1. The Flaws of Magic Bullet Theory: Retraining Unconscionability to Discretely Target Different Contexts of Unfairness in Contracts.
- Author
-
Moore, Marcus
- Subjects
- *
HYPODERMIC needle theory (Communication) , *CONTRACTS , *JURISPRUDENCE , *LEGITIMACY of governments - Abstract
Unconscionability has long been a troublesome area in Canadian jurisprudence. This is of significant concern given unconscionability’s pre-eminence as a protection of contractual fairness. This article elaborates a much-needed reorganization and rationalization of unconscionability in Canada. Under current law, a single doctrine hopelessly targets two divergent purposes. I set out here a proposed redevelopment rather of separate common law doctrines, each fit-for-purpose: (1) An English-style unconscionable bargains doctrine for avoiding bargains that exploited disability, and (2) an American-style unconscionable clauses doctrine to control unfair terms in standard form contracts. Extensive Canadian precedent supports this solution, assuring its feasibility and legitimacy. To manage the doctrines’ coexistence and clarify this universally confounding area of law, I recommend further a distinctly Canadian approach: Recognizing unconscionability as an “organizing principle”. Alongside that of good faith which governs performance, this one would address enforceability in abuse of power situations, elevating fairness in Canadian contract law. [ABSTRACT FROM AUTHOR]
- Published
- 2022