1. Performance of Anti–Topoisomerase I Antibody Testing by Multiple-Bead, Enzyme-Linked Immunosorbent Assay and Immunodiffusion in a University Setting
- Author
-
Dmitry Karayev, Jeffrey S. Warren, Amber Young, Dinesh Khanna, Allan L. Metzger, Kate Homer, Puja P. Khanna, and Vivek Nagaraja
- Subjects
030203 arthritis & rheumatology ,chemistry.chemical_classification ,biology ,Extractable nuclear antigens ,business.industry ,Autoantibody ,Anti-Topoisomerase I Antibody ,Immunodiffusion ,03 medical and health sciences ,0302 clinical medicine ,Enzyme ,Rheumatology ,chemistry ,Immunology ,I antibody ,biology.protein ,Medicine ,030212 general & internal medicine ,CRITERION STANDARD ,Antibody ,business - Abstract
Background/objective The criterion standard for anti-topoisomerase I antibody (anti-topo I antibody) testing in systemic sclerosis (SSc) uses immunodiffusion (ID) techniques, but enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA) and multiple-bead technology are often used in current settings to save time and cost. Our aim was to assess the performance of the multiple-bead assay, ELISA, and ID testing methods. Methods We conducted a retrospective study of patients at the University of Michigan whose extractable nuclear antigen 10 autoantibody panel tested positive for the anti-topo I antibody by multiple-bead technology during a 1-year period. All samples positive by multiple-bead assay were sent to the RDL Laboratories and reflexed for ELISA, and all anti-topo I antibodies positive by ELISA were further tested by ID. Clinical data were reviewed by a rheumatologist and assessed for presence of SSc. Data were analyzed via frequency tables. Results Approximately 9500 extractable nuclear antigen 10 panels were ordered by physicians at the University of Michigan. Of these, 129 patients were positive for the anti-topo I antibody by multiple-bead assay, 51 were positive by multiple-bead assay and ELISA, and 21 were positive by multiple-bead assay, ELISA, and ID. We found that 26.4% of patients positive by multiple-bead assay, 47.1% positive by multiple-bead assay and ELISA, and 95.2% positive by multiple-bead assay, ELISA, and ID had SSc. Conclusions Multiple-bead assays have a high rate of false-positive results for the anti-topo I antibody in patients without clinical evidence of SSc. A stepwise approach of confirmation of positive multiple-bead assay results using both ELISA and ID improves the predictive value of antibody testing for the diagnosis of SSc.
- Published
- 2018
- Full Text
- View/download PDF