of the patients. The BTD genetic analysis revealed 42 (38.2 %) homozygous, 42 (38.2 %) heterozygous, and 26 (23.6 %) compound heterozygous variants. The most common homozygous variant, p.Asp444His, was evaluated with 130 repeated enzyme measurements and was consistent with a partial biotinidase enzyme deficiency in 55.4 % of cases, heterozygous biotinidase enzyme deficiency in 43.8 % of cases, and profound biotinidase enzyme deficiency in one (0.8 %) case. Clinical symptoms developed in 17 patients during follow-up, of which 70.6 % were related to neurodevelopment. The most common variant was homozygous p.Asp444His (29.4 %) among the patients who developed symptoms., Conclusions: This is the first study to date to evaluate the genotype-phenotype relationship in patients with biotinidase deficiency through repeated measurements of biotinidase enzyme activity. The study reveals that biotinidase enzyme activity alone is inadequate for diagnosing biotinidase enzyme deficiency or evaluating disease severity, as genetic investigations are also required for a definitive diagnosis of biotinidase enzyme deficiency., (© 2023 Walter de Gruyter GmbH, Berlin/Boston.)

This study set out to examine pre-analytical factors affecting the frequency of positive results in newborn screening for biotinidase deficiency. This investigation was prompted by an increase in the annual screen positive rate for biotinidase deficiency in Ontario from 2.65x10 -4 in 2016 to 6.57x10 -4 in 2017. Season and trend decomposition was used to separate seasonality from an underlying trend in the time series of biotindase activity measurements for the period 2014-01-12 to 2019-07-27 (n = 798,770). This analysis revealed a marked seasonal effect (winter = median + ⩽ 17 MRU, summer = mean - ⩽20 MRU) and a non-linear negative trend. Seasonal temperature was correlated with biotinidase results (Pearson's r = 0.79) but not with the observed negative trend (Pearson's r = 0.0025). Time series analysis of biotinidase results grouped by print lot of filter paper revealed that recently printed filter paper cards inhibit biotinidase and that this inhibition resolved over time. This study demonstrates that biotindase activity is inhibited by both increased seasonal temperature and collection on newly printed filter cards., Competing Interests: Declaration of Competing Interest The authors declare that they have no known competing financial interests or personal relationships that could have appeared to influence the work reported in this paper., (Copyright © 2022. Published by Elsevier Inc.)

Objectives: This study aimed to investigate the clinical, demographic and laboratory characteristics of the patients referred with a preliminary diagnosis of biotinidase deficiency through the national newborn metabolic screening program. We also attempted to determine the cut-off level of the fluorometric method used for screening biotinidase deficiency by the Ministry of Health., Methods: A total of 700 subjects who were referred to the Pediatric Metabolism Outpatient Clinic with a preliminary diagnosis of biotinidase deficiency through the national newborn metabolic screening program were retrospectively evaluated. Patients detected by family screening were excluded. Biotinidase enzyme activity was assessed and BTD gene analysis was performed in all patients., Results: Of 700 subjects who were referred by the screening program, 284 (40.5 %) had biotinidase deficiency (BD). The enzyme activity was 0-10, 10-30 and >30 % in 39 (5.5 %), 245 (35 %) and 416 (59.5 %) patients, respectively. The BD was partial in majority of patients (86.2 %). The cut-off level was 59.5 MRU for partial BD and 50.5 MRU for profound BD. The most common mutation detected was p.Arg157His (c.470G>A) among patients with profound BD, and p.D444H (c.1330G>C) among patients with partial BD., Conclusions: Treatment should be initiated promptly in patients who are referred by the newborn screening program. Any mean activity under 59.5 MRU should be considered partial BD, while less than 50.5 MRU should be considered profound BD. It should be kept in mind that clinical manifestations may develop both in profound and partial BD., (© 2023 Walter de Gruyter GmbH, Berlin/Boston.)

