Search

Discusses research being done on medical care and outcomes in hospital stroke units in Europe. Reference to study by A. G. Rudd et al, presented at the British Geriatrics Society Communications to the Autumn Meeting in Harrogate, England from October 6 to 8, 2004; Impact of stroke unit care on outcomes; Methodology and results of the study.

Presents a response by authors to a letter to the editor about their article, published in the June 2004 issue of the journal "Thorax."

In this retrospective pilot study we examine the feasibility of establishing a confidential enquiry into why some patients die after emergency admission to hospital. After excluding those who died in the first hour or who were admitted for palliative care, pairs of physicians were able to collect quantitative and qualitative data on 200 consecutive deaths. Both physicians reported shortfalls of care in 14 patients and one of the pair in 25 patients whose deaths would not have been the expected outcome. In 25, the shortfalls of care may have contributed to their deaths. Major problems were delays in seeing doctors, inaccurate diagnoses, delays in investigations and initiation of treatment. They occurred mostly in those admitted at night. It is possible that establishing the correct diagnosis and starting appropriate treatment may have been delayed in 64% of the 200 patients. The headline figures appear worse than some previous external assessment studies but this study did concentrate on those in whom problems were more likely. Nevertheless, the frequency is too high to be overlooked. In this feasibility study we have demonstrated that it is practicable for local staff to collect and assess data in hospitals and that the types of problems identified are relevant to anyone planning how to organise emergency care. A larger definitive study should be performed.

Despite publication of several management guidelines for COPD, relatively little is known about standards of care in clinical practice. Data were collected on the management of 1400 cases of acute admission with Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease in 38 UK hospitals to compare clinical practice against the recommended British Thoracic Society standards. Variation in the process of care between the different centres was analysed and a comparison of the management by respiratory specialists and nonrespiratory specialists made. There were large variations between centres for many of the variables studied. A forced expiratory volume in one second measurement was found in only 53% of cases. Of the investigations recommended in the acute management arterial blood gases were performed in 79% (interhospital range 40-100%) of admissions and oxygen was formally prescribed in only 64% (range 9-94%). Of those cases with acidosis and hypercapnia 35% had no further blood gas analysis and only 13% received ventilatory support. Long-term management was also deficient with 246 cases known to be severely hypoxic on admission yet two-thirds had no confirmation that oxygen levels had returned to levels above the requirements for long-term oxygen therapy. Only 30% of current smokers had cessation advice documented. To conclude, the median standards of care observed fell below those recommended by the guidelines. The lowest levels of performance were for patients not under the respiratory specialists, but specialists also have room for improvement. The substantial variation in the process of care between hospitals is strong evidence that it is possible for other centres with poorer performance to improve their levels of care.

Guidelines for a variety of diseases have now been produced. However, implementation of guidelines requires that the medical profession is willing to conform to patterns of diagnostic and treatment behavior set down by others. This may not happen in practice. Early experience in the United Kingdom was gained with the introduction of guidelines for the management of asthma. For a number of years, there have been improvements in practice, but deficiencies still exist. When the introduction of guidelines for the management of COPD was planned, a new approach was taken with a consortium of the British Thoracic Society, pharmaceutical companies, and medical equipment companies being formed to promote their use. Early studies show that COPD care starts from an even lower baseline than asthma; there is poor understanding of objective diagnosis of COPD in both primary and secondary care.

There is a need to establish the proportion of adult asthmatics at each step of the recommended asthma management guidelines, the cost of their prescribed treatment, and a revised cost of treatment assuming patients who were suboptimally controlled were moved up a step. Actual prescription and cost figures and a theoretical projection of an ideal scenario was calculated from a sample of general practices in Great Britain from the Doctors Independent Network. They comprised 102 nationally distributed practices and 17,206 adult patients with a diagnosis of, and prescription related to, asthma recorded between October 1993 and March 1994. Ninety-one per cent of patients received treatment within a recognized step of the guidelines. Of these, 80% were at steps 1 and 2. Employing excess inhaled beta-agonist use as a proxy for control of asthma, between 55% and 69% of patients at Steps 1-3 should receive treatment at a higher step. This could lead to an increased expenditure of up to Pound Sterling 4.66 per adult patient per month. This would imply a rise in the annual UK cost of antiasthma prescriptions for adults from Pound Sterling 388m to a possible Pound Sterling 533m. The United Kingdom Government audit commission has suggested that current expenditure on asthma treatment appears to be insufficient. Using an entirely different approach this study has confirmed that a significant increase in asthma prescribing costs is likely to be needed if optimal control of asthma is to be achieved.

