201. Second order of stochastic dominance efficiency vs mean variance efficiency
- Author
-
Matteo Malavasi, Stefan Trück, and Sergio Ortobelli Lozza
- Subjects
Information Systems and Management ,Stochastic dominance ,General Computer Science ,Market portfolio ,0211 other engineering and technologies ,Diversification (finance) ,02 engineering and technology ,Management Science and Operations Research ,Multiple objective programming ,Industrial and Manufacturing Engineering ,Minimum-variance unbiased estimator ,0502 economics and business ,Econometrics ,Modern portfolio theory ,Expected utility hypothesis ,Mathematics ,050210 logistics & transportation ,Settore SECS-S/06 - Metodi mat. dell'economia e Scienze Attuariali e Finanziarie ,021103 operations research ,Mean variance ,05 social sciences ,Efficient frontier ,Investment analysis ,Efficient set ,Modeling and Simulation ,Portfolio - Abstract
In this paper, we compare two of the main paradigms of portfolio theory: mean variance analysis and expected utility. In particular, we show empirically that mean variance efficient portfolios are typically sub-optimal for non satiable and risk averse investors. We illustrate that the second order stochastic dominance (SSD) efficient set is the solution of a multi-objective optimization problem. We further show that the market portfolio is not necessarily a solution to this optimization problem. We also conduct an empirical analysis, examining the ex ante and ex post performance of SSD and mean variance efficient portfolios, using a bootstrap approach. In an ex ante analysis, we compare empirical moments, the level of diversification and set distances of mean variance and SSD efficient sets. We also show that the global minimum variance (GMV) portfolio and the part of the mean variance efficient frontier (MVEF) composed of highly diversified portfolios is second order stochastically dominated. This result also provides a possible alternative explanation for the diversification puzzle. Conducting an ex post analysis, we construct second order stochastic dominating strategies that outperform the GMV portfolio in terms of wealth and various other performance measures, producing a positive ex post opportunity cost.
- Published
- 2021