Background: Biotinidase deficiency (BD) is an autosomal recessively inherited disorder that was first described in 1982. Forty years after its first description, we compiled available clinical data on BD with the aim of generating a more comprehensive picture of this condition., Methods: A systematic search strategy was performed in relevant databases without limits for publication date or languages. We screened 3966 records and included 144 articles reporting individuals with BD and their clinical presentation as well as the outcomes, when available., Results: This study included 1113 individuals with BD. More than half (51.5%) of these individuals were diagnosed by newborn screening, 43.3% in presence of clinical symptoms and 5.2% due to family screening. We grouped symptomatic individuals into four main clinical presentations: neonatal-onset (<1 month; 7.9%), early childhood-onset (<2 years; 59.2%), juvenile-onset (2-16 years; 25.1%) and adult-onset (>16 years; 7.7%). BD affected five main organ systems: nervous system (67.2%), skin (53.7%), eye (34.4%), auditory (26.9%) and respiratory system (17.8%). Involvement was mainly multisystemic (82.2%) of individuals, whereas isolated system presentation was seen in only 17.2% of individuals. When reported, metabolic acidosis was present in 42.4% of symptomatic individuals and characteristic abnormal organic acid metabolites were found in 57.1%. Biotin treatment led to clinical stability or improvement in 89.2% of individuals. 1.6% of reported individuals with BD died due to non-availability of treatment or late diagnosis., Conclusion: Newborn screening has had a major positive impact on the outcome of many individuals with BD. However, undiagnosed and non-treated BD remains a health concern. Given the risk of mortality or complications associated with late or missed diagnosis if newborn screening is not available, a trial of biotin should be considered in undiagnosed infants and adults exhibiting suspected clinical signs. Enzymatic activity and/or analysis of genetic variants can readily confirm the diagnosis of BD., Competing Interests: Declaration of Competing Interest The authors declare no competing interests., (Copyright © 2023 The Authors. Published by Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.)

Biotinidase deficiency (BD) is an autosomal recessive inherited disorder in which the enzyme biotinidase is totally or partially defective and the vitamin biotin is not recycled. BD meets the major criteria for a population screening program. Newborn bloodspot screening (NBS) allows early diagnosis of BD, thus preventing the high morbidity and mortality associated with untreated disease. Both profound and partial BD variant can be detected by NBS test, and serum enzyme activity and/or mutational analysis are required for definitive diagnosis. In Italy, BD is included in the screening panel for inborn errors of metabolism (IEMs) that has been declared mandatory in 2016. We analyzed the data of the first 3 years of the NBS for BD in our region (Abruzzo, Italy), with the aim to describe the outcomes of this recently introduced screening program. In over 26,393 newborns screened, we found 2 carriers and 16 cases with genotype associated with partial BD. Since the serum biotinidase assay has been recently introduced in our algorithm, only three of our newborns met the criteria of genetic and biochemical confirmation, with an incidence of 1:8797, which is in the high range of what has been reported in the literature. All affected infants carried the 1330G>C (D444H) variant in compound heterozygosis, with variants known to be associated with profound BD. A variant previously not described and likely pathogenic was found in one newborn. None of the infants had signs or symptoms. The study of the distribution of the enzyme activity in our population allowed us to validate the adopted cutoff with which the program has a positive predictive value of 18% and to analyze some preanalytical factors influencing biotinidase activity: A correlation of the enzyme activity with gestational age and time at specimen collection was found. Lower mean values of enzyme activity were found in infants born in the summer.

Biotinidase deficiency (BD) is an autosomal recessive disorder caused by bi-allelic mutation in the BTD gene. Clinical manifestations in BD mainly depends on residual biotinidase enzyme activity, although there are some exceptions. Broadly BD disorders are classified as profound BD and partial BD. Further profound BD can be early onset, late onset, and sometimes may be asymptomatic. Clinically late-onset profound BD can present with spectrum of manifestations ranging from single organ to multiple organ involvement, typically affecting function of brain, eye, ear, and skin. Here, a first-born child to consanguineous parents with late-onset profound BD presenting with hyperventilation secondary to lactic acidosis, hypotonia, evolving spasticity, and abnormal neuroimaging findings caused by novel homozygous variant, c.466-3T>G in the BTD gene is reported., (© 2021. Dr. K C Chaudhuri Foundation.)