Study Objective: To assess the quality of inpatient care and follow-up for stroke in England, Wales and Northern Ireland., Design: Retrospective audit of case notes and service organisation., Setting: 197 trust (80% of eligible trusts in England, Wales and Northern Ireland)., Patients: 6,894 consecutive stroke patients admitted between 1 January 1998 and 31 March 1998 (up to 40 per trust). AUDIT TOOL: The Intercollegiate Stroke Audit., Results: Most patients were admitted to acute hospitals with access to the appropriate acute investigations and treatments. Only 64% of trusts had a physician with responsibility for stroke and only 50% had a stroke team. Involvement of different members of the multidisciplinary team within appropriate time-frames varied from 37% to 61%. Assessment of impairments specific to stroke was inadequate (screening for swallowing disorders in only 55%, cognitive function tests in 23% and visual field examination in 44%). Rehabilitation goals were agreed by the multidisciplinary team in only 55% of eligible cases. 41% of patients were contacted by their GP within 3 days of discharge. The best compliance with standards was achieved for the 18% of patients who spent at least 50% of their time in a stroke unit., Conclusions: This national audit demonstrates that care is suboptimal in many areas, and that there is wide variation in standards for the management of stroke across the country. This may have implications for clinical governance.

The objective of this study was to investigate the spatial distribution of respiratory morbidity and asthma in children in relation to high levels of airborne dust pollution. A cross-sectional survey of 2035 children (aged 5-11 yr) by parent-completed questionnaire, with concurrent monitoring of dust deposition rates in the vicinity of children's homes, was performed in 15 primary schools (5 in each of 3 areas of Merseyside). The main outcome measures were (1) doctor-diagnosed asthma, (2) parent-reported respiratory symptoms of recent excess cough, wheeze, and breathlessness, and (3) school absenteeism due to respiratory ill health. Proximity to the source of dust pollution was associated with increased prevalence of excess cough, breathlessness, school absence due to respiratory ill health, and doctor-diagnosed asthma, after adjusting for a range of socioeconomic, environmental, and other confounding factors. The adjusted odds for excess cough and breathlessness for children living within 2 km of the source (dock area) are estimated to be almost twice those for children living more than 2 km away: excess cough 1.9 (95% CI 1.4-2.6); breathlessness 1.9 (1.3-2.7); school absence 1.5 (1.2-1.9); and doctor-diagnosed asthma 1.5 (1.1-2.0). Excess cough was significantly associated with the mean annual dust deposition recorded in the vicinity of the child's home. The adjusted odds ratio for excess cough corresponding to an increase in mean annual dust deposition of 50 mg/m2/d was 3.1 (95% CI 1.1-8.2). These results suggest that airborne dust was associated with respiratory morbidity in these children, which could relate to the high prevalence of childhood doctor-diagnosed asthma in this community.

Fibreoptic bronchoscopy (FOB) is now commonly performed, and the number of elderly patients undergoing the procedure is increasing. Problems with oxygenation during FOB are well-recognised, but there are few data about its cardiovascular effects. Forty five patients (median age 65 yrs) undergoing elective FOB were studied prospectively. Patients were connected to a 12-lead computerized electrocardiographic recorder, a finger plethysmographic blood pressure (FPBP) monitor and pulse oximeter. Forty three patients were sedated with fentanyl and droperidol, and all were given 5 mL 2.5% cocaine intratracheally and xylocaine spray to the pharynx. Mean sphygmomanometric cuff blood pressure was raised initially (167/88 mmHg). Mean blood pressure recorded by FPBP rose on intratracheal injection (178/96 mmHg) and remained high throughout the procedure. Mean (SD) initial cardiac frequency was 93 (5.1) beats x min(-1) and rose to 134 (7.5) beats x min(-1) during the procedure. Four of the 45 patients showed unexpected ST segment depression of >1 mm for >1 min, and a further three developed bundle branch block. These seven patients had significantly greater tachycardia (152 vs 131 beats x min(-1)) and higher blood pressure (238/131 vs 207/109 mmHg). They were older (72 vs 61 yrs), had smoked more (63 vs 39 pack-years), but had similar lung function and similar changes in oxygen saturation. Oxygen desaturation occurred in 19 patients and this was associated with poor lung function (69 vs 84% predicted forced expiratory volume in one second), but was independent of the cardiovascular changes. Significant cardiovascular changes occur during fibreoptic bronchoscopy, with evidence of cardiac strain in 21% of patients over the age of 60 yrs.

