Accurate replication of genomic DNA is critical for cellular survival and proliferation. Despite the complexity of the cellular DNA replication process, the overall error rates are remarkably low. Three discrete processes contribute to the accuracy of replication. First, replicative DNA polymerases typically exhibit relatively low error frequencies of 10−3 to 10−6 errors per dNTP inserted (1). Second, misincorporation events decrease the rate of elongation significantly, thereby allowing 3′-5′ exonucleolytic proofreading to occur and decreasing the error rate by 100-fold or so. Finally, postreplicative repair enzymes reduce the overall error frequency to roughly 10−9 errors per nucleotide inserted (2). The mechanisms by which various polymerases efficiently distinguish between correct and incorrect dNTP substrates during polymerization are not yet fully understood. Furthermore, different polymerases appear to utilize significantly different mechanisms (3-4). Some low-fidelity enzymes, such as human primase, herpes primase, and Y-family DNA polymerases, appear to largely utilize the Watson-Crick hydrogen bonding groups on the incoming (d)NTPs and the templating base to help identify correct and incorrect incorporation events (5-10). On the other hand, various studies have shown that A and B family DNA polymerases do not require Watson-Crick hydrogen bond formation for dNTP incorporation (11-12). B family polymerases use specific functional groups on the base of an incoming purine dNTP to prevent misincorporation and to enhance correct incorporation (4, 13-16). The methods used by A family polymerases are less well understood; while some studies indicate that shape selectivity may be critical for correct dNTP incorporation, others imply that shape is not important (16-26). For example, Kool and coworkers showed that some A family polymerases efficiently incorporate 2,4-dihalotoluene dNTPs in a manner consistent with the enzyme using shape as a primary determinant (27). However, these enzymes also readily incorporate purine dNTP opposite a templating T and dITP opposite a templating C (19, 28), even though the shapes of purine and hypoxanthine significantly vary from the shapes of adenine and guanine, respectively. DNA polymerase α (pol α1) is a key polymerase (along with primase, pol δ, and pol e) required during nuclear DNA replication (29). Pol α is a B-family polymerase that typically exhibits low processivity, polymerizing ~12 nucleotides before dissociating, and moderate fidelity, making 10−3-10−5 errors per dNTP polymerized (30-31). Biologically, pol α is responsible for the initial extension of primase-synthesized RNA primers in all new DNA strands. Pol α lacks 3′-5′ exonuclease activity; therefore, the incorporation of an incorrect dNTP results in the dissociation of pol α and subsequent association of a processive replicative polymerase with exonuclease activity (pol δ or pol e) (29, 32). Pol α requires neither the formation of Watson-Crick hydrogen bonds nor a correctly shaped base pair for the rapid incorporation of a dNTP (16, 33-34). Instead, recent work has shown that during incorporation of dATP and related purine analogues, pol α employs a combination of positive and negative selectivity to ensure accuracy of replication. N-1 and N-3 serve as negative selectors and help prevent misincorporation, while N-1 and N6 act as positive selectors and enhance correct incorporation (4). Thus, a combination of positive and negative selectivity provides accuracy for pol α during dNTP incorporation, rather than shape or hydrogen bonding patterns. The HSV-1 polymerase, another B-family DNA polymerase, uses the same general mechanisms as pol α, although the precise roles of N-1 and N6 vary between the two enzymes (14). While the chemical features of purine bases have been examined with respect to their roles in correct incorporation and preventing misincorporation by pol α and herpes DNA polymerase, the contributions of the different functional groups on pyrimidines have not been examined. Accordingly, we examined the role of O2, N-3, and N4/O4 of pyrimidine dNTPs and template bases for incorporation and fidelity with these two enzymes.