Deficiency of the biotinidase (BTD) enzyme is an inborn error of biotin metabolism caused by biallelic pathogenic variants in the BTD gene. There are two forms, partial and profound BTD deficiency, which both can be successfully treated with pharmacological doses of biotin, justifying the inclusion of this disorder in the newborn screening in numerous countries. We investigated the BTD deficiency cohort (N = 87) in our metabolic center, as it was detected upon newborn screening since 2005, and aimed to better understand the long-term course of BTD enzyme activity and how it may relate to the patients' genetic background. We observed that individuals with partial BTD deficiency display an elevation of BTD enzyme activity with increasing age in 48% of cases-a recovery which allowed adjustment or stop of biotin supplementation in 20% of all individuals. In addition, we were able to recruit 56 patients (64%) for genetic testing, revealing 19 different variants (2 novel), and constituting 22 different genotypes. Genotype-phenotype correlations revealed that the most abundant allele in our cohort p.(Asp444His) was also the most common variant in patients displaying recovery of BTD enzyme activity. Based on our results, we recommend to retest all patients with partial BTD deficiency at the age of 5 years, as this may result in an impact on therapy. Moreover, genetic testing of BTD deficient individuals can allow prediction of the severity of BTD deficiency and of the likelihood of BTD enzyme activity recovery with age., (© 2022 The Authors. Journal of Inherited Metabolic Disease published by John Wiley & Sons Ltd on behalf of SSIEM.)

Biotinidase deficiency (BD) is a rare autosomal recessive metabolic disease. Previously the disease was identified only by clinical signs and symptoms, and since recently, it has been included in newborn screening programs (NBS) worldwide, though not commonly. In Europe, BD prevalence varies highly among different countries, e.g., from 1:7 116 in Turkey to 1:75 842 in Switzerland. This paper aimed to present the molecular spectrum of BD (profound and partial forms) in Polish patients diagnosed within the national NBS of 1,071,463 newborns. The initial suspicion of BD was based on an abnormal biotinidase activity result determined in a dry blood spot (DBS) by colorimetric and by fluorimetric methods while biochemical verification was determined by serum biotinidase activity (as quantitative analysis). The final diagnosis of BD was established by serum enzyme activity and the BTD gene direct sequencing. The obtained results allowed for the estimation of disease prevalence (1:66,966 births, while 1:178,577 for profound and 1:107,146 for partial forms), and gave novel data on the molecular etiology of BD.

Background: Phenylketonuria (PKU) and biotinidase deficiency (BD) are autosomal recessive diseases. If they are not identified and treated early, severe intellectual disability and developmental delay occur. This study was conducted to calculate the ten-year incidence of PKU and BD in the Diyarbakır province of Turkey., Methods: This cross-sectional study included patients born between 2011-2020 and diagnosed with PKU and BD. Patients with a clear diagnosis had their records evaluated retrospectively., Results: Between 2011 and 2020, blood was taken from 417,525 newborns` heels in Diyarbakir province. As a result of further diagnostic testing, 53 PKU (Incidence: 1:7878) and 177 BD (Incidence: 1:2359) were detected. Of the patients with BD, 56% had profound BD and 44% had partial BD. The records of a total of 269 patients (PKU: 25; BD: 123; Hyperphenylalaninemia: 121) were examined. Parents of 65% (n=15) of the patients diagnosed with PKU and 46.6% (n=55) of the patients diagnosed with BD were consanguineous., Conclusions: The incidence of both PKU and BD was found to be high in our region. The high number of consanguineous marriages was regarded as the most important explanation for the high frequency of these illnesses.