Acoustic analysis of cough both in the time and frequency domain has been reported using voluntary and spontaneous cough. The main aim of this study was to discover whether such analysis of capsaicin-induced cough enables differences between normal subjects to be recognized. We present data from 13 healthy subjects (with normal lung function and no history of respiratory disease) using a new method of acoustic analysis, which presents the data in three graphical forms: 1) spectrogram; 2) overall spectral energy, 3) root mean square (RMS) pressure plots. Using the RMS sound pressure traces, different subjects had either two peaks, a single peak or multiple peaks. The occurrence of single and multiple peaks has previously been associated with disease states but we found them in normal subjects. The number of peaks and the visual pattern of the spectrogram was reproducible within and specific to each individual over time. During a peal of coughs in a single expiration, the peak amplitude of successive coughs decreased as lung volume reduced. Despite similarities in the overall spectral energy between individuals, there were marked differences in the small visual details of the spectrograms. However, in an individual, these small details were remarkably constant both within and between days, and can be regarded as a "cough signature". This type of spectrographic analysis provides a new approach to the analysis both of normal and abnormal cough sounds, and has identified similarities and differences in capsaicin-induced cough in normal individuals. It has potential as a tool with which to study the pathophysiology of cough.

This study set out to assess the effect of publication of the British Guidelines on Asthma Management on the processes and outcomes of the inpatient care of acute severe asthma in the U.K. A criterion-based audit of all acute asthma admissions during August and September 1990 (immediately before) and in 1991 (1 yr after publication of the Guidelines) using eight criteria of process and outcome was performed. Thirty-six teaching and district general hospitals in England, Scotland and Wales took part. In total, 766 patients admitted in 1990, and 900 patients admitted in 1991, were studied. The 1990 and 1991 cohorts were very similar demographically and had asthma of comparable severity. Respiratory physicians achieved similar high performance rates of between 75 and 91% for seven of the eight criteria for both years. Respiratory physicians were significantly more likely to provide patients with a written management plan in 1991. General physicians' performance was significantly lower in both years, but overall there was a very small, but just significant, improvement in their performance in 1991. Some hospitals performed consistently well in both years. It is concluded that respiratory physicians consistently provide better asthma care than general physicians. Though statistically significant, the small degree of improvement was disappointing. Possible reasons include: insufficient time for the Guidelines to be incorporated into practice; inaccessibility of the Guidelines to general physicians; failure to accept responsibility for implementing the good practice reflected in the Guidelines; and an explicit need for strategies to implement the Guidelines beyond publication in a widely-read general medical journal.

The National Health Service has employed physicians since its inception, yet 46 years later there are few data on the day-to-day work done by physicians. This paper describes the case mix of general medicine in one region using data for general medical admissions to one specialty (respiratory medicine) as a working example. The pattern of general medical inpatient admissions is consistent across the 10 districts in the Mersey region: 26% have a respiratory diagnosis, 22% cardiac, and 15% gastrointestinal. For medical day cases, 60% are gastrointestinal. The average length of stay for particular conditions varies little between hospitals, and the average consultant 'cares' for 949 consultant inpatient episodes per year. In only half the Mersey districts is the respiratory consultant provision appropriate for the case mix admitted to the hospital. A simple algorithm applied to data collected routinely by regional health authorities can yield much information upon which to plan medical manpower. Applied to a specialty, it has identified mismatches between workload and consultant type. For respiratory medicine, at least six more respiratory physicians (a 30% increase) are needed to correct the underprovision in Mersey region.

This paper reviews published audit activity for a single common condition (asthma). Has this effort brought about better care for the patient? The result of this audit of audits reveals that specialists do follow the guidelines on the management of acute asthma with good results, but that general physicians, in whose care perforce many acute episodes are managed, do not seem to be aware of the published good practice guidelines.

Cold air may worsen asthmatic bronchoconstriction but can lessen breathlessness in normal individuals. Patients with COPD sometimes report improvement in their dyspnea in cold weather. We examined the effect of breathing cold air on exercise tolerance and the perception of breathlessness in 19 patients with stable COPD (age [+/- SD], 63 +/- 6 years; FEV1, 0.99 +/- 0.28 L) in a randomized open study. Patients exercised on a cycle ergometer breathing either room or cold air (-13 degrees C), breathlessness being assessed by Borg scaling. Peak exercise performance improved when breathing cold air (mean +/- SE), 46 +/- 6 W compared with 37 +/- 7 W (p < 0.05) while end-exercise breathlessness fell from 4.6 +/- 0.4 compared with 4.1 +/- 0.5 (p < 0.05) when breathing cold air. End-exercise ETCO2 was higher breathing cold air (6.1 +/- 0.3 kPa compared with 5.5 +/- 0.3 kPa) (p < 0.005). There was no difference in breathlessness at equivalent levels of ventilation. Cold air reduces breathlessness in COPD, probably by inducing relative hypoventilation.

