201. On the Origin of Anaximander’s Cosmological Model
- Author
-
Gerard Naddaf
- Subjects
Philosophy ,Position (vector) ,media_common.quotation_subject ,Figure of the Earth ,Astronomy ,Celestial sphere ,Earth (chemistry) ,Type (model theory) ,Element (category theory) ,Cosmology ,Universe ,media_common - Abstract
Although we have only one extant fragment from the sixth-century BC Milesian philosopher, Anaximander, a number of doxographies enable us to reconstruct his ideas concerning the origin and evolution of the present order of things, that is, what one may call an historia (or investigation) of the nrepi 0oiaws' type. What is distinctly important about the Milesian's historia is that, being the first rational account of this type to have come down to us, it helps us to understand just what is involved in the movement from a mythopoeic to a speculative account. Certainly one of the most interesting facets of Anaximander's system is his cosmological model, which places an immobile earth at the center of the celestial sphere. The reason given for this is that, the earth being equidistant from all the points of the celestial circumference, there is no reason for it to move up rather than down, or left rather than right. In sum, the Milesian's reasoning behind the position of the earth appears to be mathematical. It is therefore not surprising that this is often considered Anaximander's greatest achievement in cosmology; for it liberated the mind (or should have) from the idea that the earth needed a material support. This is not the only role that the earth played in his cosmology. The earth is also the most important element in determining the sizes and distances of the other celestial bodies; that is, their sizes and distances are analogous to the dimensions of the earth. This may be deduced from a certain number of doxographies which tell us that the Milesian conceived the shape of the earth as that of a column drum three times as broad as it is high and that the distance of the stars, of the moon and of the sun (or their respective rings) from the center of the earth are in a ratio of 1:2:3. It appears that Anaximander realized his universe according to a mathematical plan following the series 3. This hypothesis, first formulated by Paul Tannery in the late nineteenth century, has, in spite of its conjectural na
- Published
- 1998
- Full Text
- View/download PDF