Objective: To determine the reference interval of biotinidase activity in healthy neonates., Methods: The cross-sectional study was conducted at the Department of Chemical Pathology and Endocrinology, Armed Forces Institute of Pathology, Rawalpindi, Pakistan, from May to November 2019, and comprised blood samples collected from healthy neonates aged 2-6 days. The samples were collected on filter paper and analysed on genetic screening processor based on dissociation-enhanced lanthanide flouroimmunoassay. Data was analysed using SPSS 21., Results: Of the 120 dried blood spot specimens, 81(67.5%) were from male babies and 39(32.5%) from female babies. Reference interval for biotinidase activity, based on 2.5th and 97.5th percentiles, was from 3.0 to 11.0 nmol/ml/min., Conclusions: Screening of newborns for biotinidase deficiency is crucial to prevent irreversible neurological damage.

Objectives: Hypotonia, lethargy, eczema, alopecia, conjunctivitis, ataxia, hearing loss, optic atrophy, cognitive retardation, and seizures can occur in patients with biotinidase deficiency, and it is inherited as autosomal recessive. The aim of this study was to evaluate the cases followed up with the diagnosis of biotinidase deficiency in our unit, in terms of clinical, biochemical and genetic analyses., Methods: A total of 112 cases followed up in our centre with the diagnosis of biotinidase deficiency between August 2018-September 2020 were included in the study. Data were collected retrospectively., Results: A total of 112 cases (55.4% male, mean age: 2.2 ± 2.8 years) diagnosed with biotinidase deficiency were evaluated. Diagnoses were made by newborn screening in 90.2% of the cases, by family screening in 4.5%, and by investigating symptoms in 5.4%. The most frequently (27.5%) detected mutations were c.1330G>C (p.D444H)/c.1330G>C (p.D444H) homozygous mutation, followed by (13.0%) c.1330G>C (p.D444H)/c.470G>A (p.R157H) compound heterozygous mutation, and (13.0%) c.470G>A (p.R157H)/c.470G>A (p.R157H) homozygous mutation. Biotinidase enzyme levels were found to be higher in patients with the p.D444H homozygous mutation than patients with other mutations. Biotin treatment was started in all patients with enzyme deficiency., Conclusions: Since the treatment is inexpensive and easily available, it is vital to detect this disease before symptom onset, especially findings related to the central nervous system, hearing and vision loss. In patients diagnosed with enzyme deficiency, the diagnosis should be definitively confirmed by genetic analysis., (© 2021 Walter de Gruyter GmbH, Berlin/Boston.)

Objective: To identify the biotinidase (BTD) gene mutations in patients with biotinidase deficiency in our region; and to determine the phenotype-genotype correlations in the presence of clinical findings., Study Design: Descriptive study., Place and Duration of Study: Department of Medical Genetics and Pediatric Metabolism Outpatient Clinic, Faculty of Medicine, Harran University, between January 2018 and June 2020., Methodology: Two hundred and nine patients, who were found positive for biotinidase deficiency in heel blood screening, were included. Genomic DNA was isolated from peripheral blood. Next-generation DNA sequencing analysis was performed using primers covering the exon regions of the BTD gene. The results were analysed by the mutation surveyor programme., Results: The most common mutation was c.1330 G>C (p.D444H) and the second most common mutation was c.470 G>A (p.R157H). The majority of the mutations are missense; and they are especially located in the exon 4. The most frequent mutations were found to be D444H and R157H with a rate of 66.66% in symptomatic patients., Conclusion: Common mutations in BTD deficiencies were indentified. Associating them with phenotype-genotype data will assist clinicians in better genetic counselling and management in the future by implementing prevention programmes. Key Words: Biotinidase deficiency, BTD gene, Newborn screening, Inherited metabolic disease, Newborn screening programme.

