Plant-scale comparison of direct filtration versus conventional treatment was mg/L. It was anticipated that modifying achieved bv a solit stream ooeration at a 340-ML/day (90-mgd) water treatment the treatment process to utilize direct plant in thestate of New York. filtration would reduce the amount of alum required by about two thirds. Direct filtration was also expected to lower chemical costs, reduce sludge production (with attendant savings from reduced sludge handling and disposal costs), and reduce the aluminum hydroxide content of alum sludge, thereby improving the dewatering and landfilling characteristics of sludge. The Erie County Water Authority provides filtered water to a population of over 400 000 in twelve towns and the city of Lackawanna in Erie County, N.Y. Some two thirds of the water is treated at the water authority’s Sturgeon Point filter plant, located in the town of Evans, about 50 km (30 mi) south of the city of Buffalo. Constructed in 1961 and subsequently expanded to its present 340ML/day (90-mgd) capacity, the Sturgeon Point plant withdraws low turbidity water from an intake in Lake Erie. Treatment facilities at the plant include four flash mixers, five flocculation-sedimentation basins, and ten reverse-graded mixed media filters approved to operate at filtration rates of up to 4 mm/s (6 gpm/sq ft). Sludge from the water treatment process is gravity-thickened, conditioned, dewatered by filter pressing, and landfilled. Recent studies have indicated that for such low turbidity raw waters as that available from Lake Erie, direct filtration is capable of producing high quality water at a lower cost than conventional treatment with sedimentation ahead of filtration, particularly when reversegraded (coarse-to-fine) mixed media are used in the filters. Direct filtration eliminates the need for sedimentation prior to filtration and reduces alum usage and sludge production. In April 1978 a full-scale study of direct filtration using one reverse-graded mixed media filter was conducted by Malcolm Pirnie, Inc., for the Niagara County Water District’s water treatment plant in Lockport, N.Y., to develop preliminary design data for plant expansion. The raw water quality at this plant was essentially the same as at the Sturgeon Point plant. The study results at this