Partial bronchodilator reversibility can be demonstrated in many patients with stable chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD), but its relevance to exercise capacity and symptoms is uncertain. Previous data suggest that anticholinergic bronchodilators do not improve exercise tolerance in such patients. We studied 32 patients with stable COPD, mean age 65 yrs, in a double-blind, placebo-controlled, cross-over trial of the inhaled anticholinergic drug, oxitropium bromide. From the within and between day placebo spirometry, we derived the spontaneous variation in forced expiratory volume in one second (FEV1) and forced vital capacity (FVC) of this population (FEV1 140 ml; FVC 390 ml) and considered responses beyond this to be significant. Oxitropium bromide increased baseline FEV1 from 0.70 (0.28) l (mean (SD)) to 0.88 (0.36) l. The 6 min walking distance increased by 7% compared with placebo, whilst resting breathlessness scores fell from 2.0 to 1.23 at rest and 4.09 to 3.28 at the end of exercise after the active drug. Improvements in walking distances and symptoms were unrelated to changes in either FEV1 or FVC, indicating that routine reversibility testing is not a good predictor of symptomatic benefit in these patients.

Inspiratory lung crackles are a diagnostic feature of interstitial pulmonary fibrosis, but expiratory crackles are not well documented. In a phonopneumographic study of 13 patients with fibrosing alveolitis, expiratory crackles were audible with the stethoscope in 12. Phonopneumographic analysis of these 12 patients showed the crackles to be fine with the initial wave deflection of the expiratory and inspiratory crackles in opposite directions. They were few in number, occurred predominantly in mid- and late expiration, and were not affected by varying the volume history or by breath holding maneuvers. These observations support the theory that some crackles are produced by vibration of the walls of peripheral airways. In addition, this group of patients showed a significant correlation between the number of expiratory crackles and the reduction in predicted transfer factor, suggesting that expiratory crackles may be a clinical indicator of the severity of disease in fibrosing alveolitis.

We studied the prevalence of ventilatory impairment, chest symptoms, and radiographic abnormality in a selected sample of more than 2,000 kaolin workers from east central Georgia. The presence of ventilatory impairment was related to the presence of complicated pneumoconiosis, employment in clay calcining, and cigarette smoking. In those working with calcined clay, there was an increased prevalence of abnormality of the FEV1, but not the FVC, when compared to both wet and dry processors and which could not be explained by either cigarette smoking or the presence of pneumoconiosis. The magnitude of abnormality in the calcined clay workers was, however, unlikely to lead to disabling impairment. In workers with more than 3-yr tenure, there were 90 subjects with simple pneumoconiosis and 18 with complicated pneumoconiosis, yielding an adjusted prevalence of 3.2% and 0.63%, respectively, in the sample examined. Dry processing was associated with a greater risk of developing pneumoconiosis than wet processing.

We investigated in vitro NMR properties of bleomycin-induced alveolitis and pulmonary fibrosis in 18 Lewis rats (6 controls). When alveolitis or fibrosis had developed, animal lungs were excised and examined histologically and gravimetrically and their T1 and T2 were determined by a NMR spectrometer at 10.7 MHz and 37 degrees C. Clinical diagnosis was confirmed histologically in each case. The NMR signal intensities were significantly elevated in both disease states (P less than 0.001). Both T1 and T2 values of alveolitic lungs were about the same as in controls, but were significantly decreased in fibrotic lungs (P less than 0.01). Changes in T1 and T2 correlated well (P less than 0.001) with changes in water content of diseased lungs.

Were aminophylline to improve mucociliary function, it might prove useful in the management of irreversible airflow limitation. Eight subjects with irreversible airflow limitation due to emphysema inhaled an aerosol of 99mTc sulphur-colloid particles on each of 2 days. On day 1 aminophylline was administered intravenously, while on the other nothing was given. Particle clearance was measured by recording posterior gamma-camera images sequentially over a 24 h period. No significant differences were recorded between aminophylline and control studies, but there were marked variations in clearance between study days and between individuals. These differences were compatible with the known effects of airways obstruction and breathing pattern on the sites of particle deposition within the bronchial tree. The latter factors appeared to exert a far greater influence on the observed mucociliary clearance than did aminophylline.