Background: The aim of this study was to evaluate the clinical, biochemical, and molecular analysis of Pakistani patients with biotinidase deficiency (BD)., Methods: Medical charts, urine organic acid (UOA) chromatograms, and biotinidase (BTD) enzyme activity of 113 suspected BD cases and BTD gene results of BTD enzyme deficient patients presenting at the Biochemical Genetics Clinic, AKUH from January 2010 to December 2019 were reviewed. Details were collected on a prestructured questionnaire. SPSS 22 was used for data analysis., Results: BD was found in 33 (29.23%) cases, 28 being profound and 5 partial BD. The median age of BD diagnosis was 171 days (IQR: 81 - 1,022.75) and 300 days (IQR: 25 - 1,540) for the profound and partial BD, respectively. The median BTD levels in the partial BD and profound BD groups were 35 U (IQR: 25.5 - 62.5) and 15 U (IQR: 11 - 17), respectively. UOA analysis exhibited sensitivity, specificity, and agreement of 52.94%, 86.05%, and 76.67% with BTD enzyme activity. The BTD sequencing revealed seven recurrent homozygous single nucleotide variants (SNVs) and small indels. These variants include three frameshift, protein truncating variants and four missense variants. We report two novel protein truncating variants, c.929GinsA, p.S310fs*14 and c.394insA, p.T132Nfs*30 and one missense variant, c.416G>A, p.S139N that had not been reported in BD associated literature and clinical databases., Conclusions: Thirty-three cases of BD from a single center indicates a high frequency of BD in Pakistan. Late diagnosis emphasizes the need for increased clinical awareness and preferably screening for BD in this population.

Biotinidase deficiency (BD) may cause neurological symptoms and developmental problems. However, newborn screening of BD and early biotin treatment prevent the manifestation of the majority of symptoms. This study intended to examine the developmental and behavioral outcomes as well as maternal anxiety and depressive symptoms of preschool-aged children with BD and to compare these with the outcomes of healthy preschool-aged children. In total, 49 children with BD and 23 healthy children are included. All children were screened for developmental and behavioral problems. Moreover anxiety and depressive symptomatology of their mothers were evaluated. Despite the high percentage of developmental delay in BD group, the numbers of children screened positive for a developmental delay were statistically similar in children with BD and healthy children. Among patients with BD, children with risk of developmental delay had more unfavorable socio-demographic features compared to typically developing ones. Behavioral problem scores, maternal anxiety, and depressive symptoms scores of children with BD were not higher than the healthy children.Conclusion: Children with BD were not different from their healthy peers in terms of developmental and behavioral outcomes. Developmental problems of children with BD may be related to the unfavorable socio-demographic features, not the BD itself. What is known: • Biotinidase deficiency (BD) may result in neurological symptoms and developmental problems. • Newborn screening and early biotin supplementation prevent the manifestation of the majority of symptoms. What is new: • Preschool-aged children with BD identified by newborn screening are not different from their healthy peers in terms of developmental and behavioral outcomes. • Maternal anxiety and depressive symptoms scores of children with BD are similar to scores of healthy children.

Neonatal screening for biotinidase deficiency is still lacking in several countries worldwide, although this neurocutaneous disorder is treatable and preventable. Therefore, unscreened patients are diagnosed when symptomatic; treatment with Biotin is known to reverse cutaneous symptoms and improve neurological outcome. We describe a series of five symptomatic patients diagnosed with profound biotinidase deficiency and followed at a tertiary care center in Lebanon, for a variable period from 16 months to 11 years. Adjustment of Biotin therapy is correlated to clinical response and biochemical profile including 3-hydroxyisovalerylcarnitine on dried blood spots and urine organic acids. A previously unreported mutation is also reported in a patient who displayed an unusual outcome with reversible hearing loss on Biotin therapy. Clinical responsiveness to Biotin may be related to the underlying genetic mutation, although no clear genotype-phenotype correlation in biotinidase deficiency is proven. Furthermore, in the absence of systematic newborn screening for this disorder in several countries, identification of a reliable blood biomarker of Biotin responsiveness is warranted for better management of late diagnosed symptomatic patients., (Copyright © 2020 The Canadian Society of Clinical Chemists. Published by Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.)

