1. The <italic>Place</italic> of Reduction in Aristotle's <italic>Prior Analytic</italic>s.
- Author
-
Boger, George
- Abstract
Studies of Aristotle’s syllogistic system, since Corcoran’s deductionist interpretation supplanted Łukasiewicz’ axiomaticist interpretation, misrepresent Aristotle’s logic in two important respects. Following Corcoran, they take indirect deduction to occur only once in a deduction discourse; they then obviate the system having a
reductio rule. Second, they representreduction as a deductive process for deriving ‘imperfect’ syllogisms from ‘perfect’ syllogisms to impose an axiomatic interpretation on the logic. Denying that Aristotle's logic admits of areductio rule results from this misrepresentation of reduction. This discussion shows that the defects imputed to Aristotle's logic, and systems devised to resolve them, result from misunderstanding reduction, which itself results from misapprehendingPrior Analytics expressly to identify in a metadiscourse deduction rules and not deductions per se. [ABSTRACT FROM AUTHOR]- Published
- 2024
- Full Text
- View/download PDF