We investigated the regional deposition in the lungs, of an inhaled submicron aerosol at rest and during exercise in 13 normal volunteers of whom 5 were cigarette smokers. The degree of exercise (VO2 approximately 2 L/min) was chosen to simulate moderately heavy physical labour. Tracheobronchial and alveolar components of deposition were measured by comparing images immediately after inhalation of aerosol and 24 h later when mucociliary clearance was complete. At rest almost all deposition was alveolar (97%). The increase in total deposition on exercise was of similar order to the increase in ventilation. On exercise regional alveolar deposition became more even, although basal still exceeded apical deposition. Tracheobronchial deposition on exercise was increased in all zones but particularly in the upper zones, thereby contrasting with the base to apex gradient of parenchymal deposition. These changes were exaggerated in the smokers. The increased upper zone tracheobronchial deposition may have implications in regard to the pathogenesis of diseases caused by the inhalation of dusts and fumes.

We have characterized another subset of acute nonlymphocytic leukemia (ANLL) based on the cytogenetic and morphologic findings in a group of nine patients. Five patients had chromosomal analyses performed at the University of Chicago, two patients were studied at the All-Union Cancer Research Center in Moscow, and one patient each was studied at the University of Maryland and at Fairfax Hospital in Fairfax, Virginia. All nine patients had a reciprocal translocation involving the short arm of chromosome 6 and the long arm of chromosome 9 [t(6;9)(p23;q34)]. The patients, four males and five females, ranged in age from 5 to 51 years; the median age of 38 years is lower than that typically seen in ANLL. Only two of eight treated patients entered a complete remission. Classification of bone marrow morphology according to FAB Cooperative Group criteria revealed AML-M1 in one patient, AML-M2 in four, and AMMoL-M4 in three. One patient had refractory anemia with excess blasts (RAEB) which evolved to AML-M2. All bone marrow specimens showed severe myelodysplasia, with Auer rods present in seven of the nine cases. Of note was the particular prominence of bone marrow basophils (greater than 1%) in eight of the nine (89%) patients. Among 160 evaluable patients with ANLL de novo seen at the University of Chicago whose cells lacked a t(6;9), only five (3%) had greater than 1% basophils in the marrow aspirates. It is of interest that the breakpoint in 9q involves the same chromosomal band as that in the t(9;22) observed in chronic myelogenous leukemia (CML), in which increased basophils are a prominent feature. Thus, the association of the t(6;9) with increased bone marrow basophils in ANLL may provide additional insight into the chromosomal location of genes regulating the production and/or maturation of basophils.

Fourteen patients with acute nonlymphocytic leukemia (ANLL) or dysmyelopoietic syndromes were found to have abnormalities involving the long arm of chromosome 3. In eight patients, the structural rearrangements involved both bands 3q21 and 3q26 and included t(3;3) (four patients), inv(3) (three patients), and ins(5;3) (one patient). Before treatment, seven of these eight patients had platelet counts above 100,000 per microliter, five had normal or elevated platelet counts, and four had significantly elevated platelet counts (600,000 to 1,731,000 per microliter). In each of the eight cases, normal or elevated platelet counts were associated with marked abnormalities of megakaryocytopoiesis, including increased numbers of megakaryocytes and numerous micromegakaryocytes. Classification within the French-American-British system was difficult in most of these cases; however, the leukemia in five of the eight patients with abnormalities of chromosome 3 that involved both bands 3q21 and 3q26 was classified as M4. The remaining six of the 14 patients had translocations between chromosome 3 and another chromosome. None involved both bands 3q21 and 3q26, and a break in either q21 or q26 was noted in only two patients. One of the six, who had ANLL (M4) with a normal platelet count, had a 3;5 translocation which involved band 3q25. These data suggest that in patients with ANLL, abnormalities of chromosome 3 which simultaneously involve bands 3q21 and 3q26 are associated with unusually high platelet counts.

We describe a subject with lymphangioleiomyomatosis who presented with chylothorax but who had an otherwise normal chest radiograph. The diagnosis was established by means of whole-body computerized tomographic scanning, which demonstrated asymptomatic involvement of the lungs, lymphatics, and kidneys. This diagnostic modality offers the potential for noninvasive serial monitoring of this rare condition, and in doing so provides an opportunity to obtain a better understanding of the disease process.

Three patients with malignant mesothelioma of the pleura presented with unilateral pleural effusion and recurrent horizontal linear opacities on the chest radiograph. Although an initial diagnosis of pulmonary embolism was made in all three patients and two received anticoagulants, it is more likely that the opacities represented plate atelectases due to restriction of basal lung expansion by severe chest pain. It is suggested that the early manifestations of malignant mesothelioma of pleura may be confused with recurrent pulmonary embolism.