Objectives: Biotinidase Deficiency (BD) is an autosomal recessive metabolic disorder. However, the relationship between genotype and biochemical phenotype has not been completely elucidated yet. But still, some mutations are accepted to be associated with profound or partial deficiency. We aimed to evaluate the results of biochemical enzyme activity in accordance with the presence of genetic mutations and investigate the correlation between genotype and biochemical phenotype together in the study., Methods: This retrospective study was carried out using data from medical records of 133 infants detected by the newborn screening followed by serum biotinidase activity (BA) detection with semi-quantitative colorimetric method. Mutation analysis was performed to confirm the diagnosis. In addition, the expected biochemical phenotype based on the known mutant alleles were compared with the observed biochemical phenotype., Results: When confirmed with mutation analysis results, the diagnostic sensitivity and specificity of serum BA with spectrophotometric method was 93.1% and 95.1%, respectively. In 93.98% of the cases conformity was observed between the biochemical phenotype and the genotype. The c.1330 G>C(p.D444H) and c.470 G>A (p.Arg157His) were the most common allelic variants with frequencies of 63.69% and 33.75%, respectively., Conclusions: The diagnostic test is supposed to have a high sensitivity to identify asymptomatic BD patients. Apparently healthy cases with almost normal enzyme activity and a variant allele in the genetic analysis were reported to present symptoms under stress conditions, which should be kept in mind. This study can be accepted as an informative report as it may contribute to the literature in terms of the allelic frequency and determination of the relation between genotype and biochemical phenotype. Also, method verification including the assessment of possible effects of non-genetic factors on BA according to the certain mutation types is warranted., (© 2020 Walter de Gruyter GmbH, Berlin/Boston.)

Objective: The prevalence of biotinidase deficiency and the frequency of biotinidase gene variants in Brazil are not documented. We aimed to determine the incidence of partial and profound biotinidase deficiency in the state of Minas Gerais, Brazil, and to calculate the frequency of biotinidase gene variants in the newborn screening program of Minas Gerais., Methods: Neonates (1,168,385) were screened from May 2013 to June 2018. Those detected with abnormal biotinidase activity based on semi-quantitative assays underwent confirmatory serum tests. The biotinidase gene was sequenced in all confirmed cases., Results: The combined incidence of partial and profound biotinidase deficiency was estimated at 1:13,909 live births (95% confidence limit 1:11,235-1:17,217), much higher than the incidence rates reported in other populations worldwide. The most frequent biotinidase gene variants were p.D444H (allele frequency, 0.016), haplotype c.1330G>C;c.511G>A (p.D444H;A171T), p.D543E, c.310-15delT (intronic), p.V199M, and p.H485Q. Together these accounted for 74.6% of the alleles analysed., Conclusion: Newborn screening for biotinidase deficiency, which revealed a higher incidence in Minas Gerais, is feasible and plays a critical role in the early identification of affected neonates and prevention of symptoms and irreversible sequelae. Biotinidase gene sequencing is a useful tool to confirm the diagnosis, and also provides valuable information about genetic variability among different populations.

We present a case of biotinidase deficiency mimicking neuromyelitis optica spectrum disorder (NMOSD) with tetraparesis and transverse myelitis, who was diagnosed with profound biotinidase deficiency after developing optic atrophy and hearing loss before the age of one year, and was untreated for six months. Biotinidase deficiency should be considered in the differential diagnosis of seronegative NMOSD., (Copyright © 2020 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.)

Biotinidase deficiency is a rare hereditary metabolic disease. Only a few cases have been reported in China, almost all of which have been in the pediatric population. We report a case of a girl with characteristic skin and hair findings with a negative family history, although her grandparents were consanguineous. The metabolites in the proband's blood and urine increased prominently, and the percentage of biotinase was 1.168%, much lower than normal. Genotyping identified two heterozygous mutations, which were C.1457T>A (p.L486Q) and C.1491dupT (p.L498Ffs*13) in the BTD gene. The diagnosis of biotinidase deficiency was established. No relevant reports about the missense mutation at the mutation site C.1457T>A (p.L486Q) of the BTD gene have been retrieved. Biotin replacement therapy was administered in the dose of 20 mg/d. The dermatitis subsided after 1 month, and the hair color was almost normal after 3 months. This reminds dermatologists to include biotinidase deficiency in their clinical differential when faced with children's intractable dermatitis, yellow hair, and alopecia., (Copyright © 2020 Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.)

Background: Biotinidase deficiency is an autosomal recessive inherited inborn error of biotin metabolism. Biotin as a water-soluble vitamin is the prosthetic group of biotin-dependent carboxylase enzymes, and by enhancing their function plays a key role in amino acid catabolism, fatty acid synthesis, and gluconeogenesis. Beyond its prosthetic group role, it has been recognized that biotin regulates the level of gene transcription in the eukaryotic cells, therefore any defect in these pathways causes a multisystem metabolic disorder characterized by neurological and cutaneous symptoms., Methods and Results: We report the identification of a novel pathogenic variant in the BTD gene, c.528&#95;542del15 (p.Asn197&#95;Ser201del, UniProt P43251-1) in an Iranian consanguineous family with a severe form of the disease. The segregation analysis in the family was consistent with phenotype and the identified variant was predicated as a pathogenic mutation by the in-silico prediction tools. Computer structural modeling suggests the deleted amino acid residues are located near the biotinidase active site and disrupt the special conformations which are critical for the enzyme activity, and also N-glycosylation., Conclusions: This study further expands the mutation spectrum of the BTD gene underlying cause of profound biotinidase deficiency.

Introduction: Biotinidase deficiency is an inherited disorder of biotin metabolism that is untreated may present within the first few month of life., Objective: We report the exceptional observation of a biotinidase deficiency in Morocco. The rarity of this pathology, its age of onset, its mode of revelation and the lack of treatment in Morocco make the particularity of this observation., Observation: A newborn child born from a 24-year-old mother, followed by an estimated pregnancy of 37 weeks of amenorrhea according to the Farr score (morphological maturation score used for the dating of the pregnancy term). The infant presented at 7 days of life with a cutaneous-mucous eruption with icithiosic dry erythroderma of interest to the trunk, the face, the scalp associated with alopecia and depilation of the eyebrow. The biotinoidase deficiency was confirmed by its low serum concentration at 49 nka / l. The newborn died at 20 days of life before starting the specific treatment., Conclusion: Biotinidase deficiency is a rare condition requiring early screening and rapid management. The delay in diagnosis and the unavailability of treatment in Morocco can have fatal consequences.

Biotinidase deficiency is an autosomal recessive inherited metabolic disorder caused by mutations in the BTD gene. Clinical manifestations can be treated and effectively prevented with pharmacological doses of biotin. Nine novel mutations in BTD are reported in 14 children diagnosed by the newborn screening program in Minas Gerais, Brazil, from June 2013 to December 2017. Serum BTD enzyme activity was determined for all cases and some parents. Two of the mutations are deletions and seven missense mutations located in the exonic region of the BTD gene, mostly in exon 4. Two newborns were profoundly biotinidase-deficient (one homozygous p.A534V [c.1601C > T] and another, double heterozygous for a novel mutation p.R211S [c.631C > A] co-inherited with an already described mutation p.T532 M [c.1595C > T]). Two mutations were associated with a partial deficiency of biotinidase (p.F361 V [c.1081 T > G] in two homozygous children, and p.S311 T [c.932G > C] in a compound heterozygous child who co-inherited a known severe mutation p.Y438X [c.1314 T > A]). The remaining five mutations were found in compound heterozygous children. Hence, a definitive conclusion about the degree of biotinidase deficiency is not possible yet. These results emphasize the importance of sequencing the BTD gene as an important tool to gain a better understanding of the correlation between biochemical phenotype and genotype., (© 2019 Wiley Periodicals, Inc.)

Background: Multiple sclerosis is a disorder of the central and peripheral nervous system of young and old adults that is characterized by muscle, coordination and vision abnormalities. Multiple sclerosis is likely due to numerous causes., Methods: Recently, adolescents and adults with ophthalmological and or neurological findings have been diagnosed with biotinidase deficiency. These individuals have exhibited myelopathy, paresis and/or spastic diplegia/tetraplegia with or without optic neuropathy/vision loss. These older individuals with biotinidase deficiency were considered initially to have multiple sclerosis or similar disorders before they were determined to have biotinidase deficiency., Results: If a symptomatic individual with biotinidase deficiency is treated with biotin early enough, the symptoms markedly improve or completely resolve, but if treatment is delayed, the symptoms may be irreversible., Conclusion: Therefore, although biotinidase deficiency is rare relative to that of multiple sclerosis, the disorder should be included in the differential diagnosis of individuals thought to have multiple sclerosis or related disorders. Biotinidase deficiency should be considered in individuals thought to have multiple sclerosis or related disorders., (Copyright © 2018 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.)

Background Biotinidase deficiency (BD) is an autosomal recessively inherited disorder of biotin recycling. It is classified into two levels based on the biotinidase enzyme activity: partial deficiency (10%-30% enzyme activity) and profound deficiency (0%-10% enzyme activity). The aims of this study were to evaluate our patients with BD, identify the spectrum of biotinidase (BTD) gene mutations in Turkish patients and to determine the clinical and laboratory findings of our patients and their follow-up period. Methods A total of 259 patients who were diagnosed with BD were enrolled in the study. One hundred and forty-eight patients were male (57.1%), and 111 patients were female (42.9%). Results The number of patients detected by newborn screening was 221 (85.3%). By family screening, 31 (12%) patients were diagnosed with BD. Seven patients (2.7%) had different initial complaints and were diagnosed with BD. Partial BD was detected in 186 (71.8%) patients, and the profound deficiency was detected in 73 (28.2%) patients. Most of our patients were asymptomatic. The most commonly found variants were p.D444H, p.R157H, c.98&#95;104delinsTCC. The novel mutations which were detected in this study are p.D401N(c.1201G>A), p.A82G (c.245C>G), p.F128S(c.383T>C), c617&#95;619del/TTG (p.Val207del), p.A287T(c.859G>A), p.S491H(c.1471A>G). The most common mutation was p.R157H in profound BD and p.D444H in partial BD. All diagnosed patients were treated with biotin. Conclusions The diagnosis of BD should be based on plasma biotinidase activity and molecular analysis. We determined the clinical and genetic spectra of a large group of patients with BD from Western Turkey. The frequent mutations in our study were similar to the literature. In this study, six novel mutations were described.

All States screen for biotinidase deficiency and galactosemia, and X-linked adrenoleukodystrophy (X-ALD) has recently been added to the Recommended Uniform Screening Panel (RUSP).We sought to consolidate these tests by combining them into a single multiplex tandem mass spectrometry assay as well as to improve the current protocol for newborn screening of galactosemia.A 3 mm punch of a dried blood spot (DBS) was extracted with organic solvent for analysis of the C26:0-lysophosphatidylcholine biomarker for X-ALD.An additional punch was used to assay galactose-1-phosphate uridyltransferase (GALT) and biotinidase.All assays were combined for a single injection for analysis by liquid chromatography-tandem mass spectrometry (LC-MS/MS) (2.3 min per sample).The GALT LC-MS/MS assay does not give a false positive for galactosemia if glucose-6-phosphate dehydrogenase is deficient.The multiplex assay shows acceptable reproducibility and provides for rapid analysis of X-ALD, biotinidase deficiency, and galactosemia.The throughput and ease of sample preparation are acceptable for newborn screening laboratories.We also show that the LC-MS/MS assay is expandable to include several other diseases including Pompe and Hurler diseases (enzymatic activities and biomarkers).Because of consolidation of assays, less manpower is needed compared to running individual assays on separate platforms.The flexibility of the LC-MS/MS platform allows each newborn screening laboratory to analyze the set of diseases offered in their panel., (Copyright © 2018 Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.)